Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Finite-size scaling above the upper critical dimension revisited: The case of the five-dimensional Ising model

Erik Luijten, Kurt Binder, Henk W. J. Blöte

Published Jan 1, 1999• 44 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

. Monte Carlo results for the moments #M k # of the magnetization distribution of the nearestneighbor Ising ferromagnet in a L d geometry, where L (4 # L # 22) is the linear dimension of a hypercubic lattice with periodic boundary conditions in d = 5 dimensions, are analyzed in the critical region and compared to a recent theory of Chen and Dohm (CD) [X.S. Chen and V. Dohm, Int. J. Mod. Phys. C (1998)]. We show that this finite-size scaling theory (formulated in terms of two scaling variables) can account for the longstanding discrepancies between Monte Carlo results and the so-called "lowest-mode" theory, which uses a single scaling variable tL d/2 where t = T/T c - 1 is the temperature distance from the critical temperature, only to a very limited extent. While the CD theory gives a somewhat improved description of corrections to the "lowest-mode" results (to which the CD theory can easily be reduced in the limit t # 0, L ##, tL d/2 fixed) for the fourth-order cum...

Related papers

Reexamination of scaling in the five-dimensional Ising model

Muneer A. Sumour, Dietrich Stauffer, Mohammed Musa Shabat +1 more

In three dimensions, or more generally, below the upper critical dimension, scaling laws for critical phenomena seem well understood, for both infinite and for finite systems. Above the upper critical dimension of four, finite-size scaling is more difficult. Chen and Dohm predicted deviation in the universality of the Binder cumulants for three dimensions and more for the Ising model. This deviation occurs if the critical point T = Tc is approached along lines of constant A = L*L*(T-Tc)/Tc, then different exponents a function of system size L are found depending on whether this constant A is taken as positive, zero, or negative. This effect was confirmed by Monte Carlo simulations with Glauber and Creutz kinetics. Because of the importance of this effect and the unclear situation in the analogous percolation problem, we here reexamine the five-dimensional Glauber kinetics.

arXiv:cond-mat/0603087•Mar 3, 2006•2 citations

Finite-size scaling of the Ising model in four dimensions

Pik-Yin Lai, K. K. Mon

The four-dimensional Ising model is studied to probe the possibility of observing in Monte Carlo simulations the logarithmic corrections to the mean-field theory near criticality. The finite-size-scaling behavior for the correlation length is proposed. The scaling forms of the finite-size renormalized coupling, susceptibility, and fourth field derivative at the renormalized tree-level approximation are derived. These results are used to analyze simulation data of the simple hypercubic lattices of sizes 4\ensuremath{\le}L\ensuremath{\le}14, near criticality. Our simulation results are in agreement with the presence of logarithmic corrections and recent field-theoretical calculations of the specific heat. The approach to the nonscattering theory is observed and is consistent with the predicted logarithmic finite-size dependence.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 1, 1990•23 citations

Lattice φ4 Theory of Finite-Size Effects Above the Upper Critical Dimension

X. S. Chen, V. Dohm

We present a perturbative calculation of finite-size effects near Tc of the φ4 lattice model in a d-dimensional cubic geometry of size L with periodic boundary conditions for d>4. The structural differences between the φ4 lattice theory and the φ4 field theory found previously in the spherical limit are shown to exist also for a finite number of components of the order parameter. The two-variable finite-size scaling functions of the field theory are nonuniversal whereas those of the lattice theory are independent of the nonuniversal model parameters. One-loop results for finite-size scaling functions are derived. Their structure disagrees with the single-variable scaling form of the lowest-mode approximation for any finite ξ/L where ξ is the bulk correlation length. At Tc, the large-L behavior becomes lowest-mode like for the lattice model but not for the field-theoretic model. Characteristic temperatures close to Tc of the lattice model, such as T max (L) of the maximum of the susceptibility χ, are found to scale asymptotically as Tc-T max (L) ~L-d/2, in agreement with previous Monte Carlo (MC) data for the five-dimensional Ising model. We also predict χ max ~Ld/2 asymptotically. On a quantitative level, the asymptotic amplitudes of this large-L behavior close to Tc have not been observed in previous MC simulations at d=5 because of nonnegligible finite-size terms ~L(4-d)/2 caused by the inhomogeneous modes. These terms identify the possible origin of a significant discrepancy between the lowest-mode approximation and previous MC data. MC data of larger systems would be desirable for testing the magnitude of the L(4-d)/2 and L4-d terms predicted by our theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/9809394•International Journal of Modern Physics C•Oct 1, 1998•16 citations

