Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Butlerov Communications

Theoretical and empirical justification of hydrogen atom planetary model

Aleksey A. Potapov

Published Apr 30, 2019• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The basis for the hydrogen atom planetary model, which represents the development of the Rutherford-Bohr atom model, is presented. The measurements of the atom polarizability, radius, electric and magnetic moments, as well as the Stark and Zeeman effects are given as an argument. The central paragraph of the Article is a comparison of the binding energy obtained based on wave measurement data (the Rydberg constant) and the binding energy obtained by calculation according to the data of the electron charge and mass fundamental constants and applying the principle of momentum conservation. The substantiation of the atom stability is given proceeding from the atom planetary model. The nature and mechanism of the optical spectrum formation is discussed. The substantiation of the fine structure of the hydrogen atom spectral lines is presented, proceeding from the fundamental association between the electric field strength of the electron charge and the speed of its velocity. The origin of the optical spectrum hyperfine structure is discussed within the planetary model. The difficulty in constructing an acceptable theory of the electronic structure of atoms is primarily due to the complexity of obtaining direct information on the atoms internal structure. The point is that the outermost electron shell of an atom behaves itself like an effective screen for external probing electrical fields. This circumstance sharply limits the possibilities of experimental methods for studying the intra-atomic structure. On the other hand, it is imperative that the research methods being employed be non-destructive ones in order to obtain reliable information concerning the structure of atoms. This means that the action on the atom during measurement process must meet the condition of the electron shell perturbation smallness of the atom or ion being investigated. Concerns associated with the inaccessibility of the electronic structure of atoms served as a pretext for a conclusion of the limited possibilities of the empirical method of knowing the internal structure of atoms at the proper time.

DOI
10.37952/roi-jbc-01/19-58-4-1

Related papers

The Non-relativistic Hydrogen Atom

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

One must always do what one really cannot. —Niels Bohr A groundbreaking event in the development of the quantum theory of atomic structure is the remarkable discovery by Johann Jacob Balmer in 1884. He figured out that Anders Jonas Angstrom's measurements of the wavelengths = 4101.2, 4340.1, 4860.74, and 6562.10 Å of the four prominent lines in the spectrum of the hydrogen atom fit the formula, where b = 3645.6 Å, and n = 3, 4, 5, 6. This is an outstanding illustration of the arithmetic genius that Balmer was, being an arithmetic teacher in a girls’ school. Balmer's formula was independently rediscovered by Johannes Robert Rydberg six years later, and rationalized in the planetary model of the old quantum theory proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913. Orbits, however, are intangible, position and momentum measurements not being compatible. Solution to the Schrödinger equation with appropriate boundary conditions satisfactorily account for the Balmer–Rydberg–Bohr formula, explaining the discrete eigenenergies of the hydrogen atom. In Section 5.1, we discuss the bound-state solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. However, the Schrödinger equation does not fully account for the degeneracy of the energy levels of (even the nonrelativistic) hydrogen atom. This bemusing condition is addressed in the Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of this chapter, and the continuum eigenfunctions are discussed in Section 5.4. 5.1 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Hydrogen Atom As the very first atom in the periodic table, the hydrogen atom is the simplest one. It is the prototype of one-electron central field atomic systems (including ions) for which exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation can be obtained. The electron–proton two-particles Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom is where and are respectively the notional position vectors in a laboratory frame of reference of the electron and the proton, and m e and m p their respective masses. The gradient operators and seek space derivatives with respect to the electron and the proton coordinates respectively, and the interaction potential energy operator depends on the relative distance between the two particles. The center of mass of the two particles is located at and the reduced mass which is located at the position vector with respect to the center of mass.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

The Quantum of Action and Atomic Models

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations

Derivations

R.C. Olsen

The existence of line spectra can be explained bymeans of the first “quantum”model of the atom, developed by Bohr in 1913. Although the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom was eventually replaced, it yields the correct values for the observed spectral lines, and gives a substantial insight into the structure of atoms in general. The following derivation has the objective of obtaining the energy levels of the Bohr atom. If we can obtain the energy levels, we can reproduce the hydrogen atom spectra. The derivation proceeds with three major elements: first, use force balance to relate the velocity to the radius of the electron orbit, then use a quantum assumption to get the radius, then solve for the energies.

