Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Re-examining a local-realism test by modifying the classical boundary for modular phase-space measurements

Ming‐Da Huang, Ya-Fei Yu, Zhi‐Ming Zhang

Published Aug 27, 2020• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In recent work, Arora and Asadian have proposed a sophisticated physical structure for testing the macroscopic Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality of two entangled particles using a multislit Young experiment that employs classical-like modular variables and measurements. By imposing the algebraic CHSH constraint on the Wigner representations of these observables, they found that a strong connection exists between the non-negative Wigner function of a quantum state and having the macroscopic CHSH inequality hold. The entangled states with negative Wigner functions violate the macroscopic CHSH inequality when the number of slits is $N\ensuremath{\ge}8$ and the maximum violation, in principle, requires $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}+\ensuremath{\infty}$. In this paper, we further study this macroscopic local-realism test by analyzing the eigenvalues of the classical-like modular variables when $N$ is finite. Through this analysis, we find that one can modify the classical boundary for the macroscopic CHSH inequality when $N$ is finite, which makes it possible to demonstrate macroscopic Bell nonlocality for entangled states with $N<8$. More interestingly, we find another form of an entangled state that violates the macroscopic CHSH inequality under the modified boundaries when the number of slits is $N=2$. But the violation of the macroscopic CHSH inequality under the modified classical boundaries with a finite $N$ does not necessarily correspond to states with a non-positive-definite Wigner function.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.022229

Related papers

Proposal for a macroscopic test of local realism with phase-space measurements

Atul Singh Arora, Ali Asadian

We propose a test of local realism based on correlation measurements of continuum valued functions of positions and momenta, known as modular variables. The Wigner representations of these observables are bounded in phase space and, therefore, the associated inequality holds for any state described by a non-negative Wigner function. This agrees with Bell's remark that positive Wigner functions, serving as a valid probability distribution over local (hidden) phase-space coordinates, do not reveal nonlocality. We construct a class of entangled states resulting in a violation of the inequality and thus truly demonstrate nonlocality in phase space. The states can be realized through grating techniques in spacelike separated interferometric setups. The nonlocality is verified from the spatial correlation data that is collected from the screens.

arXiv:1508.04588•Physical Review A•Dec 4, 2015•15 citations

Quantum entanglement with Freedman's inequality

Jed Brody, Charlotte Selton

The assumption of local realism imposes constraints, such as Bell inequalities, on quantities obtained from measurements. In recent years, various tests of local realism have gained popularity in undergraduate laboratories, giving students the exciting opportunity to experimentally contradict this philosophical assumption. The standard test of the CHSH (Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt) Bell inequality requires 16 measurements, whereas a test of Freedman's inequality requires only three measurements. The calculations required to test Freedman's inequality are correspondingly simpler and the theory is less abstract. We suggest that students may benefit from testing Freedman's inequality before proceeding to the CHSH inequality and other more complicated experiments. Our measured data violated Freedman's inequality by more than six standard deviations.

American Journal of Physics•May 18, 2018•7 citations

Violation of multipartite Bell inequalities with classical subsystems via operationally local transformations

Mark S. Williamson, Libby Heaney, Wonmin Son

Recently, it was demonstrated by Son et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 110404 (2009), that a separable bipartite continuous-variable quantum system can violate the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality via operationally local transformations. Operationally local transformations are parametrized only by local variables; however, in order to allow violation of the CHSH inequality, a maximally entangled ancilla was necessary. The use of the entangled ancilla in this scheme caused the state under test to become dependent on the measurement choice one uses to calculate the CHSH inequality, thus violating one of the assumptions used in deriving a Bell inequality, namely, the free will or statistical independence assumption. The novelty in this scheme however is that the measurement settings can be external free parameters. In this paper, we generalize these operationally local transformations for multipartite Bell inequalities (with dichotomic observables) and provide necessary and sufficient conditions for violation within this scheme. Namely, a violation of a multipartite Bell inequality in this setting is contingent on whether an ancillary system admits any realistic local hidden variable model (i.e., whether the ancilla violates the given Bell inequality). These results indicate that violation of a Bell inequality performed on a system does not necessarily imply that the system is nonlocal. In fact, the system under test may be completely classical. However, nonlocality must have resided somewhere, this may have been in the environment, the physical variables used to manipulate the system or the detectors themselves provided the measurement settings are external free variables.

