Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A New Paradox Using Electrodynamics and Relativity

Laxman Bist

Published Jan 1, 2018• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The laws of physics including the laws of electrodynamics and relativity have worked very well so far when applied within their proper domain. But the history of physics hasn’t always been smooth. Various philosophical, mathematical and physical consequences have sometimes led scientists to face arguments leading to paradoxes. Here, using the laws of electrodynamics and relativity, I propose a thought experiment which leads to a paradox challenging the common conception of reality. In this thought experiment, the two inertial observers will end up with paradoxical consequences while analyzing the measurement, taken from their own frame, from a force measuring device.

Related papers

The Bohr—Einstein confrontation: phenomena and physical reality

Sandro Petruccioli

As Quine wrote in 1961, what strikes us in a paradox is its initial air of absurdity, which develops into a sort of psychological discomfort when we compare the conclusions of the reasoning with the apparently irrefutable arguments on which it is based. However, as he went on to observe, ‘More than once in history the discovery of paradox has been the occasion for major reconstruction at the foundations of thought’. Catastrophe may therefore lurk even in the most innocent-seeming of paradoxes and force us to recognize the arbitrary nature ‘of a buried premise or of some preconception previously reckoned as central to physical theory, to mathematics or to the thinking process’. More recently, ideas of this kind have been used to assert in general that the role of paradox in the growth of knowledge is to generate category switches and to construct new universes of discourse. It could also be argued that paradoxes constitute elements of the logic of discovery capable of amplifying and thus making intelligible the still obscure phases accompanying paradigm shifts. Paradoxes would thus represent points of accumulation for the tension created between a given system of conceptual representation and a theory or empirical discovery that violates it. Historians of science have tried different interpretative approaches in their attempts to unravel the thought process that was to lead Einstein in 1905 to the formulation of special relativity and the simultaneous demolition of the classical conception of space and time.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 18, 1993•0 citations

The Relativity of Physical Laws: A Philosophical Inquiry

begum yildirim

This paper investigates whether physical laws are absolute or observer-dependent, bridging scientific theories and philosophical thought. It contrasts the absoluteness foundational to classical physics with the relativity introduced by Einstein and the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics. The author argues that while physical laws appear universal, their interpretation and application may vary depending on the observer’s frame of reference. The discussion highlights how modern physics challenges traditional notions of objectivity, suggesting that context and observation play crucial roles in defining physical reality. Originality and AI-use statement: This work is an original research output by Begüm Yıldırım. AI tools, if used, were limited to language refinement, grammar correction, formatting, translation assistance, and clarity improvement. The conceptual framework, research direction, interpretation, models, and conclusions belong to the author. External sources, datasets, or prior works are cited where applicable.

•May 19, 2026•0 citations

Expanding Research Paradigms and Reconciling the Two Binary Oppositions: Exploring the Unified Path of Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Runsheng Tu

By expanding the research paradigm and reconciling the two binary oppositions of "relative and absolute" and "quantum and classical" in physics, a new theoretical framework that is compatible with relativity and quantum mechanics is proposed. Firstly, excavate and establish three universal axioms: Axiom 1 (consensus guarantees equal rights), Axiom 2 (objective existence independent of measurement), and Axiom 3 (universality of causality and dialectical logic), based on which to criticize the logical contradictions of existing theories. In the field of relativity, this article points out that there is a logical paradox in the explanation of "clock slowing down depends on relative motion" in special relativity (A clock is both faster and slower than B clock), and proposes a relative absolute spacetime view that "absolute motion leads to clock slowing down". By extending the Lorentz transformation, absolute motion and relative motion are unified, solving problems such as the twin paradox. At the same time, based on the prediction of the Dirac equation for negative mass matter, the "negative mass spacetime curvature paradox" is proposed, challenging Einstein's physical explanation of spacetime curvature and arguing that it is only a mathematical tool (the mathematical expression of gravity) rather than a physical reality. In the field of quantum mechanics, this article criticizes the Copenhagen interpretation for violating Axiom 2 (denying the independent eigenstates of microscopic particles). By modifying the Schrödinger equation twice (For the first time, electromagnetic potential energy was replaced with gravitational potential energy, and the Schrödinger-Tu equation was established to describe macroscopic objects such as the Earth's revolution; The second step is to convert potential energy into electromagnetic/gravitational force and derive the wave mechanics equation of classical mechanics laws, such as Newton's second law with force operator), proves that quantum and classical theories are compatible within the same mathematical framework. In the experiment, it was demonstrated through the "anti-interference electron diffraction experiment" that a strong magnetic field only changes the shape of diffraction fringes without causing them to disappear, denying the inevitability of quantum decoherence. The establishment of "generalized wave dynamics" and "relative absolute spacetime view" breaks the binary opposition of traditional theories and provides a new paradigm for the unity of relativity and quantum mechanics. The core value of these jobs lies in: In terms of theoretical innovation, reconstruct the space-time and quantum interpretation system, while retaining the original mathematical form system; In terms of experimental verification, design feasible schemes such as hollow glass disk Jones experiment and geometric optical velocimetry experiment; In terms of philosophical significance, replacing "mathematical symmetry" with "content unity" and returning to the objectivity of physical mechanisms. The research conclusion indicates that by expanding paradigms and axiomatic constraints, the contradiction between relativity and quantum mechanics can be transformed into a complementary relationship, laying the foundation for the great unity of physics theory

