We propose a new picture of the renormalization group (RG) approach in the presence of disorder, which considers the RG trajectories of each random sample (realization) separately instead of the usual renormalization of the averaged free energy. The main consequence of the theory is that the average over randomness has to be taken after finding the critical point of each realization. To demonstrate these concepts, we study the finite-size scaling properties of the two-dimensional random-bond Ising model. We find that most of the previously observed finite-size corrections are due to the sample-to-sample fluctuation of the critical temperature and scaling predictions are fulfilled only by the new average.
For phase transitions in disordered systems, an exact theorem provides a bound on the finite size correlation length exponent: ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{\mathrm{FS}}\ensuremath{\ge}2/d$. It is believed that the intrinsic $\ensuremath{\nu}$ satisfies the same bound. We argue that the standard averaging introduces a noise and a new diverging length scale. For $\ensuremath{\nu}\ensuremath{\le}2/d$ self-averaging breaks down, disconnecting $\ensuremath{\nu}$ from ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{\mathrm{FS}}$, and the bound applies only for the latter. We illustrate these ideas on two exact examples, with $\ensuremath{\nu}<2/d$. We propose a new method of disorder averaging, which is able to capture the intrinsic exponents.
The phase diagram of a quantum
XY spin chain with Gaussian-distributed random anisotropies and transverse fields is investigated, with focus on the fidelity susceptibility, a recently introduced quantum information theoretical measure. Monitoring the finite-size scaling of the probability distribution of this quantity as well as its average and typical values, we detect a disorder-induced disappearance of criticality and the emergence of Griffiths phases in this model. It is found that the fidelity susceptibility is not self-averaging near the disorder-free quantum-critical lines. At the Ising critical point the fidelity susceptibility scales as a disorder-strength independent stretched exponential of the system size, in contrast with the quadratic scaling at the corresponding point in the disorder-free
XY chain. Along the line where the average anisotropy vanishes the fidelity susceptibility appears to scale extensively, whereas in the disorder-free case this point is quantum critical with quadratic finite-size scaling.