Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases for Robust Quantum Computation

Sam Roberts

Published Feb 28, 2019• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

In recent years, topological phases of matter have presented exciting new avenues to achieve scalable quantum computation. In this thesis, we investigate a class of quantum many-body spin models known as symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases for use in quantum information processing and storage. We explore the fault-tolerant properties of SPT phases, and how they can be utilized in the design of a quantum computer. Of central importance in this thesis is the concept of quantum error-correction, which in addition to its importance in fault-tolerant quantum computation, is used to characterise the stability of topological phases at finite temperature. We begin with an introduction to quantum computation, quantum error correction, and topological phases of matter. We then focus on the fundamental question of whether symmetry-protected topological phases of matter can exist in thermal equilibrium; we prove that systems protected by global onsite symmetries cannot be ordered at nonzero temperature. Subsequently, we show that certain three-dimensional models with generalised higher-form symmetries can be thermally SPT ordered, and we relate this order to the ability to perform fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation. Following this, we assess feasibility of these phases as quantum memories, motivated by the fact that SPT phases in three dimensions can possess protected topological degrees of freedom on their boundary. We find that certain SPT ordered systems can be self-correcting, allowing quantum information to be stored for arbitrarily long times without requiring active error correction. Finally, we develop a framework to construct new schemes of fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation. As a notable example, we develop a cluster-state scheme that simulates the braiding and fusion of surface-code defects, offering novel alternative methods to achieve fault-tolerant universal quantum computation.

Related papers

Lattice quantum codes and exotic topological phases of matter

Jeongwan Haah

This thesis addresses whether it is possible to build a robust memory device for quantum information. Many schemes for fault-tolerant quantum information processing have been developed so far, one of which, called topological quantum computation, makes use of degrees of freedom that are inherently insensitive to local errors. However, this scheme is not so reliable against thermal errors. Other fault-tolerant schemes achieve better reliability through active error correction, but incur a substantial overhead cost. Thus, it is of practical importance and theoretical interest to design and assess fault-tolerant schemes that work well at finite temperature without active error correction. In this thesis, a three-dimensional gapped lattice spin model is found which demonstrates for the first time that a reliable quantum memory at finite temperature is possible, at least to some extent. When quantum information is encoded into a highly entangled ground state of this model and subjected to thermal errors, the errors remain easily correctable for a long time without any active intervention, because a macroscopic energy barrier keeps the errors well localized. As a result, stored quantum information can be retrieved faithfully for a memory time which grows exponentially with the square of the inverse temperature. In contrast, for previously known types of topological quantum storage in three or fewer spatial dimensions the memory time scales exponentially with the inverse temperature, rather than its square. This spin model exhibits a previously unexpected topological quantum order, in which ground states are locally indistinguishable, pointlike excitations are immobile, and the immobility is not affected by small perturbations of the Hamiltonian. The degeneracy of the ground state, though also insensitive to perturbations, is a complicated number-theoretic function of the system size, and the system bifurcates into multiple noninteracting copies of itself under real-space renormalization group transformations. The degeneracy, the excitations, and the renormalization group flow can be analyzed using a framework that exploits the spin model's symmetry and some associated free resolutions of modules over polynomial algebras.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•May 15, 2013•15 citations

Symmetry-protected topological order at nonzero temperature

Sam Roberts, Beni Yoshida, Aleksander Kubica +1 more

We address the question of whether symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order can persist at nonzero temperature, with a focus on understanding the thermal stability of several models studied in the theory of quantum computation. We present three results in this direction. First, we prove that nontrivial SPT order protected by a global onsite symmetry cannot persist at nonzero temperature, demonstrating that several quantum computational structures protected by such onsite symmetries are not thermally stable. Second, we prove that the three-dimensional (3D) cluster-state model used in the formulation of topological measurement-based quantum computation possesses a nontrivial SPT-ordered thermal phase when protected by a generalized (1-form) symmetry. The SPT order in this model is detected by long-range localizable entanglement in the thermal state, which compares with related results characterizing SPT order at zero temperature in spin chains using localizable entanglement as an order parameter. Our third result is to demonstrate that the high-error tolerance of this 3D cluster-state model for quantum computation, even without a protecting symmetry, can be understood as an application of quantum error correction to effectively enforce a 1-form symmetry.

