Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Matched detectors as definers of force

F. Hadi Madjid, John M. Myers

Published Jan 1, 2004• 19 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Although quantum states nicely express interference effects, outcomes of experimental trials show no states directly; they indicate properties of probability distributions for outcomes. We prove categorically that probability distributions leave open a choice of quantum states and operators and particles, resolvable only by a move beyond logic, which, inspired or not, can be characterized as a guess. By recognizing guesswork as inescapable in choosing quantum states and particles, we free up the use of particles as theoretical inventions by which to describe experiments with devices, and thereby replace the postulate of state reductions by a theorem. By using the freedom to invent probe particles in modeling light detection, we develop a quantum model of the balancing of a light-induced force, with application to models and detecting devices by which to better distinguish one source of weak light from another. Finally, we uncover a symmetry between entangled states and entangled detectors, a dramatic example of how the judgment about what light state is generated by a source depends on choosing how to model the detector of that light.

Related papers

Simplified quantum mechanics of light detection for quantum cryptography

John M. Myers, F. Hadi Madjid

Strong light signals are detected reliably on a time scale of a nanosecond; however, known detectors of weak light signals used in quantum key distribution (QKD) are much slower; they involve pulse-shaping arbiters based on flip-flops that take many nanoseconds to produce a stable output. Based on a recently shown logical independence of quantum particles from the devices that they are employed to explain, we make use of quantum mechanics fine-tuned so that particles serve not as rigid foundations but as improvised hypotheses useful in models that describe the recorded behavior of devices. On the experimental side, we augment the arbitrating flip-flop of a detector so that it fans out to a matched pair of auxiliary flip-flops, and show how this imparts to a detector a "self-awareness" of its own teetering, as announced by disagreements between the auxiliary flip-flops. We introduce a quantum model of this arrangement, invoking a pair of probe particles, and show this model corresponds well to an experiment. The matched pair of auxiliary flip-flops not only confirms the model of hesitation in a detector, but serves as an instrument, both conceptual and practical, that gives an added dimension to the characterization of signal sources.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 24, 2004•0 citations

Speaking of sensing in the language of quantum mechanics

John M. Myers

Currently there is interest in the possibility of using quantum-mechanically entangled light to enhance the spatial resolution of sensors. Here I review some applications of equations in quantum-mechanical form to the design of sensors and related systems. In order to consider comparing equations against experiments, we will need to distinguish models comprised of mathematical formulas, whether quantum-mechanical or classical, from experiments with devices such as lasers and light detectors. The following sections sketch: * two known ways to connect quantum models to experiments (one statistical-mechanical, the other by way of probabilities); * an approximate way to translate from equations of classical electromagnetism to the quantum language of photons and detection probabilities, concentrating on interferometric effects; * quantum-mechanically suggested possibilities and obstacles for light-based radar (lidar) to enhance positional accuracy and spatial resolution; * a recently proved universal gap between, on one hand, quantum-mechanical models composed of equations and, on the other hand, experiments with devices, with the consequent need and opportunities for a designer to choose models as descriptions of measured behavior.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Apr 27, 2007•1 citation

Synchronizing Rhythms of Logic

John M. Myers, Hadi Madjid

Although quantum states nicely explain experiments, the outcomes of experiments are not states. Instead, outcomes correspond to probability distributions. Twenty years ago we proved categorically that probability distributions leave open a choice of quantum states to explain experiments that is resolvable only by a move beyond logic, which, inspired or not, can be characterized as a guess. Guesses link the inner lives of investigators to their explanations of experimental results. Recognizing the inescapability of guesswork in physics leads to avenues of investigation, one of which is presented here. We invert the quest for the logical foundations of physics to reveal a physical basis for logic and calculation, and we represent this basis mathematically, in such a way as to show the shaping and re-shaping of calculations by guesswork. We draw on the interplay between guessing and computation in digital contexts that, perhaps surprisingly, include living organisms. Digital computation and communication depend on a type of synchronization that coordinates transitions among physically distinct conditions represented by "digits." This logical synchronization, known to engineers but neglected in physics, requires guesswork for its maintenance. By abstracting digital hardware, we model the structure of human thinking as logically synchronized computation, punctuated by guesses. We adapt marked graphs to mathematically represent computation and represent guesses by unpredictable changes in these marked graphs. The marked graphs reveal a logical substructure to spatial and temporal navigation, with implications across physics and its biological applications. By limiting our model to the logical aspect of communications and computations we unveil logical structure in relation to guesswork, applicable not just to electronics but also to the functioning of living organisms.

