We present a new quantum-markovian model of two-alternative forced choice (2AFC) decision-making. We treatthe decision-making process as an accumulation of evidencebetween two competing alternatives, analogous to the drift dif-fusion model (DDM), in which the stimulus acts as a gener-ative process, emitting bits of information that are treated asquantum particles. The particles are acted on by a landscapedetermined by the agent’s experience with the task or stimu-lus, signal strength, and allocated cognitive control. We de-rive closed form expressions for success rates under both theinterrogation and free response paradigms. Under the free re-sponse paradigm, we show that this model reduces to a Markovprocess with closed form response time (RT) distributions thattake the form of inverse gaussians (IGs) with periodic noisecharacteristic to the task set. In the limit of long RT, the RTdistributions become smooth, recovering true IG distributionsanalogous to the standard DDM.
We present a new quantum-markovian model of two-alternative forced choice (2AFC) decision-making. We treatthe decision-making process as an accumulation of evidencebetween two competing alternatives, analogous to the drift dif-fusion model (DDM), in which the stimulus acts as a gener-ative process, emitting bits of information that are treated asquantum particles. The particles are acted on by a landscapedetermined by the agent’s experience with the task or stimu-lus, signal strength, and allocated cognitive control. We de-rive closed form expressions for success rates under both theinterrogation and free response paradigms. Under the free re-sponse paradigm, we show that this model reduces to a Markovprocess with closed form response time (RT) distributions thattake the form of inverse gaussians (IGs) with periodic noisecharacteristic to the task set. In the limit of long RT, the RTdistributions become smooth, recovering true IG distributionsanalogous to the standard DDM.
Abstract Tools from quantum theory have been effectively leveraged in modeling otherwise poorly understood effects in decision-making such as apparent fallacies in probability judgments and context effects. This approach has described the dynamics of two alternative forced choice (2AFC) decisions in terms of the path of a single quantum particle evolving in a single potential well. Here, we present a variant on that approach, which we name the Multi-Particle and Multi-Well (MPMW) quantum cognitive framework, in which decisions among N alternatives are treated by the sum of positional measurements of many independent quantum particles representing stimulus information, acted on by an N-well landscape that defines the decision alternatives. In this article, we apply the MPMW model to the simplest and most common case of N-alternative decision making, 2AFC dynamics. This application calls for a multi-particle double-well implementation, which allows us to construct a simple, analytically tractable discrete drift diffusion model (DDM), in the form of a Markov chain, wherein the parameters of the attractor wells reflect bottom-up (automatic) and top-down (control-dependent) influences on the integration of external information. We first analyze this Markov chain in its simplest form, as a single integrator with a generative process arising from a static quantum landscape and fixed thresholds, and then consider the case of multi-integrator processing under the same conditions. Within this system, stochasticity arises directly from the double-well quantum attractor landscape as a function of the dimensions of its wells, rather than as an external parameter requiring independent fitting. The simplicity of the Markov chain component of this model allows for easy analytical computation of closed forms for response time distributions and response probabilities that match qualitative properties of the accuracies and reaction times of humans performing 2AFC tasks. The MPMW framework produces response time distributions following inverse gaussian curves familiar from previous DDM models and empirical data, including the common observation that mean response times are faster for incorrect than for correct responses. The work presented in this paper serves as a proof of concept, based on which the MPMW framework can be extended to address more complex decision-making processes, (e.g., N-alternative forced choice, dynamic control allocation, and nesting quantum landscapes to allow for modeling at both the task and stimulus levels of processing) that we discuss as future directions.
We present a quantum cognitive model that can be implemented on a quantum machine. This model uses solutions of the Schrödinger equation to model human cognitive control and decision making in a standard paradigm in psychology: the two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) task, where participants are forced to choose between two competing alternatives. In the model, the two alternatives map to a multiple square well potential energy function. The depths of the wells correspond to attentional control, while the widths corresponds to features of the stimulus. Using this potential energy, the time-independent Schrodinger equation can be solved for an energy eigenstate basis of the bound states of the system, with higher energies corresponding to higher levels of focus. The full time-dependent Hamiltonian involves an oscillating field that evolves the system from ground state to superpositions of the excited states. The probabilities of the choices in the task are calculated as the probability of finding particles in a particular potential well. Furthermore, the quantum framing of this problem makes this problem suitable for mapping to quantum computing implementations. The state of the system follows the trajectory of a ground state, which can be mapped to a variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) implementation. Meanwhile, the time-dependency and oscillating field can be simulated using current quantum simulation methods and Rabi oscillations. Since our problems can be mapped onto currently-available NISQ prototypes of 2040 qubits, they represent an application domain with tractable near-term quantum-computing resource requirements.
