Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Error Correction via Convex Optimization

Robert L. Kosut, Daniel A. Lidar

Published Jun 9, 2006• 35 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We show that the problem of designing a quantum information error correcting procedure can be cast as a bi-convex optimization problem, iterating between encoding and recovery, each being a semidefinite program. For a given encoding operator the problem is convex in the recovery operator. For a given method of recovery, the problem is convex in the encoding scheme. This allows us to derive new codes that are locally optimal. We present examples of such codes that can handle errors which are too strong for codes derived by analogy to classical error correction techniques. 1

Related papers

Optimum quantum error recovery using semidefinite programming

Andrew S. Fletcher, Peter W. Shor, Moe Z. Win

Quantum error correction (QEC) is an essential element of physical quantum information processing systems. Most QEC efforts focus on extending classical error correction schemes to the quantum regime. The input to a noisy system is embedded in a coded subspace, and error recovery is performed via an operation designed to perfectly correct for a set of errors, presumably a large subset of the physical noise process. In this paper, we examine the choice of recovery operation. Rather than seeking perfect correction on a subset of errors, we seek a recovery operation to maximize the entanglement fidelity for a given input state and noise model. In this way, the recovery operation is optimal for the given encoding and noise process. This optimization is shown to be calculable via a semidefinite program, a well-established form of convex optimization with efficient algorithms for its solution. The error recovery operation may also be interpreted as a combining operation following a quantum spreading channel, thus providing a quantum analogy to the classical diversity combining operation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0606035•Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2007•124 citations

Robust Quantum Error Correction via Convex Optimization

Robert L. Kosut, Alireza Shabani, Daniel A. Lidar

We present a semidefinite program optimization approach to quantum error correction that yields codes and recovery procedures that are robust against significant variations in the noise channel. Our approach allows us to optimize the encoding, recovery, or both, and is amenable to approximations that significantly improve computational cost while retaining fidelity. We illustrate our theory numerically for optimized 5-qubit codes, using the standard [5,1,3] code as a benchmark. Our optimized encoding and recovery yields fidelities that are uniformly higher by 1-2 orders of magnitude against random unitary weight-2 errors compared to the [5,1,3] code with standard recovery.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703274•Physical Review Letters•Jan 16, 2008•72 citations

Channel-Adapted Quantum Error Correction

Andrew S. Fletcher

Quantum error correction (QEC) is an essential concept for any quantum information processing device. Typically, QEC is designed with minimal assumptions about the noise process; this generic assumption exacts a high cost in efficiency and performance. In physical systems, errors are not likely to be arbitrary; rather we will have reasonable models for the structure of quantum decoherence. We may choose quantum error correcting codes and recovery operations that specifically target the most likely errors. We present a convex optimization method to determine the optimal (in terms of average entanglement fidelity) recovery operation for a given channel, encoding, and information source. This is solvable via a semidefinite program (SDP). We present computational algorithms to generate near-optimal recovery operations structured to begin with a projective syndrome measurement. These structured operations are more computationally scalable than the SDP required for computing the optimal; we can thus numerically analyze longer codes. Using Lagrange duality, we bound the performance of the structured recovery operations and show that they are nearly optimal in many relevant cases. We present two classes of channel-adapted quantum error correcting codes specifically designed for the amplitude damping channel. These have significantly higher rates with shorter block lengths than corresponding generic quantum error correcting codes. Both classes are stabilizer codes, and have good fidelity performance with stabilizer recovery operations. The encoding, syndrome measurement, and syndrome recovery operations can all be implemented with Clifford group operations.