Advances in Theoretical & Computational Physics•Aug 25, 2026•0 citations

The original Wigner’s friend paradox within a realist toy model

Matteo Lostaglio, Joseph Bowles

The original Wigner’s friend paradox is a gedankenexperiment involving an observer described by an external agent. The paradox highlights the tension between unitary evolution and collapse in quantum theory, and is sometimes taken as requiring a reassessment of the notion of objective reality. In this note, however, we present a classical toy model in which (i) the contradicting predictions at the heart of the thought experiment are reproduced (ii) every system is in a well-defined state at all times. The toy model shows how puzzles such as Wigner’s friend’s experience of being in a superposition, conflicts between different agents’ descriptions of the experiment, the positioning of the Heisenberg’s cut and the apparent lack of objectivity of measurement outcomes can be explained within a classical model where there exists an objective state of affairs about every physical system at all times. Within the model, the debate surrounding the original Wigner’s friend thought experiment and its resolution have striking similarities with arguments concerning the nature of the second law of thermodynamics. The same conclusion however does not apply to more recent extensions of the gedankenexperiment featuring multiple encapsulated observers, and shows that such extensions are indeed necessary avoid simple classical explanations.

arXiv:2101.11032•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Oct 1, 2021•43 citations

The link between relativity and quantum mechanics

Mohamed Daris

During the last years, many innovations in the exploration and exploitation of theorems and new models in physics have been realized. But the problem that is very often is how we have seen the bodies, particles and systems moving through our planet. For that I decided to make a research action that allows the connection between two different concepts and very difficult to understand them or interpret them are the quantum mechanics and relativity. This book essentially deals with this big problem with all the aspects possible and all cases of research were put in this book. This book should be aimed at the scientific community, at the most by the young researchers, the students of the scientific and technical faculties of different levels, or any person has a scientific aspect and wants to investigate the new in physics.

•Jul 7, 2018•0 citations

Decoherence and Perceptual Smoothing in a Discretely Updated EQGT Universe

Toru Kawahara

Decoherence and Perceptual Smoothing in a Discretely Updated EQGT Universe presents a conceptual extension of the EQGT framework, offering a structural reinterpretation of decoherence, observable continuity, and conservation laws. Rather than treating decoherence as a fundamental physical process or conservation laws as axiomatic principles, this work argues that all three emerge naturally from a universe that is updated discretely at scales far below observational resolution. Physical reality is modeled not as a collection of persistent static entities, but as dynamically regenerated patterns that either succeed or fail to propagate across successive frame updates. Two key mechanisms are introduced: Frame Skipping: sub-frame events that do not survive across frame boundaries leave no trace in observable history. Perceptual Smoothing: the effective averaging imposed by observational limitations, whereby only frame-persistent structures dominate experienced continuity. Within this framework, decoherence arises as the failure of fine-grained correlations to survive statistical dominance and inter-frame propagation, rather than as an active destruction of coherence. Conservation laws emerge as effective constraints applying only to quantities that persist across frames, while sub-frame redistributions remain observationally inaccessible. This paper is intentionally qualitative and structural. It does not propose new dynamical equations, but instead clarifies how discreteness, continuity, decoherence, and conservation can be understood as mutually consistent consequences of observational embedding within a regenerative universe. The work is released under a CC0 (public domain) license to encourage unrestricted examination, critique, and extension across physics, information theory, and philosophy of science.

