Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Algebraic Quantum Mechanics and Pregeometry

David Böhm, Davies, Philip, Basil J. Hiley

Published Jan 1, 2006• 12 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We discuss the relation between the q-number approach to quantum mechanics suggested by Dirac and the notion of "pregeometry" introduced by Wheeler. By associating the q-numbers with the elements of an algebra and regarding the primitive idempotents as "generalized points" we suggest an approach that may make it possible to dispense with an a priori given space manifold. In this approach the algebra itself would carry the symmetries of translation, rotation, etc. Our suggestion is illustrated in a preliminary way by using a particular generalized Clifford algebra proposed originally by Weyl, which approaches the ordinary Heisenberg algebra a suitable limit. We thus obtain a certain insight into how quantum mechanics may be regarded as a purely algebraic theory, provided that we further introduce a new set of "neighbourhood operators", which remove an important kind of arbitrariness that has thus far been present in the attempt to treat quantum mechanics solely in terms of a Heisenberg algebra.

Related papers

Algebraic Quantum Mechanics and Pregeometry

David Böhm

We discuss the relation between the q‐number approach to quantum mechanics suggested by Dirac and the notion of “pregeometry” introduced by Wheeler. By associating the q‐numbers with the elements of an algebra and regarding the primitive idempotents as “generalized points”, we suggest an approach that may make it possible to dispense with an a priori given space‐time manifold. In this approach the algebra itself would carry the symmetries of translation, rotation, etc. Our suggestion is illustrated in a preliminary way by using a particular generalized Clifford algebra proposed originally by Weyl, which approaches the ordinary Heisenberg algebra a suitable limit. We thus obtain a certain insight into how quantum mechanics may be regarded as a purely algebraic theory, provided that we further introduce a new set of “neighbourhood operators”, which remove an important kind of arbitrariness that has thus far been present in the attempt to treat quantum mechanics solely in terms of a Heisenberg algebra.

arXiv:quant-ph/0612002•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•5 citations

Relativity quantum mechanics with an application to compton scattering

P. A. M. Dirac

Abstract The new quantum mechanics, introduced by Heisenberg and since developed from different points of view by various authors, takes its simplest form if one assumes merely that the dynamical variables are numbers of a special type (called q-numbers to distinguish them from ordinary or c-numbers) that obey all the ordinary algebraic laws except the commutative law of multiplication, and satisfy instead of this the relations qrqs – qsqr =0, prps – pspr = 0 } qrqs – psqr = 0 (r ≠ s) or ih(r = s) where the p's and q's are a set of canonical variables and h is a c-number euqal to (2π)-1 times the usual Planck’s constant. Equations (1) may be regarded as replacing the commutative law of the classical theory, as one can, with their help, build up a complete algebraic theory of quantities that are analytic functions of a set of canonical variables. Further, it may easily be seen that the quantity [x, y] defined by xy – yz = ih [x, y] is completely analogous to the Poisson bracket of the classical theory. By means of this analogy the whole of the classical dynamical theory, in so far as it can be expressed in terms of P. B.’s instead of differential coefficients, may be taken over immediately into the quantum theory.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Jun 2, 1926•146 citations

A Review of The Algebraic Approaches to Quantum Mechanics. Appraisals on Their Theoretical Relevance

Antonino Drago

I review the various algebraic foundations of quantum mechanics. They have been suggested since the birth of this theory till up to last year. They are the following ones: Heisenberg-Born-Jordan (1925), Weyl (1928), Dirac (1930), von Neumann (1936), Segal (1947), T.F. Jordan (1986), Morchio and Strocchi (2009) and Buchholz and Fregenhagen (2019). Three cases are stressed: 1) the misinterpretation of Dirac foundation; 2) von Neumann conversion from the analytic approach of Hilbert space to the algebraic approach of the rings of operators; 3) the recent foundation of quantum mechanics upon the algebra of perturbation Lagrangians. Moreover, historical considerations on the go-and-stop path performed by the algebraic approach in the history of QM are offered. The level of formalism has increased from the mere introduction of matrices till up to group theory and C*-algebras. But there was no progress in approaching closer the foundations of physics; therefore the problem of discovering an algebraic formulation of QM organized as a problem-based theory and making use of no more than constructive mathematics is open.

