Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Bootstrap embedding with an unrestricted mean-field bath

Henry K. Tran, Hong‐Zhou Ye, Troy Van Voorhis

Published Dec 1, 2020• 18 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A suite of quantum embedding methods have recently been developed where the Schmidt decomposition is applied to the full system wavefunction to derive basis states that preserve the entanglement between the fragment and the bath. The quality of these methods can depend heavily on the quality of the initial full system wavefunction. Most of these methods, including bootstrap embedding (BE) [M. Welborn et al; J. Chem. Phys. 145, 074102 (2016)], start from a spin-restricted mean-field wavefunction [call this restricted BE (RBE)]. Given that spin-unrestricted wavefunctions can capture a significant amount of strong correlation at the mean-field level, we suspect that starting from a spin-unrestricted mean-field wavefunction will improve these embedding methods for strongly correlated systems. In this work, BE is generalized to an unrestricted Hartree-Fock bath [call this unrestricted BE (UBE)], and UBE is applied to model hydrogen ring systems. UBE's improved versatility over RBE is utilized to calculate high spin symmetry states that were previously unattainable with RBE. Ionization potentials, electron affinities, and spin-splittings are computed using UBE with accuracy on par with spin-unrestricted coupled cluster singles and doubles. Even for cases where RBE is viable, UBE converges more reliably. We discuss the limitations or weaknesses of each calculation and how improvements to RBE and density matrix embedding theory these past few years can also improve UBE.

DOI
10.1063/5.0029092

Related papers

Bootstrap Embedding for Molecules

Hong‐Zhou Ye, Nathan D. Ricke, Henry K. Tran +1 more

Fragment embedding is one way to circumvent the high computational scaling of accurate electron correlation methods. The challenge of applying fragment embedding to molecular systems primarily lies in the strong entanglement and correlation that prevent accurate fragmentation across chemical bonds. Recently, Schmidt decomposition has been shown effective for embedding fragments that are strongly coupled to a bath in several model systems. In this work, we extend a recently developed quantum embedding scheme, bootstrap embedding (BE), to molecular systems. The resulting method utilizes the matching conditions naturally arising from using overlapping fragments to optimize the embedding. Numerical simulation suggests that the accuracy of the embedding improves rapidly with fragment size for small molecules, whereas larger fragments that include orbitals from different atoms may be needed for larger molecules. BE scales linearly with system size (apart from an integral transform) and hence can potentially be useful for large-scale calculations.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jul 25, 2019•64 citations

Bootstrap embedding: An internally consistent fragment-based method

Matthew Welborn, Takashi Tsuchimochi, Troy Van Voorhis

Strong correlation poses a difficult problem for electronic structure theory, with computational cost scaling quickly with system size. Fragment embedding is an attractive approach to this problem. By dividing a large complicated system into smaller manageable fragments "embedded" in an approximate description of the rest of the system, we can hope to ameliorate the steep cost of correlated calculations. While appealing, these methods often converge slowly with fragment size because of small errors at the boundary between fragment and bath. We describe a new electronic embedding method, dubbed "Bootstrap Embedding," a self-consistent wavefunction-in-wavefunction embedding theory that uses overlapping fragments to improve the description of fragment edges. We apply this method to the one dimensional Hubbard model and a translationally asymmetric variant, and find that it performs very well for energies and populations. We find Bootstrap Embedding converges rapidly with embedded fragment size, overcoming the surface-area-to-volume-ratio error typical of many embedding methods. We anticipate that this method may lead to a low-scaling, high accuracy treatment of electron correlation in large molecular systems.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Aug 15, 2016•101 citations