•Jan 3, 2026•0 citations
The laws of physics including the laws of electrodynamics and relativity have worked very well so far when applied within their proper domain. But the history of physics hasn’t always been smooth. Various philosophical, mathematical and physical consequences have sometimes led scientists to face arguments leading to paradoxes. Here, using the laws of electrodynamics and relativity, I propose a thought experiment which leads to a paradox challenging the common conception of reality. In this thought experiment, the two inertial observers will end up with paradoxical consequences while analyzing the measurement, taken from their own frame, from a force measuring device.
As Quine wrote in 1961, what strikes us in a paradox is its initial air of absurdity, which develops into a sort of psychological discomfort when we compare the conclusions of the reasoning with the apparently irrefutable arguments on which it is based. However, as he went on to observe, ‘More than once in history the discovery of paradox has been the occasion for major reconstruction at the foundations of thought’. Catastrophe may therefore lurk even in the most innocent-seeming of paradoxes and force us to recognize the arbitrary nature ‘of a buried premise or of some preconception previously reckoned as central to physical theory, to mathematics or to the thinking process’. More recently, ideas of this kind have been used to assert in general that the role of paradox in the growth of knowledge is to generate category switches and to construct new universes of discourse. It could also be argued that paradoxes constitute elements of the logic of discovery capable of amplifying and thus making intelligible the still obscure phases accompanying paradigm shifts. Paradoxes would thus represent points of accumulation for the tension created between a given system of conceptual representation and a theory or empirical discovery that violates it. Historians of science have tried different interpretative approaches in their attempts to unravel the thought process that was to lead Einstein in 1905 to the formulation of special relativity and the simultaneous demolition of the classical conception of space and time.
This paper investigates whether physical laws are absolute or observer-dependent, bridging scientific theories and philosophical thought. It contrasts the absoluteness foundational to classical physics with the relativity introduced by Einstein and the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics. The author argues that while physical laws appear universal, their interpretation and application may vary depending on the observer’s frame of reference. The discussion highlights how modern physics challenges traditional notions of objectivity, suggesting that context and observation play crucial roles in defining physical reality. Originality and AI-use statement: This work is an original research output by Begüm Yıldırım. AI tools, if used, were limited to language refinement, grammar correction, formatting, translation assistance, and clarity improvement. The conceptual framework, research direction, interpretation, models, and conclusions belong to the author. External sources, datasets, or prior works are cited where applicable.
By expanding the research paradigm and reconciling the two binary oppositions of "relative and absolute" and "quantum and classical" in physics, a new theoretical framework that is compatible with relativity and quantum mechanics is proposed. Firstly, excavate and establish three universal axioms: Axiom 1 (consensus guarantees equal rights), Axiom 2 (objective existence independent of measurement), and Axiom 3 (universality of causality and dialectical logic), based on which to criticize the logical contradictions of existing theories. In the field of relativity, this article points out that there is a logical paradox in the explanation of "clock slowing down depends on relative motion" in special relativity (A clock is both faster and slower than B clock), and proposes a relative absolute spacetime view that "absolute motion leads to clock slowing down". By extending the Lorentz transformation, absolute motion and relative motion are unified, solving problems such as the twin paradox. At the same time, based on the prediction of the Dirac equation for negative mass matter, the "negative mass spacetime curvature paradox" is proposed, challenging Einstein's physical explanation of spacetime curvature and arguing that it is only a mathematical tool (the mathematical expression of gravity) rather than a physical reality. In the field of quantum mechanics, this article criticizes the Copenhagen interpretation for violating Axiom 2 (denying the independent eigenstates of microscopic particles). By modifying the Schrödinger equation twice (For the first time, electromagnetic potential energy was replaced with gravitational potential energy, and the Schrödinger-Tu equation was established to describe macroscopic objects such as the Earth's revolution; The second step is to convert potential energy into electromagnetic/gravitational force and derive the wave mechanics equation of classical mechanics laws, such as Newton's second law with force operator), proves that quantum and classical