arXiv:2102.00861•Jan 29, 2021•1 citation

Dirac, Bohm and the Algebraic Approach

Basil J. Hiley, Glen Dennis

In this paper we show how Dirac, in 1947, anticipated the Bohm approach using an argument based on what is now called the Heisenberg picture. From a detailed examination of these ideas, we show that the role played by the Dirac standard ket is equivalent to the introduction and use of the idempotent in the orthogonal and symplectic Clifford algebras. This formalism is then used to show that the so-called `Bohm trajectories' are the average of an ensemble of individual stochastic Feynman paths. Since the Bohm approach can be simply reduced to classical mechanics, the algebraic formalism presented here provides a natural way to relate quantum mechanics to classical mechanics without the need for decoherence. We show that this approach suggests an underlying fractal space-time of the type discussed by Nottale.

arXiv:1901.01979•Jan 5, 2019•3 citations

GROUP-THEORETICAL FORMALISM OF QUANTUM-MECHANICS AND CLASSICAL-QUANTUM CORRESPONDENCE

Yingfei Gu

This article presents a mathematical framework for group-theoretical formalism of quantum mechanics and discusses the geometric quantization of the classical systems associated with a Lie group. The classical-quantum correspondence is realized by identifying quantum observable algebra and its classical analogue with the set of distributions with compact supports on a Lie group and on the associated Lie algebra respectively, both having a convolution-type associative algebraic structure. The general mathematical constructs are illustrated by studying systems associated with the Heisenberg-Weyl group. It is shown that the exponential mapping from Heisenberg-Weyl algebra to the corresponding Lie group gives Weyl quantization.

•Jan 1, 1992•2 citations

Algebraic and Statistical Methods in Quantum and Gravitational Physics

D. A. Slavnov

Abstract A scheme for constructing quantum mechanics is described, in which the Hilbert space and linear operators are not the primary notions of the theory. Instead, a variant of the algebraic approach is considered. The noncommutative algebra elements (observables) and the functionals on this algebra (elementary states), which are associated with the results of individual measurements, are used as primary notions. This scheme makes it possible, on the one hand, to use the apparatus of the classical (Kolmogorov) probability theory, and on the other hand, to reproduce the standard mathematical apparatus of quantum mechanics and determine the limits to its applicability.

