Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Momentum Exchange in the Electron Double-Slit Experiment

Herman Batelaan, Eric Jones, Wayne Huang, Roger Bach

Published Jan 1, 2016• 13 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We provide support for the claim that momentum is conserved for individual events in the electron double slit experiment. The natural consequence is that a physical mechanism is responsible for this momentum exchange, but that even if the fundamental mechanism is known for electron crystal diffraction and the Kapitza–Dirac effect, it is unknown for electron diffraction from nano-fabricated double slits. Work towards a proposed explanation in terms of particle trajectories affected by a vacuum field is discussed. The contentious use of trajectories is discussed within the context of oil droplet analogues of double slit diffraction.

Related papers

Momentum exchange in the electron double-slit experiment

Herman Batelaan, Eric Jones, Wayne Cheng-Wei Huang +1 more

We provide support for the claim that momentum is conserved for individual events in the electron double slit experiment. The natural consequence is that a physical mechanism is responsible for this momentum exchange, but that even if the fundamental mechanism is known for electron crystal diffraction and the Kapitza-Dirac effect, it is unknown for electron diffraction from nano-fabricated double slits. Work towards a proposed explanation in terms of particle trajectories affected by a vacuum field is discussed. The contentious use of trajectories is discussed within the context of oil droplet analogues of double slit diffraction.

arXiv:2012.02141•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2016•18 citations

Explaining the Double-Slit Experiment

Moshe Wallace Callen, Shaul Sorek

In response to Orion and Laitman’s [1] explanation of the classic double-slit experiment of quantum mechanics, we propose an alternate explanation of that experiment by treating physical degrees of freedom as a conserved physical quantity, instead of referring to “vague terms” used in previous explanations, [1], that are not broadly applicable. Explanation in [1] refers to properties of groups of particles, even though the double-slit experiment’s results should address only to a single particle. By using physical degrees of freedom and the application of Hamilton’s principle, we obtain a single particle explanation of the double-slit experiment in terms of properties and via methods which apply equally in a quantum and a classical regime.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Quantum fluctuations and the double-slit experiment

Jaume Giné

The double-slit experiment is a demonstration of wave-particle duality and one of the most fundamental experiments that help us understand the nature of quantum mechanics. In this work, we give a new explanation of this experiment in terms of the uncertainty principle and vacuum fluctuations. This explanation allows one to understand why the electron interferes with itself when being shot through the double-slit.

Modern Physics Letters A•Apr 18, 2019•5 citations

A Unified Physical Mechanism of Electron Single-Slit and Double-Slit Diffraction Based on Electromagnetic Interaction and Particle Exchange at Slit Walls

Jiaqing Yan

The mainstream quantum mechanics uses “probability wave superposition and single-electron self-interference” to explain electron single-slit and double-slit diffraction. This theory deviates from the essential nature of real particle interactions and has fundamental logical flaws. The electron is a negatively charged real particle with a definite physical size and high-frequency transverse oscillation; a single real particle has no physical basis for self-interference. Abandoning the abstract probability wave hypothesis, this paper establishes a complete real-interaction model including electrostatic repulsion deflection, surface electron exchange, collision scattering, microscopic refraction, and barrier diffraction, based on the three-dimensional random transverse oscillation and charge repulsion of electrons. The model uniformly explains the real formation mechanism of electron single-slit diffraction and double-slit interference fringes. This paper proves that in single-electron sequential emission, each electron passes through only one slit; all bright and dark fringes are the statistical result of multiple microscopic interactions between electrons and slit walls or the central barrier. The disappearance of fringes under observation is caused by external disturbance to the inherent oscillation and wall-interaction equilibrium, not by wave function collapse. This paper further clarifies that whether an electron can pass through a slit is determined by its transverse oscillation amplitude, not by wavelength. Amplitude directly corresponds to slit width and is the core controlling variable of diffraction. Meanwhile, if no slit is placed, electrons flying directly to the screen produce no diffraction or interference fringes, proving that electrons themselves have no self-interference ability. Fringes are generated by slit structures, not by intrinsic wave interference of electrons. This study corrects the century-long misunderstanding of electron diffraction and establishes a new microscopic diffraction mechanism consistent with classical real-particle physics.

