A hidden variables matrix mechanics model of the harmonic oscillator is presented as a counter-example in examining fundamental assumptions of quantum mechanics. Solutions are obtained which can be interpreted as describing continuous motion of a particle at all times located at points in space. While this is contrary to the basic postulate of Heisenberg, the experimental results of the standard matrix mechanics treatment are nevertheless reproduced. The proposed model is motivated by the foundational issues raised by Bell. Inequalities violation is however, attributed to the mathematical representation of outcome quantities as metric variables rather than the consensus assumption of local causality. Examining the consequence of this alternative conclusion on an actual quantum system creates an overlapping between Bell inspired foundational issues and the original postulates of Heisenberg and Born. Heisenberg’s basic postulates – randomness of transitions and treating the system as an ensemble – are critical. Bohr’s assumption that transitions occur instantaneously, together with Heisenberg’s non-path postulate where the particle can be measured at spatially separated locations without continuous movement between locations, are discarded. The proposed hidden variables are non-contextual. These results question the commonly accepted inequalities violation conclusions that any local and/or non-contextual hidden variables theory cannot reproduce quantum predictions. That the wave function gives a complete description of the quantum state is likewise not supported by the model. Heisenberg’s measurable-only quantities are interpreted as arising from a substructure of periodic endogenous motion of the system.
A hidden variables matrix mechanics model of the harmonic oscillator is presented as a counter-example in examining fundamental assumptions of quantum mechanics. Solutions are obtained which can be interpreted as describing continuous motion of a particle at all times located at points in space. While this is contrary to the basic postulate of Heisenberg, the experimental results of the standard matrix mechanics treatment are nevertheless reproduced. The proposed model is motivated by the foundational issues raised by Bell. Inequalities violation is however, attributed to the mathematical representation of outcome quantities as metric variables rather than the consensus assumption of local causality. Examining the consequence of this alternative conclusion on an actual quantum system creates an overlapping between Bell inspired foundational issues and the original postulates of Heisenberg and Born. Heisenberg’s basic postulates – randomness of transitions and treating the system as an ensemble – are critical. Bohr’s assumption that transitions occur instantaneously, together with Heisenberg’s non-path postulate where the particle can be measured at spatially separated locations without continuous movement between locations, are discarded. The proposed hidden variables are non-contextual. These results question the commonly accepted inequalities violation conclusions that any local and/or non-contextual hidden variables theory cannot reproduce quantum predictions. That the wave function gives a complete description of the quantum state is likewise not supported by the model. Heisenberg’s measurable-only quantities are interpreted as arising from a substructure of periodic endogenous motion of the system.
Abstract Quantum theory has accounted for a wide range of physical effects in systems ranging from microscopic to macroscopic. However, it is associated with various paradoxes—such as the well-known EPR example. Einstein’s suggestion that the theory was incomplete has led to numerous attempts to underpin quantum theory by a hidden variable theory, including the Bell approach. This approach was originally based on certain assumptions: (i) realism (ii) locality and (iii) non-contextuality. In its developed form, the theory involved only probabilities for outcome values of system observables. For systems involving two sub-systems, the hidden variable theory predicted that correlations between measurement outcomes of observable pairs of from different sub-systems would satisfy certain—such as the CHSH Bell inequality. The inequality was inconsistent with quantum theory predictions and with experiment. Hence, the question arose: Which of the three assumptions was invalid? A widely held view is that a non-local theory is needed—another is that hidden variable theory should be contextual. In this article, derivations of the CHSH Bell inequality based on various combinations of locality/non-locality and non-contextuality/contextuality assumptions are outlined, leading to the conclusion that for a hidden variable theory to underpin quantum theory, it must be both non-local and contextual. Non-locality or contextuality alone is insufficient. However, it is also concluded that the realism assumption is questionable. At present an alternative approach of augmenting quantum theory by adding additional features—such as the deterministic trajectories of Bohmian mechanics (also a non-local theory) may be a better route for completeness.
The possibility that quantum mechanics is foundationally the same as classical theories in explaining phenomena in space and time is postulated. Such a view is motivated by interpreting the experimental violation of Bell inequalities as resulting from questions of geometry and algebraic representation of variables, and thereby the structure of space, rather than realism or locality. While time remains Euclidean in the proposed new structure, space is described by Projective geometry. A dual geometry facilitates description of a physically real quantum particle trajectory. Implications for the physical basis of Bohmian mechanics is briefly examined, and found that the hidden variables pilot-wave model is local. Conceptually, the consequence of this proposal is that quantum mechanics has common ground with relativity as ultimately geometrical. This permits the derivation of physically meaningful quantum Lorentz transformations. Departure from classical notions of measurability is discussed.