Physics of Particles and Nuclei•Jun 1, 2022•3 citations
We discuss the relation between the q-number approach to quantum mechanics suggested by Dirac and the notion of "pregeometry" introduced by Wheeler. By associating the q-numbers with the elements of an algebra and regarding the primitive idempotents as "generalized points" we suggest an approach that may make it possible to dispense with an a priori given space manifold. In this approach the algebra itself would carry the symmetries of translation, rotation, etc. Our suggestion is illustrated in a preliminary way by using a particular generalized Clifford algebra proposed originally by Weyl, which approaches the ordinary Heisenberg algebra a suitable limit. We thus obtain a certain insight into how quantum mechanics may be regarded as a purely algebraic theory, provided that we further introduce a new set of "neighbourhood operators", which remove an important kind of arbitrariness that has thus far been present in the attempt to treat quantum mechanics solely in terms of a Heisenberg algebra.
We discuss the relation between the q‐number approach to quantum mechanics suggested by Dirac and the notion of “pregeometry” introduced by Wheeler. By associating the q‐numbers with the elements of an algebra and regarding the primitive idempotents as “generalized points”, we suggest an approach that may make it possible to dispense with an a priori given space‐time manifold. In this approach the algebra itself would carry the symmetries of translation, rotation, etc. Our suggestion is illustrated in a preliminary way by using a particular generalized Clifford algebra proposed originally by Weyl, which approaches the ordinary Heisenberg algebra a suitable limit. We thus obtain a certain insight into how quantum mechanics may be regarded as a purely algebraic theory, provided that we further introduce a new set of “neighbourhood operators”, which remove an important kind of arbitrariness that has thus far been present in the attempt to treat quantum mechanics solely in terms of a Heisenberg algebra.
Abstract The new quantum mechanics, introduced by Heisenberg and since developed from different points of view by various authors, takes its simplest form if one assumes merely that the dynamical variables are numbers of a special type (called q-numbers to distinguish them from ordinary or c-numbers) that obey all the ordinary algebraic laws except the commutative law of multiplication, and satisfy instead of this the relations qrqs – qsqr =0, prps – pspr = 0 } qrqs – psqr = 0 (r ≠ s) or ih(r = s) where the p's and q's are a set of canonical variables and h is a c-number euqal to (2π)-1 times the usual Planck’s constant. Equations (1) may be regarded as replacing the commutative law of the classical theory, as one can, with their help, build up a complete algebraic theory of quantities that are analytic functions of a set of canonical variables. Further, it may easily be seen that the quantity [x, y] defined by xy – yz = ih [x, y] is completely analogous to the Poisson bracket of the classical theory. By means of this analogy the whole of the classical dynamical theory, in so far as it can be expressed in terms of P. B.’s instead of differential coefficients, may be taken over immediately into the quantum theory.
I review the various algebraic foundations of quantum mechanics. They have been suggested since the birth of this theory till up to last year. They are the following ones: Heisenberg-Born-Jordan (1925), Weyl (1928), Dirac (1930), von Neumann (1936), Segal (1947), T.F. Jordan (1986), Morchio and Strocchi (2009) and Buchholz and Fregenhagen (2019). Three cases are stressed: 1) the misinterpretation of Dirac foundation; 2) von Neumann conversion from the analytic approach of Hilbert space to the algebraic approach of the rings of operators; 3) the recent foundation of quantum mechanics upon the algebra of perturbation Lagrangians. Moreover, historical considerations on the go-and-stop path performed by the algebraic approach in the history of QM are offered. The level of formalism has increased from the mere introduction of matrices till up to group theory and C*-algebras. But there was no progress in approaching closer the foundations of physics; therefore the problem of discovering an algebraic formulation of QM organized as a problem-based theory and making use of no more than constructive mathematics is open.
In this paper we show how Dirac, in 1947, anticipated the Bohm approach using an argument based on what is now called the Heisenberg picture. From a detailed examination of these ideas, we show that the role played by the Dirac standard ket is equivalent to the introduction and use of the idempotent in the orthogonal and symplectic Clifford algebras. This formalism is then used to show that the so-called `Bohm trajectories' are the average of an ensemble of individual stochastic Feynman paths. Since the Bohm approach can be simply reduced to classical mechanics, the algebraic formalism presented here provides a natural way to relate quantum mechanics to classical mechanics without the need for decoherence. We show that this approach suggests an underlying fractal space-time of the type discussed by Nottale.
This article presents a mathematical framework for group-theoretical formalism of quantum mechanics and discusses the geometric quantization of the classical systems associated with a Lie group. The classical-quantum correspondence is realized by identifying quantum observable algebra and its classical analogue with the set of distributions with compact supports on a Lie group and on the associated Lie algebra respectively, both having a convolution-type associative algebraic structure. The general mathematical constructs are illustrated by studying systems associated with the Heisenberg-Weyl group. It is shown that the exponential mapping from Heisenberg-Weyl algebra to the corresponding Lie group gives Weyl quantization.
Abstract A scheme for constructing quantum mechanics is described, in which the Hilbert space and linear operators are not the primary notions of the theory. Instead, a variant of the algebraic approach is considered. The noncommutative algebra elements (observables) and the functionals on this algebra (elementary states), which are associated with the results of individual measurements, are used as primary notions. This scheme makes it possible, on the one hand, to use the apparatus of the classical (Kolmogorov) probability theory, and on the other hand, to reproduce the standard mathematical apparatus of quantum mechanics and determine the limits to its applicability.