Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Symmetry

Modern State of the Pauli Exclusion Principle and the Problems of Its Theoretical Foundation

Ilya G. Kaplan

Published Dec 24, 2020• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Pauli exclusion principle (PEP) can be considered from two aspects. First, it asserts that particles that have half-integer spin (fermions) are described by antisymmetric wave functions, and particles that have integer spin (bosons) are described by symmetric wave functions. It is called spin-statistics connection (SSC). The physical reasons why SSC exists are still unknown. On the other hand, PEP is not reduced to SSC and can be consider from another aspect, according to it, the permutation symmetry of the total wave function can be only of two types: symmetric or antisymmetric. They both belong to one-dimensional representations of the permutation group, while other types of permutation symmetry are forbidden. However, the solution of the Schrödinger equation may have any permutation symmetry. We analyze this second aspect of PEP and demonstrate that proofs of PEP in some wide-spread textbooks on quantum mechanics, basing on the indistinguishability principle, are incorrect. The indistinguishability principle is insensitive to the permutation symmetry of wave function. So, it cannot be used as a criterion for the PEP verification. However, as follows from our analysis of possible scenarios, the permission of states with permutation symmetry more general than symmetric and antisymmetric leads to contradictions with the concepts of particle identity and their independence. Thus, the existence in our Nature particles only in symmetric and antisymmetric permutation states is not accidental, since all symmetry options for the total wave function, except the antisymmetric and symmetric, cannot be realized. From this an important conclusion follows, we may not expect that in future some unknown elementary particles that are not fermions or bosons can be discovered.

DOI
10.3390/sym13010021

Related papers

Can the Pauli Exclusion Principle Be Proved?

Ilya G. Kaplan

The general formulation of the Pauli Exclusion Principle can be considered from two viewpoints. It asserts that particles with half-integer spin (fermions) are described by antisymmetric wave functions and particles with integer spin (bosons) are described by symmetric wave functions. This is the so-called spin–statistics connection. According to it, only two types of permutation symmetry are allowed: symmetric and antisymmetric. The Schrodinger equation is invariant under any permutation of identical particles and its solutions may belong to any representation of the permutation group, including the multidimensional representations that are forbidden by the Pauli Exclusion Principle. This chapter discusses the case of a spinless Hamiltonian when the total spin S is a good quantum number and labels the energy levels of the system. The permission of multidimensional representations of the permutation group for the total wave function leads to contradictions with the concepts of particle identity and their independence.

Wiley eBooks•Nov 18, 2016•0 citations

Is the Pauli exclusive principle an independent quantum mechanical postulate?

Ilya G. Kaplan

Abstract Foundation of the Pauli exclusive principle is discussed. It is demonstrated that the indistinguishability principle is insensitive to the permutation symmetry of the wave function and cannot be used as a criterion for the verification of the Pauli exclusive principle. The heuristic arguments are given in favor that the existence in nature of only the nondegenerate permutation representations (symmetrical and antisymmetrical) is not occasional. As follows from our analysis of possible scenarios, the permission of degenerate permutation representations leads to contradictions with the concept of particle identity and their independence. Thus, the prohibition of degenerate permutation states by the Pauli exclusive principle follows from the general physical assumptions inside quantum theory, but the problem of spin–statistics connection is still open. It is pointed out that the Pauli exclusive principle and the Jahn–Teller effect have some similar features. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2002

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 2002•30 citations

The exclusion principle and indistinguishability of identical particles in quantum mechanics

Inna G Kaplan

The connection between the exclusion principle and the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles in quantum mechanics is discussed. It is shown with the aid of a density matrix defined for states with arbitrary permutation symmetry that the particles are indistinguishable only for one-dimensional representations of the permutation group (symmetrical and antisymmetrycal), and are distinguishable in all the states that are degenerate in the permutations. It is demonstrated by the same token that the exclusion principle follows from the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles and the Pauli theorem on the connection between spin and statistics.

