Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Why are complex numbers needed in quantum mechanics? Some answers for the introductory level

Ricardo Karam

Published Dec 23, 2019• 33 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Complex numbers are broadly used in physics, normally as a calculation tool that makes things easier due to Euler's formula. In the end, it is only the real component that has physical meaning or the two parts (real and imaginary) are treated separately as real quantities. However, the situation seems to be different in quantum mechanics, since the imaginary unit i appears explicitly in its fundamental equations. From a learning perspective, this can create some challenges to newcomers. In this article, four conceptually different justifications for the use/need of complex numbers in quantum mechanics are presented and some pedagogical implications are discussed.

DOI
10.1119/10.0000258

Related papers

The Imaginary Part as an Internal Coordinate: A Real Two-Component Formulation of Quantum Mechanics

Faical, Lami

> In standard quantum mechanics, the imaginary part of the wavefunction is treated as a mathematical convenience. This work shows that it corresponds to a real internal coordinate in a strictly real two-component representation Ψ = (R, I). The quantum phase is identified as a rotation angle in this internal plane, and Schrödinger dynamics becomes a continuous rotation between R and I. Crucially, the I-component — though not directly measurable in a single projective measurement — can be fully reconstructed via controlled phase shifts and interferometry against a known reference. This explains why real-only models fail: they lack the second degree of freedom required to produce the sinθ term in interference patterns (P(θ) = A + B cosθ + C sinθ, with C ≠ 0). The model is empirically equivalent to complex quantum mechanics but provides a clear physical interpretation of the “imaginary” part as an internal information coordinate. > This document is self-contained, uses no complex notation, and is fully compatible with established quantum theory. It includes a testable experimental signature and connects to quantum tomography, interferometry, and foundational questions about the role of complex numbers in physics. This work is conceptually related to recent discussions on the necessity of complex numbers in quantum theory (Renou et al. 2021; Chen et al. 2022; Weilenmann et al. 2025), but takes a different approach by giving an explicitly real two-component interpretation of the imaginary part.”

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

Complexifying Quantum States

Alice Flarend, Bob Hilborn

Abstract This chapter explains why complex numbers are important for more general quantum mechanical situations. The complex exponential function, aka Euler’s formula, plays a critical role in expressing phase differences between components of a quantum state vector. These phase differences affect the outcome of quantum operations. The Bloch sphere and Bloch vector provide a visual representation of these more complex quantum states with the real and imaginary parts on different axes. The complex exponential is important in the quantum Fourier transform, which is then used to prove an important result for finding the repetition period in the Shor algorithm.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 15, 2022•0 citations

Geometric Law of Quantum Mechanics and the Imaginary Unit

Kwon, Se Kyun

Mathematically, the imaginary unit 𝑖 has long been regarded as an algebraic generator extending the real numbers to the complex field. Yet a century after the birth of quantum mechanics (1925–2025), the answer to its oldest question is now clear: quantum mechanics is not merely a mathematical structure—it is a physical reality, and all quantities appearing in its non-commutative relations are physical. Therefore, 𝑖 is not a mere algebraic extension but the universal operator demanded by the geometric completeness of non-commutative reality between position and momentum. The imaginary unit is a physical reality. The canonical relation [𝑥, 𝑝] = 𝑖ℏ is not merely algebraic—it is a geometric law, showing that the complex structure of quantum mechanics arises inevitably from physical reality itself. It stands without contradiction, without complexity. This is nature. In the (𝑥, 𝑝) plane, 𝑖 represents a 90° rotation and ℏ quantizes the curvature of that rotation. Complex numbers thus arise as the natural geometric language of non-commutative physics, providing a geometric resolution to the century-old question of physical completeness first raised by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935).

