Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

State and Process Tomography : In Spekkens' Toy Model

Andreas J. Andersson

Published Jan 1, 2020• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In 2004 Robert W. Spekkens introduced a toy theory designed to make a case for the epistemic view of quantum mechanics. But how does Spekkens’ toy model differ from quantum theory? While some differences are well-established, we attempt to approach this question from a tomographic point of view. More specifically, we provide experimentally viableprocedureswhichenablesustocompletelycharacterizethestatesandgatesthatare available in the toy model. We show that, in contrast to quantum theory, decompositions of transformations in the toy model must be done in a non-linear fashion.

Related papers

A consolidating review of Spekkens' toy theory

Ladina Hausmann, Nuriya Nurgalieva, Lídia del Rio

In order to better understand a complex theory like quantum mechanics, it is sometimes useful to take a step back and create alternative theories, with more intuitive foundations, and examine which features of quantum mechanics can be reproduced by such a foil theory. A prominent example is Spekkens' toy theory, which is based off a simple premise: "What if we took a common classical theory and added the uncertainty principle as a postulate?" In other words, the theory imposes an epistemic restriction on our knowledge about a physical system: only half of the variables can ever be known to an observer. Like good science fiction, from this simple principle a rich behaviour emerges, most notoriously when we compose several systems. The toy theory emulates some aspects of quantum non-locality, although crucially it is still a non-contextual model. In this pedagogical review we consolidate different approaches to Spekkens' toy theory, including the stabilizer formalism and the generalization to arbitrary dimensions, completing them with new results where necessary. In particular, we introduce a general characterization of measurements, superpositions and entanglement in the toy theory.

arXiv:2105.03277•May 7, 2021•11 citations

On the epistemic view of quantum states

Michalis Skotiniotis, Aidan Roy, Barry C. Sanders

We investigate the strengths and limitations of the Spekkens toy model, which is a local hidden variable model that replicates many important properties of quantum dynamics. First, we present a set of five axioms that fully encapsulate Spekkens’ toy model. We then test whether these axioms can be extended to capture more quantum phenomena by allowing operations on epistemic as well as ontic states. We discover that the resulting group of operations is isomorphic to the projective extended Clifford group for two qubits. This larger group of operations results in a physically unreasonable model; consequently, we claim that a relaxed definition of valid operations in Spekkens’ toy model cannot produce an equivalence with the Clifford group for two qubits. However, the new operations do serve as tests for correlation in a two toy bit model, analogous to the well known Horodecki criterion for the separability of quantum states.

arXiv:0707.0074•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2008•6 citations

Toys can’t play: physical agents in Spekkens’ theory

Ladina Hausmann, Nuriya Nurgalieva, Lídia del Rio

Abstract Information is physical(Landauer 1961IBM J. Res. Dev.5183–91), and for a physical theory to be universal, it should model observers as physical systems, with concrete memories where they store the information acquired through experiments and reasoning. Here we address these issues in Spekkens’ toy theory (Spekkens 2005Phys. Rev.A71052108), a non-contextual epistemically restricted model that partially mimics the behaviour of quantum mechanics. We propose a way to model physical implementations of agents, memories, measurements, conditional actions and information processing. We find that the actions of toy agents are severely limited: although there are non-orthogonal states in the theory, there is no way for physical agents to consciously prepare them. Their memories are also constrained: agents cannot forget in which of two arbitrary states a system is. Finally, we formalize the process of making inferences about other agents’ experiments and model multi-agent experiments like Wigner’s friend. Unlike quantum theory (Nurgalieva and del Rio Lidia 2019Electron. Proc. Theor. Comput. Sci.287267–97; Fraseret al2020 Fitch’s knowability axioms are incompatible with quantum theory arXiv: 2009.00321 ; Frauchiger and Renner 2018Nat. Commun.93711; Nurgalieva and Renner 2021Contemp. Phys.611–24; Brukner 2018Entropy20350) or box world (Vilasiniet al2019New J. Phys.21113028), in toy theory there are no inconsistencies when physical agents reason about each other’s knowledge.

arXiv:2207.07445•New Journal of Physics•Jan 17, 2023•5 citations

Spekkens’ toy model in all dimensions and its relationship with stabiliser quantum mechanics

Lorenzo Catani, Dan E. Browne

Spekkens’ toy model is a non-contextual hidden variable model with an epistemic restriction, a constraint on what an observer can know about reality. The aim of the model, developed for continuous and discrete prime degrees of freedom, is to advocate the epistemic view of quantum theory, where quantum states are states of incomplete knowledge about a deeper underlying reality. Many aspects of quantum mechanics and protocols from quantum information can be reproduced in the model. In spite of its significance, a number of aspects of Spekkens’ model remained incomplete. Formal rules for the update of states after measurement had not been written down, and the theory had only been constructed for prime-dimensional and infinite dimensional systems. In this work, we remedy this, by deriving measurement update rules and extending the framework to derive models in all dimensions, both prime and non-prime. Stabiliser quantum mechanics (SQM) is a sub-theory of quantum mechanics with restricted states, transformations and measurements. First derived for the purpose of constructing error correcting codes, it now plays a role in many areas of quantum information theory. Previously, it had been shown that Spekkens’ model was operationally equivalent to SQM in the case of odd prime dimensions. Here, exploiting known results on Wigner functions, we extend this to show that Spekkens’ model is equivalent to SQM in all odd dimensions, prime and non-prime. This equivalence provides new technical tools for the study of technically difficult compound-dimensional SQM.

