Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

3 Entanglement Zoo II: Examples in Physics and Cognition

Diederik Aerts, Sandro Sozzo

Published Jan 1, 2014• 2 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We have recently presented a general scheme enabling quantum modeling of different types of situations that violate Bell's inequalities [1]. In this paper, we specify this scheme for a combination of two concepts. We work out a quantum Hilbert space model where 'entangled measurements' occur in addition to the expected 'entanglement between the component concepts', or 'state entanglement'. We extend this result to a macroscopic physical entity, the 'connected vessels of water', which maximally violates Bell's inequalities. We enlighten the structural and conceptual analogies between the cognitive and physical situations which are both examples of a nonlocal non-marginal box modeling in our classification.

Related papers

General Quantum Hilbert Space Modeling Scheme for Entanglement

Diederik Aerts, Sandro Sozzo

We work out a classification scheme for quantum modeling in Hilbert space of any kind of composite entity violating Bell's inequalities and exhibiting entanglement. Our theoretical framework includes situations with entangled states and product measurements ('customary quantum situation'), and also situations with both entangled states and entangled measurements ('nonlocal box situation', 'nonlocal non-marginal box situation'). We show that entanglement is structurally a joint property of states and measurements. Furthermore, entangled measurements enable quantum modeling of situations that are usually believed to be 'beyond quantum'. Our results are also extended from pure states to quantum mixtures.

arXiv:1304.3733•Apr 12, 2013•2 citations

Entanglement in Cognition violating Bell Inequalities Beyond Cirel'son's Bound

Diederik Aerts, Jonito Aerts Arguëlles, Lester Beltran +2 more

We present the results of two tests where a sample of human participants were asked to make judgements about the conceptual combinations {\it The Animal Acts} and {\it The Animal eats the Food}. Both tests significantly violate the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt version of Bell inequalities (`CHSH inequality'), thus exhibiting manifestly non-classical behaviour due to the meaning connection between the individual concepts that are combined. We then apply a quantum-theoretic framework which we developed for any Bell-type situation and represent empirical data in complex Hilbert space. We show that the observed violations of the CHSH inequality can be explained as a consequence of a strong form of `quantum entanglement' between the component conceptual entities in which both the state and measurements are entangled. We finally observe that a quantum model in Hilbert space can be elaborated in these Bell-type situations even when the CHSH violation exceeds the known `Cirel'son bound', in contrast to a widespread belief. These findings confirm and strengthen the results we recently obtained in a variety of cognitive tests and document and image retrieval operations on the same conceptual combinations.

arXiv:2102.03847•Feb 7, 2021•7 citations

Quantum entanglement in physical and cognitive systems: A conceptual analysis and a general representation

Diederik Aerts, Jonito Aerts Arguëlles, Lester Beltran +4 more

Abstract We provide a general description of the phenomenon of entanglement in bipartite systems, as it manifests in micro and macro physical systems, as well as in human cognitive processes. We do so by observing that when genuine coincidence measurements are considered, the violation of the ‘marginal laws’, in addition to the Bell-CHSH inequality, is also to be expected. The situation can be described in the quantum formalism by considering the presence of entanglement not only at the level of the states, but also at the level of the measurements. However, at the “local” level of a specific joint measurement, a description where entanglement is only incorporated in the state remains always possible, by adopting a fine-tuned tensor product representation. But contextual tensor product representations should only be considered when there are good reasons to describe the outcome-states as (non-entangled) product states. This will not in general be true, hence, the entanglement resource will have to generally be allocated both in the states and in the measurements. In view of the numerous violations of the marginal laws observed in physics’ laboratories, it remains unclear to date if entanglement in micro-physical systems is to be understood only as an ‘entanglement of the states’, or also as an ‘entanglement of the measurements’. But even if measurements would also be entangled, the corresponding violation of the marginal laws (also called ‘no-signaling conditions’) would not for this imply that a superluminal communication would be possible.

arXiv:1903.09103•The European Physical Journal Plus•Oct 1, 2019•48 citations

A Hilbert Space Model of Cognition – II

Partha Ghose, Sudip Patra

In the Brussels’ operational-realistic approach to cognition, concepts are treated as entities that can be in different states and be subjected to measurements performed by human minds. The Brussels group also considered two other examples of bipartite systems, the famous Bohm-EPR state of two spin-1/2 particles forming a singlet state (microscopic level) and a model of breakable elastic bands (macroscopic level) to show that they violate Bell-CHSH inequalities. Sandeau et al. employed entangled states of classical Maxwell fields coupling the polarization and spatial parity degrees of freedom in order to implement the analogue of non-unitary transformations, leading to maximal correlations beyond Tsirelson’s bound. Their approach relies on the realization at the level of classical Maxwell fields of a so-called positive operator valued measure. POVM stands for ‘positive operator valued measure’. They are the most general kinds of measurement. In standard quantum mechanics one uses ideal measurements which are one-dimensional projection operators.