SPIE eBooks•Mar 16, 2010•0 citations

Theory of Atomic Structure and Spin of Electron

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

One of the main aims of the quantum theory was to clarify the atomic structure by making use of the various atomic phenomena as clues. On the basis of the success of Bohr's theory of the hydrogen atom, many kinds of challenge were made one after another. Generally speaking, the clarification of the atomic structure was proceeded through two ways. One way was based on the results in the spectroscopy of X-rays as well as light. The other was one that brought the phenomenological summaries of valuable chemical knowledge, such as represented by Mendelev's table of periodicity in 1869, to a substantialistic stage by analyzing them in connection with the atomic structure. This was the stage that became at length realizable on account of the progress in the quantum theory. The old quantum mechanics, which was developed on the basis of the quantum condition and selection rule, encountered with the difficulty of the factor 2. That is, firstly, the analyses of the anomalous Zeeman effect required half-integer quantum numbers and the anomalous coefficient 2 of magnetic moment. Secondly, in Stern-Gerlach's experiment, which was interpreted as proving the directional quantization, the atomic beam split into two components, instead of three components as in the normal Zeeman effect. Thirdly, the results of experiments on magnetization of matter demanded such a value for the specific charge of the electron as was twice as large as the value hitherto known. The analysis of X-ray spectra brought into existence another kind of spectral fine structure different from the relativistic fine structure. Of the substantialistic processes in which these problems were thrown into relief, not enough analyses have hitherto been made in the field of the history of science. Of the developments through which these problems were brought to solution, more or less similar situation has been seen. Bohr was in doubt about the half-integer quantum number and thus sought to solve the problem in terms of "non-mechanical constraint", introducing two kinds of azimuthal quantum numbers to treat the atomic structure. It was made clear by Landé and by Millikan and Bowen, however, that this was contradictory to experimental observations. Stoner then revised, with the use of half-integer quantum number, Bohr's scheme of configuration of electrons in atoms. This revision opened the way to Pauli's proposal of the exclusion principle and Uhlenbeck-Goudsmidt's introduction of the spin of the electron.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations

A Review of Research Achievements and Their Applications on the Essence of Electron Spin

Runsheng Tu

A model of the electronic internal structure has been developed, revealing the specific movement mode of electrons outside the nucleus. Building on this, the Bohr's planetary model of the hydrogen atom has been adapted into the Saturn model, suitable for describing multi-center and multi-electron bound systems. It has been discovered that the mathematical formalism of Bohr's old quantum theory and wave mechanics are compatible. A quantum chemistry method has been established to implement this compatibility (where the Saturn model and wave mechanics can complement each other), using this method, the energy eigenvalues of s electrons in atoms and the binding energies and bond lengths of four diatomic molecules such as hydrogen molecules have been successfully calculated. This provides new insights into material structure theory. The aforementioned compatibility could lead to the birth of local realism quantum mechanics.

Advances in Theoretical & Computational Physics•Nov 18, 2024•2 citations

Quantum Numbers of the Electron

Ibrahima Sakho

This chapter helps readers to gain knowledge on the properties of the quantum numbers of the electron. It explains how to use the empirical Balmer formula and the Ritz combination principle. The chapter describes the main limitations of the planetary model of the atom and the shell model of electron configurations. It then states the two postulates of Bohr's theory, describes Planck's linear oscillator in the phase space, deduces Bohr's quantization principle using Planck's linear oscillator, and presents the energy level diagram for the hydrogen atom. Bohr's model is an important stage in understanding the quantum theory of the atom. This model introduces the principal quantum number and consistently explains the emission and absorption spectra of hydrogen-like systems. It is however a simplified model for describing the electron behavior in hydrogen-like systems. The chapter also explains Sommerfeld's atomic model, electron spin, and electron magnetic moments.