arXiv:0912.3615•Physical Review A•Sep 9, 2010•4 citations

Less entanglement exhibiting more nonlocality with noisy measurements

Gaoyan Zhu, Daniel Dilley, Kunkun Wang +3 more

Abstract The Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) inequality test is widely used as a mean of invalidating the local deterministic theories. Most attempts to experimentally test nonlocality have presumed unphysical idealizations that do not hold in real experiments, namely, noiseless measurements. We demonstrate an experimental violation of the CHSH inequality that is free of idealization and rules out local models with high confidence. We show that the CHSH inequality can always be violated for any nonzero noise parameter of the measurement. Intriguingly, less entanglement exhibits more nonlocality in the CHSH test with noisy measurements. Furthermore, we theoretically propose and experimentally demonstrate how the CHSH test with noisy measurements can be used to detect weak entanglement on two-qubit states. Our results offer a deeper insight into the relation between entanglement and nonlocality.

npj Quantum Information•Dec 6, 2021•4 citations

A Bell inequality which can be used to test locality more simply than Clauser-Horne inequality and which is violated by a larger magnitude of violation than Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality

M. Ardehali

A correlation inequality is derived from local realism and a supplementary assumption. Unlike Clauser-Horne (CH) inequality [or Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality] which is violated by quantum mechanics by a factor of $\sqrt 2$, this inequality is violated by a factor of 1.5. Thus the magnitude of violation of this inequality is approximately 20.7% larger than the magnitude of violation of previous inequalities. Moreover, unlike CH (or CHSH) inequality which requires the measurement of five detection probabilities, the present inequality requires the measurement of only two detection probabilities. This inequality can therefore be used to test locality more simply than CH or CHSH inequality.