Finite-Size Scaling and Universality above the Upper Critical Dimensionality

Erik Luijten, Henk W. J. Blöte

According to renormalization theory, Ising systems above their upper critical dimensionality ${d}_{u}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}4$ have classical critical behavior and the ratio of magnetization moments $Q\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}〈{m}^{2}{〉}^{2}/〈{m}^{4}〉$ has the universal value $0.456947\dots{}$. However, Monte Carlo simulations of $d\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}5$ Ising models have been reported which yield strikingly different results, suggesting that the renormalization scenario is incorrect. We investigate this issue by simulation of a more general model in which ${d}_{u}<4$, and a careful analysis of the corrections to scaling. Our results are in perfect agreement with the renormalization theory and provide an explanation of the discrepancy mentioned.

arXiv:cond-mat/9601130•Physical Review Letters•Mar 4, 1996•99 citations

Finite-size scaling of the magnetization probability density for the critical Ising model in slab geometry

David Lopes Cardozo, P. C. W. Holdsworth

The magnetization probability density in d = 2 and 3 dimensional Ising models in slab geometry of volume [Formula: see text] is computed through Monte-Carlo simulation at the critical temperature and zero magnetic field. The finite-size scaling of this distribution and its dependence on the system aspect-ratio [Formula: see text]and boundary conditions are discussed. In the limiting case [Formula: see text] of a macroscopically large slab ([Formula: see text]) the distribution is found to scale as a Gaussian function for all tested system sizes and boundary conditions.

arXiv:1512.02488•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Mar 29, 2016•5 citations

A finite size scaling study of the five‐dimensional Ising model

Ch. Rickwardt, P. Nielaba, Kurt Binder

Abstract For systems above the marginal dimension d*, where mean field theory starts to become valid, such as Ising models in d = 5 for which d* = 4, hyperscaling is invalid and hence it was suggested that finite size scaling is not ruled by the correlation length ξ (∝ |t| −1/2 in Landau theory, t being the distance from the critical point) but by a “thermodynamic length” l (∝ |t| −2/d). Early simulation work by Binder et al. using nearest neighbor hypercubic L5 lattices with L ⩽ 7 yielded some evidence for this prediction, but the renormalized coupling constant gL = −3 + 〈M4〉/〈M2〉2 at Tc was gL ≈ −1.0 instead of the prediction of Brézin and Zinn‐Justin, gL(Tc) = −3 + Γ4(1/4)/(8 π2) ≈ −0.812. In the present work, we try to shed light on this controversy obtaining much more precise Monte Carlo data using multihistogram techniques and lattices as large as L = 17 (i.e., 1419857 Ising spins). While our value of Tc agrees nicely with recent high temperature series work (KBTc/J ≈ 8.7774 ± 0.0035), the coupling at Tc {gL(Tc) ≈ −0.958 ± 0.050} confirms the work for small lattices and disagrees with the analytical prediction. Hence the data are better consistent with a shift of the effective critical temperature Tc(L) ‐ Tc(∝) ∝ L−d/2 rather than with L−(d−2) according to the analytical theory. If the latter behavior is correct, it can hence be seen for extremely large systems only.