Bootstrap Embedding For Large Molecular Systems

Hong‐Zhou Ye, Henry K. Tran, Troy Van Voorhis

Recent developments in quantum embedding theories have provided attractive approaches to correlated calculations for large systems. In this work, we extend our previous work [ J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 4497–4506; J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2019, 10, 6368–6374] on bootstrap embedding (BE) to enable correlated ab initio calculations at the coupled cluster with singles and doubles (CCSD) level for large molecules. We introduce several new algorithmic developments that significantly reduce the computational cost of BE, while maintaining its accuracy. The resulting implementation scales as O ( N 3 ) for the integral transform and O ( N ) for the CCSD calculation. Numerical results on a series of conjugated molecules suggest that BE with reasonably sized fragments can recover more than 99.5% of the total correlation energy of a full CCSD calculation, while the required computational resources (time and storage) compare favorably to one popular local correlation scheme: domain localized pair natural orbital (DLPNO). The largest BE calculation in this work involves ∼2900 basis functions and can be performed on a single node with 16 CPU cores and 64 GB of memory in a few days. We anticipate that these developments represent an important step toward the application of BE to solve practical problems.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jun 26, 2020•44 citations

Energy-weighted density matrix embedding of open correlated chemical fragments

Edoardo Fertitta, George H. Booth

We present a multiscale approach to efficiently embed an ab initio correlated chemical fragment described by its energy-weighted density matrices and entangled with a wider mean-field many-electron system. This approach, first presented by Fertitta and Booth [Phys. Rev. B 98, 235132 (2018)], is here extended to account for realistic long-range interactions and broken symmetry states. The scheme allows for a systematically improvable description in the range of correlated fluctuations out of the fragment into the system, via a self-consistent optimization of a coupled auxiliary mean-field system. It is discussed that the method has rigorous limits equivalent to the existing quantum embedding approaches of both dynamical mean-field theory and density matrix embedding theory, to which this method is compared, and the importance of these correlated fluctuations is demonstrated. We derive a self-consistent local energy functional within the scheme and demonstrate the approach for hydrogen rings, where quantitative accuracy is achieved despite only a single atom being explicitly treated.

arXiv:1904.08019•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 3, 2019•41 citations

Density matrix embedding from broken symmetry lattice mean fields

Ireneusz W. Bulik, Gustavo E. Scuseria, J. Dukelsky

Several variants of the recently proposed density matrix embedding theory (DMET) [G. Knizia and G. K-L. Chan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 186404 (2012)] are formulated and tested. We show that spin symmetry breaking of the lattice mean-field allows precise control of the lattice and fragment filling while providing very good agreement between predicted properties and exact results. We present a rigorous proof that at convergence this method is guaranteed to preserve lattice and fragment filling. Differences arising from fitting the fragment one-particle density matrix alone versus fitting fragment plus bath are scrutinized. We argue that it is important to restrict the density matrix fitting to solely the fragment. Furthermore, in the proposed broken symmetry formalism, it is possible to substantially simplify the embedding procedure without sacrificing its accuracy by resorting to density instead of density matrix fitting. This simplified density embedding theory (DET) greatly improves the convergence properties of the algorithm.

arXiv:1310.0051•Physical Review B•Jan 27, 2014•127 citations

Merging symmetry projection with coupled cluster theory

Yiheng Qiu

The goal of electronic structure theory is to solve the time-independent Schrodinger equation with a method that scales polynomially with the system size. The problem has been solved in the weakly-correlated regime, where coupled cluster theory (CC) with singles, doubles and perturbative triples (CCSD(T)) can achieve chemical accuracy. However, in the strongly-correlated regime, where the two-body interaction dominates, there are still no methods that can achieve a comparable accomplishment. Strong correlation always comes hand in hand with spontaneous symmetry breaking in mean-field theory. For example, coupled cluster theory faces a symmetry dilemma in the strongly correlated regime, where it either completely fails to describe the system if symmetry adapted, or has to artificially break certain symmetries in order to produce reasonable energies. It is plausible that the problem of strong correlation can be solved by curing the symptoms, i.e., fixing the symmetries. Symmetry projection has been carried out at the mean-field level, but it was unclear until this work how to incorporate correlation on top of it because of the language barrier between symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory. This thesis is devoted to combining CC and symmetry projection, focusing on spin and number symmetry. Different flavours of theories are obtained depending on whether a restricted or unrestricted reference is used. On the restricted side, the spin projected unrestricted Hartree Fock (SUHF) state can be rewritten as a polynomial of particle-hole excitations, acting on the restricted reference. Thus, this formalism opens up many ways to combine SUHF with CC. One the unrestricted side, the concept of disentangled cluster is introduced to describe the CC wavefunction transformed by symmetry rotation. A scheme basing on differential equations is devised to approximate these disentangled clusters, which scales polynomially and is systematically improvable. By combining symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory, the symmetry dilemma can be solved to a good extent.