arXiv:1611.05450•Physical Review A•Aug 7, 2017•69 citations

Computational power of one-dimensional symmetry-protected topological phases

David T. Stephen

We consider ground states of quantum spin chains with symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order as resources for measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC). Using tensor network methods, we show that SPT phases protected by a finite abelian on-site symmetry group exhibit uniform computational power. That is, any state from a given phase leads to the same Lie group of executable gates when used as a resource for MBQC. This Lie group is determined by the same algebraic information that labels the SPT phase itself, and we give a necessary condition on the phase that guarantees a full set of single-qubit gates. To obtain our results, we construct several new techniques in MBQC and refine the structure of quantum states with abelian SPT order. Our results are analogous to similar results relating topological order and topological quantum computation, and we comments on their implications on the general connection between quantum phases of matter and quantum computation.

•Jan 1, 2017•3 citations

Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases of Quantum Particles with Integer Spin

泓 楊

ymmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases have been gaining much attention.Gapped SPT phases refer to the quantum phases of those unique gapped ground states that can never be smoothly connected to trivial product states while preserving certain symmetry.An example is the Haldane phase, which is a (1+1)-dimensional (D) gapped SPT phase protected by the Z 2 × Z 2 symmetry.In quantum critical systems, it was recently realized that the concept of gapless SPT phases can also be developed.In this thesis, I focus on SPT phases in many-body spinful boson systems [1] and spin systems [2].In fact, boson and spin degrees of freedom (DOF) have no intrinsic difference from each other, because they are both bosonic: In both cases, operators on DOF at different spatial locations commute with each other.In the first three chapters, I will give an introduction to bosonic SPT phases.Chapter 2 discusses how to understand and classify (1+1)D SPT phases, including both gapped and gapless cases.Chapter 3 is about higher dimensional gapped SPT phases.In particular, weak SPT phases, Lieb-Shultz-Mattis (LSM) anomaly, and crystalline SPT phases will be discussed.In Chapter 4, we theoretically demonstrate that gapped SPT phases can be realized with ultracold spinful bosonic atoms loaded on the lattices which have a flat band at the bottom of the band structure [1].Ground states of such systems are not conventional Mott insulators in the sense that the ground states possess not only spin fluctuations but also non-negligible charge fluctuations.The SPT phases in such systems are determined by both spin and charge fluctuations at zero temperature.We find that the many-body ground states of such systems can be exactly obtained in some special cases, and these exact ground states turn out to serve as representative states of the SPT phases.As a concrete example, we demonstrate that spin-1 bosons on a sawtooth chain can be in a Haldane phase and that this SPT phase is a result of spin fluctuations.We also show that spin-3 bosons on a kagome lattice can be in an SPT phase protected by D 2 point group symmetry; however, this SPT phase is a result of charge fluctuations.Chapter 5 focuses more on the gapless phases [2].In quantum spin-1 chains, there is a nonlocal unitary transformation known as the Kennedy-Tasaki transformation U KT , which defines a duality between the Haldane phase and the Z 2 × Z 2 symmetry-breaking phase.We find that U KT also defines a duality between an SPT Ising critical phase and a iii ABSTRACT trivial Ising critical phase, which provides a "hidden symmetry breaking" interpretation for the topological criticality.Moreover, since the duality relates different phases of matter, we argue that a model with self-duality (i.e., invariant under U KT ) is natural to be at a critical or multicritical point.We study concrete examples to demonstrate this argument.In particular, when H is the Hamiltonian of the spin-1 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain, we prove that the self-dual model H + U KT HU KT is exactly equivalent to a gapless spin-1 2 XY chain, which also implies an emergent LSM anomaly.On the other hand, we show that the SPT and trivial Ising criticalities that are dual to each other meet at a multicritical point which is indeed self-dual.Our discussions can be generalized to other symmetries beyond the spin-1 chains.