arXiv:1701.07801•New Journal of Physics•Jul 27, 2017•27 citations

Quantum protocols within Spekkens' toy model

Leonardo Disilvestro, Damian Markham

Quantum mechanics is known to provide significant improvements in information processing tasks when compared to classical models. These advantages range from computational speedups to security improvements. A key question is where these advantages come from. The toy model developed by Spekkens [R. W. Spekkens, Phys. Rev. A 75, 032110 (2007)] mimics many of the features of quantum mechanics, such as entanglement and no cloning, regarded as being important in this regard, despite being a local hidden variable theory. In this work, we study several protocols within Spekkens' toy model where we see it can also mimic the advantages and limitations shown in the quantum case. We first provide explicit proofs for the impossibility of toy bit commitment and the existence of a toy error correction protocol and consequent $k$-threshold secret sharing. Then, defining a toy computational model based on the quantum one-way computer, we prove the existence of blind and verified protocols. Importantly, these two last quantum protocols are known to achieve a better-than-classical security. Our results suggest that such quantum improvements need not arise from any Bell-type nonlocality or contextuality, but rather as a consequence of steering correlations.

arXiv:1608.09012•Physical Review A•May 12, 2017•18 citations

Non-classicality as a computational resource

Lorenzo Catani

One of the main questions in the field of quantum computation is where the quantum computational speed-up comes from. Recent studies in the field of quantum foundations have suggested which are the features to be considered as inherently non-classical. One of the major contributions in this direction comes from a result known as Spekkens' toy theory, which is a model built to reproduce quantum theory as a classical phase-space-inspired theory with restrictions on what an observer can know about reality. The model reproduces many of the features of quantum mechanics, but it does not reproduce non-locality and contextuality. In this thesis we first complete Spekkens' toy theory with measurement update rules and a mathematical framework that generalises it to systems of any finite dimensions (prime and non-prime). We also extend the operational equivalence between the toy theory and stabilizer quantum mechanics to all odd dimensions via Gross' Wigner functions. We then use the toy theory to represent the non-contextual and classically simulatable part of the computation in state-injection schemes of quantum computation where contextuality is a resource. In the case of qubits, we show that the subtheories of quantum mechanics represented in the toy model can achieve the full stabilizer theory via state-injection and we associate different proofs of contextuality to different injection processes. Stepping back from Spekkens' toy theory, we conclude by focusing on single system protocols that compute non-linear functions (similarly to the popular CHSH game) which show quantum advantages even in absence of non-locality and contextuality (in its standard notions). We analyse their performances (formalised in Bell's and Tsirelson's bounds) in relation to Landauer's principle, which associates entropic costs to irreversible computations, and to a new notion of contextuality for sequences of transformations.