Sequential sampling models have provided accurate accounts of people’s choice, response time, and preference strength in value-based decision-making tasks. Conventionally, these models are developed as Markov-type processes (such as random walks or diffusion processes) following the Kolmogorov axioms. Quantum probability theory has been proposed as an alternative framework upon which to develop models of cognition, including quantum random walk models. When modeling people's behavior during decision-making tasks, previous work has demonstrated that both the Markov and quantum models have their respective strengths. Recently, the open system model, which is a hybrid version of the Markov and quantum models, has been shown to provide a more accurate account of preference strength compared to the Markov and quantum models in isolation. In this work, we extend the open system model to make predictions on pairwise choice and response time and compare it to the Markov and quantum random walkmodels.
We present a short review of discrete-time quantum walks (DTQW) as a potentially useful and rich formalism to model human decision-making. We present a pedagogical introduction of the underlying formalism and main structural properties. We suggest that DTQW are particularly suitable for combining the two strands of literature on evidence accumulator models and on the quantum formalism of cognition. Due to the additional spin degree of freedom, models based on DTQW allow for a natural modeling of model choice and confidence rating in separate bases. Levels of introspection and self-assessment during choice deliberations can be modeled by the introduction of a probability for measurement of either position and/or spin of the DTQW, where each measurement act leads to a partial decoherence (corresponding to a step towards rationalization) of the deliberation process. We show how quantum walks predict observed probabilistic misperception like S-shaped subjective probability and conjunction fallacy. Our framework emphasizes the close relationship between response times and type of preferences and of responses. In particular, decision theories based on DTQW do not need to invoke two systems ("fast" and "slow") as in dual process theories. Within our DTQW framework, the two fast and slow systems are replaced by a single system, but with two types of self-assessment or introspection. The "thinking fast" regime is obtained with no or little self-assessment, while the "thinking slow" regime corresponds to a strong rate of self-assessment. We predict a trade-off between speed and accuracy, as empirically reported.
We present a quantum cognitive model that integrates the influence of cognitive control into human perceptual decision-making. The model employs a multiple-square-well potential, where each well corresponds to a distinct decision outcome. In this framework, well depth encodes signal strength, while well width represents the domain generality of the outcome. The probability of particle localization within each well determines the subjective probability, which subsequently drives a standard Markovian evidence accumulation process to predict empirical choice and response times. We validate the model using the classic dot motion two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) task. The model successfully replicates key empirical findings of the task, such as the correlation between motion coherence and drift rates. Furthermore, we apply the model to the Yerkes-Dodson law, capturing the approximate inverted U-shaped relationship between task accuracy and cognitive arousal. We compare two theoretical approaches to modeling arousal (1) as eigenenergy values and (2) as kinetic energy terms, contrasting their qualitative predictions regarding the Yerkes-Dodson law. Our work provides the first quantitative model of arousal's influence on human perceptual decision-making and establishes a foundation for determining the exact functional form of the Yerkes-Dodson law.
What kind of dynamic decision process do humans use to make decisions? In this article, two different types of processes are reviewed and compared: Markov and quantum. Markov processes are based on the idea that at any given point in time a decision maker has a definite and specific level of support for available choice alternatives, and the dynamic decision process is represented by a single trajectory that traces out a path across time. When a response is requested, a person's decision or judgment is generated from the current location along the trajectory. By contrast, quantum processes are founded on the idea that a person's state can be represented by a superposition over different degrees of support for available choice options, and that the dynamics of this state form a wave moving across levels of support over time. When a response is requested, a decision or judgment is constructed out of the superposition by "actualizing" a specific degree or range of degrees of support to create a definite state. The purpose of this article is to introduce these two contrasting theories, review empirical studies comparing the two theories, and identify conditions that determine when each theory is more accurate and useful than the other. This article is categorized under: Economics > Individual Decision-Making Psychology > Reasoning and Decision Making Psychology > Theory and Methods.