Soviet Physics Uspekhi•Dec 31, 1975•17 citations

The Pauli Exclusion Principle: Origin, Verifications, and Applications

Ilya G. Kaplan

This is the first scientific book devoted to the Pauli Exclusion Principle, which is a fundamental principle of quantum mechanics and is permanently applied in chemistry, physics, molecular biology and in physical astronomy. However, while the principle has been studied for more than 90 years, rigorous theoretical foundations still have not been established and many unsolved problems remain. Following an introduction and historical survey, this book discusses the still unresolved questions around this fundamental principle. For instance, why, according to the Pauli Exclusion Principle, are only symmetric and antisymmetric permutation symmetries for identical particles realized, while the Schrödinger equation is satisfied by functions with any permutation symmetry? Chapter 3 covers possible answers to this, while chapter 4 presents effective and elegant methods for finding the Pauli-allowed states in atomic, molecular and nuclear spectroscopy. Chapter 5 discusses parastatistics and fractional statistics, demonstrating that the quasiparticles in a periodical lattice, including excitons and magnons, are obeying modified parafermi statistics. With detailed appendices, The Pauli Exclusion Principle: Origin, Verifications and Applications is intended as a self-sufficient guide for graduate students and academic researchers in the fields of quantum mechanics, theoretical chemistry, physics, and applied mathematics. It will be a valuable resource for any reader interested in the foundations of quantum mechanics and its applications in areas such as atomic and molecular spectroscopy, spintronics, molecular biology, and applied fields of quantum information.

•Jan 17, 2017•20 citations

Symmetry and statistics

Kenichi Konishi, Giampiero Paffuti

Abstract Two concepts, of fundamental importance to quantum mechanics, will be discussed in this chapter. The first is that of symmetry. Even though the concept of symmetry is familiar in a wide range of natural sciences, the way symmetry constrains the consequences of quantum mechanics is rather subtle and, at the same time, far-reaching. The second is the symmetry property of the states under the exchange of two identical particles. Identical particles with a half-integer spin (fermions) obey the Fermi–Dirac statistics: the wave functions are totally antisymmetric under the exchange of the particles. Identical particles with an integer spin (bosons) are instead subject to the Bose–Einstein statistics. Their wave functions are totally symmetric.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2009•0 citations

The Pauli Exclusion Principle and the Spin-Statistics Theorem from Worldline Non-Injectivity: Exchange Phase, Rapidity, and Topological Sheet Structure

Alex De Giuseppe

The Pauli Exclusion Principle and the Spin-Statistics Theorem from Worldline Non-Injectivity: Exchange Phase, Rapidity, and Topological Sheet Structure For nearly a century, the Pauli exclusion principle (PEP) and the spin-statistics theorem have stood as foundational postulates of quantum mechanics and relativistic quantum field theory. The PEP dictates that no two identical fermions can occupy the same quantum state, determining the structure of atoms, the stability of matter, and the properties of neutron stars and white dwarfs. The spin-statistics theorem connects the intrinsic spin of a particle to its statistical behavior: half-integer spin particles (fermions) obey Fermi-Dirac statistics, while integer spin particles (bosons) obey Bose-Einstein statistics. Despite their universal success, these principles have never been derived from a more primitive geometric or topological principle — until now. This paper demonstrates that both the Pauli exclusion principle and the spin-statistics theorem emerge naturally and rigorously from a single geometric fact: the **non-injectivity of a timelike worldline** for Lorentz factors exceeding a critical threshold, \(\gamma > \gamma_{\text{crit}}\). In this regime, a single worldline intersects a constant-time hypersurface \(\Sigma_t\) in \(N > 1\) distinct spatial points, generating a multi‑sheet spacetime structure. This phenomenon, known as **worldline non-injectivity**, is the foundation of the TPST–DGQ framework. **Key results and logical flow:** 1. **Multi‑sheet structure for a single particle:** For \(\gamma > \gamma_{\text{crit}}\), a particle's worldline produces \(N(\epsilon) \sim \epsilon^{-(d-2)}\) topological sheets, each carrying the same physical properties (mass, charge, spin) via the Ontological Identity Principle. 