Annalen der Physik•Jan 1, 1994•45 citations
. Monte Carlo results for the moments #M k # of the magnetization distribution of the nearestneighbor Ising ferromagnet in a L d geometry, where L (4 # L # 22) is the linear dimension of a hypercubic lattice with periodic boundary conditions in d = 5 dimensions, are analyzed in the critical region and compared to a recent theory of Chen and Dohm (CD) [X.S. Chen and V. Dohm, Int. J. Mod. Phys. C (1998)]. We show that this finite-size scaling theory (formulated in terms of two scaling variables) can account for the longstanding discrepancies between Monte Carlo results and the so-called "lowest-mode" theory, which uses a single scaling variable tL d/2 where t = T/T c - 1 is the temperature distance from the critical temperature, only to a very limited extent. While the CD theory gives a somewhat improved description of corrections to the "lowest-mode" results (to which the CD theory can easily be reduced in the limit t # 0, L ##, tL d/2 fixed) for the fourth-order cum...
In three dimensions, or more generally, below the upper critical dimension, scaling laws for critical phenomena seem well understood, for both infinite and for finite systems. Above the upper critical dimension of four, finite-size scaling is more difficult. Chen and Dohm predicted deviation in the universality of the Binder cumulants for three dimensions and more for the Ising model. This deviation occurs if the critical point T = Tc is approached along lines of constant A = L*L*(T-Tc)/Tc, then different exponents a function of system size L are found depending on whether this constant A is taken as positive, zero, or negative. This effect was confirmed by Monte Carlo simulations with Glauber and Creutz kinetics. Because of the importance of this effect and the unclear situation in the analogous percolation problem, we here reexamine the five-dimensional Glauber kinetics.
The four-dimensional Ising model is studied to probe the possibility of observing in Monte Carlo simulations the logarithmic corrections to the mean-field theory near criticality. The finite-size-scaling behavior for the correlation length is proposed. The scaling forms of the finite-size renormalized coupling, susceptibility, and fourth field derivative at the renormalized tree-level approximation are derived. These results are used to analyze simulation data of the simple hypercubic lattices of sizes 4\ensuremath{\le}L\ensuremath{\le}14, near criticality. Our simulation results are in agreement with the presence of logarithmic corrections and recent field-theoretical calculations of the specific heat. The approach to the nonscattering theory is observed and is consistent with the predicted logarithmic finite-size dependence.
We present a perturbative calculation of finite-size effects near Tc of the φ4 lattice model in a d-dimensional cubic geometry of size L with periodic boundary conditions for d>4. The structural differences between the φ4 lattice theory and the φ4 field theory found previously in the spherical limit are shown to exist also for a finite number of components of the order parameter. The two-variable finite-size scaling functions of the field theory are nonuniversal whereas those of the lattice theory are independent of the nonuniversal model parameters. One-loop results for finite-size scaling functions are derived. Their structure disagrees with the single-variable scaling form of the lowest-mode approximation for any finite ξ/L where ξ is the bulk correlation length. At Tc, the large-L behavior becomes lowest-mode like for the lattice model but not for the field-theoretic model. Characteristic temperatures close to Tc of the lattice model, such as T max (L) of the maximum of the susceptibility χ, are found to scale asymptotically as Tc-T max (L) ~L-d/2, in agreement with previous Monte Carlo (MC) data for the five-dimensional Ising model. We also predict χ max ~Ld/2 asymptotically. On a quantitative level, the asymptotic amplitudes of this large-L behavior close to Tc have not been observed in previous MC simulations at d=5 because of nonnegligible finite-size terms ~L(4-d)/2 caused by the inhomogeneous modes. These terms identify the possible origin of a significant discrepancy between the lowest-mode approximation and previous MC data. MC data of larger systems would be desirable for testing the magnitude of the L(4-d)/2 and L4-d terms predicted by our theory.
According to renormalization theory, Ising systems above their upper critical dimensionality du=4{d}_{u}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}4du​=4 have classical critical behavior and the ratio of magnetization moments Q=〈m2〉2/〈m4〉Q\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}〈{m}^{2}{〉}^{2}/〈{m}^{4}〉Q=〈m2〉2/〈m4〉 has the universal value 0.456947…0.456947\dots{}0.456947…. However, Monte Carlo simulations of d=5d\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}5d=5 Ising models have been reported which yield strikingly different results, suggesting that the renormalization scenario is incorrect. We investigate this issue by simulation of a more general model in which du<4{d}_{u}<4du​<4, and a careful analysis of the corrections to scaling. Our results are in perfect agreement with the renormalization theory and provide an explanation of the discrepancy mentioned.
The magnetization probability density in d = 2 and 3 dimensional Ising models in slab geometry of volume [Formula: see text] is computed through Monte-Carlo simulation at the critical temperature and zero magnetic field. The finite-size scaling of this distribution and its dependence on the system aspect-ratio [Formula: see text]and boundary conditions are discussed. In the limiting case [Formula: see text] of a macroscopically large slab ([Formula: see text]) the distribution is found to scale as a Gaussian function for all tested system sizes and boundary conditions.
Abstract For systems above the marginal dimension d*, where mean field theory starts to become valid, such as Ising models in d = 5 for which d* = 4, hyperscaling is invalid and hence it was suggested that finite size scaling is not ruled by the correlation length ξ (∝ |t| −1/2 in Landau theory, t being the distance from the critical point) but by a “thermodynamic length” l (∝ |t| −2/d). Early simulation work by Binder et al. using nearest neighbor hypercubic L5 lattices with L ⩽ 7 yielded some evidence for this prediction, but the renormalized coupling constant gL = −3 + 〈M4〉/〈M2〉2 at Tc was gL ≈ −1.0 instead of the prediction of Brézin and Zinn‐Justin, gL(Tc) = −3 + Γ4(1/4)/(8 π2) ≈ −0.812. In the present work, we try to shed light on this controversy obtaining much more precise Monte Carlo data using multihistogram techniques and lattices as large as L = 17 (i.e., 1419857 Ising spins). While our value of Tc agrees nicely with recent high temperature series work (KBTc/J ≈ 8.7774 ± 0.0035), the coupling at Tc {gL(Tc) ≈ −0.958 ± 0.050} confirms the work for small lattices and disagrees with the analytical prediction. Hence the data are better consistent with a shift of the effective critical temperature Tc(L) ‐ Tc(∝) ∝ L−d/2 rather than with L−(d−2) according to the analytical theory. If the latter behavior is correct, it can hence be seen for extremely large systems only.