Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Phase Diagram of the Gonihedric 3d Ising Model via CVM

Emilio N. M. Cirillo, G. Gonnella, Desmond A. Johnston, A. Pelizzola

Published Jul 30, 1996• 20 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We use the cluster variation method (CVM) to investigate the phase structure of the 3d gonihedric Ising actions defined by Savvidy and Wegner. The geometrical spin cluster boundaries in these systems serve as models for the string worldsheets of the gonihedric string embedded in Z 3. The models are interesting from the statistical mechanical point of view because they have a vanishing bare surface tension. As a result the action depends only on the angles of the discrete surface and not on the area, which is the antithesis of the standard 3d Ising model. The results obtained with the CVM are in good agreement with Monte Carlo simulations for the critical temperatures and the order of the transition as the selfavoidance coupling κ is varied. The value of the magnetization critical exponent β = 0.062 ±0.003, calculated with the cluster variation–Padè approximant method, is also close to the simulation results. 1 The Model In this paper we discuss the use of the cluster variation method (CVM) in mapping out the phase diagram of the gonihedric 3d Ising model. The gonihedric 3d Ising model is a generalization of the usual 3d Ising model where planar Peierls boundaries between + and − spins can be created at zero energy cost. It has been introduced in [1] in relations with string theory. The CVM method in other contexts has shown itself to be an accurate and economical way of describing the phase diagram both for first order and continuous transitions. As both the model and the method may be unfamiliar, we outline both in turn before going on to describe our results. The genesis of the model is in a novel discretized random surface theory, the so-called gonihedric string [1],

Related papers

String tension in gonihedric three-dimensional Ising models

M. Baig, Domènec Espriu, Desmond A. Johnston +1 more

For the three-dimensional gonihedric Ising models defined by Savvidy and Wegner the bare string tension is zero and the energy of a spin interface depends only on the number of bends and self-intersections, in antithesis to the standard nearest-neighbour three-dimensional Ising action. When the parameter , weighting the self-intersections, is small the model has a first-order transition and when it is larger the transition is continuous. In this paper we investigate the scaling of the renormalized string tension, which is entirely generated by fluctuations, using Monte Carlo simulations for , 0.1, 0.5 and 1.0. The scaling of the string tension allows us to obtain an estimate for the critical exponents and using both finite-size scaling and data collapse for the scaling function. The behaviour of the string tension when the self-avoidance parameter is small also clearly demonstrates the first-order nature of the transition in this case, in contrast to larger values. Direct estimates of are in good agreement with those obtained from the scaling of the string tension. We have also measured .

arXiv:hep-lat/9703008•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 21, 1997•19 citations

Finite size analysis of the 3D gonihedric Ising model with k=0

M. Baig, J. Clua, Desmond A. Johnston +1 more

We perform a high statistics analysis of the phase transition for the 3D Gonihedric Ising model with kappa=0. This corresponds to an enhanced symmetry point in a class of models defined by Savvidy and Wegner which were originally intended as discrete versions of string theories on cubic lattices. In a previous paper it was shown that the model appeared to display a distinct first order phase transition which persisted for small values of kappa, becoming second order when this latter parameter was further increased. Our finite size analysis here shows that the scaling behaviour actually differs from that expected for a standard first order phase transition and suggests that this may be due to the fixed boundary conditions we employed to ease the definition of a magnetic order parameter. We compare the results with those for the q=8 Potts model in 2D (which also displays a strong first order transition) with fixed boundary conditions in order to provide further supporting evidence.

arXiv:hep-lat/9807043•Jul 30, 1998•0 citations

Another Dual Gonihedric 3D Ising Model

Desmond A. Johnston, R P K C M Ranasinghe

The gonihedric Ising Hamiltonians defined in three and higher dimensions by Savvidy and Wegner provide an extensive, and little explored, catalogue of spin models on (hyper)cubic lattices with many interesting features. In three dimensions the kappa=0 gonihedric Ising model on a cubic lattice has been shown to possess a degenerate low-temperature phase and a first order phase transition, as well as interesting dynamical properties. The dual Hamiltonian to this may be written as an anisotropic Ashkin-Teller model and also has a degenerate low-temperature phase as a result of similar symmetries to the original plaquette action. It is possible to write an alternative dual formulation which utilizes three flavours of spins, rather than the two of the Ashkin-Teller model. This still possesses anisotropic couplings, but all the interaction terms are now four spin couplings and it acquires an additional, local gauge symmetry. We investigate this alternative dual Hamiltonian using zero temperature and mean-field methods together with Monte-Carlo simulations and discuss its properties and the relation to the Ashkin-Teller variant.