2. **Composite worldline for two identical particles:** By combining two identical particles into a composite worldline in configuration space, we obtain a two‑particle sheet structure. Identical particles share isomorphic sheet structures, reducing the \(N \times N\) sheet pairs to \(N\) independent pairs. 3. **Exchange as a permutation of sheet blocks:** The exchange operator \(P_{12}\) swaps the sheet blocks associated with the two particles. This permutation is a topological operation in the two‑particle configuration space. 4. **Exchange phase from winding number:** The exchange path corresponds to half of a complete winding cycle around the fold structure of the composite worldline. The accumulated topological phase is \(\Phi_{\text{exchange}} = \pi w\), where \(w\) is the **winding number** of the worldline. Hence the exchange phase factor is \(\eta = e^{i\pi w} = (-1)^w\). 5. **Spin from winding number:** The winding number \(w\) is directly related to the spin \(s\) by the requirement that a \(4\pi\) rotation returns the physical state to itself (single‑valuedness). This yields \(w = 2s\). Therefore \(\eta = (-1)^{2s}\): half‑integer spin gives \(\eta = -1\) (fermions, antisymmetric), integer spin gives \(\eta = +1\) (bosons, symmetric). This is the spin‑statistics theorem derived from geometry. 6. **Pauli exclusion principle:** For two identical fermions (\(\eta = -1\)) at spatial coincidence, the two‑particle amplitude satisfies \(\mathcal{A} = \eta\mathcal{A}\), forcing \(\mathcal{A} = 0\). Thus no two fermions can occupy the same quantum state. The PEP is no longer a postulate; it is a theorem. 7. **Rapidity as inter‑sheet phase measure:** The rapidity \(\zeta = \operatorname{artanh}(v/c)\) is shown to be a monotonic function of the inter‑sheet phase difference \(\Phi_n\). The non‑injectivity threshold \(\gamma > \gamma_{\text{crit}}\) corresponds to \(\zeta > \zeta_{\text{crit}}\). The speed of light \(c\) emerges as the asymptotic limit where the inter‑sheet phase diverges, making \(v = c\) unreachable for massive particles. 8. **Universal cancellation identity:** The same algebraic identity \(N(\epsilon)\cdot\epsilon^{d-2} = O(1)\) that regularizes holographic entropy, Coulomb self‑energy, wavefunction normalization, electromagnetic fields, and the cosmological constant also regularizes the two‑particle exchange amplitude — zero for fermions, finite for bosons. Quantum statistics thus joins the list of phenomena unified under the principle of worldline non‑injectivity. **Implications:** This work completes the derivation of the foundations of quantum mechanics within the TPST–DGQ framework, following previous derivations of the Born rule, the Schrödinger equation, Planck’s constant, and wavefunction collapse. It also establishes a geometric origin for the spin‑statistics connection, a result that in standard physics relies on the heavy machinery of relativistic quantum field theory (unitarity, causality, positivity of energy). Here, it follows from the topology of worldline folds. This manuscript is current in Official Peer Review. Not final version.Copyright©2026 Alex De Giuseppe.All rights reserved. This work is protected by copyright. Any form of plagiarism, unauthorized reproduction, or misappropriation of ideas, mathematically results, or text without proper citation constitutes a violation of academic and intellectual property standards and common laws. No commercial use, adaptation, or derivative works are permitted without explicit written permission from the author. For correspondence, citations, collaboration inquiries, or feedback please contact:degiuseppealex@gmail.com The hash files that determine ownership have been created.

