Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Non-Markovianity in Logical Fidelity Estimation

Athena Caesura

Published Feb 26, 2021• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

As quantum devices are progressively scaled and refined, quantum codes will become indispensable to guarantee reliable computation in the presence of noise. Due to the difficulties of characterizing physical noise, direct measures of logical performance will be of paramount use to tune quantum codes [18]. Logical Randomized Benchmarking in [5] aimed to characterize the logical operations directly by performing randomized benchmarking using logical operators and following each operation with perfect QEC. However, due to resource limitations, physical implementations such as [14] only measure the syndrome at the end of a computation. \n \nWe develop a generalized framework for procedures that measure the fidelity of logical operations directly, logical fidelity estimation (LFE). We identify several freedoms that arise when attempting to define a fidelity which characterizes quantum error correction, specifically, in how error detection events are processed and in how often error correction is performed. We explore these freedoms by conducting a survey to eliminate inviable procedures guided by the presence of upticks, a standard signature of non-Markovianity [33]. Our survey highlights procedures that are robust to gate-dependent noise and procedures which are implementable in the near-term. We recommend applying post-selection after each gate as a benchmark for quantum codes which is robust to gate-dependent noise. We manage to eliminate some naive near-term protocols, but guaranteeing the robustness when QEC is applied at a at fixed time or when post-selection is applied at the end, are open problems.

Related papers

Emergent Non-Markovianity in Logical Qubit Dynamics

Jalan A. Ziyad, Robin Blume-Kohout, Kenneth Rudinger

Logical qubits encoded in quantum error correcting codes can exhibit non-Markovian dynamical evolution, even when the underlying physical noise is Markovian. To understand this emergent non-Markovianity, we define a Markovianity condition appropriate to logical gate operations, and study it by relating logical operations to their physical implementation (operations on the data qubits into which the logical qubit is encoded). We apply our analysis to small quantum codes, and show that they exhibit non-Markovian dynamics even for very simple physical noise models. We show that non-Markovianity can emerge from Markovian physical operations if (and only if) the physical qubits are not necessarily returned to the code subspace after every round of QEC. In this situation, the syndrome qubits can act as a memory, mediating time correlations and enabling violation of the Markov condition. We quantify the emergent non-Markovianity in simple examples, and propose sufficient conditions for reliable use of gate-based characterization techniques like gate set tomography in early fault-tolerant quantum devices.

quant-pharXiv:2512.08893•Dec 10, 2025

Operational Markovianization in randomized benchmarking

Pedro Figueroa–Romero, Miha Papič, A Auer +3 more

Abstract A crucial task to obtain optimal and reliable quantum devices is to quantify their overall performance. The average fidelity of quantum gates is a particular figure of merit that can be estimated efficiently by randomized benchmarking (RB). However, the concept of gate-fidelity itself relies on the crucial assumption that noise behaves in a predictable, time-local, or so-called Markovian manner, whose breakdown can naturally become the leading source of errors as quantum devices scale in size and depth. We analytically show that error suppression techniques such as dynamical decoupling (DD) and Pauli-twirling can operationally Markovianize RB: (i) fast DD reduces non-Markovian RB to an exponential decay plus longer-time corrections, while on the other hand, (ii) Pauli-twirling generally does not affect the average, but (iii) it always suppresses the variance of such RB outputs. We demonstrate these effects numerically with a qubit noise model. Our results show that simple and efficient error suppression methods can simultaneously tame non-Markovian noise and allow for standard and reliable gate quality estimation, a fundamentally important task in the path toward fully functional quantum devices.

arXiv:2305.04704•Quantum Science and Technology•Apr 16, 2024•11 citations

Logical Randomized Benchmarking

Joshua Combes, Christopher Granade, Christopher Ferrie +1 more

Extrapolating physical error rates to logical error rates requires many assumptions and thus can radically under- or overestimate the performance of an error correction implementation. We introduce logical randomized benchmarking, a characterization procedure that directly assesses the performance of a quantum error correction implementation at the logical level, and is motivated by a reduction to the well-studied case of physical randomized benchmarking. We show that our method reliably reports logical performance and can estimate the average probability of correctable and uncorrectable errors for a given code and physical channel.

arXiv:1702.03688•Feb 13, 2017•64 citations

Towards a general framework of Randomized Benchmarking incorporating non-Markovian Noise