arXiv:1106.0325•Jun 1, 2011•4 citations

Multicriticality of the three-dimensional Ising model with plaquette interactions: An extension of Novotny’s transfer-matrix formalism

Yoshihiro Nishiyama

A three-dimensional Ising model with the plaquette-type (next-nearest-neighbor and four-spin) interactions is investigated numerically. This extended Ising model, the so-called gonihedric model, was introduced by Savvidy and Wegner as a discretized version of the interacting (closed) surfaces without surface tension. The gonihedric model is notorious for its slow relaxation to the thermal equilibrium (glassy behavior), which deteriorates the efficiency of the Monte Carlo sampling. We employ the transfer-matrix (TM) method, implementing Novotny's idea, which enables us to treat an arbitrary number of spins N for one TM slice even in three dimensions. This arbitrariness admits systematic finite-size-scaling analyses. Accepting the extended parameter space by Cirillo et al., we analyzed the (multi-) criticality of the gonihedric model for N</=13. Thereby, we found that, as first noted by Cirillo et al. analytically (cluster-variation method), the data are well described by the multicritical (crossover) scaling theory. That is, the previously reported nonstandard criticality for the gonihedric model is reconciled with a crossover exponent and the ordinary three-dimensional-Ising universality class. We estimate the crossover exponent and the correlation-length critical exponent at the multicritical point as phi=0.6(2) and nu; =0.45(15), respectively.

arXiv:cond-mat/0407284•Physical Review E•Aug 31, 2004•12 citations

Cluster-variation–Padé-approximants method and the critical exponents of the fcc Ising model

Alessandro Pelizzola

We report results of the application of a recently proposed technique, which combines the cluster variation method (CVM) and Pad\'e approximants, to the analysis of the critical behavior of the face-centered-cubic Ising model. The highest-order CVM approximation ever considered for this lattice is used to estimate magnetization and susceptibility, which are then analyzed by means of Dlog Pad\'e approximants in order to extract information about the critical behavior, taking also into account the effects of confluent singularities. Our results are in good agreement with the most recent simulation and series expansion estimates and require a remarkably small numerical effort. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Jun 1, 1996•12 citations

Toward a 3d Ising model with a weakly-coupled string theory dual

Nabil Iqbal, John McGreevy

It has long been expected that the 3d Ising model can be thought of as a string theory, where one interprets the domain walls that separate up spins from down spins as two-dimensional string worldsheets. The usual Ising Hamiltonian measures the area of these domain walls. This theory has string coupling of unit magnitude. We add new local terms to the Ising Hamiltonian that further weight each spin configuration by a factor depending on the genus of the corresponding domain wall, resulting in a new 3d Ising model that has a tunable bare string coupling g_s g s . We use a combination of analytical and numerical methods to analyze the phase structure of this model as g_s g s is varied. We study statistical properties of the topology of worldsheets and discuss the prospects of using this new deformation at weak string coupling to find a worldsheet description of the 3d Ising transition.

