Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review X

Comment on “Equilibration Time Scales of Physically Relevant Observables”

Robin Heveling, Lars Knipschild, Jochen Gemmer B

Published Jun 15, 2020• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Putting a generally valid upper bound on equilibration times of physically relevant observables is a much pursued endeavor. Recently, such a bound has been suggested by Garcia-Pintos et al. While the mathematical correctness of the bound as such is undisputed, its concrete calculation requires the knowledge of certain quantities, which Garcia-Pintos et al. assess by means of assumptions. We show that, e.g., in standard cases of slow, exponential equilibration, (at least) one of these assumptions is not valid. This demonstration highlights the difficulty to judge the validity of the above assumptions without further information. Such information is, in general, very hard to obtain.

DOI
10.1103/physrevx.10.028001

Related papers

Compelling bounds on equilibration times—the issue with Fermi’s golden rule

Robin Heveling, Lars Knipschild, Jochen Gemmer B

Abstract Putting a general, physically relevant upper bound on equilibration times in closed quantum systems is a recently much pursued endeavor. In 2017 Phys. Rev. X 7 031027 García-Pintos et al suggest such a bound. We point out that the general assumptions which allow for an actual estimation of this bound are violated in cases in which Fermi’s golden rule and related open quantum system theories apply. To probe the range of applicability of Fermi’s golden rule for systems of the type addressed in the above work, we numerically solve the corresponding Schrödinger equation for some finite spin systems comprising up to 25 spins. These calculations shed light on the breakdown of standard quantum master equations in the ‘superweak’ coupling limit, which occurs for finite sized baths.

arXiv:1910.13262•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 18, 2020•3 citations

Equilibration time scales in closed many-body quantum systems

Thiago R de Oliveira, Christos Charalambous, Daniel Jonathan +2 more

We show that the physical mechanism for the equilibration of closed quantum systems is dephasing, and identify the energy scales that determine the equilibration timescale of a given observable. For realistic physical systems (e.g those with local Hamiltonians), our arguments imply timescales that do not increase with the system size, in contrast to previously known upper bounds. In particular we show that, for such Hamiltonians, the matrix representation of local observables in the energy basis is banded, and that this property is crucial in order to derive equilibration times that are non-negligible in macroscopic systems. Finally, we give an intuitive interpretation to recent theorems on equilibration time-scales.

arXiv:1704.06646•New Journal of Physics•Feb 16, 2018•69 citations

Equilibration Time Scales of Physically Relevant Observables

Luis Pedro García-Pintos, Noah Linden, Artur S. L. Malabarba +2 more

The tendency for a macroscopic system to reach equilibrium could depend on underlying quantum behaviors, but showing that this can happen in a reasonable time is difficult. A new analysis demonstrates that for certain classes of physically relevant observables, conditions exist where this is possible.

arXiv:1509.05732•Physical Review X•Aug 10, 2017•89 citations

Bounds on Observables in Elementary Excitation Models

Duane P. Johnson, Allen Jay Kassman, William M. Visscher

A general technique is presented for finding upper and lower bounds on the value of any physical quantity consistent with measured values of other physical quantities and the assumption that all these quantities can be described by the same elementary excitation states. These bounds are independent of the details of the distribution of the states and in some instances can be quite restrictive.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 4, 1971•8 citations

Towards local equilibration in closed interacting quantum many-body systems

Henrik Wilming, M. Goihl, Christian Krumnow +1 more

One of the main questions of research on quantum many-body systems following unitary out of equilibrium dynamics is to find out how local expectation values equilibrate in time. For non-interacting models, this question is rather well understood. However, the best known bounds for general quantum systems are vastly crude, scaling unfavorable with the system size. Nevertheless, empirical and numerical evidence suggests that for generic interacting many-body systems, generic local observables, and sufficiently well-behaved states, the equilibration time does not depend strongly on the system size, but only the precision with which this occurs does. In this discussion paper, we aim at giving very simple and plausible arguments for why this happens. While our discussion does not yield rigorous results about equilibration time scales, we believe that it helps to clarify the essential underlying mechanisms, the intuition and important figure of merits behind equilibration. We then connect our arguments to common assumptions and numerical results in the field of equilibration and thermalization of closed quantum systems, such as the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis as well as rigorous results on interacting quantum many-body systems. Finally, we complement our discussions with numerical results - both in the case of examples and counter-examples of equilibrating systems.