•Apr 1, 2026•0 citations
The Pauli exclusion principle (PEP) can be considered from two aspects. First, it asserts that particles that have half-integer spin (fermions) are described by antisymmetric wave functions, and particles that have integer spin (bosons) are described by symmetric wave functions. It is called spin-statistics connection (SSC). The physical reasons why SSC exists are still unknown. On the other hand, PEP is not reduced to SSC and can be consider from another aspect, according to it, the permutation symmetry of the total wave function can be only of two types: symmetric or antisymmetric. They both belong to one-dimensional representations of the permutation group, while other types of permutation symmetry are forbidden. However, the solution of the Schrödinger equation may have any permutation symmetry. We analyze this second aspect of PEP and demonstrate that proofs of PEP in some wide-spread textbooks on quantum mechanics, basing on the indistinguishability principle, are incorrect. The indistinguishability principle is insensitive to the permutation symmetry of wave function. So, it cannot be used as a criterion for the PEP verification. However, as follows from our analysis of possible scenarios, the permission of states with permutation symmetry more general than symmetric and antisymmetric leads to contradictions with the concepts of particle identity and their independence. Thus, the existence in our Nature particles only in symmetric and antisymmetric permutation states is not accidental, since all symmetry options for the total wave function, except the antisymmetric and symmetric, cannot be realized. From this an important conclusion follows, we may not expect that in future some unknown elementary particles that are not fermions or bosons can be discovered.
The general formulation of the Pauli Exclusion Principle can be considered from two viewpoints. It asserts that particles with half-integer spin (fermions) are described by antisymmetric wave functions and particles with integer spin (bosons) are described by symmetric wave functions. This is the so-called spin–statistics connection. According to it, only two types of permutation symmetry are allowed: symmetric and antisymmetric. The Schrodinger equation is invariant under any permutation of identical particles and its solutions may belong to any representation of the permutation group, including the multidimensional representations that are forbidden by the Pauli Exclusion Principle. This chapter discusses the case of a spinless Hamiltonian when the total spin S is a good quantum number and labels the energy levels of the system. The permission of multidimensional representations of the permutation group for the total wave function leads to contradictions with the concepts of particle identity and their independence.
Abstract Foundation of the Pauli exclusive principle is discussed. It is demonstrated that the indistinguishability principle is insensitive to the permutation symmetry of the wave function and cannot be used as a criterion for the verification of the Pauli exclusive principle. The heuristic arguments are given in favor that the existence in nature of only the nondegenerate permutation representations (symmetrical and antisymmetrical) is not occasional. As follows from our analysis of possible scenarios, the permission of degenerate permutation representations leads to contradictions with the concept of particle identity and their independence. Thus, the prohibition of degenerate permutation states by the Pauli exclusive principle follows from the general physical assumptions inside quantum theory, but the problem of spin–statistics connection is still open. It is pointed out that the Pauli exclusive principle and the Jahn–Teller effect have some similar features. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2002
The connection between the exclusion principle and the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles in quantum mechanics is discussed. It is shown with the aid of a density matrix defined for states with arbitrary permutation symmetry that the particles are indistinguishable only for one-dimensional representations of the permutation group (symmetrical and antisymmetrycal), and are distinguishable in all the states that are degenerate in the permutations. It is demonstrated by the same token that the exclusion principle follows from the principle of indistinguishability of identical particles and the Pauli theorem on the connection between spin and statistics.
This is the first scientific book devoted to the Pauli Exclusion Principle, which is a fundamental principle of quantum mechanics and is permanently applied in chemistry, physics, molecular biology and in physical astronomy. However, while the principle has been studied for more than 90 years, rigorous theoretical foundations still have not been established and many unsolved problems remain. Following an introduction and historical survey, this book discusses the still unresolved questions around this fundamental principle. For instance, why, according to the Pauli Exclusion Principle, are only symmetric and antisymmetric permutation symmetries for identical particles realized, while the Schrödinger equation is satisfied by functions with any permutation symmetry? Chapter 3 covers possible answers to this, while chapter 4 presents effective and elegant methods for finding the Pauli-allowed states in atomic, molecular and nuclear spectroscopy. Chapter 5 discusses parastatistics and fractional statistics, demonstrating that the quasiparticles in a periodical lattice, including excitons and magnons, are obeying modified parafermi statistics. With detailed appendices, The Pauli Exclusion Principle: Origin, Verifications and Applications is intended as a self-sufficient guide for graduate students and academic researchers in the fields of quantum mechanics, theoretical chemistry, physics, and applied mathematics. It will be a valuable resource for any reader interested in the foundations of quantum mechanics and its applications in areas such as atomic and molecular spectroscopy, spintronics, molecular biology, and applied fields of quantum information.