Wiley eBooks•Oct 11, 2019•0 citations
The basis for the hydrogen atom planetary model, which represents the development of the Rutherford-Bohr atom model, is presented. The measurements of the atom polarizability, radius, electric and magnetic moments, as well as the Stark and Zeeman effects are given as an argument. The central paragraph of the Article is a comparison of the binding energy obtained based on wave measurement data (the Rydberg constant) and the binding energy obtained by calculation according to the data of the electron charge and mass fundamental constants and applying the principle of momentum conservation. The substantiation of the atom stability is given proceeding from the atom planetary model. The nature and mechanism of the optical spectrum formation is discussed. The substantiation of the fine structure of the hydrogen atom spectral lines is presented, proceeding from the fundamental association between the electric field strength of the electron charge and the speed of its velocity. The origin of the optical spectrum hyperfine structure is discussed within the planetary model. The difficulty in constructing an acceptable theory of the electronic structure of atoms is primarily due to the complexity of obtaining direct information on the atoms internal structure. The point is that the outermost electron shell of an atom behaves itself like an effective screen for external probing electrical fields. This circumstance sharply limits the possibilities of experimental methods for studying the intra-atomic structure. On the other hand, it is imperative that the research methods being employed be non-destructive ones in order to obtain reliable information concerning the structure of atoms. This means that the action on the atom during measurement process must meet the condition of the electron shell perturbation smallness of the atom or ion being investigated. Concerns associated with the inaccessibility of the electronic structure of atoms served as a pretext for a conclusion of the limited possibilities of the empirical method of knowing the internal structure of atoms at the proper time.
One must always do what one really cannot. —Niels Bohr A groundbreaking event in the development of the quantum theory of atomic structure is the remarkable discovery by Johann Jacob Balmer in 1884. He figured out that Anders Jonas Angstrom's measurements of the wavelengths = 4101.2, 4340.1, 4860.74, and 6562.10 Å of the four prominent lines in the spectrum of the hydrogen atom fit the formula, where b = 3645.6 Å, and n = 3, 4, 5, 6. This is an outstanding illustration of the arithmetic genius that Balmer was, being an arithmetic teacher in a girls’ school. Balmer's formula was independently rediscovered by Johannes Robert Rydberg six years later, and rationalized in the planetary model of the old quantum theory proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913. Orbits, however, are intangible, position and momentum measurements not being compatible. Solution to the Schrödinger equation with appropriate boundary conditions satisfactorily account for the Balmer–Rydberg–Bohr formula, explaining the discrete eigenenergies of the hydrogen atom. In Section 5.1, we discuss the bound-state solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. However, the Schrödinger equation does not fully account for the degeneracy of the energy levels of (even the nonrelativistic) hydrogen atom. This bemusing condition is addressed in the Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of this chapter, and the continuum eigenfunctions are discussed in Section 5.4. 5.1 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Hydrogen Atom As the very first atom in the periodic table, the hydrogen atom is the simplest one. It is the prototype of one-electron central field atomic systems (including ions) for which exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation can be obtained. The electron–proton two-particles Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom is where and are respectively the notional position vectors in a laboratory frame of reference of the electron and the proton, and m e and m p their respective masses. The gradient operators and seek space derivatives with respect to the electron and the proton coordinates respectively, and the interaction potential energy operator depends on the relative distance between the two particles. The center of mass of the two particles is located at and the reduced mass which is located at the position vector with respect to the center of mass.
Einstein consider that in a new electromagnetic theory that would settle the problem of the self-energy of electron, the Planck constant h would be given in terms of the elementary electric charge and light velocity. In contrast to this, Haas supposed that h could be deduced from the atomic radius assumed in the Thomson model of the atom and the charge and mass of electron. In connection with this, it should be greatly appreciated concerning in the history of the formation of quantum mechanics that Sommerfeld gave the view that the existence of the molecule is the function and result of the existence of h. It should never be forgotten also that, different from Ritz who tried to explain the combination rule of spectral lines with special mathematical models, Nicholson followed Sommerfeld's view to discuss the spectra of coronae of the sun on the basis of an atomic model of the Nagaoka type with several electrons, in which no assumption is made of the atomic radius, and came to point out the existence of the quantum nature of angular momentum due to h, together with an estimation of the atomic radius. Bohr, who determined the number of electrons in the hydrogen atom from his analysis of the energy loss of α-rays through hydrogen gas, and thus understood that the problem of the stability of atoms could not be solved with the classical mechanics, presented the Bohr model of the atom, in which the existence of atomic discrete energy levels results from the quantum nature of angular momentum, and the combination rule of spectral lines is grasped with the frequency relation.