arXiv:2003.04349•SciPost Physics•Aug 13, 2020•33 citations
We use the cluster variation method (CVM) to investigate the phase structure of the 3d gonihedric Ising actions defined by Savvidy and Wegner. The geometrical spin cluster boundaries in these systems serve as models for the string worldsheets of the gonihedric string embedded in Z 3. The models are interesting from the statistical mechanical point of view because they have a vanishing bare surface tension. As a result the action depends only on the angles of the discrete surface and not on the area, which is the antithesis of the standard 3d Ising model. The results obtained with the CVM are in good agreement with Monte Carlo simulations for the critical temperatures and the order of the transition as the selfavoidance coupling κ is varied. The value of the magnetization critical exponent β = 0.062 ±0.003, calculated with the cluster variation–Padè approximant method, is also close to the simulation results. 1 The Model In this paper we discuss the use of the cluster variation method (CVM) in mapping out the phase diagram of the gonihedric 3d Ising model. The gonihedric 3d Ising model is a generalization of the usual 3d Ising model where planar Peierls boundaries between + and − spins can be created at zero energy cost. It has been introduced in [1] in relations with string theory. The CVM method in other contexts has shown itself to be an accurate and economical way of describing the phase diagram both for first order and continuous transitions. As both the model and the method may be unfamiliar, we outline both in turn before going on to describe our results. The genesis of the model is in a novel discretized random surface theory, the so-called gonihedric string [1],
For the three-dimensional gonihedric Ising models defined by Savvidy and Wegner the bare string tension is zero and the energy of a spin interface depends only on the number of bends and self-intersections, in antithesis to the standard nearest-neighbour three-dimensional Ising action. When the parameter , weighting the self-intersections, is small the model has a first-order transition and when it is larger the transition is continuous. In this paper we investigate the scaling of the renormalized string tension, which is entirely generated by fluctuations, using Monte Carlo simulations for , 0.1, 0.5 and 1.0. The scaling of the string tension allows us to obtain an estimate for the critical exponents and using both finite-size scaling and data collapse for the scaling function. The behaviour of the string tension when the self-avoidance parameter is small also clearly demonstrates the first-order nature of the transition in this case, in contrast to larger values. Direct estimates of are in good agreement with those obtained from the scaling of the string tension. We have also measured .
We perform a high statistics analysis of the phase transition for the 3D Gonihedric Ising model with kappa=0. This corresponds to an enhanced symmetry point in a class of models defined by Savvidy and Wegner which were originally intended as discrete versions of string theories on cubic lattices. In a previous paper it was shown that the model appeared to display a distinct first order phase transition which persisted for small values of kappa, becoming second order when this latter parameter was further increased. Our finite size analysis here shows that the scaling behaviour actually differs from that expected for a standard first order phase transition and suggests that this may be due to the fixed boundary conditions we employed to ease the definition of a magnetic order parameter. We compare the results with those for the q=8 Potts model in 2D (which also displays a strong first order transition) with fixed boundary conditions in order to provide further supporting evidence.
The gonihedric Ising Hamiltonians defined in three and higher dimensions by Savvidy and Wegner provide an extensive, and little explored, catalogue of spin models on (hyper)cubic lattices with many interesting features. In three dimensions the kappa=0 gonihedric Ising model on a cubic lattice has been shown to possess a degenerate low-temperature phase and a first order phase transition, as well as interesting dynamical properties. The dual Hamiltonian to this may be written as an anisotropic Ashkin-Teller model and also has a degenerate low-temperature phase as a result of similar symmetries to the original plaquette action. It is possible to write an alternative dual formulation which utilizes three flavours of spins, rather than the two of the Ashkin-Teller model. This still possesses anisotropic couplings, but all the interaction terms are now four spin couplings and it acquires an additional, local gauge symmetry. We investigate this alternative dual Hamiltonian using zero temperature and mean-field methods together with Monte-Carlo simulations and discuss its properties and the relation to the Ashkin-Teller variant.
A three-dimensional Ising model with the plaquette-type (next-nearest-neighbor and four-spin) interactions is investigated numerically. This extended Ising model, the so-called gonihedric model, was introduced by Savvidy and Wegner as a discretized version of the interacting (closed) surfaces without surface tension. The gonihedric model is notorious for its slow relaxation to the thermal equilibrium (glassy behavior), which deteriorates the efficiency of the Monte Carlo sampling. We employ the transfer-matrix (TM) method, implementing Novotny's idea, which enables us to treat an arbitrary number of spins N for one TM slice even in three dimensions. This arbitrariness admits systematic finite-size-scaling analyses. Accepting the extended parameter space by Cirillo et al., we analyzed the (multi-) criticality of the gonihedric model for N</=13. Thereby, we found that, as first noted by Cirillo et al. analytically (cluster-variation method), the data are well described by the multicritical (crossover) scaling theory. That is, the previously reported nonstandard criticality for the gonihedric model is reconciled with a crossover exponent and the ordinary three-dimensional-Ising universality class. We estimate the crossover exponent and the correlation-length critical exponent at the multicritical point as phi=0.6(2) and nu; =0.45(15), respectively.
We report results of the application of a recently proposed technique, which combines the cluster variation method (CVM) and Pad\'e approximants, to the analysis of the critical behavior of the face-centered-cubic Ising model. The highest-order CVM approximation ever considered for this lattice is used to estimate magnetization and susceptibility, which are then analyzed by means of Dlog Pad\'e approximants in order to extract information about the critical behavior, taking also into account the effects of confluent singularities. Our results are in good agreement with the most recent simulation and series expansion estimates and require a remarkably small numerical effort. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
It has long been expected that the 3d Ising model can be thought of as a string theory, where one interprets the domain walls that separate up spins from down spins as two-dimensional string worldsheets. The usual Ising Hamiltonian measures the area of these domain walls. This theory has string coupling of unit magnitude. We add new local terms to the Ising Hamiltonian that further weight each spin configuration by a factor depending on the genus of the corresponding domain wall, resulting in a new 3d Ising model that has a tunable bare string coupling g_s g s . We use a combination of analytical and numerical methods to analyze the phase structure of this model as g_s g s is varied. We study statistical properties of the topology of worldsheets and discuss the prospects of using this new deformation at weak string coupling to find a worldsheet description of the 3d Ising transition.