Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Theory of Relativity and Measurement Uncertainty

Ratan Dasgupta

Published Oct 1, 2020• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Relativity of simultaneity is shown to limit the accuracy in simultaneous measurement of position and momentum of a moving body by an inertial observer. The inaccuracy or uncertainty product derived from special relativity theory is found to be similar to the much known quantum mechanical uncertainty relation. However, whether the above two uncertainty relations indicate the same physics is debatable and any conclusion is not attempted here. A modification of this relativistic uncertainty formula under gravitational field is achieved using general relativity principles, and a small gravitational correction term has to be introduced. This gravitational term being small remains negligible in ordinary conditions but becomes appreciable at small time scale.

Related papers

Incompatibility between Einstein's general relativity and Heisenberg's uncertainty principle

Alexandre Georges

Are General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics incompatible?Each in their world, that of the infinitely large and that of the infinitely small, they did not seem to interfere as long as they avoided each other.However, it is their fundamental oppositions that prevent the scientific community from achieving a unification of physics.The proposal of this paper is to provide a mathematical proof of incompatibility, beyond the fact that they have fundamentally different principles, between the foundations of General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, namely, the deformation of the space-time geometry and the Uncertainty Principle.It will thus be possible to provide an absolute limitation in establishing a unifying theory of physics, if any.Moreover, while respecting the conditions fixed by the Uncertainty Principle, it will be tempted to determine with accuracy and simultaneity, the position and the speed of a nonrelativistic particle, by application of relativistic principles and bypassing the problems raised by such an operation.The Uncertainty Principle as stated by Werner Heisenberg will be then, in the light of observations made on the measurement of the time dilatation and in accordance with its own terms, refuted by the present.

Physics Essays•Sep 1, 2018•3 citations

Theory and phenomenology of relativistic corrections to the Heisenberg principle

Giovanni Amelino-camelia A, Valerio Astuti

One of the main objectives of quantum-gravity research is to establish how the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty principle is modified by Planck-scale effects. We here focus on some residual gray areas of our understanding of the interplay between the uncertainty principle and special relativity, which might have been an obstacle for the further generalization needed in order to include gravitational effects. In its original formulation the uncertainty principle is inconsistent with special relativity, and in nearly a century of investigation not much progress has been made toward a satisfactory reformulation. Some partial insight has been gained in the ultra-high-velocity regime, but a full description is still missing and in particular we have no clue about the intermediate regime of particles whose speeds are much smaller than the speed of light but still high enough for tangible departures from the Heisenberg formulation. As we stress here, that intermediate regime is also our best chance for testing experimentally our understanding of the implications of special relativity for the uncertainty principle. We introduce a new approach toward facing these challenges, based mainly on the observation that the only operative notion of position of a particle at a given time involves the crossing of the worldline of that particle with the worldline of a test particle. We find that the worldline-crossing perspective opens a path toward a special-relativistic version of the uncertainty principle, which indeed could be tested experimentally.

arXiv:2209.04350•Modern Physics Letters A•Mar 25, 2026•3 citations

W. Heisenberg's Measurement Uncertainty Principle and A. Einstein's General Theory of Relativity

Thierry Periat

In exposing his uncertainty principle, W. Heisenberg has pointed out the fact that positions and speeds form two separate and independent sets of observables. He also suggested that infinitesimal variations of energies and lapses of times were following a similar logic. Unfortunately, there is up to now no operator representing the time and, at least at a technical level, this absence is blocking the progression of any development for the second pair. Whatever the interpretation of that principle is, a fact is that it introduces a finite limit for the relative variations of these pairs. The situations realizing the minimum value of a product between both elements of a given pair are labeled as “quantum limit”. And this is the information on which I build my theoretical proposition. Following a well-known and accepted principle affirming that the laws of physics must be the same everywhere, I look for technical circumstances allowing to go further on that road. Concretely, that quantum limit must be the same for two observers, wherever they stay in the world. I consider the simplest transposition of Heisenberg’ suggested interdependence between the elements of the pair (delta energy, delta lapse of time) in a simple one-dimensional world. And I ask me where, in the arsenal of formulas and laws of physics, I can find a plausible manner to introduce these ingredients softly.

•Nov 1, 2020•0 citations

Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle

The more precisely the position of a particle is determined, the less precisely its momentum can be known, and conversely. This is the content of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. First stated in 1927, the inequality Δ x Δ p ≥ ℏ /2 is not a limitation of measuring instruments but a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics: position and momentum are complementary observables whose simultaneous sharp values are excluded by the structure of the theory. Few relations have so thoroughly changed the meaning of physical knowledge at the microscopic scale.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations

