Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Measurement, Gravitation, and Locality

D. V. Ahluwalia

Published Jan 1, 1994• 145 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This essay argues that when measurement processes involve energies of the order of the Planck scale, the fundamental assumption of locality may no longer be a good approximation. Idealized position measurements of two distinguishable spin-$0$ particles are considered. The measurements alter the space-time metric in a fundamental manner governed by the commutation relations $[x_i\\,\\,p_j]= i\\hbar\\,\\delta_{ij}$ and the classical field equations of gravitation. This {\\it in-principle} unavoidable change in the space-time metric destroys the commutativity (and hence locality) of position measurement operators.

Related papers

Entanglement of quantum clocks through gravity

Esteban Castro-Ruiz, Flaminia Giacomini, Časlav Brukner

In general relativity, the picture of space-time assigns an ideal clock to each world line. Being ideal, gravitational effects due to these clocks are ignored and the flow of time according to one clock is not affected by the presence of clocks along nearby world lines. However, if time is defined operationally, as a pointer position of a physical clock that obeys the principles of general relativity and quantum mechanics, such a picture is, at most, a convenient fiction. Specifically, we show that the general relativistic mass-energy equivalence implies gravitational interaction between the clocks, whereas the quantum mechanical superposition of energy eigenstates leads to a nonfixed metric background. Based only on the assumption that both principles hold in this situation, we show that the clocks necessarily get entangled through time dilation effect, which eventually leads to a loss of coherence of a single clock. Hence, the time as measured by a single clock is not well defined. However, the general relativistic notion of time is recovered in the classical limit of clocks.

arXiv:1507.01955•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Mar 7, 2017•84 citations

Space-time localization with electromagnetic fields

Marc-Thierry Jaekel, Serge Reynaud

The necessity to reconcile the laws of mechanics and electromagnetism has led to question our representation of space and time and to the development of relativity theory. Present most accurate determinations of positions in space and time rely on the exchange of electromagnetic signals and strongly depend on the relativistic conception of space-time. Despite the quantum nature of the electromagnetic fields and atomic clocks used for localization, space-time positions are yet usually treated as classical parameters. As discussed here, relativistic localization may be described by quantum observables representing space-time postions, and defined on the exchanged quantum fields. These quantum localization observables differ from their classical analogs by their non vanishing commutator, which involves spin observables. Alternatively, quantum positions may be defined as commuting but complex observables, which do not commute with their complex conjugates. There result new relations of space-time to algebra and geometry, and in particular modifications of relativistic frame transformations and covariance rules.

•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Quantum Gravity: A Self-Adjoint Time Operator as a Quantum Observable

Ilija Barukčić

In quantum mechanics energy is an observable, whereas time is a parameter; Pauli's theorem and the problem of time in canonical quantum gravity reflect this asymmetry. We define the time operator \( \hat{t}=\hat{x}/c \) and form, with the relativistic energy \( \hat{E}_R \), Einstein's constant \( \kappa \) and the time \( \hat{t}_0 \) in the rest system, operators of gravitational-field and curvature type, and derive their commutation relations, wave equations and spectra. The commutator \( [\hat{t},\hat{E}_R]=\tfrac{i\hbar}{c}\hat{v}_x \) is bounded with norm \( \hbar \) and is not a multiple of the identity, so Pauli's theorem is not contradicted. The sum \( c\,\hat{t}+\kappa\hat{E}_R \) is unitarily equivalent to the time operator and has a continuous spectrum. A postulated field equation, \( \hat{G}_0+\hat{\Lambda}=\kappa\hat{E}_R \), has the structure of Einstein's equation; for small velocities it becomes the Schrödinger equation of a particle in a homogeneous field. The metric tensor of this scalar model is not quantized. A metric operator is constructed from commuting position operators; in the vacuum sector it reproduces the Schwarzschild line element, which serves as a consistency test, and in general it is obtained only under an explicit correspondence condition, which is a postulate and not derived.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Spatial Localization of Relativistic Quantum Systems: The Commutativity Requirement and the Locality Principle. Part I: A General Analysis

Valter Moretti

We investigate whether commutativity is necessary to represent relativistic locality for localization observables of relativistic quantum systems in Minkowski spacetime. A well known no-go theorem by Halvorson and Clifton shows that commutativity of localization effects for causally separated regions is incompatible with other seemingly natural assumptions about spatial localization. Since commutativity is taken to represent locality in the Araki-Haag-Kastler framework of QFT, this prompts the question whether it follows from more elementary locality principles of quantum theory. Using Busch's operational analysis in terms of no-signaling and relativistic consistency, we argue that for particle-like systems commutativity is not implied by these principles. Assuming a natural local detectability principle, elementary localization observables are not localized in arbitrarily small spacetime neighborhoods of the relevant spatial regions, but rather in regions containing the entire rest space (a Cauchy surface) on which the measurement is performed. This reflects the particle picture itself, where localization occurs at a unique place on a rest space filled with ideal detectors, and therefore does not directly conflict with the Araki-Haag-Kastler notion of locality. We also show that commutativity and localization can coexist for less idealized localization procedures. To this end, we introduce conditional localization POVMs associated with bounded spatial regions interpreted as laboratories. By the gentle measurement lemma, these observables describe conditional localization probabilities and can, in principle, satisfy commutativity for causally separated laboratories. They may therefore be represented by local observables in the Araki-Haag-Kastler sense. Explicit examples are presented in a second work within local QFT.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2604.03729•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Apr 7, 2026•2 citations