•May 30, 2026•0 citations

Taking quantisation seriously: a farewell to waves

Geoff Beck

The dual wave-particle nature of quantum objects is a notoriously unintuitive feature of quantum theories. However, it is often deemed essential, due to quantum objects exhibiting diffraction and interference. We extend the work of Landé and Lévy-Leblond to demonstrate that de Broglie wavelengths are not relativistically covariant as simultaneous spatial structures, making wave properties an unviable explanation of apparent interference. We then explore whether modern experiments vindicate an alternative view: that apparent waviness in diffraction and interference scenarios emerges as a consequence of quantised interactions between particles. Such a view has historically received very little attention, despite being the exact modern explanation of both the Kapitza-Dirac effect and ultrafast electron diffraction. We then study a photon orbital angular momentum realisation of the double slit to show that quantised exchanges can mimic interference. Finally, we demonstrate that the quantum formalism demands that particle momentum is determined at the point of scattering, contravening wave-based explanations of quantum interference.

arXiv:2503.14533•Mar 17, 2025•0 citations

Interaction of wave-driven particles with slit structures

C. Ellegaard, Mogens T. Levinsen

Just over a decade ago Couder and Fort [Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 154101 (2006)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.97.154101] published a provocative paper suggesting that a classical system might be able to simulate the truly fundamental quantum mechanical single- and double-slit experiment. The system they investigated was that of an oil droplet walking on a vibrated oil surface. Their results have since been challenged by Andersen et al. [Phys. Rev. E 92, 013006 (2015)PLEEE81539-375510.1103/PhysRevE.92.013006] by pointing to insufficient statistical support and a lack of experimental control over critical parameters. Here we show that the randomness in the original experiment is an artifact of lack of control. We present experimental data from an extensive scan of the parameter space of the system including the use of different size slits and tight control of critical parameters. For the single-slit we find very diverse samples of interference-like patterns but all causal by nature. This also holds for the double-slit. However, an extra interference effect appears here. The origin of this is investigated by blocking either the inlet or the outlet of one slit. Hereby we show that the extra interference is solely due to back-scatter of the associated wave field from the outlet of the slit not passed by the droplet. Recently Pucci et al. [J. Fluid Mech. 835, 1136 (2018)JFLSA70022-112010.1017/jfm.2017.790] using a much broader slit also showed that the classical system is basically causal. They, too, observed the extra interference effect for the double-slit. However, the reason behind was not determined. Moreover they claimed the existence of a chaotic regime just below the cri- tical acceleration for spontaneous generation of Faraday surface waves. Our measurements do not support the validity of this claim. However, the drop dynamics turns out to have an interesting multifaceted interaction with the slit structure.