arXiv:0706.3400•Jun 22, 2007•28 citations

Structured near-optimal channel-adapted quantum error correction

Andrew S. Fletcher, Peter W. Shor, Moe Z. Win

We present a class of numerical algorithms which adapt a quantum error correction scheme to a channel model. Given an encoding and a channel model, it was previously shown that the quantum operation that maximizes the average entanglement fidelity may be calculated by a semidefinite program (SDP), which is a convex optimization. While optimal, this recovery operation is computationally difficult for long codes. Furthermore, the optimal recovery operation has no structure beyond the completely positive trace-preserving constraint. We derive methods to generate structured channel-adapted error recovery operations. Specifically, each recovery operation begins with a projective error syndrome measurement. The algorithms to compute the structured recovery operations are more scalable than the SDP and yield recovery operations with an intuitive physical form. Using Lagrange duality, we derive performance bounds to certify near-optimality.

arXiv:0708.3658•Physical Review A•Jan 17, 2008•66 citations

Comment on "Optimum Quantum Error Recovery using Semidefinite Programming"

Michael Reimpell, Reinhard F. Werner, Audenaert, K.

In a recent paper ([1]=quant-ph/0606035) it is shown how the optimal recovery operation in an error correction scheme can be considered as a semidefinite program. As a possible future improvement it is noted that still better error correction might be obtained by optimizing the encoding as well. In this note we present the result of such an improvement, specifically for the four-bit correction of an amplitude damping channel considered in [1]. We get a strict improvement for almost all values of the damping parameter. The method (and the computer code) is taken from our earlier study of such correction schemes (quant-ph/0307138).