•Sep 22, 2022•0 citations

Subsystem symmetries, quantum cellular automata, and computational phases of quantum matter

David T. Stephen, Hendrik Poulsen Nautrup, Juani Bermejo-Vega +2 more

Quantum phases of matter are resources for notions of quantum computation. In this work, we establish a new link between concepts of quantum information theory and condensed matter physics by presenting a unified understanding of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order protected by subsystem symmetries and its relation to measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC). The key unifying ingredient is the concept of quantum cellular automata (QCA) which we use to define subsystem symmetries acting on rigid lower-dimensional lines or fractals on a 2D lattice. Notably, both types of symmetries are treated equivalently in our framework. We show that states within a non-trivial SPT phase protected by these symmetries are indicated by the presence of the same QCA in a tensor network representation of the state, thereby characterizing the structure of entanglement that is uniformly present throughout these phases. By also formulating schemes of MBQC based on these QCA, we are able to prove that most of the phases we construct are computationally universal phases of matter, in which every state is a resource for universal MBQC. Interestingly, our approach allows us to construct computational phases which have practical advantages over previous examples, including a computational speedup. The significance of the approach stems from constructing novel computationally universal phases of matter and showcasing the power of tensor networks and quantum information theory in classifying subsystem SPT order.

arXiv:1806.08780•Quantum•May 20, 2019•115 citations

Measurement-Based Quantum Computation and Symmetry-Protected Topological Order

Jacob Miller

While quantum computers can achieve dramatic speedups over the classical computers familiar to us, identifying the origin of this quantum advantage in physical systems remains a major goal of quantum information science. A useful tool here is measurement-based quantum computation (MQC), a computational framework utilizing the quantum entanglement found in many-body resource states. Not all resource states are useful for quantum computation however, so an important question is what properties of many-body entanglement characterize universal resource states, which can implement any quantum computation. Many-body states are also studied in condensed matter physics, where the collective behavior of quantum many-body systems sometimes define topological phases of matter. These phases are defined by nonlocal many-body entanglement, making topologically-ordered states natural candidates for MQC. We might wonder if these topological phases could be organized as phases of quantum computation, so that every state within the phase is universal for MQC. While phases of symmetry-protected topological order (SPTO) have arisen as natural candidates, previous attempts to demonstrate an MQC-SPTO correspondence were mostly limited to nonuniversal 1D spin chains, leaving the important 2D setting wide open. In this dissertation, we explore the wide and varied connections between MQC and SPTO, and obtain new results for 1D and 2D systems. After identifying a new MQC-SPTO correspondence within 1D spin chains, we move up and explore the operational use of 2D states with two complementary forms of SPTO. We create a new Union Jack resource state, whose different form of SPTO than previous 2D resource states permits a hierarchical notion of MQC universality. This state leads us to consider an idealized model of 2D SPTO, where we show that an additional symmetry condition makes these model states form universal resources for MQC only when they have nontrivial SPTO. We finally study the intrinsic complexity of SPTO-inspired states for classically intractable sampling, and identify inherent advantages of MQC for this purpose. Our work highlights the rich complexity available in states of entangled quantum matter, providing new evidence which sharpens our understanding of the diverse connections between MQC and SPTO.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations
In recent years, topological phases of matter have presented exciting new avenues to achieve scalable quantum computation. In this thesis, we investigate a class of quantum many-body spin models known as symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases for use in quantum information processing and storage. We explore the fault-tolerant properties of SPT phases, and how they can be utilized in the design of a quantum computer. Of central importance in this thesis is the concept of quantum error-correction, which in addition to its importance in fault-tolerant quantum computation, is used to characterise the stability of topological phases at finite temperature. We begin with an introduction to quantum computation, quantum error correction, and topological phases of matter. We then focus on the fundamental question of whether symmetry-protected topological phases of matter can exist in thermal equilibrium; we prove that systems protected by global onsite symmetries cannot be ordered at nonzero temperature. Subsequently, we show that certain three-dimensional models with generalised higher-form symmetries can be thermally SPT ordered, and we relate this order to the ability to perform fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation. Following this, we assess feasibility of these phases as quantum memories, motivated by the fact that SPT phases in three dimensions can possess protected topological degrees of freedom on their boundary. We find that certain SPT ordered systems can be self-correcting, allowing quantum information to be stored for arbitrarily long times without requiring active error correction. Finally, we develop a framework to construct new schemes of fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computation. As a notable example, we develop a cluster-state scheme that simulates the braiding and fusion of surface-code defects, offering novel alternative methods to achieve fault-tolerant universal quantum computation.