Theory of Temporal Relativity

Alessio Piccinotti

The Theory of Temporal Relativity proposes a unified theoretical framework that extends Special and General Relativity into the complex domain, integrating aspects of Quantum Mechanics within a single geometrical structure. The theory introduces a generalized Hilbert-space geometry and interprets quantum states as observer-dependent, arising from complex temporal relations between reference frames. Theory of Temporal Relativity is a theoretical framework proposing a unified extension of Special and General Relativity into the complex domain, with the goal of incorporating aspects of Quantum Mechanics within a consistent geometrical model. The theory generalizes Hilbert-space geometry and relativistic invariance to complex coordinates, introducing observer-dependent descriptions of physical quantities and a reinterpretation of quantum states as complex-phase relations between reference frames. Within this model, fundamental constants such as c, G, and h are not strictly universal but can exhibit apparent local variations arising from the observer’s position in the complex spacetime manifold. These variations preserve global covariance and CPT symmetry while reconciling quantum non-locality with relativistic kinematics. The framework predicts experimentally testable effects, including measurable phase shifts in interferometric experiments, possible frequency modulations in non-inertial systems, and small local deviations of physical constants detectable in condensed-matter and gravitational contexts. The supplementary work, “Quantum Uncertainty, Planck’s Constant, and Ontological Insights from Complex Spacetime Geometry and Local Metric Deformations”, develops the principle of Temporal Relativity as a foundational element of the theory. It formalizes the connection between quantum uncertainty, metric deformations, and complex temporal structures, within an alternative logical framework (AU). This extension provides both an ontological interpretation of the wavefunction and a basis for the emergence of quantum indeterminacy from geometric causes. Together, these works present a coherent attempt to unify the relativistic and quantum domains under a single complex-geometric view of spacetime, maintaining mathematical rigor while providing clear experimental pathways for empirical validation.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

The Derivation and Some Explanations of the Uncertainty Principle

Haoran Huang

This paper is a small discussion about the uncertainty principle. With the great discoveries and researches made by predecessors, I try to answer some questions within the uncertainty principle. Using the definition of momentum, the momentum in de Broglie wave, the property of cosine function, the Euler’s formula, the basic property of plane wave, the law of derivative, the energy of quantum discovered by Max Planck, the photon energy discovered by Albert Einstein, the energy equation of a system and the Hamiltonian operator, I figure out the Schrodinger equation successfully. With the help of Schrodinger equation, the possibility density of a wave function, the concept of normalization, the average value of position and momentum, the Fourier transform, the integration by parts and the limit of normalized wave functions, I find the position operator and the momentum operator. Then using some knowledge of the standard deviation and the variance, the concept of inner product of vectors, some property of Dirac symbol, the law of calculation of complex number and the law of operator calculation, I obtain the general uncertainty relationship of abstract mathematical quantities. According to the general relationship, I get the inequality of uncertainty principle, and discuss the specific relationship between the position and the momentum. After getting the inequality, I use Heisenberg’s experiment of measuring an electron by using the γ ray to hit the electron to explain why we cannot measure the position and the momentum simultaneously. Based on Heisenberg’s experiment, I give my own explanation by discussing the earth and a spacecraft. Transforming the perspective, we can easily see how the accuracies of position and momentum change. In addition, I attempt to figure out why the uncertainty exists. However, I can only explain it by discussing the time and frequency in mathematical method and have no idea to work it out in a pure physics approach.