Abstract Two concepts, of fundamental importance to quantum mechanics, will be discussed in this chapter. The first is that of symmetry. Even though the concept of symmetry is familiar in a wide range of natural sciences, the way symmetry constrains the consequences of quantum mechanics is rather subtle and, at the same time, far-reaching. The second is the symmetry property of the states under the exchange of two identical particles. Identical particles with a half-integer spin (fermions) obey the Fermi–Dirac statistics: the wave functions are totally antisymmetric under the exchange of the particles. Identical particles with an integer spin (bosons) are instead subject to the Bose–Einstein statistics. Their wave functions are totally symmetric.
The Pauli Exclusion Principle and the Spin-Statistics Theorem from Worldline Non-Injectivity: Exchange Phase, Rapidity, and Topological Sheet Structure For nearly a century, the Pauli exclusion principle (PEP) and the spin-statistics theorem have stood as foundational postulates of quantum mechanics and relativistic quantum field theory. The PEP dictates that no two identical fermions can occupy the same quantum state, determining the structure of atoms, the stability of matter, and the properties of neutron stars and white dwarfs. The spin-statistics theorem connects the intrinsic spin of a particle to its statistical behavior: half-integer spin particles (fermions) obey Fermi-Dirac statistics, while integer spin particles (bosons) obey Bose-Einstein statistics. Despite their universal success, these principles have never been derived from a more primitive geometric or topological principle — until now. This paper demonstrates that both the Pauli exclusion principle and the spin-statistics theorem emerge naturally and rigorously from a single geometric fact: the **non-injectivity of a timelike worldline** for Lorentz factors exceeding a critical threshold, γ>γcrit\gamma > \gamma_{\text{crit}}γ>γcrit​. In this regime, a single worldline intersects a constant-time hypersurface Σt\Sigma_tΣt​ in N>1N > 1N>1 distinct spatial points, generating a multi‑sheet spacetime structure. This phenomenon, known as **worldline non-injectivity**, is the foundation of the TPST–DGQ framework. **Key results and logical flow:** 1. **Multi‑sheet structure for a single particle:** For γ>γcrit\gamma > \gamma_{\text{crit}}γ>γcrit​, a particle's worldline produces N(ϵ)∼ϵ−(d−2)N(\epsilon) \sim \epsilon^{-(d-2)}N(ϵ)∼ϵ−(d−2) topological sheets, each carrying the same physical properties (mass, charge, spin) via the Ontological Identity Principle. 2. **Composite worldline for two identical particles:** By combining two identical particles into a composite worldline in configuration space, we obtain a two‑particle sheet structure. Identical particles share isomorphic sheet structures, reducing the N×NN \times NN×N sheet pairs to NNN independent pairs. 3. **Exchange as a permutation of sheet blocks:** The exchange operator P12P_{12}P12​ swaps the sheet blocks associated with the two particles. This permutation is a topological operation in the two‑particle configuration space. 4. **Exchange phase from winding number:** The exchange path corresponds to half of a complete winding cycle around the fold structure of the composite worldline. The accumulated topological phase is Φexchange=πw\Phi_{\text{exchange}} = \pi wΦexchange​=πw, where www is the **winding number** of the worldline. Hence the exchange phase factor is η=eiπw=(−1)w\eta = e^{i\pi w} = (-1)^wη=eiπw=(−1)w. 5. **Spin from winding number:** The winding number www is directly related to the spin sss by the requirement that a 4π4\pi4π rotation returns the physical state to itself (single‑valuedness). This yields w=2sw = 2sw=2s. Therefore η=(−1)2s\eta = (-1)^{2s}η=(−1)2s: half‑integer spin gives η=−1\eta = -1η=−1 (fermions, antisymmetric), integer spin gives η=+1\eta = +1η=+1 (bosons, symmetric). This is the spin‑statistics theorem derived from geometry. 6. **Pauli exclusion principle:** For two identical fermions (η=−1\eta = -1η=−1) at spatial coincidence, the two‑particle amplitude satisfies A=ηA\mathcal{A} = \eta\mathcal{A}A=ηA, forcing A=0\mathcal{A} = 0A=0. Thus no two fermions can occupy the same quantum state. The PEP is no longer a postulate; it is a theorem. 7. **Rapidity as inter‑sheet phase measure:** The rapidity ζ=artanh⁡(v/c)\zeta = \operatorname{artanh}(v/c)ζ=artanh(v/c) is shown to be a monotonic function of the inter‑sheet phase difference Φn\Phi_nΦn​. The non‑injectivity threshold γ>γcrit\gamma > \gamma_{\text{crit}}γ>γcrit​ corresponds to ζ>ζcrit\zeta > \zeta_{\text{crit}}ζ>ζcrit​. The speed of light ccc emerges as the asymptotic limit where the inter‑sheet phase diverges, making v=cv = cv=c unreachable for massive particles. 8. **Universal cancellation identity:** The same algebraic identity N(ϵ)⋅ϵd−2=O(1)N(\epsilon)\cdot\epsilon^{d-2} = O(1)N(ϵ)⋅ϵd−2=O(1) that regularizes holographic entropy, Coulomb self‑energy, wavefunction normalization, electromagnetic fields, and the cosmological constant also regularizes the two‑particle exchange amplitude — zero for fermions, finite for bosons. Quantum statistics thus joins the list of phenomena unified under the principle of worldline non‑injectivity. **Implications:** This work completes the derivation of the foundations of quantum mechanics within the TPST–DGQ framework, following previous derivations of the Born rule, the Schrödinger equation, Planck’s constant, and wavefunction collapse. It also establishes a geometric origin for the spin‑statistics connection, a result that in standard physics relies on the heavy machinery of relativistic quantum field theory (unitarity, causality, positivity of energy). Here, it follows from the topology of worldline folds. This manuscript is current in Official Peer Review. Not final version.Copyright©2026 Alex De Giuseppe.All rights reserved. This work is protected by copyright. Any form of plagiarism, unauthorized reproduction, or misappropriation of ideas, mathematically results, or text without proper citation constitutes a violation of academic and intellectual property standards and common laws. No commercial use, adaptation, or derivative works are permitted without explicit written permission from the author. For correspondence, citations, collaboration inquiries, or feedback please contact:degiuseppealex@gmail.com The hash files that determine ownership have been created.