arXiv:2005.12335•Physical review. E•Aug 26, 2020•32 citations
We provide support for the claim that momentum is conserved for individual events in the electron double slit experiment. The natural consequence is that a physical mechanism is responsible for this momentum exchange, but that even if the fundamental mechanism is known for electron crystal diffraction and the Kapitza–Dirac effect, it is unknown for electron diffraction from nano-fabricated double slits. Work towards a proposed explanation in terms of particle trajectories affected by a vacuum field is discussed. The contentious use of trajectories is discussed within the context of oil droplet analogues of double slit diffraction.
We provide support for the claim that momentum is conserved for individual events in the electron double slit experiment. The natural consequence is that a physical mechanism is responsible for this momentum exchange, but that even if the fundamental mechanism is known for electron crystal diffraction and the Kapitza-Dirac effect, it is unknown for electron diffraction from nano-fabricated double slits. Work towards a proposed explanation in terms of particle trajectories affected by a vacuum field is discussed. The contentious use of trajectories is discussed within the context of oil droplet analogues of double slit diffraction.
In response to Orion and Laitman’s [1] explanation of the classic double-slit experiment of quantum mechanics, we propose an alternate explanation of that experiment by treating physical degrees of freedom as a conserved physical quantity, instead of referring to “vague terms” used in previous explanations, [1], that are not broadly applicable. Explanation in [1] refers to properties of groups of particles, even though the double-slit experiment’s results should address only to a single particle. By using physical degrees of freedom and the application of Hamilton’s principle, we obtain a single particle explanation of the double-slit experiment in terms of properties and via methods which apply equally in a quantum and a classical regime.
The mainstream quantum mechanics uses “probability wave superposition and single-electron self-interference” to explain electron single-slit and double-slit diffraction. This theory deviates from the essential nature of real particle interactions and has fundamental logical flaws. The electron is a negatively charged real particle with a definite physical size and high-frequency transverse oscillation; a single real particle has no physical basis for self-interference. Abandoning the abstract probability wave hypothesis, this paper establishes a complete real-interaction model including electrostatic repulsion deflection, surface electron exchange, collision scattering, microscopic refraction, and barrier diffraction, based on the three-dimensional random transverse oscillation and charge repulsion of electrons. The model uniformly explains the real formation mechanism of electron single-slit diffraction and double-slit interference fringes. This paper proves that in single-electron sequential emission, each electron passes through only one slit; all bright and dark fringes are the statistical result of multiple microscopic interactions between electrons and slit walls or the central barrier. The disappearance of fringes under observation is caused by external disturbance to the inherent oscillation and wall-interaction equilibrium, not by wave function collapse. This paper further clarifies that whether an electron can pass through a slit is determined by its transverse oscillation amplitude, not by wavelength. Amplitude directly corresponds to slit width and is the core controlling variable of diffraction. Meanwhile, if no slit is placed, electrons flying directly to the screen produce no diffraction or interference fringes, proving that electrons themselves have no self-interference ability. Fringes are generated by slit structures, not by intrinsic wave interference of electrons. This study corrects the century-long misunderstanding of electron diffraction and establishes a new microscopic diffraction mechanism consistent with classical real-particle physics.
The dual wave-particle nature of quantum objects is a notoriously unintuitive feature of quantum theories. However, it is often deemed essential, due to quantum objects exhibiting diffraction and interference. We extend the work of Landé and Lévy-Leblond to demonstrate that de Broglie wavelengths are not relativistically covariant as simultaneous spatial structures, making wave properties an unviable explanation of apparent interference. We then explore whether modern experiments vindicate an alternative view: that apparent waviness in diffraction and interference scenarios emerges as a consequence of quantised interactions between particles. Such a view has historically received very little attention, despite being the exact modern explanation of both the Kapitza-Dirac effect and ultrafast electron diffraction. We then study a photon orbital angular momentum realisation of the double slit to show that quantised exchanges can mimic interference. Finally, we demonstrate that the quantum formalism demands that particle momentum is determined at the point of scattering, contravening wave-based explanations of quantum interference.
Just over a decade ago Couder and Fort [Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 154101 (2006)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.97.154101] published a provocative paper suggesting that a classical system might be able to simulate the truly fundamental quantum mechanical single- and double-slit experiment. The system they investigated was that of an oil droplet walking on a vibrated oil surface. Their results have since been challenged by Andersen et al. [Phys. Rev. E 92, 013006 (2015)PLEEE81539-375510.1103/PhysRevE.92.013006] by pointing to insufficient statistical support and a lack of experimental control over critical parameters. Here we show that the randomness in the original experiment is an artifact of lack of control. We present experimental data from an extensive scan of the parameter space of the system including the use of different size slits and tight control of critical parameters. For the single-slit we find very diverse samples of interference-like patterns but all causal by nature. This also holds for the double-slit. However, an extra interference effect appears here. The origin of this is investigated by blocking either the inlet or the outlet of one slit. Hereby we show that the extra interference is solely due to back-scatter of the associated wave field from the outlet of the slit not passed by the droplet. Recently Pucci et al. [J. Fluid Mech. 835, 1136 (2018)JFLSA70022-112010.1017/jfm.2017.790] using a much broader slit also showed that the classical system is basically causal. They, too, observed the extra interference effect for the double-slit. However, the reason behind was not determined. Moreover they claimed the existence of a chaotic regime just below the cri- tical acceleration for spontaneous generation of Faraday surface waves. Our measurements do not support the validity of this claim. However, the drop dynamics turns out to have an interesting multifaceted interaction with the slit structure.