This thesis addresses whether it is possible to build a robust memory device for quantum information. Many schemes for fault-tolerant quantum information processing have been developed so far, one of which, called topological quantum computation, makes use of degrees of freedom that are inherently insensitive to local errors. However, this scheme is not so reliable against thermal errors. Other fault-tolerant schemes achieve better reliability through active error correction, but incur a substantial overhead cost. Thus, it is of practical importance and theoretical interest to design and assess fault-tolerant schemes that work well at finite temperature without active error correction. In this thesis, a three-dimensional gapped lattice spin model is found which demonstrates for the first time that a reliable quantum memory at finite temperature is possible, at least to some extent. When quantum information is encoded into a highly entangled ground state of this model and subjected to thermal errors, the errors remain easily correctable for a long time without any active intervention, because a macroscopic energy barrier keeps the errors well localized. As a result, stored quantum information can be retrieved faithfully for a memory time which grows exponentially with the square of the inverse temperature. In contrast, for previously known types of topological quantum storage in three or fewer spatial dimensions the memory time scales exponentially with the inverse temperature, rather than its square. This spin model exhibits a previously unexpected topological quantum order, in which ground states are locally indistinguishable, pointlike excitations are immobile, and the immobility is not affected by small perturbations of the Hamiltonian. The degeneracy of the ground state, though also insensitive to perturbations, is a complicated number-theoretic function of the system size, and the system bifurcates into multiple noninteracting copies of itself under real-space renormalization group transformations. The degeneracy, the excitations, and the renormalization group flow can be analyzed using a framework that exploits the spin model's symmetry and some associated free resolutions of modules over polynomial algebras.
We address the question of whether symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order can persist at nonzero temperature, with a focus on understanding the thermal stability of several models studied in the theory of quantum computation. We present three results in this direction. First, we prove that nontrivial SPT order protected by a global onsite symmetry cannot persist at nonzero temperature, demonstrating that several quantum computational structures protected by such onsite symmetries are not thermally stable. Second, we prove that the three-dimensional (3D) cluster-state model used in the formulation of topological measurement-based quantum computation possesses a nontrivial SPT-ordered thermal phase when protected by a generalized (1-form) symmetry. The SPT order in this model is detected by long-range localizable entanglement in the thermal state, which compares with related results characterizing SPT order at zero temperature in spin chains using localizable entanglement as an order parameter. Our third result is to demonstrate that the high-error tolerance of this 3D cluster-state model for quantum computation, even without a protecting symmetry, can be understood as an application of quantum error correction to effectively enforce a 1-form symmetry.
We consider ground states of quantum spin chains with symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order as resources for measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC). Using tensor network methods, we show that SPT phases protected by a finite abelian on-site symmetry group exhibit uniform computational power. That is, any state from a given phase leads to the same Lie group of executable gates when used as a resource for MBQC. This Lie group is determined by the same algebraic information that labels the SPT phase itself, and we give a necessary condition on the phase that guarantees a full set of single-qubit gates. To obtain our results, we construct several new techniques in MBQC and refine the structure of quantum states with abelian SPT order. Our results are analogous to similar results relating topological order and topological quantum computation, and we comments on their implications on the general connection between quantum phases of matter and quantum computation.
ymmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases have been gaining much attention.Gapped SPT phases refer to the quantum phases of those unique gapped ground states that can never be smoothly connected to trivial product states while preserving certain symmetry.An example is the Haldane phase, which is a (1+1)-dimensional (D) gapped SPT phase protected by the Z 2 × Z 2 symmetry.In quantum critical systems, it was recently realized that the concept of gapless SPT phases can also be developed.In this thesis, I focus on SPT phases in many-body spinful boson systems [1] and spin systems [2].In fact, boson and spin degrees of freedom (DOF) have no intrinsic difference from each other, because they are both bosonic: In both cases, operators on DOF at different spatial locations commute with each other.In the first three chapters, I will give an introduction to bosonic SPT phases.Chapter 2 discusses how to understand and classify (1+1)D SPT phases, including both gapped and gapless cases.Chapter 3 is about higher dimensional gapped SPT phases.In particular, weak SPT phases, Lieb-Shultz-Mattis (LSM) anomaly, and crystalline SPT phases will be discussed.In Chapter 4, we theoretically demonstrate that gapped SPT phases can