arXiv:2405.20788•May 19, 2024•2 citations

Experimenters' Free Will and Quantum Certainty

J.J. Bisognano

Physics has long lived with a schizophrenia that desires determinism for measured systems while demanding that experimenters decide what to measure on a whim. Intriguingly, such a free will assumption for experimenters has thwarted many attempts to provide a satisfactory explanation of how quantum probabilities evolve to clear-cut measurements. An overview of this quantum measurement problem is presented without equations, and the lesson is drawn that denial of experimenters' free will may be the only workable solutions. If the free will assumption is rejected, then a door is open that may ultimately reconcile quantum mechanics with the definiteness of individual experiments. A holistic view is offered for an Escher-like self-consistent space-time net of events rather than a conspiracy of initial conditions as a way forward.

arXiv:1211.1917•Nov 8, 2012•0 citations

Experimental Bound on the Maximum Predictive Power of Physical Theories

Terence E. Stuart, Joshua A. Slater, Roger Colbeck +2 more

The question of whether the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanical predictions can be alleviated by supplementing the wave function with additional information has received a lot of attention during the past century. A few specific models have been suggested and subsequently falsified. Here we give a more general answer to this question: We provide experimental data that, as well as falsifying these models, cannot be explained within any alternative theory that could predict the outcomes of measurements on maximally entangled particles with significantly higher probability than quantum theory. Our conclusion is based on the assumptions that all measurement settings have been chosen freely (within a causal structure compatible with relativity theory), and that the presence of the detection loophole did not affect the measurement outcomes.

arXiv:1105.0133•Physical Review Letters•Jul 9, 2012•35 citations

Quantum-mechanical motion and the stillness of experimental records

F. Hadi Madjid, John M. Myers

Experimenting with metastability in recording devices leads us to wonder about an interface between equations of motion and the stillness of experimental records. Here we delineate an interface between wave functions as language to describe motion and Turing tapes as language to describe experimental records. After extending quantum formalism to make this interface explicit, we report on constraints and freedoms in choosing quantum-mechanical equations to model experiments with devices. We prove that choosing equations of wave functions and operators to achieve a fit between calculated probabilities and experimental records requires reaching beyond both logic and the experimental records. Although informed by experience, a "reach beyond" can fairly be called a guess. Recognizing that particles as features of wave functions depend on guesswork, we introduce their use not as objects of physical investigation but as elements of thought in quantum-mechanical models of devices. We make informed guesses to offer a quantum-mechanical model of a 1-bit recording device in a metastable condition. Probabilities calculated from the model fit an experimental record of an oscillation in a time-varying probability, showing a temperature-independent role for Planck's constant in what heretofore was viewed as a "classical" electronic device.