Highlights in Science Engineering and Technology•Jul 30, 2023•0 citations
Relativity of simultaneity is shown to limit the accuracy in simultaneous measurement of position and momentum of a moving body by an inertial observer. The inaccuracy or uncertainty product derived from special relativity theory is found to be similar to the much known quantum mechanical uncertainty relation. However, whether the above two uncertainty relations indicate the same physics is debatable and any conclusion is not attempted here. A modification of this relativistic uncertainty formula under gravitational field is achieved using general relativity principles, and a small gravitational correction term has to be introduced. This gravitational term being small remains negligible in ordinary conditions but becomes appreciable at small time scale.
Are General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics incompatible?Each in their world, that of the infinitely large and that of the infinitely small, they did not seem to interfere as long as they avoided each other.However, it is their fundamental oppositions that prevent the scientific community from achieving a unification of physics.The proposal of this paper is to provide a mathematical proof of incompatibility, beyond the fact that they have fundamentally different principles, between the foundations of General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, namely, the deformation of the space-time geometry and the Uncertainty Principle.It will thus be possible to provide an absolute limitation in establishing a unifying theory of physics, if any.Moreover, while respecting the conditions fixed by the Uncertainty Principle, it will be tempted to determine with accuracy and simultaneity, the position and the speed of a nonrelativistic particle, by application of relativistic principles and bypassing the problems raised by such an operation.The Uncertainty Principle as stated by Werner Heisenberg will be then, in the light of observations made on the measurement of the time dilatation and in accordance with its own terms, refuted by the present.
One of the main objectives of quantum-gravity research is to establish how the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty principle is modified by Planck-scale effects. We here focus on some residual gray areas of our understanding of the interplay between the uncertainty principle and special relativity, which might have been an obstacle for the further generalization needed in order to include gravitational effects. In its original formulation the uncertainty principle is inconsistent with special relativity, and in nearly a century of investigation not much progress has been made toward a satisfactory reformulation. Some partial insight has been gained in the ultra-high-velocity regime, but a full description is still missing and in particular we have no clue about the intermediate regime of particles whose speeds are much smaller than the speed of light but still high enough for tangible departures from the Heisenberg formulation. As we stress here, that intermediate regime is also our best chance for testing experimentally our understanding of the implications of special relativity for the uncertainty principle. We introduce a new approach toward facing these challenges, based mainly on the observation that the only operative notion of position of a particle at a given time involves the crossing of the worldline of that particle with the worldline of a test particle. We find that the worldline-crossing perspective opens a path toward a special-relativistic version of the uncertainty principle, which indeed could be tested experimentally.
In exposing his uncertainty principle, W. Heisenberg has pointed out the fact that positions and speeds form two separate and independent sets of observables. He also suggested that infinitesimal variations of energies and lapses of times were following a similar logic. Unfortunately, there is up to now no operator representing the time and, at least at a technical level, this absence is blocking the progression of any development for the second pair. Whatever the interpretation of that principle is, a fact is that it introduces a finite limit for the relative variations of these pairs. The situations realizing the minimum value of a product between both elements of a given pair are labeled as “quantum limit”. And this is the information on which I build my theoretical proposition. Following a well-known and accepted principle affirming that the laws of physics must be the same everywhere, I look for technical circumstances allowing to go further on that road. Concretely, that quantum limit must be the same for two observers, wherever they stay in the world. I consider the simplest transposition of Heisenberg’ suggested interdependence between the elements of the pair (delta energy, delta lapse of time) in a simple one-dimensional world. And I ask me where, in the arsenal of formulas and laws of physics, I can find a plausible manner to introduce these ingredients softly.
The more precisely the position of a particle is determined, the less precisely its momentum can be known, and conversely. This is the content of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. First stated in 1927, the inequality Δ x Δ p ≥ ℏ /2 is not a limitation of measuring instruments but a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics: position and momentum are complementary observables whose simultaneous sharp values are excluded by the structure of the theory. Few relations have so thoroughly changed the meaning of physical knowledge at the microscopic scale.
The Theory of Temporal Relativity proposes a unified theoretical framework that extends Special and General Relativity into the complex domain, integrating aspects of Quantum Mechanics within a single geometrical structure. The theory introduces a generalized Hilbert-space geometry and interprets quantum states as observer-dependent, arising from complex temporal relations between reference frames. Theory of Temporal Relativity is a theoretical framework proposing a unified extension of Special and General Relativity into the complex domain, with the goal of incorporating aspects of Quantum Mechanics within a consistent geometrical model. The theory generalizes Hilbert-space geometry and relativistic invariance to complex coordinates, introducing observer-dependent descriptions of physical quantities and a reinterpretation of quantum states as complex-phase relations between reference frames. Within this model, fundamental constants such as c, G, and h are not strictly universal but can exhibit apparent local variations arising from the observer’s position in the complex spacetime manifold. These variations preserve global covariance and CPT symmetry while reconciling quantum non-locality with relativistic kinematics. The framework predicts experimentally testable effects, including measurable phase shifts in interferometric experiments, possible frequency modulations in non-inertial systems, and small local deviations of physical constants detectable in condensed-matter and gravitational contexts. The supplementary work, “Quantum Uncertainty, Planck’s Constant, and Ontological Insights from Complex Spacetime Geometry and Local Metric Deformations”, develops the principle of Temporal Relativity as a foundational element of the theory. It formalizes the connection between quantum uncertainty, metric deformations, and complex temporal structures, within an alternative logical framework (AU). This extension provides both an ontological interpretation of the wavefunction and a basis for the emergence of quantum indeterminacy from geometric causes. Together, these works present a coherent attempt to unify the relativistic and quantum domains under a single complex-geometric view of spacetime, maintaining mathematical rigor while providing clear experimental pathways for empirical validation.
This paper is a small discussion about the uncertainty principle. With the great discoveries and researches made by predecessors, I try to answer some questions within the uncertainty principle. Using the definition of momentum, the momentum in de Broglie wave, the property of cosine function, the Euler’s formula, the basic property of plane wave, the law of derivative, the energy of quantum discovered by Max Planck, the photon energy discovered by Albert Einstein, the energy equation of a system and the Hamiltonian operator, I figure out the Schrodinger equation successfully. With the help of Schrodinger equation, the possibility density of a wave function, the concept of normalization, the average value of position and momentum, the Fourier transform, the integration by parts and the limit of normalized wave functions, I find the position operator and the momentum operator. Then using some knowledge of the standard deviation and the variance, the concept of inner product of vectors, some property of Dirac symbol, the law of calculation of complex number and the law of operator calculation, I obtain the general uncertainty relationship of abstract mathematical quantities. According to the general relationship, I get the inequality of uncertainty principle, and discuss the specific relationship between the position and the momentum. After getting the inequality, I use Heisenberg’s experiment of measuring an electron by using the γ ray to hit the electron to explain why we cannot measure the position and the momentum simultaneously. Based on Heisenberg’s experiment, I give my own explanation by discussing the earth and a spacecraft. Transforming the perspective, we can easily see how the accuracies of position and momentum change. In addition, I attempt to figure out why the uncertainty exists. However, I can only explain it by discussing the time and frequency in mathematical method and have no idea to work it out in a pure physics approach.