Pedro Figueroa–Romero, Kavan Kishore Modi, Min-Hsiu Hsieh

The rapid progress in the development of quantum devices is in large part due to the availability of a wide range of characterization techniques allowing to probe, test and adjust them. Nevertheless, these methods often make use of approximations that hold in rather simplistic circumstances. In particular, assuming that error mechanisms stay constant in time and have no dependence in the past, is something that will be impossible to do as quantum processors continue scaling up in depth and size. We establish a theoretical framework for the Randomized Benchmarking protocol encompassing temporally-correlated, so-called non-Markovian noise, at the gate level, for any gate set belonging to a wide class of finite groups. We obtain a general expression for the Average Sequence Fidelity (ASF) and propose a way to obtain average gate fidelities of full non-Markovian noise processes. Moreover, we obtain conditions that are fulfilled when an ASF displays authentic non-Markovian deviations. Finally, we show that even though gate-dependence does not translate into a perturbative term within the ASF, as in the Markovian case, the non-Markovian sequence fidelity nevertheless remains stable under small gate-dependent perturbations.

arXiv:2202.11338•Quantum•Dec 1, 2022•17 citations

Characterization of Quantum Gate Noise Using Randomized Benchmarking

Goutam Paul

Benchmarking noise in quantum gates is crucial for developing dependable quantum computers, as noise directly affects gate fidelity and computational accuracy. Randomized benchmarking (RB) protocols, which evaluate performance through random gate sequences, provide a reliable way to quantify average error rates due to their scalability and robustness in averaging out complex, device-specific noise. In this talk, we will discuss several variants of randomized benchmarking protocols including an overview of our recent work in this area.

River Publishers eBooks•Jan 26, 2026•0 citations

On Realistic Errors in Quantum Computers

Joshua Skanes-Norman

In this thesis, we are concerned with the problem of characterizing noise associated with implementations of quantum circuits. We first explore the notion of error rates of quantum circuits and argue that the semantic distinction between process fidelity as “average error rate” and diamond distance as “worst-case error rate” is wrong. To this end, we analyze their worst-case and average analogies, and show they are proportional to their original measures. We show that the non-unital contributions to the diamond distance are negligible and the discrepancy between the process fidelity and diamond distance is primarily due to unitary errors. \n \nWe then turn to a new analysis of cycle benchmarking, a randomized benchmarking-like protocol to estimate the process fidelity of a cycle as engineered by randomized compiling. Using this approach, we prove that gate-dependent noise on the randomized gates is de- scribed by a single perturbation term that decays rapidly as long as the implementation is close to a representation. We also comment on how the protocol can be extended to qudits, what the cycle benchmarking decay actually measures, and how our analysis is amenable to the Fourier analysis of randomized benchmarking. We end with a discussion of how the gate-dependent cycle benchmarking process fidelity relates to gate-dependent randomized compiling.