•Aug 31, 2018•0 citations
A suite of quantum embedding methods have recently been developed where the Schmidt decomposition is applied to the full system wavefunction to derive basis states that preserve the entanglement between the fragment and the bath. The quality of these methods can depend heavily on the quality of the initial full system wavefunction. Most of these methods, including bootstrap embedding (BE) [M. Welborn et al; J. Chem. Phys. 145, 074102 (2016)], start from a spin-restricted mean-field wavefunction [call this restricted BE (RBE)]. Given that spin-unrestricted wavefunctions can capture a significant amount of strong correlation at the mean-field level, we suspect that starting from a spin-unrestricted mean-field wavefunction will improve these embedding methods for strongly correlated systems. In this work, BE is generalized to an unrestricted Hartree-Fock bath [call this unrestricted BE (UBE)], and UBE is applied to model hydrogen ring systems. UBE's improved versatility over RBE is utilized to calculate high spin symmetry states that were previously unattainable with RBE. Ionization potentials, electron affinities, and spin-splittings are computed using UBE with accuracy on par with spin-unrestricted coupled cluster singles and doubles. Even for cases where RBE is viable, UBE converges more reliably. We discuss the limitations or weaknesses of each calculation and how improvements to RBE and density matrix embedding theory these past few years can also improve UBE.
Fragment embedding is one way to circumvent the high computational scaling of accurate electron correlation methods. The challenge of applying fragment embedding to molecular systems primarily lies in the strong entanglement and correlation that prevent accurate fragmentation across chemical bonds. Recently, Schmidt decomposition has been shown effective for embedding fragments that are strongly coupled to a bath in several model systems. In this work, we extend a recently developed quantum embedding scheme, bootstrap embedding (BE), to molecular systems. The resulting method utilizes the matching conditions naturally arising from using overlapping fragments to optimize the embedding. Numerical simulation suggests that the accuracy of the embedding improves rapidly with fragment size for small molecules, whereas larger fragments that include orbitals from different atoms may be needed for larger molecules. BE scales linearly with system size (apart from an integral transform) and hence can potentially be useful for large-scale calculations.
Strong correlation poses a difficult problem for electronic structure theory, with computational cost scaling quickly with system size. Fragment embedding is an attractive approach to this problem. By dividing a large complicated system into smaller manageable fragments "embedded" in an approximate description of the rest of the system, we can hope to ameliorate the steep cost of correlated calculations. While appealing, these methods often converge slowly with fragment size because of small errors at the boundary between fragment and bath. We describe a new electronic embedding method, dubbed "Bootstrap Embedding," a self-consistent wavefunction-in-wavefunction embedding theory that uses overlapping fragments to improve the description of fragment edges. We apply this method to the one dimensional Hubbard model and a translationally asymmetric variant, and find that it performs very well for energies and populations. We find Bootstrap Embedding converges rapidly with embedded fragment size, overcoming the surface-area-to-volume-ratio error typical of many embedding methods. We anticipate that this method may lead to a low-scaling, high accuracy treatment of electron correlation in large molecular systems.
Recent developments in quantum embedding theories have provided attractive approaches to correlated calculations for large systems. In this work, we extend our previous work [ J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 4497–4506; J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2019, 10, 6368–6374] on bootstrap embedding (BE) to enable correlated ab initio calculations at the coupled cluster with singles and doubles (CCSD) level for large molecules. We introduce several new algorithmic developments that significantly reduce the computational cost of BE, while maintaining its accuracy. The resulting implementation scales as O ( N 3 ) for the integral transform and O ( N ) for the CCSD calculation. Numerical results on a series of conjugated molecules suggest that BE with reasonably sized fragments can recover more than 99.5% of the total correlation energy of a full CCSD calculation, while the required computational resources (time and storage) compare favorably to one popular local correlation scheme: domain localized pair natural orbital (DLPNO). The largest BE calculation in this work involves ∼2900 basis functions and can be performed on a single node with 16 CPU cores and 64 GB of memory in a few days. We anticipate that these developments represent an important step toward the application of BE to solve practical problems.