Measuring time with physical clocks

Esteban Castro-Ruiz, Flaminia Giacomini, Časlav Brukner

In general relativity, the picture of spacetime assigns an ideal clock to each spacetime point. Being ideal, gravitational effects due to these clocks are ignored and the flow of time according to one clock is not affected by the presence of surrounding clocks. However, if time is defined operationally, as a pointer position of a physical clock that obeys the laws of quantum mechanics and general relativity, such a picture is at most a convenient fiction. We show that the mass-energy equivalence implies gravitational interaction between the clocks, while the superposition of energy eigenstates leads to a non-fixed metric background. Based only on the assumption that both quantum mechanics and general relativity are valid in this situation, we show that the clocks necessarily get entangled through time dilation effect, which eventually leads to a loss of coherence of a single clock. Hence, the time as measured by a single clock is not well-defined. However, the general relativistic notion of time is recovered in the classical limit of clocks.

•Jul 7, 2015•1 citation

Events and processes in the quantum world

Abner Shimony

PROSPECTIVE The concern of this paper will be different from that of most studies of quantum gravity. There will be no discussion of the problem of quantizing the gravitational field equations, hence nothing about the modifications which quantization requires of space-time structure at distances of the order of the Planck length (∼ 10 −33 cm). The emphasis will be rather upon the implications of quantum mechanics for certain general properties of events and processes which occur in the theatre of space-time, specifically with non-locality and nonlinearity . Quantum mechanics is undoubtedly a non-local theory when it treats correlated spatially separated systems. When one examines closely the character of this non-locality, however, one does not find reasons for modifying the causal structure of space-time as described by special or general relativity theory, but rather reasons for refining the concept of an event. The occurrence of definite outcomes of measurements implies that there are processes in nature governed by nonlinear laws. Nonlinearity is very peculiar from the standpoint of quantum mechanics, since it is contrary to the linearity of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, which is commonly assumed to govern the dynamics of any isolated physical system. Hence it is necessary to inquire whether a rational treatment of the occurrence of outcomes is possible without some modifications of current quantum mechanics. Whatever decision is reached on this question, however, it does not appear to bear directly on space-time structure, but rather on the general character of processes.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•119 citations
This essay argues that when measurement processes involve energies of the order of the Planck scale, the fundamental assumption of locality may no longer be a good approximation. Idealized position measurements of two distinguishable spin-000 particles are considered. The measurements alter the space-time metric in a fundamental manner governed by the commutation relations [xi,,pj]=ihbar,deltaij[x_i\\,\\,p_j]= i\\hbar\\,\\delta_{ij}[xi​,,pj​]=ihbar,deltaij​ and the classical field equations of gravitation. This {\it in-principle} unavoidable change in the space-time metric destroys the commutativity (and hence locality) of position measurement operators.
In general relativity, the picture of space-time assigns an ideal clock to each world line. Being ideal, gravitational effects due to these clocks are ignored and the flow of time according to one clock is not affected by the presence of clocks along nearby world lines. However, if time is defined operationally, as a pointer position of a physical clock that obeys the principles of general relativity and quantum mechanics, such a picture is, at most, a convenient fiction. Specifically, we show that the general relativistic mass-energy equivalence implies gravitational interaction between the clocks, whereas the quantum mechanical superposition of energy eigenstates leads to a nonfixed metric background. Based only on the assumption that both principles hold in this situation, we show that the clocks necessarily get entangled through time dilation effect, which eventually leads to a loss of coherence of a single clock. Hence, the time as measured by a single clock is not well defined. However, the general relativistic notion of time is recovered in the classical limit of clocks.
The necessity to reconcile the laws of mechanics and electromagnetism has led to question our representation of space and time and to the development of relativity theory. Present most accurate determinations of positions in space and time rely on the exchange of electromagnetic signals and strongly depend on the relativistic conception of space-time. Despite the quantum nature of the electromagnetic fields and atomic clocks used for localization, space-time positions are yet usually treated as classical parameters. As discussed here, relativistic localization may be described by quantum observables representing space-time postions, and defined on the exchanged quantum fields. These quantum localization observables differ from their classical analogs by their non vanishing commutator, which involves spin observables. Alternatively, quantum positions may be defined as commuting but complex observables, which do not commute with their complex conjugates. There result new relations of space-time to algebra and geometry, and in particular modifications of relativistic frame transformations and covariance rules.