•May 27, 2021•0 citations
As quantum devices are progressively scaled and refined, quantum codes will become indispensable to guarantee reliable computation in the presence of noise. Due to the difficulties of characterizing physical noise, direct measures of logical performance will be of paramount use to tune quantum codes [18]. Logical Randomized Benchmarking in [5] aimed to characterize the logical operations directly by performing randomized benchmarking using logical operators and following each operation with perfect QEC. However, due to resource limitations, physical implementations such as [14] only measure the syndrome at the end of a computation. \n \nWe develop a generalized framework for procedures that measure the fidelity of logical operations directly, logical fidelity estimation (LFE). We identify several freedoms that arise when attempting to define a fidelity which characterizes quantum error correction, specifically, in how error detection events are processed and in how often error correction is performed. We explore these freedoms by conducting a survey to eliminate inviable procedures guided by the presence of upticks, a standard signature of non-Markovianity [33]. Our survey highlights procedures that are robust to gate-dependent noise and procedures which are implementable in the near-term. We recommend applying post-selection after each gate as a benchmark for quantum codes which is robust to gate-dependent noise. We manage to eliminate some naive near-term protocols, but guaranteeing the robustness when QEC is applied at a at fixed time or when post-selection is applied at the end, are open problems.
Logical qubits encoded in quantum error correcting codes can exhibit non-Markovian dynamical evolution, even when the underlying physical noise is Markovian. To understand this emergent non-Markovianity, we define a Markovianity condition appropriate to logical gate operations, and study it by relating logical operations to their physical implementation (operations on the data qubits into which the logical qubit is encoded). We apply our analysis to small quantum codes, and show that they exhibit non-Markovian dynamics even for very simple physical noise models. We show that non-Markovianity can emerge from Markovian physical operations if (and only if) the physical qubits are not necessarily returned to the code subspace after every round of QEC. In this situation, the syndrome qubits can act as a memory, mediating time correlations and enabling violation of the Markov condition. We quantify the emergent non-Markovianity in simple examples, and propose sufficient conditions for reliable use of gate-based characterization techniques like gate set tomography in early fault-tolerant quantum devices.
Abstract A crucial task to obtain optimal and reliable quantum devices is to quantify their overall performance. The average fidelity of quantum gates is a particular figure of merit that can be estimated efficiently by randomized benchmarking (RB). However, the concept of gate-fidelity itself relies on the crucial assumption that noise behaves in a predictable, time-local, or so-called Markovian manner, whose breakdown can naturally become the leading source of errors as quantum devices scale in size and depth. We analytically show that error suppression techniques such as dynamical decoupling (DD) and Pauli-twirling can operationally Markovianize RB: (i) fast DD reduces non-Markovian RB to an exponential decay plus longer-time corrections, while on the other hand, (ii) Pauli-twirling generally does not affect the average, but (iii) it always suppresses the variance of such RB outputs. We demonstrate these effects numerically with a qubit noise model. Our results show that simple and efficient error suppression methods can simultaneously tame non-Markovian noise and allow for standard and reliable gate quality estimation, a fundamentally important task in the path toward fully functional quantum devices.
Extrapolating physical error rates to logical error rates requires many assumptions and thus can radically under- or overestimate the performance of an error correction implementation. We introduce logical randomized benchmarking, a characterization procedure that directly assesses the performance of a quantum error correction implementation at the logical level, and is motivated by a reduction to the well-studied case of physical randomized benchmarking. We show that our method reliably reports logical performance and can estimate the average probability of correctable and uncorrectable errors for a given code and physical channel.
The rapid progress in the development of quantum devices is in large part due to the availability of a wide range of characterization techniques allowing to probe, test and adjust them. Nevertheless, these methods often make use of approximations that hold in rather simplistic circumstances. In particular, assuming that error mechanisms stay constant in time and have no dependence in the past, is something that will be impossible to do as quantum processors continue scaling up in depth and size. We establish a theoretical framework for the Randomized Benchmarking protocol encompassing temporally-correlated, so-called non-Markovian noise, at the gate level, for any gate set belonging to a wide class of finite groups. We obtain a general expression for the Average Sequence Fidelity (ASF) and propose a way to obtain average gate fidelities of full non-Markovian noise processes. Moreover, we obtain conditions that are fulfilled when an ASF displays authentic non-Markovian deviations. Finally, we show that even though gate-dependence does not translate into a perturbative term within the ASF, as in the Markovian case, the non-Markovian sequence fidelity nevertheless remains stable under small gate-dependent perturbations.
Benchmarking noise in quantum gates is crucial for developing dependable quantum computers, as noise directly affects gate fidelity and computational accuracy. Randomized benchmarking (RB) protocols, which evaluate performance through random gate sequences, provide a reliable way to quantify average error rates due to their scalability and robustness in averaging out complex, device-specific noise. In this talk, we will discuss several variants of randomized benchmarking protocols including an overview of our recent work in this area.
In this thesis, we are concerned with the problem of characterizing noise associated with implementations of quantum circuits. We first explore the notion of error rates of quantum circuits and argue that the semantic distinction between process fidelity as “average error rate” and diamond distance as “worst-case error rate” is wrong. To this end, we analyze their worst-case and average analogies, and show they are proportional to their original measures. We show that the non-unital contributions to the diamond distance are negligible and the discrepancy between the process fidelity and diamond distance is primarily due to unitary errors. \n \nWe then turn to a new analysis of cycle benchmarking, a randomized benchmarking-like protocol to estimate the process fidelity of a cycle as engineered by randomized compiling. Using this approach, we prove that gate-dependent noise on the randomized gates is de- scribed by a single perturbation term that decays rapidly as long as the implementation is close to a representation. We also comment on how the protocol can be extended to qudits, what the cycle benchmarking decay actually measures, and how our analysis is amenable to the Fourier analysis of randomized benchmarking. We end with a discussion of how the gate-dependent cycle benchmarking process fidelity relates to gate-dependent randomized compiling.