We present a multiscale approach to efficiently embed an ab initio correlated chemical fragment described by its energy-weighted density matrices and entangled with a wider mean-field many-electron system. This approach, first presented by Fertitta and Booth [Phys. Rev. B 98, 235132 (2018)], is here extended to account for realistic long-range interactions and broken symmetry states. The scheme allows for a systematically improvable description in the range of correlated fluctuations out of the fragment into the system, via a self-consistent optimization of a coupled auxiliary mean-field system. It is discussed that the method has rigorous limits equivalent to the existing quantum embedding approaches of both dynamical mean-field theory and density matrix embedding theory, to which this method is compared, and the importance of these correlated fluctuations is demonstrated. We derive a self-consistent local energy functional within the scheme and demonstrate the approach for hydrogen rings, where quantitative accuracy is achieved despite only a single atom being explicitly treated.
Several variants of the recently proposed density matrix embedding theory (DMET) [G. Knizia and G. K-L. Chan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 186404 (2012)] are formulated and tested. We show that spin symmetry breaking of the lattice mean-field allows precise control of the lattice and fragment filling while providing very good agreement between predicted properties and exact results. We present a rigorous proof that at convergence this method is guaranteed to preserve lattice and fragment filling. Differences arising from fitting the fragment one-particle density matrix alone versus fitting fragment plus bath are scrutinized. We argue that it is important to restrict the density matrix fitting to solely the fragment. Furthermore, in the proposed broken symmetry formalism, it is possible to substantially simplify the embedding procedure without sacrificing its accuracy by resorting to density instead of density matrix fitting. This simplified density embedding theory (DET) greatly improves the convergence properties of the algorithm.
The goal of electronic structure theory is to solve the time-independent Schrodinger equation with a method that scales polynomially with the system size. The problem has been solved in the weakly-correlated regime, where coupled cluster theory (CC) with singles, doubles and perturbative triples (CCSD(T)) can achieve chemical accuracy. However, in the strongly-correlated regime, where the two-body interaction dominates, there are still no methods that can achieve a comparable accomplishment. Strong correlation always comes hand in hand with spontaneous symmetry breaking in mean-field theory. For example, coupled cluster theory faces a symmetry dilemma in the strongly correlated regime, where it either completely fails to describe the system if symmetry adapted, or has to artificially break certain symmetries in order to produce reasonable energies. It is plausible that the problem of strong correlation can be solved by curing the symptoms, i.e., fixing the symmetries. Symmetry projection has been carried out at the mean-field level, but it was unclear until this work how to incorporate correlation on top of it because of the language barrier between symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory. This thesis is devoted to combining CC and symmetry projection, focusing on spin and number symmetry. Different flavours of theories are obtained depending on whether a restricted or unrestricted reference is used. On the restricted side, the spin projected unrestricted Hartree Fock (SUHF) state can be rewritten as a polynomial of particle-hole excitations, acting on the restricted reference. Thus, this formalism opens up many ways to combine SUHF with CC. One the unrestricted side, the concept of disentangled cluster is introduced to describe the CC wavefunction transformed by symmetry rotation. A scheme basing on differential equations is devised to approximate these disentangled clusters, which scales polynomially and is systematically improvable. By combining symmetry projection and coupled cluster theory, the symmetry dilemma can be solved to a good extent.