arXiv:1704.06291•Apr 20, 2017•30 citations

The equilibration time scales of the quantum lattice model

Zhiqiang Huang, Qing-yu Cai

Finding the equilibration time scale is an important open question in studying the equilibration of quantum systems. There are many kinds of systems that are unable to achieve equilibration, such as Anderson insulator, many-body localization systems and some integrable systems. For those systems that can reach equilibration, it was proved that there exists a general equilibration time scale. But these upper bounds are unrealistically long, and the lower bounds are also unrealistically short. How to get an accurate and general equilibration time scale is still unclear. In this paper, we study local equilibration time scales in quantum lattice systems. With the relation between equilibration and entanglement entropy, we define a new criterion for equilibration. This criterion is based on Rényi entropy, which is simpler for calculation. Moreover, the production of Rényi entropy is highly dependent on the spreading of information, and hence the tools developed in quantum information theory can help a lot. For the upper bound of equilibration time, we use the normal criterion of the time average ofthe fluctuation of the observation. This equilibration criterion is assessed with concrete observable operator, hence it is more accurate than the criterion of Rényi entropy. But this criterion is more complicated for calculation. With an appropriate assumption about the initial state, we present a new upper bound of equilibration time. Since the results are not constrained by the Hamiltonian of the system, this bound can be applied to various situations. If we are concerned with the local equilibration, we can limit the observation to a small region. If the whole system is big enough, the local observation would always find that the rest part is staying at the canonical ensemble, so that the local equilibration time will not increase with the size of whole system. When the local region is small enough, the upper bound of equilibration time can be much shorter. The local Rényi entropy has close relation to the propagation of information. The limitation of the speed of information propagation in a quantum lattice system can be given by the Lieb-Robinson bound, with which we evaluate the production rate of local 2-Rényi entropy. With these, we give a new lower bound of equilibration time for systems whose interactions are respectively short-range, exponentially-decaying and long-range. In earlier works, the lower bound of equilibration time is equal to the Lieb-Robinson time of the local system. In our rigorous proof, however, the lower bound is related to the strength of hopping, which also decides the Lieb-Robinson velocity. This means the equilibration time is related to the Lieb-Robinson time indeed. But the strictly equal relation may not hold. These new bounds are important to understanding the process of quantum equilibration.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•May 20, 2018•0 citations
Putting a generally valid upper bound on equilibration times of physically relevant observables is a much pursued endeavor. Recently, such a bound has been suggested by Garcia-Pintos et al. While the mathematical correctness of the bound as such is undisputed, its concrete calculation requires the knowledge of certain quantities, which Garcia-Pintos et al. assess by means of assumptions. We show that, e.g., in standard cases of slow, exponential equilibration, (at least) one of these assumptions is not valid. This demonstration highlights the difficulty to judge the validity of the above assumptions without further information. Such information is, in general, very hard to obtain.
Abstract Putting a general, physically relevant upper bound on equilibration times in closed quantum systems is a recently much pursued endeavor. In 2017 Phys. Rev. X 7 031027 García-Pintos et al suggest such a bound. We point out that the general assumptions which allow for an actual estimation of this bound are violated in cases in which Fermi’s golden rule and related open quantum system theories apply. To probe the range of applicability of Fermi’s golden rule for systems of the type addressed in the above work, we numerically solve the corresponding Schrödinger equation for some finite spin systems comprising up to 25 spins. These calculations shed light on the breakdown of standard quantum master equations in the ‘superweak’ coupling limit, which occurs for finite sized baths.
We show that the physical mechanism for the equilibration of closed quantum systems is dephasing, and identify the energy scales that determine the equilibration timescale of a given observable. For realistic physical systems (e.g those with local Hamiltonians), our arguments imply timescales that do not increase with the system size, in contrast to previously known upper bounds. In particular we show that, for such Hamiltonians, the matrix representation of local observables in the energy basis is banded, and that this property is crucial in order to derive equilibration times that are non-negligible in macroscopic systems. Finally, we give an intuitive interpretation to recent theorems on equilibration time-scales.
One of the main questions of research on quantum many-body systems following unitary out of equilibrium dynamics is to find out how local expectation values equilibrate in time. For non-interacting models, this question is rather well understood. However, the best known bounds for general quantum systems are vastly crude, scaling unfavorable with the system size. Nevertheless, empirical and numerical evidence suggests that for generic interacting many-body systems, generic local observables, and sufficiently well-behaved states, the equilibration time does not depend strongly on the system size, but only the precision with which this occurs does. In this discussion paper, we aim at giving very simple and plausible arguments for why this happens. While our discussion does not yield rigorous results about equilibration time scales, we believe that it helps to clarify the essential underlying mechanisms, the intuition and important figure of merits behind equilibration. We then connect our arguments to common assumptions and numerical results in the field of equilibration and thermalization of closed quantum systems, such as the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis as well as rigorous results on interacting quantum many-body systems. Finally, we complement our discussions with numerical results - both in the case of examples and counter-examples of equilibrating systems.
Finding the equilibration time scale is an important open question in studying the equilibration of quantum systems. There are many kinds of systems that are unable to achieve equilibration, such as Anderson insulator, many-body localization systems and some integrable systems. For those systems that can reach equilibration, it was proved that there exists a general equilibration time scale. But these upper bounds are unrealistically long, and the lower bounds are also unrealistically short. How to get an accurate and general equilibration time scale is still unclear. In this paper, we study local equilibration time scales in quantum lattice systems. With the relation between equilibration and entanglement entropy, we define a new criterion for equilibration. This criterion is based on Rényi entropy, which is simpler for calculation. Moreover, the production of Rényi entropy is highly dependent on the spreading of information, and hence the tools developed in quantum information theory can help a lot. For the upper bound of equilibration time, we use the normal criterion of the time average ofthe fluctuation of the observation. This equilibration criterion is assessed with concrete observable operator, hence it is more accurate than the criterion of Rényi entropy. But this criterion is more complicated for calculation. With an appropriate assumption about the initial state, we present a new upper bound of equilibration time. Since the results are not constrained by the Hamiltonian of the system, this bound can be applied to various situations. If we are concerned with the local equilibration, we can limit the observation to a small region. If the whole system is big enough, the local observation would always find that the rest part is staying at the canonical ensemble, so that the local equilibration time will not increase with the size of whole system. When the local region is small enough, the upper bound of equilibration time can be much shorter. The local Rényi entropy has close relation to the propagation of information. The limitation of the speed of information propagation in a quantum lattice system can be given by the Lieb-Robinson bound, with which we evaluate the production rate of local 2-Rényi entropy. With these, we give a new lower bound of equilibration time for systems whose interactions are respectively short-range, exponentially-decaying and long-range. In earlier works, the lower bound of equilibration time is equal to the Lieb-Robinson time of the local system. In our rigorous proof, however, the lower bound is related to the strength of hopping, which also decides the Lieb-Robinson velocity. This means the equilibration time is related to the Lieb-Robinson time indeed. But the strictly equal relation may not hold. These new bounds are important to understanding the process of quantum equilibration.