arXiv:quant-ph/0305096•May 19, 2003•0 citations
Although quantum states nicely express interference effects, outcomes of experimental trials show no states directly; they indicate properties of probability distributions for outcomes. We prove categorically that probability distributions leave open a choice of quantum states and operators and particles, resolvable only by a move beyond logic, which, inspired or not, can be characterized as a guess. By recognizing guesswork as inescapable in choosing quantum states and particles, we free up the use of particles as theoretical inventions by which to describe experiments with devices, and thereby replace the postulate of state reductions by a theorem. By using the freedom to invent probe particles in modeling light detection, we develop a quantum model of the balancing of a light-induced force, with application to models and detecting devices by which to better distinguish one source of weak light from another. Finally, we uncover a symmetry between entangled states and entangled detectors, a dramatic example of how the judgment about what light state is generated by a source depends on choosing how to model the detector of that light.
Strong light signals are detected reliably on a time scale of a nanosecond; however, known detectors of weak light signals used in quantum key distribution (QKD) are much slower; they involve pulse-shaping arbiters based on flip-flops that take many nanoseconds to produce a stable output. Based on a recently shown logical independence of quantum particles from the devices that they are employed to explain, we make use of quantum mechanics fine-tuned so that particles serve not as rigid foundations but as improvised hypotheses useful in models that describe the recorded behavior of devices. On the experimental side, we augment the arbitrating flip-flop of a detector so that it fans out to a matched pair of auxiliary flip-flops, and show how this imparts to a detector a "self-awareness" of its own teetering, as announced by disagreements between the auxiliary flip-flops. We introduce a quantum model of this arrangement, invoking a pair of probe particles, and show this model corresponds well to an experiment. The matched pair of auxiliary flip-flops not only confirms the model of hesitation in a detector, but serves as an instrument, both conceptual and practical, that gives an added dimension to the characterization of signal sources.
Currently there is interest in the possibility of using quantum-mechanically entangled light to enhance the spatial resolution of sensors. Here I review some applications of equations in quantum-mechanical form to the design of sensors and related systems. In order to consider comparing equations against experiments, we will need to distinguish models comprised of mathematical formulas, whether quantum-mechanical or classical, from experiments with devices such as lasers and light detectors. The following sections sketch: * two known ways to connect quantum models to experiments (one statistical-mechanical, the other by way of probabilities); * an approximate way to translate from equations of classical electromagnetism to the quantum language of photons and detection probabilities, concentrating on interferometric effects; * quantum-mechanically suggested possibilities and obstacles for light-based radar (lidar) to enhance positional accuracy and spatial resolution; * a recently proved universal gap between, on one hand, quantum-mechanical models composed of equations and, on the other hand, experiments with devices, with the consequent need and opportunities for a designer to choose models as descriptions of measured behavior.
Although quantum states nicely explain experiments, the outcomes of experiments are not states. Instead, outcomes correspond to probability distributions. Twenty years ago we proved categorically that probability distributions leave open a choice of quantum states to explain experiments that is resolvable only by a move beyond logic, which, inspired or not, can be characterized as a guess. Guesses link the inner lives of investigators to their explanations of experimental results. Recognizing the inescapability of guesswork in physics leads to avenues of investigation, one of which is presented here. We invert the quest for the logical foundations of physics to reveal a physical basis for logic and calculation, and we represent this basis mathematically, in such a way as to show the shaping and re-shaping of calculations by guesswork. We draw on the interplay between guessing and computation in digital contexts that, perhaps surprisingly, include living organisms. Digital computation and communication depend on a type of synchronization that coordinates transitions among physically distinct conditions represented by "digits." This logical synchronization, known to engineers but neglected in physics, requires guesswork for its maintenance. By abstracting digital hardware, we model the structure of human thinking as logically synchronized computation, punctuated by guesses. We adapt marked graphs to mathematically represent computation and represent guesses by unpredictable changes in these marked graphs. The marked graphs reveal a logical substructure to spatial and temporal navigation, with implications across physics and its biological applications. By limiting our model to the logical aspect of communications and computations we unveil logical structure in relation to guesswork, applicable not just to electronics but also to the functioning of living organisms.
Physics has long lived with a schizophrenia that desires determinism for measured systems while demanding that experimenters decide what to measure on a whim. Intriguingly, such a free will assumption for experimenters has thwarted many attempts to provide a satisfactory explanation of how quantum probabilities evolve to clear-cut measurements. An overview of this quantum measurement problem is presented without equations, and the lesson is drawn that denial of experimenters' free will may be the only workable solutions. If the free will assumption is rejected, then a door is open that may ultimately reconcile quantum mechanics with the definiteness of individual experiments. A holistic view is offered for an Escher-like self-consistent space-time net of events rather than a conspiracy of initial conditions as a way forward.
The question of whether the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanical predictions can be alleviated by supplementing the wave function with additional information has received a lot of attention during the past century. A few specific models have been suggested and subsequently falsified. Here we give a more general answer to this question: We provide experimental data that, as well as falsifying these models, cannot be explained within any alternative theory that could predict the outcomes of measurements on maximally entangled particles with significantly higher probability than quantum theory. Our conclusion is based on the assumptions that all measurement settings have been chosen freely (within a causal structure compatible with relativity theory), and that the presence of the detection loophole did not affect the measurement outcomes.
Experimenting with metastability in recording devices leads us to wonder about an interface between equations of motion and the stillness of experimental records. Here we delineate an interface between wave functions as language to describe motion and Turing tapes as language to describe experimental records. After extending quantum formalism to make this interface explicit, we report on constraints and freedoms in choosing quantum-mechanical equations to model experiments with devices. We prove that choosing equations of wave functions and operators to achieve a fit between calculated probabilities and experimental records requires reaching beyond both logic and the experimental records. Although informed by experience, a "reach beyond" can fairly be called a guess. Recognizing that particles as features of wave functions depend on guesswork, we introduce their use not as objects of physical investigation but as elements of thought in quantum-mechanical models of devices. We make informed guesses to offer a quantum-mechanical model of a 1-bit recording device in a metastable condition. Probabilities calculated from the model fit an experimental record of an oscillation in a time-varying probability, showing a temperature-independent role for Planck's constant in what heretofore was viewed as a "classical" electronic device.