Routledge eBooks•Nov 6, 2023•0 citations

Quantum and Concept Combination, Entangled Measurements, and Prototype Theory

Diederik Aerts

We analyze the meaning of the violation of the marginal probability law for situations of correlation measurements where entanglement is identified. We show that for quantum theory applied to the cognitive realm such a violation does not lead to the type of problems commonly believed to occur in situations of quantum theory applied to the physical realm. We briefly situate our quantum approach for modeling concepts and their combinations with respect to the notions of "extension" and "intension" in theories of meaning, and in existing concept theories.

arXiv:1303.2430•Topics in Cognitive Science•Jan 1, 2014•15 citations

Quantum and Concept Combination, Entangled Measurements and Prototype Theory

Diederik Aerts

Abstract: We analyze the meaning of the violation of the marginal probability law for situations of correlation measurements where entanglement is identified. We show that for quantum theory applied to the cognitive realm such a violation does not lead to the type of problems commonly believed to occur in situations of quantum theory applied to the physical realm. We briefly situate our quantum approach for modeling concepts and their combinations with respect to the notions of ‘extension’ and ‘intension ’ in theories of meaning, and in existing concept theories. This article is a reply to the publications Dzhafarov & Kujala (2013) and Hampton (2013), which are commentaries on Aerts, Gabora & Sozzo (2013), and contains at the same time specifications and elaborations of many aspects

•Jan 1, 2014•13 citations
We have recently presented a general scheme enabling quantum modeling of different types of situations that violate Bell's inequalities [1]. In this paper, we specify this scheme for a combination of two concepts. We work out a quantum Hilbert space model where 'entangled measurements' occur in addition to the expected 'entanglement between the component concepts', or 'state entanglement'. We extend this result to a macroscopic physical entity, the 'connected vessels of water', which maximally violates Bell's inequalities. We enlighten the structural and conceptual analogies between the cognitive and physical situations which are both examples of a nonlocal non-marginal box modeling in our classification.
We work out a classification scheme for quantum modeling in Hilbert space of any kind of composite entity violating Bell's inequalities and exhibiting entanglement. Our theoretical framework includes situations with entangled states and product measurements ('customary quantum situation'), and also situations with both entangled states and entangled measurements ('nonlocal box situation', 'nonlocal non-marginal box situation'). We show that entanglement is structurally a joint property of states and measurements. Furthermore, entangled measurements enable quantum modeling of situations that are usually believed to be 'beyond quantum'. Our results are also extended from pure states to quantum mixtures.
We present the results of two tests where a sample of human participants were asked to make judgements about the conceptual combinations {\it The Animal Acts} and {\it The Animal eats the Food}. Both tests significantly violate the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt version of Bell inequalities (`CHSH inequality'), thus exhibiting manifestly non-classical behaviour due to the meaning connection between the individual concepts that are combined. We then apply a quantum-theoretic framework which we developed for any Bell-type situation and represent empirical data in complex Hilbert space. We show that the observed violations of the CHSH inequality can be explained as a consequence of a strong form of `quantum entanglement' between the component conceptual entities in which both the state and measurements are entangled. We finally observe that a quantum model in Hilbert space can be elaborated in these Bell-type situations even when the CHSH violation exceeds the known `Cirel'son bound', in contrast to a widespread belief. These findings confirm and strengthen the results we recently obtained in a variety of cognitive tests and document and image retrieval operations on the same conceptual combinations.
Abstract We provide a general description of the phenomenon of entanglement in bipartite systems, as it manifests in micro and macro physical systems, as well as in human cognitive processes. We do so by observing that when genuine coincidence measurements are considered, the violation of the ‘marginal laws’, in addition to the Bell-CHSH inequality, is also to be expected. The situation can be described in the quantum formalism by considering the presence of entanglement not only at the level of the states, but also at the level of the measurements. However, at the “local” level of a specific joint measurement, a description where entanglement is only incorporated in the state remains always possible, by adopting a fine-tuned tensor product representation. But contextual tensor product representations should only be considered when there are good reasons to describe the outcome-states as (non-entangled) product states. This will not in general be true, hence, the entanglement resource will have to generally be allocated both in the states and in the measurements. In view of the numerous violations of the marginal laws observed in physics’ laboratories, it remains unclear to date if entanglement in micro-physical systems is to be understood only as an ‘entanglement of the states’, or also as an ‘entanglement of the measurements’. But even if measurements would also be entangled, the corresponding violation of the marginal laws (also called ‘no-signaling conditions’) would not for this imply that a superluminal communication would be possible.
In the Brussels’ operational-realistic approach to cognition, concepts are treated as entities that can be in different states and be subjected to measurements performed by human minds. The Brussels group also considered two other examples of bipartite systems, the famous Bohm-EPR state of two spin-1/2 particles forming a singlet state (microscopic level) and a model of breakable elastic bands (macroscopic level) to show that they violate Bell-CHSH inequalities. Sandeau et al. employed entangled states of classical Maxwell fields coupling the polarization and spatial parity degrees of freedom in order to implement the analogue of non-unitary transformations, leading to maximal correlations beyond Tsirelson’s bound. Their approach relies on the realization at the level of classical Maxwell fields of a so-called positive operator valued measure. POVM stands for ‘positive operator valued measure’. They are the most general kinds of measurement. In standard quantum mechanics one uses ideal measurements which are one-dimensional projection operators.
We analyze the meaning of the violation of the marginal probability law for situations of correlation measurements where entanglement is identified. We show that for quantum theory applied to the cognitive realm such a violation does not lead to the type of problems commonly believed to occur in situations of quantum theory applied to the physical realm. We briefly situate our quantum approach for modeling concepts and their combinations with respect to the notions of "extension" and "intension" in theories of meaning, and in existing concept theories.
Abstract: We analyze the meaning of the violation of the marginal probability law for situations of correlation measurements where entanglement is identified. We show that for quantum theory applied to the cognitive realm such a violation does not lead to the type of problems commonly believed to occur in situations of quantum theory applied to the physical realm. We briefly situate our quantum approach for modeling concepts and their combinations with respect to the notions of ‘extension’ and ‘intension ’ in theories of meaning, and in existing concept theories. This article is a reply to the publications Dzhafarov & Kujala (2013) and Hampton (2013), which are commentaries on Aerts, Gabora & Sozzo (2013), and contains at the same time specifications and elaborations of many aspects