arXiv:quant-ph/0606059•Jun 7, 2006•13 citations

Optimization-based quantum error correction

Andrew S. Fletcher

The purpose of quantum error correction (QEC) is to preserve a quantum state despite the presence of decoherence. As we see throughout this book, the desired robustness exacts a cost in resources, most commonly the inclusion of redundant qubits. The following are reasonable engineering queries: How much will it cost to provide the desired robustness? For a fixed cost, what is the best performance I can achieve? In this chapter, we present some numerical tools to illuminate these kinds of questions. To understand the cost/performance trade-off quantitatively, we need a clear measure of performance and a model for permissible operations. With this in mind, we will revisit the concepts of fidelity and quantum operations. As it turns out, this quantitative approach can yield very well structured convex optimization problems. Using powerful numerical tools, we determine optimal encodings and recovery operations. Even if the optimal results are not directly implemented, the optimization tools can provide insight into practical solutions by providing the ultimate performance limits. Limitation of the independent arbitrary errors model As pointed out in Chapter 2, our rich history of classical error correction has provided a significant foundation for QEC methods. As such, the initial QEC breakthroughs involved importing classical coding concepts into a framework that made robust quantum codes (such as CSS codes or the stabilizer code formalism). We learned that we could create general purpose codes that made minimal assumptions about the structure of the decoherence process.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 5, 2013•0 citations
We show that the problem of designing a quantum information error correcting procedure can be cast as a bi-convex optimization problem, iterating between encoding and recovery, each being a semidefinite program. For a given encoding operator the problem is convex in the recovery operator. For a given method of recovery, the problem is convex in the encoding scheme. This allows us to derive new codes that are locally optimal. We present examples of such codes that can handle errors which are too strong for codes derived by analogy to classical error correction techniques. 1
Quantum error correction (QEC) is an essential element of physical quantum information processing systems. Most QEC efforts focus on extending classical error correction schemes to the quantum regime. The input to a noisy system is embedded in a coded subspace, and error recovery is performed via an operation designed to perfectly correct for a set of errors, presumably a large subset of the physical noise process. In this paper, we examine the choice of recovery operation. Rather than seeking perfect correction on a subset of errors, we seek a recovery operation to maximize the entanglement fidelity for a given input state and noise model. In this way, the recovery operation is optimal for the given encoding and noise process. This optimization is shown to be calculable via a semidefinite program, a well-established form of convex optimization with efficient algorithms for its solution. The error recovery operation may also be interpreted as a combining operation following a quantum spreading channel, thus providing a quantum analogy to the classical diversity combining operation.
We present a semidefinite program optimization approach to quantum error correction that yields codes and recovery procedures that are robust against significant variations in the noise channel. Our approach allows us to optimize the encoding, recovery, or both, and is amenable to approximations that significantly improve computational cost while retaining fidelity. We illustrate our theory numerically for optimized 5-qubit codes, using the standard [5,1,3] code as a benchmark. Our optimized encoding and recovery yields fidelities that are uniformly higher by 1-2 orders of magnitude against random unitary weight-2 errors compared to the [5,1,3] code with standard recovery.
Quantum error correction (QEC) is an essential concept for any quantum information processing device. Typically, QEC is designed with minimal assumptions about the noise process; this generic assumption exacts a high cost in efficiency and performance. In physical systems, errors are not likely to be arbitrary; rather we will have reasonable models for the structure of quantum decoherence. We may choose quantum error correcting codes and recovery operations that specifically target the most likely errors. We present a convex optimization method to determine the optimal (in terms of average entanglement fidelity) recovery operation for a given channel, encoding, and information source. This is solvable via a semidefinite program (SDP). We present computational algorithms to generate near-optimal recovery operations structured to begin with a projective syndrome measurement. These structured operations are more computationally scalable than the SDP required for computing the optimal; we can thus numerically analyze longer codes. Using Lagrange duality, we bound the performance of the structured recovery operations and show that they are nearly optimal in many relevant cases. We present two classes of channel-adapted quantum error correcting codes specifically designed for the amplitude damping channel. These have significantly higher rates with shorter block lengths than corresponding generic quantum error correcting codes. Both classes are stabilizer codes, and have good fidelity performance with stabilizer recovery operations. The encoding, syndrome measurement, and syndrome recovery operations can all be implemented with Clifford group operations.
We present a class of numerical algorithms which adapt a quantum error correction scheme to a channel model. Given an encoding and a channel model, it was previously shown that the quantum operation that maximizes the average entanglement fidelity may be calculated by a semidefinite program (SDP), which is a convex optimization. While optimal, this recovery operation is computationally difficult for long codes. Furthermore, the optimal recovery operation has no structure beyond the completely positive trace-preserving constraint. We derive methods to generate structured channel-adapted error recovery operations. Specifically, each recovery operation begins with a projective error syndrome measurement. The algorithms to compute the structured recovery operations are more scalable than the SDP and yield recovery operations with an intuitive physical form. Using Lagrange duality, we derive performance bounds to certify near-optimality.
In a recent paper ([1]=quant-ph/0606035) it is shown how the optimal recovery operation in an error correction scheme can be considered as a semidefinite program. As a possible future improvement it is noted that still better error correction might be obtained by optimizing the encoding as well. In this note we present the result of such an improvement, specifically for the four-bit correction of an amplitude damping channel considered in [1]. We get a strict improvement for almost all values of the damping parameter. The method (and the computer code) is taken from our earlier study of such correction schemes (quant-ph/0307138).
The purpose of quantum error correction (QEC) is to preserve a quantum state despite the presence of decoherence. As we see throughout this book, the desired robustness exacts a cost in resources, most commonly the inclusion of redundant qubits. The following are reasonable engineering queries: How much will it cost to provide the desired robustness? For a fixed cost, what is the best performance I can achieve? In this chapter, we present some numerical tools to illuminate these kinds of questions. To understand the cost/performance trade-off quantitatively, we need a clear measure of performance and a model for permissible operations. With this in mind, we will revisit the concepts of fidelity and quantum operations. As it turns out, this quantitative approach can yield very well structured convex optimization problems. Using powerful numerical tools, we determine optimal encodings and recovery operations. Even if the optimal results are not directly implemented, the optimization tools can provide insight into practical solutions by providing the ultimate performance limits. Limitation of the independent arbitrary errors model As pointed out in Chapter 2, our rich history of classical error correction has provided a significant foundation for QEC methods. As such, the initial QEC breakthroughs involved importing classical coding concepts into a framework that made robust quantum codes (such as CSS codes or the stabilizer code formalism). We learned that we could create general purpose codes that made minimal assumptions about the structure of the decoherence process.