In quantum mechanics energy is an observable, whereas time is a parameter; Pauli's theorem and the problem of time in canonical quantum gravity reflect this asymmetry. We define the time operator t^=x^/c \hat{t}=\hat{x}/c t^=x^/c and form, with the relativistic energy E^R \hat{E}_R E^R​, Einstein's constant κ \kappa κ and the time t^0 \hat{t}_0 t^0​ in the rest system, operators of gravitational-field and curvature type, and derive their commutation relations, wave equations and spectra. The commutator [t^,E^R]=iℏcv^x [\hat{t},\hat{E}_R]=\tfrac{i\hbar}{c}\hat{v}_x [t^,E^R​]=ciℏ​v^x​ is bounded with norm ℏ \hbar ℏ and is not a multiple of the identity, so Pauli's theorem is not contradicted. The sum c t^+κE^R c\,\hat{t}+\kappa\hat{E}_R ct^+κE^R​ is unitarily equivalent to the time operator and has a continuous spectrum. A postulated field equation, G^0+Λ^=κE^R \hat{G}_0+\hat{\Lambda}=\kappa\hat{E}_R G^0​+Λ^=κE^R​, has the structure of Einstein's equation; for small velocities it becomes the Schrödinger equation of a particle in a homogeneous field. The metric tensor of this scalar model is not quantized. A metric operator is constructed from commuting position operators; in the vacuum sector it reproduces the Schwarzschild line element, which serves as a consistency test, and in general it is obtained only under an explicit correspondence condition, which is a postulate and not derived.
We investigate whether commutativity is necessary to represent relativistic locality for localization observables of relativistic quantum systems in Minkowski spacetime. A well known no-go theorem by Halvorson and Clifton shows that commutativity of localization effects for causally separated regions is incompatible with other seemingly natural assumptions about spatial localization. Since commutativity is taken to represent locality in the Araki-Haag-Kastler framework of QFT, this prompts the question whether it follows from more elementary locality principles of quantum theory. Using Busch's operational analysis in terms of no-signaling and relativistic consistency, we argue that for particle-like systems commutativity is not implied by these principles. Assuming a natural local detectability principle, elementary localization observables are not localized in arbitrarily small spacetime neighborhoods of the relevant spatial regions, but rather in regions containing the entire rest space (a Cauchy surface) on which the measurement is performed. This reflects the particle picture itself, where localization occurs at a unique place on a rest space filled with ideal detectors, and therefore does not directly conflict with the Araki-Haag-Kastler notion of locality. We also show that commutativity and localization can coexist for less idealized localization procedures. To this end, we introduce conditional localization POVMs associated with bounded spatial regions interpreted as laboratories. By the gentle measurement lemma, these observables describe conditional localization probabilities and can, in principle, satisfy commutativity for causally separated laboratories. They may therefore be represented by local observables in the Araki-Haag-Kastler sense. Explicit examples are presented in a second work within local QFT.
In general relativity, the picture of spacetime assigns an ideal clock to each spacetime point. Being ideal, gravitational effects due to these clocks are ignored and the flow of time according to one clock is not affected by the presence of surrounding clocks. However, if time is defined operationally, as a pointer position of a physical clock that obeys the laws of quantum mechanics and general relativity, such a picture is at most a convenient fiction. We show that the mass-energy equivalence implies gravitational interaction between the clocks, while the superposition of energy eigenstates leads to a non-fixed metric background. Based only on the assumption that both quantum mechanics and general relativity are valid in this situation, we show that the clocks necessarily get entangled through time dilation effect, which eventually leads to a loss of coherence of a single clock. Hence, the time as measured by a single clock is not well-defined. However, the general relativistic notion of time is recovered in the classical limit of clocks.
PROSPECTIVE The concern of this paper will be different from that of most studies of quantum gravity. There will be no discussion of the problem of quantizing the gravitational field equations, hence nothing about the modifications which quantization requires of space-time structure at distances of the order of the Planck length (∼ 10 −33 cm). The emphasis will be rather upon the implications of quantum mechanics for certain general properties of events and processes which occur in the theatre of space-time, specifically with non-locality and nonlinearity . Quantum mechanics is undoubtedly a non-local theory when it treats correlated spatially separated systems. When one examines closely the character of this non-locality, however, one does not find reasons for modifying the causal structure of space-time as described by special or general relativity theory, but rather reasons for refining the concept of an event. The occurrence of definite outcomes of measurements implies that there are processes in nature governed by nonlinear laws. Nonlinearity is very peculiar from the standpoint of quantum mechanics, since it is contrary to the linearity of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, which is commonly assumed to govern the dynamics of any isolated physical system. Hence it is necessary to inquire whether a rational treatment of the occurrence of outcomes is possible without some modifications of current quantum mechanics. Whatever decision is reached on this question, however, it does not appear to bear directly on space-time structure, but rather on the general character of processes.