theories are compatible within the same mathematical framework. In the experiment, it was demonstrated through the "anti-interference electron diffraction experiment" that a strong magnetic field only changes the shape of diffraction fringes without causing them to disappear, denying the inevitability of quantum decoherence. The establishment of "generalized wave dynamics" and "relative absolute spacetime view" breaks the binary opposition of traditional theories and provides a new paradigm for the unity of relativity and quantum mechanics. The core value of these jobs lies in: In terms of theoretical innovation, reconstruct the space-time and quantum interpretation system, while retaining the original mathematical form system; In terms of experimental verification, design feasible schemes such as hollow glass disk Jones experiment and geometric optical velocimetry experiment; In terms of philosophical significance, replacing "mathematical symmetry" with "content unity" and returning to the objectivity of physical mechanisms. The research conclusion indicates that by expanding paradigms and axiomatic constraints, the contradiction between relativity and quantum mechanics can be transformed into a complementary relationship, laying the foundation for the great unity of physics theory
The original Wigner’s friend paradox is a gedankenexperiment involving an observer described by an external agent. The paradox highlights the tension between unitary evolution and collapse in quantum theory, and is sometimes taken as requiring a reassessment of the notion of objective reality. In this note, however, we present a classical toy model in which (i) the contradicting predictions at the heart of the thought experiment are reproduced (ii) every system is in a well-defined state at all times. The toy model shows how puzzles such as Wigner’s friend’s experience of being in a superposition, conflicts between different agents’ descriptions of the experiment, the positioning of the Heisenberg’s cut and the apparent lack of objectivity of measurement outcomes can be explained within a classical model where there exists an objective state of affairs about every physical system at all times. Within the model, the debate surrounding the original Wigner’s friend thought experiment and its resolution have striking similarities with arguments concerning the nature of the second law of thermodynamics. The same conclusion however does not apply to more recent extensions of the gedankenexperiment featuring multiple encapsulated observers, and shows that such extensions are indeed necessary avoid simple classical explanations.
During the last years, many innovations in the exploration and exploitation of theorems and new models in physics have been realized. But the problem that is very often is how we have seen the bodies, particles and systems moving through our planet. For that I decided to make a research action that allows the connection between two different concepts and very difficult to understand them or interpret them are the quantum mechanics and relativity. This book essentially deals with this big problem with all the aspects possible and all cases of research were put in this book. This book should be aimed at the scientific community, at the most by the young researchers, the students of the scientific and technical faculties of different levels, or any person has a scientific aspect and wants to investigate the new in physics.
Decoherence and Perceptual Smoothing in a Discretely Updated EQGT Universe presents a conceptual extension of the EQGT framework, offering a structural reinterpretation of decoherence, observable continuity, and conservation laws. Rather than treating decoherence as a fundamental physical process or conservation laws as axiomatic principles, this work argues that all three emerge naturally from a universe that is updated discretely at scales far below observational resolution. Physical reality is modeled not as a collection of persistent static entities, but as dynamically regenerated patterns that either succeed or fail to propagate across successive frame updates. Two key mechanisms are introduced: Frame Skipping: sub-frame events that do not survive across frame boundaries leave no trace in observable history. Perceptual Smoothing: the effective averaging imposed by observational limitations, whereby only frame-persistent structures dominate experienced continuity. Within this framework, decoherence arises as the failure of fine-grained correlations to survive statistical dominance and inter-frame propagation, rather than as an active destruction of coherence. Conservation laws emerge as effective constraints applying only to quantities that persist across frames, while sub-frame redistributions remain observationally inaccessible. This paper is intentionally qualitative and structural. It does not propose new dynamical equations, but instead clarifies how discreteness, continuity, decoherence, and conservation can be understood as mutually consistent consequences of observational embedding within a regenerative universe. The work is released under a CC0 (public domain) license to encourage unrestricted examination, critique, and extension across physics, information theory, and philosophy of science.