Abstract The experimentally verified violation of Bell’s inequalities apparently implies that at least one of two beliefs, which are accepted as true in almost all scientific practice, must be false. These beliefs are: that effects propagating at infinite velocity do not exist, and that natural phenomena occur independently of being observed. Giving up any one of these two beliefs (usually known together as Local Realism) is controversial. For many years, many theories have been proposed to reconcile the violation of Bell’s inequalities with Local Realism, but none has been fully successful. In this paper, it is recalled that Bell’s inequalities are equivalent to the conditions to decide the completeness of a theory according to Boolean logic. Therefore, any theory aimed to violate Bell’s inequalities must start by giving up Boolean logic. Two problems are therefore defined: the “soft” one is to explain the violation of Bell’s inequalities without violating (non-Boolean) Local Realism; the “hard” one is to predict the time values when single particles are detected, in such a way that the resulting number of coincidences violates Bell’s inequalities. A simple hidden variables model is introduced, which solves the “soft” problem even in an ideal setup. This is possible thanks to the use of vectors in real space as the hidden variables and the corresponding operation (projection), which do not hold to Boolean logic. This model reconciles the violation of Bell’s inequalities with Local Realism and should end a controversy that has lasted for decades. Regarding the “hard” problem, the introduced model is as incomplete as Quantum Mechanics is. It is claimed that solving the “hard” problem requires devising a new kind of quantum computer, which should be able to accept (non-Boolean) hidden variable values as input data and to replace the statistical Born’s rule of Quantum Mechanics with a deterministic threshold condition.
The standard formalism of quantum mechanics is one of the most successful theoretical constructions in the history of science. Its predictions have been confirmed to extraordinary precision. This paper explores a question it never asked --- and assumed closed without ever testing it. Bell's theorem rules out local hidden variables, and a continuously oscillating variable is no exception: sampled at the instant of measurement, it is still local. What the post-Bell consensus never tested is a different question --- whether quantum unpredictability could rest on a dynamic, deterministic substrate whose properties oscillate, with each measurement capturing a snapshot of that oscillation. In such a model, quantum outcomes are unpredictable --- as the result of a die throw is unpredictable --- without being indeterminate in the ontological sense claimed by the Copenhagen interpretation. [Proposed] We derive a falsifiable prediction: two successive weak measurements on a system governed by a dynamic hidden variable should exhibit a correlation function oscillating at frequency 2ω, where ω is the characteristic oscillation frequency of the hidden variable. Standard quantum mechanics predicts oscillation at ω with amplitude proportional to the measurement strength g. These two predictions are experimentally distinguishable with current technology at frequencies up to ∼1015 Hz.
Bell’s theorem presents a fundamental limit on the correlations achievable by any local hidden variable theory, seemingly precluding such models from reproducing quantum mechanical predictions. In this paper, we introduce a local hidden variable model based on phenomenological velocity and curvature operator techniques. By constructing a mathematical framework that maintains locality and realism, we demonstrate that it is possible to reproduce the quantum mechanical correlation functions that violate Bell’s inequalities. This challenges the conventional understanding imposed by Bell’s theorem and suggests the need for a re-examination of the foundational assumptions in quantum mechanics.
The measurement problem in quantum mechanics is re-examined and it is shown that it cannot really be solved in a satisfactory way, within the framework of the usual interpretation of the theory. We then discuss von Neumann's attempts to prove that quantum mechanics is incompatible with the introduction of hidden variables, and develop a more detailed form of Bell's argument, showing that von Neumann's analysis is invalid. Using certain ideas that are implicit in the "differential-space" theory of Wiener and Siegel, we go on to propose a new deterministic equation of motion, describing a kind of coupling of the measuring instrument to the observed system that explains in detail how the wave packet is "reduced" during a measurement in a continuous and causally determined way. By averaging over the hidden parameters, we then recover the usual statistical results of quantum mechanics as a special case. However, a more detailed analysis of the theory shows that new experimental and theoretical questions can now be raised, which go outside the framework of the quantum theory as it is now formulated. These questions are examined briefly.