•Oct 28, 2018•0 citations
In 2004 Robert W. Spekkens introduced a toy theory designed to make a case for the epistemic view of quantum mechanics. But how does Spekkens’ toy model differ from quantum theory? While some differences are well-established, we attempt to approach this question from a tomographic point of view. More specifically, we provide experimentally viableprocedureswhichenablesustocompletelycharacterizethestatesandgatesthatare available in the toy model. We show that, in contrast to quantum theory, decompositions of transformations in the toy model must be done in a non-linear fashion.
In order to better understand a complex theory like quantum mechanics, it is sometimes useful to take a step back and create alternative theories, with more intuitive foundations, and examine which features of quantum mechanics can be reproduced by such a foil theory. A prominent example is Spekkens' toy theory, which is based off a simple premise: "What if we took a common classical theory and added the uncertainty principle as a postulate?" In other words, the theory imposes an epistemic restriction on our knowledge about a physical system: only half of the variables can ever be known to an observer. Like good science fiction, from this simple principle a rich behaviour emerges, most notoriously when we compose several systems. The toy theory emulates some aspects of quantum non-locality, although crucially it is still a non-contextual model. In this pedagogical review we consolidate different approaches to Spekkens' toy theory, including the stabilizer formalism and the generalization to arbitrary dimensions, completing them with new results where necessary. In particular, we introduce a general characterization of measurements, superpositions and entanglement in the toy theory.
We investigate the strengths and limitations of the Spekkens toy model, which is a local hidden variable model that replicates many important properties of quantum dynamics. First, we present a set of five axioms that fully encapsulate Spekkens’ toy model. We then test whether these axioms can be extended to capture more quantum phenomena by allowing operations on epistemic as well as ontic states. We discover that the resulting group of operations is isomorphic to the projective extended Clifford group for two qubits. This larger group of operations results in a physically unreasonable model; consequently, we claim that a relaxed definition of valid operations in Spekkens’ toy model cannot produce an equivalence with the Clifford group for two qubits. However, the new operations do serve as tests for correlation in a two toy bit model, analogous to the well known Horodecki criterion for the separability of quantum states.
Abstract Information is physical(Landauer 1961IBM J. Res. Dev.5183–91), and for a physical theory to be universal, it should model observers as physical systems, with concrete memories where they store the information acquired through experiments and reasoning. Here we address these issues in Spekkens’ toy theory (Spekkens 2005Phys. Rev.A71052108), a non-contextual epistemically restricted model that partially mimics the behaviour of quantum mechanics. We propose a way to model physical implementations of agents, memories, measurements, conditional actions and information processing. We find that the actions of toy agents are severely limited: although there are non-orthogonal states in the theory, there is no way for physical agents to consciously prepare them. Their memories are also constrained: agents cannot forget in which of two arbitrary states a system is. Finally, we formalize the process of making inferences about other agents’ experiments and model multi-agent experiments like Wigner’s friend. Unlike quantum theory (Nurgalieva and del Rio Lidia 2019Electron. Proc. Theor. Comput. Sci.287267–97; Fraseret al2020 Fitch’s knowability axioms are incompatible with quantum theory arXiv: 2009.00321 ; Frauchiger and Renner 2018Nat. Commun.93711; Nurgalieva and Renner 2021Contemp. Phys.611–24; Brukner 2018Entropy20350) or box world (Vilasiniet al2019New J. Phys.21113028), in toy theory there are no inconsistencies when physical agents reason about each other’s knowledge.
Spekkens’ toy model is a non-contextual hidden variable model with an epistemic restriction, a constraint on what an observer can know about reality. The aim of the model, developed for continuous and discrete prime degrees of freedom, is to advocate the epistemic view of quantum theory, where quantum states are states of incomplete knowledge about a deeper underlying reality. Many aspects of quantum mechanics and protocols from quantum information can be reproduced in the model. In spite of its significance, a number of aspects of Spekkens’ model remained incomplete. Formal rules for the update of states after measurement had not been written down, and the theory had only been constructed for prime-dimensional and infinite dimensional systems. In this work, we remedy this, by deriving measurement update rules and extending the framework to derive models in all dimensions, both prime and non-prime. Stabiliser quantum mechanics (SQM) is a sub-theory of quantum mechanics with restricted states, transformations and measurements. First derived for the purpose of constructing error correcting codes, it now plays a role in many areas of quantum information theory. Previously, it had been shown that Spekkens’ model was operationally equivalent to SQM in the case of odd prime dimensions. Here, exploiting known results on Wigner functions, we extend this to show that Spekkens’ model is equivalent to SQM in all odd dimensions, prime and non-prime. This equivalence provides new technical tools for the study of technically difficult compound-dimensional SQM.
Quantum mechanics is known to provide significant improvements in information processing tasks when compared to classical models. These advantages range from computational speedups to security improvements. A key question is where these advantages come from. The toy model developed by Spekkens [R. W. Spekkens, Phys. Rev. A 75, 032110 (2007)] mimics many of the features of quantum mechanics, such as entanglement and no cloning, regarded as being important in this regard, despite being a local hidden variable theory. In this work, we study several protocols within Spekkens' toy model where we see it can also mimic the advantages and limitations shown in the quantum case. We first provide explicit proofs for the impossibility of toy bit commitment and the existence of a toy error correction protocol and consequent kkk-threshold secret sharing. Then, defining a toy computational model based on the quantum one-way computer, we prove the existence of blind and verified protocols. Importantly, these two last quantum protocols are known to achieve a better-than-classical security. Our results suggest that such quantum improvements need not arise from any Bell-type nonlocality or contextuality, but rather as a consequence of steering correlations.
One of the main questions in the field of quantum computation is where the quantum computational speed-up comes from. Recent studies in the field of quantum foundations have suggested which are the features to be considered as inherently non-classical. One of the major contributions in this direction comes from a result known as Spekkens' toy theory, which is a model built to reproduce quantum theory as a classical phase-space-inspired theory with restrictions on what an observer can know about reality. The model reproduces many of the features of quantum mechanics, but it does not reproduce non-locality and contextuality. In this thesis we first complete Spekkens' toy theory with measurement update rules and a mathematical framework that generalises it to systems of any finite dimensions (prime and non-prime). We also extend the operational equivalence between the toy theory and stabilizer quantum mechanics to all odd dimensions via Gross' Wigner functions. We then use the toy theory to represent the non-contextual and classically simulatable part of the computation in state-injection schemes of quantum computation where contextuality is a resource. In the case of qubits, we show that the subtheories of quantum mechanics represented in the toy model can achieve the full stabilizer theory via state-injection and we associate different proofs of contextuality to different injection processes. Stepping back from Spekkens' toy theory, we conclude by focusing on single system protocols that compute non-linear functions (similarly to the popular CHSH game) which show quantum advantages even in absence of non-locality and contextuality (in its standard notions). We analyse their performances (formalised in Bell's and Tsirelson's bounds) in relation to Landauer's principle, which associates entropic costs to irreversible computations, and to a new notion of contextuality for sequences of transformations.