arXiv:quant-ph/9709043•Sep 19, 1997•1 citation

All Bipartite Entangled States Display Some Hidden Nonlocality

Lluís Masanes, Yeong-Cherng Liang, Andrew C. Doherty

One of the most significant and well-known properties of entangled states is that they may lead to violations of Bell inequalities and are thus inconsistent with any local-realistic theory. However, there are entangled states that cannot violate any Bell inequality, and in general the precise relationship between entanglement and observable nonlocality is not well understood. We demonstrate that a violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality can be demonstrated in a certain kind of Bell experiment for all entangled states. Our proof of the result consists of two main steps. We first provide a simple characterization of the set of states that do not violate the CHSH inequality even after general local operations and classical communication. Second, we prove that for each entangled state sigma, there exists another state rho not violating the CHSH inequality, such that rhomultiply sign in circlesigma violates the CHSH inequality.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703268•Physical Review Letters•Mar 4, 2008•142 citations
In recent work, Arora and Asadian have proposed a sophisticated physical structure for testing the macroscopic Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality of two entangled particles using a multislit Young experiment that employs classical-like modular variables and measurements. By imposing the algebraic CHSH constraint on the Wigner representations of these observables, they found that a strong connection exists between the non-negative Wigner function of a quantum state and having the macroscopic CHSH inequality hold. The entangled states with negative Wigner functions violate the macroscopic CHSH inequality when the number of slits is N\ensuremath≥8N\ensuremath{\ge}8N\ensuremath≥8 and the maximum violation, in principle, requires N\ensuremath→+\ensuremath∞N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}+\ensuremath{\infty}N\ensuremath→+\ensuremath∞. In this paper, we further study this macroscopic local-realism test by analyzing the eigenvalues of the classical-like modular variables when NNN is finite. Through this analysis, we find that one can modify the classical boundary for the macroscopic CHSH inequality when NNN is finite, which makes it possible to demonstrate macroscopic Bell nonlocality for entangled states with N<8N<8N<8. More interestingly, we find another form of an entangled state that violates the macroscopic CHSH inequality under the modified boundaries when the number of slits is N=2N=2N=2. But the violation of the macroscopic CHSH inequality under the modified classical boundaries with a finite NNN does not necessarily correspond to states with a non-positive-definite Wigner function.
We propose a test of local realism based on correlation measurements of continuum valued functions of positions and momenta, known as modular variables. The Wigner representations of these observables are bounded in phase space and, therefore, the associated inequality holds for any state described by a non-negative Wigner function. This agrees with Bell's remark that positive Wigner functions, serving as a valid probability distribution over local (hidden) phase-space coordinates, do not reveal nonlocality. We construct a class of entangled states resulting in a violation of the inequality and thus truly demonstrate nonlocality in phase space. The states can be realized through grating techniques in spacelike separated interferometric setups. The nonlocality is verified from the spatial correlation data that is collected from the screens.
The assumption of local realism imposes constraints, such as Bell inequalities, on quantities obtained from measurements. In recent years, various tests of local realism have gained popularity in undergraduate laboratories, giving students the exciting opportunity to experimentally contradict this philosophical assumption. The standard test of the CHSH (Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt) Bell inequality requires 16 measurements, whereas a test of Freedman's inequality requires only three measurements. The calculations required to test Freedman's inequality are correspondingly simpler and the theory is less abstract. We suggest that students may benefit from testing Freedman's inequality before proceeding to the CHSH inequality and other more complicated experiments. Our measured data violated Freedman's inequality by more than six standard deviations.
Recently, it was demonstrated by Son et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 110404 (2009), that a separable bipartite continuous-variable quantum system can violate the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality via operationally local transformations. Operationally local transformations are parametrized only by local variables; however, in order to allow violation of the CHSH inequality, a maximally entangled ancilla was necessary. The use of the entangled ancilla in this scheme caused the state under test to become dependent on the measurement choice one uses to calculate the CHSH inequality, thus violating one of the assumptions used in deriving a Bell inequality, namely, the free will or statistical independence assumption. The novelty in this scheme however is that the measurement settings can be external free parameters. In this paper, we generalize these operationally local transformations for multipartite Bell inequalities (with dichotomic observables) and provide necessary and sufficient conditions for violation within this scheme. Namely, a violation of a multipartite Bell inequality in this setting is contingent on whether an ancillary system admits any realistic local hidden variable model (i.e., whether the ancilla violates the given Bell inequality). These results indicate that violation of a Bell inequality performed on a system does not necessarily imply that the system is nonlocal. In fact, the system under test may be completely classical. However, nonlocality must have resided somewhere, this may have been in the environment, the physical variables used to manipulate the system or the detectors themselves provided the measurement settings are external free variables.
Abstract The Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) inequality test is widely used as a mean of invalidating the local deterministic theories. Most attempts to experimentally test nonlocality have presumed unphysical idealizations that do not hold in real experiments, namely, noiseless measurements. We demonstrate an experimental violation of the CHSH inequality that is free of idealization and rules out local models with high confidence. We show that the CHSH inequality can always be violated for any nonzero noise parameter of the measurement. Intriguingly, less entanglement exhibits more nonlocality in the CHSH test with noisy measurements. Furthermore, we theoretically propose and experimentally demonstrate how the CHSH test with noisy measurements can be used to detect weak entanglement on two-qubit states. Our results offer a deeper insight into the relation between entanglement and nonlocality.
A correlation inequality is derived from local realism and a supplementary assumption. Unlike Clauser-Horne (CH) inequality [or Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality] which is violated by quantum mechanics by a factor of 2\sqrt 22​, this inequality is violated by a factor of 1.5. Thus the magnitude of violation of this inequality is approximately 20.7% larger than the magnitude of violation of previous inequalities. Moreover, unlike CH (or CHSH) inequality which requires the measurement of five detection probabilities, the present inequality requires the measurement of only two detection probabilities. This inequality can therefore be used to test locality more simply than CH or CHSH inequality.
One of the most significant and well-known properties of entangled states is that they may lead to violations of Bell inequalities and are thus inconsistent with any local-realistic theory. However, there are entangled states that cannot violate any Bell inequality, and in general the precise relationship between entanglement and observable nonlocality is not well understood. We demonstrate that a violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality can be demonstrated in a certain kind of Bell experiment for all entangled states. Our proof of the result consists of two main steps. We first provide a simple characterization of the set of states that do not violate the CHSH inequality even after general local operations and classical communication. Second, we prove that for each entangled state sigma, there exists another state rho not violating the CHSH inequality, such that rhomultiply sign in circlesigma violates the CHSH inequality.