be realized with ultracold spinful bosonic atoms loaded on the lattices which have a flat band at the bottom of the band structure [1].Ground states of such systems are not conventional Mott insulators in the sense that the ground states possess not only spin fluctuations but also non-negligible charge fluctuations.The SPT phases in such systems are determined by both spin and charge fluctuations at zero temperature.We find that the many-body ground states of such systems can be exactly obtained in some special cases, and these exact ground states turn out to serve as representative states of the SPT phases.As a concrete example, we demonstrate that spin-1 bosons on a sawtooth chain can be in a Haldane phase and that this SPT phase is a result of spin fluctuations.We also show that spin-3 bosons on a kagome lattice can be in an SPT phase protected by D 2 point group symmetry; however, this SPT phase is a result of charge fluctuations.Chapter 5 focuses more on the gapless phases [2].In quantum spin-1 chains, there is a nonlocal unitary transformation known as the Kennedy-Tasaki transformation U KT , which defines a duality between the Haldane phase and the Z 2 × Z 2 symmetry-breaking phase.We find that U KT also defines a duality between an SPT Ising critical phase and a iii ABSTRACT trivial Ising critical phase, which provides a "hidden symmetry breaking" interpretation for the topological criticality.Moreover, since the duality relates different phases of matter, we argue that a model with self-duality (i.e., invariant under U KT ) is natural to be at a critical or multicritical point.We study concrete examples to demonstrate this argument.In particular, when H is the Hamiltonian of the spin-1 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain, we prove that the self-dual model H + U KT HU KT is exactly equivalent to a gapless spin-1 2 XY chain, which also implies an emergent LSM anomaly.On the other hand, we show that the SPT and trivial Ising criticalities that are dual to each other meet at a multicritical point which is indeed self-dual.Our discussions can be generalized to other symmetries beyond the spin-1 chains.
Quantum phases of matter are resources for notions of quantum computation. In this work, we establish a new link between concepts of quantum information theory and condensed matter physics by presenting a unified understanding of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order protected by subsystem symmetries and its relation to measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC). The key unifying ingredient is the concept of quantum cellular automata (QCA) which we use to define subsystem symmetries acting on rigid lower-dimensional lines or fractals on a 2D lattice. Notably, both types of symmetries are treated equivalently in our framework. We show that states within a non-trivial SPT phase protected by these symmetries are indicated by the presence of the same QCA in a tensor network representation of the state, thereby characterizing the structure of entanglement that is uniformly present throughout these phases. By also formulating schemes of MBQC based on these QCA, we are able to prove that most of the phases we construct are computationally universal phases of matter, in which every state is a resource for universal MBQC. Interestingly, our approach allows us to construct computational phases which have practical advantages over previous examples, including a computational speedup. The significance of the approach stems from constructing novel computationally universal phases of matter and showcasing the power of tensor networks and quantum information theory in classifying subsystem SPT order.
While quantum computers can achieve dramatic speedups over the classical computers familiar to us, identifying the origin of this quantum advantage in physical systems remains a major goal of quantum information science. A useful tool here is measurement-based quantum computation (MQC), a computational framework utilizing the quantum entanglement found in many-body resource states. Not all resource states are useful for quantum computation however, so an important question is what properties of many-body entanglement characterize universal resource states, which can implement any quantum computation. Many-body states are also studied in condensed matter physics, where the collective behavior of quantum many-body systems sometimes define topological phases of matter. These phases are defined by nonlocal many-body entanglement, making topologically-ordered states natural candidates for MQC. We might wonder if these topological phases could be organized as phases of quantum computation, so that every state within the phase is universal for MQC. While phases of symmetry-protected topological order (SPTO) have arisen as natural candidates, previous attempts to demonstrate an MQC-SPTO correspondence were mostly limited to nonuniversal 1D spin chains, leaving the important 2D setting wide open. In this dissertation, we explore the wide and varied connections between MQC and SPTO, and obtain new results for 1D and 2D systems. After identifying a new MQC-SPTO correspondence within 1D spin chains, we move up and explore the operational use of 2D states with two complementary forms of SPTO. We create a new Union Jack resource state, whose different form of SPTO than previous 2D resource states permits a hierarchical notion of MQC universality. This state leads us to consider an idealized model of 2D SPTO, where we show that an additional symmetry condition makes these model states form universal resources for MQC only when they have nontrivial SPTO. We finally study the intrinsic complexity of SPTO-inspired states for classically intractable sampling, and identify inherent advantages of MQC for this purpose. Our work highlights the rich complexity available in states of entangled quantum matter, providing new evidence which sharpens our understanding of the diverse connections between MQC and SPTO.