The existence of line spectra can be explained bymeans of the first “quantum”model of the atom, developed by Bohr in 1913. Although the Bohr model of the hydrogen atom was eventually replaced, it yields the correct values for the observed spectral lines, and gives a substantial insight into the structure of atoms in general. The following derivation has the objective of obtaining the energy levels of the Bohr atom. If we can obtain the energy levels, we can reproduce the hydrogen atom spectra. The derivation proceeds with three major elements: first, use force balance to relate the velocity to the radius of the electron orbit, then use a quantum assumption to get the radius, then solve for the energies.
One of the main aims of the quantum theory was to clarify the atomic structure by making use of the various atomic phenomena as clues. On the basis of the success of Bohr's theory of the hydrogen atom, many kinds of challenge were made one after another. Generally speaking, the clarification of the atomic structure was proceeded through two ways. One way was based on the results in the spectroscopy of X-rays as well as light. The other was one that brought the phenomenological summaries of valuable chemical knowledge, such as represented by Mendelev's table of periodicity in 1869, to a substantialistic stage by analyzing them in connection with the atomic structure. This was the stage that became at length realizable on account of the progress in the quantum theory. The old quantum mechanics, which was developed on the basis of the quantum condition and selection rule, encountered with the difficulty of the factor 2. That is, firstly, the analyses of the anomalous Zeeman effect required half-integer quantum numbers and the anomalous coefficient 2 of magnetic moment. Secondly, in Stern-Gerlach's experiment, which was interpreted as proving the directional quantization, the atomic beam split into two components, instead of three components as in the normal Zeeman effect. Thirdly, the results of experiments on magnetization of matter demanded such a value for the specific charge of the electron as was twice as large as the value hitherto known. The analysis of X-ray spectra brought into existence another kind of spectral fine structure different from the relativistic fine structure. Of the substantialistic processes in which these problems were thrown into relief, not enough analyses have hitherto been made in the field of the history of science. Of the developments through which these problems were brought to solution, more or less similar situation has been seen. Bohr was in doubt about the half-integer quantum number and thus sought to solve the problem in terms of "non-mechanical constraint", introducing two kinds of azimuthal quantum numbers to treat the atomic structure. It was made clear by Landé and by Millikan and Bowen, however, that this was contradictory to experimental observations. Stoner then revised, with the use of half-integer quantum number, Bohr's scheme of configuration of electrons in atoms. This revision opened the way to Pauli's proposal of the exclusion principle and Uhlenbeck-Goudsmidt's introduction of the spin of the electron.
A model of the electronic internal structure has been developed, revealing the specific movement mode of electrons outside the nucleus. Building on this, the Bohr's planetary model of the hydrogen atom has been adapted into the Saturn model, suitable for describing multi-center and multi-electron bound systems. It has been discovered that the mathematical formalism of Bohr's old quantum theory and wave mechanics are compatible. A quantum chemistry method has been established to implement this compatibility (where the Saturn model and wave mechanics can complement each other), using this method, the energy eigenvalues of s electrons in atoms and the binding energies and bond lengths of four diatomic molecules such as hydrogen molecules have been successfully calculated. This provides new insights into material structure theory. The aforementioned compatibility could lead to the birth of local realism quantum mechanics.
This chapter helps readers to gain knowledge on the properties of the quantum numbers of the electron. It explains how to use the empirical Balmer formula and the Ritz combination principle. The chapter describes the main limitations of the planetary model of the atom and the shell model of electron configurations. It then states the two postulates of Bohr's theory, describes Planck's linear oscillator in the phase space, deduces Bohr's quantization principle using Planck's linear oscillator, and presents the energy level diagram for the hydrogen atom. Bohr's model is an important stage in understanding the quantum theory of the atom. This model introduces the principal quantum number and consistently explains the emission and absorption spectra of hydrogen-like systems. It is however a simplified model for describing the electron behavior in hydrogen-like systems. The chapter also explains Sommerfeld's atomic model, electron spin, and electron magnetic moments.