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

Complex Numbers in Quantum Theory

Glenn H. Maynard

In 1927, Nobel prize winning physicist, E. Schrodinger, in correspondence with Ehrenfest, wrote the following about the new theory: “What is unpleasant here, and indeed directly to be objected to, is the use of complex numbers. Psi is surely fundamentally a real function.” This seemingly simple issue remains unexplained almost ninety years later. In this dissertation I elucidate the physical and theoretical origins of the complex requirement. I identify a freedom/constraint situation encountered by vectors when, employed in accordance with adopted quantum representational methodology, and representing angular momentum states in particular. Complex vectors, quite simply, provide more available adjustable variables than do real vectors. The additional variables relax the constraint situation allowing the theory’s representational program to carry through. This complex number issue, which lies at the deepest foundations of the theory, has implications for important issues located higher in the theory. For example, any unification of the classical and quantum accounts of the settled order of nature, will rest squarely on our ability to account for the introduction of the imaginary unit.

•Aug 1, 2015•0 citations

Introduction to the Maths and Physics of Quantum Mechanics

L. Piccirillo

Introduction to the Maths and Physics of Quantum Mechanics details the mathematics and physics that are needed to learn the principles of quantum mechanics. It provides an accessible treatment of how to use quantum mechanics and why it is so successful in explaining natural phenomena. This book clarifies various aspects of quantum physics such as ‘why quantum mechanics equations contain “I”, the imaginary number?’, ‘Is it possible to make a transition from classical mechanics to quantum physics without using postulates?’ and ‘What is the origin of the uncertainty principle?’. A significant proportion of discussion is dedicated to the issue of why the wave function must be complex to properly describe our “real” world. The book also addresses the different formulations of quantum mechanics. A relatively simple introductory treatment is given for the “standard” Heisenberg matrix formulation and Schrodinger wave-function formulation and Feynman path integrals and second quantization are then discussed. This book will appeal to first- and second-year university students in physics, mathematics, engineering and other sciences studying quantum mechanics who will find material and clarifications not easily found in other textbooks. It will also appeal to self-taught readers with a genuine interest in modern physics who are willing to examine the mathematics and physics in a simple but rigorous way. Key Features: Written in an engaging and approachable manner, with fully explained mathematics and physics concepts Suitable as a companion to all introductory quantum mechanics textbooks Accessible to a general audience

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 25, 2023•0 citations

Schrödinger's original struggles with a complex wave function

Ricardo Karam

In this paper, some of Schrödinger's initial struggles with the complex nature of his wave function are outlined. It is shown that he first attached physical meaning only to its real component and even tried to avoid the explicit appearance of the imaginary unit i in his fundamental (time-dependent) equation. This attitude is quite understandable, since he was committed to the classical framework of wave theory, not only ontologically, but also formally. Around one year after the publication of his famous papers on wave mechanics, Schrödinger seems to have accepted that the wave function must be complex and that the physical interpretation is to be related to its absolute square. This is justified by him both due to equivalence considerations with matrix mechanics and in analogy with Maxwell's equations. It is argued that an awareness of the struggles Schrödinger went through to accept a complex wave function can be a relief to students who themselves wonder why ψ needs to be complex when they encounter the topic for the first time.

American Journal of Physics•May 21, 2020•18 citations
Complex numbers are broadly used in physics, normally as a calculation tool that makes things easier due to Euler's formula. In the end, it is only the real component that has physical meaning or the two parts (real and imaginary) are treated separately as real quantities. However, the situation seems to be different in quantum mechanics, since the imaginary unit i appears explicitly in its fundamental equations. From a learning perspective, this can create some challenges to newcomers. In this article, four conceptually different justifications for the use/need of complex numbers in quantum mechanics are presented and some pedagogical implications are discussed.
> In standard quantum mechanics, the imaginary part of the wavefunction is treated as a mathematical convenience. This work shows that it corresponds to a real internal coordinate in a strictly real two-component representation Ψ = (R, I). The quantum phase is identified as a rotation angle in this internal plane, and Schrödinger dynamics becomes a continuous rotation between R and I. Crucially, the I-component — though not directly measurable in a single projective measurement — can be fully reconstructed via controlled phase shifts and interferometry against a known reference. This explains why real-only models fail: they lack the second degree of freedom required to produce the sinθ term in interference patterns (P(θ) = A + B cosθ + C sinθ, with C ≠ 0). The model is empirically equivalent to complex quantum mechanics but provides a clear physical interpretation of the “imaginary” part as an internal information coordinate. > This document is self-contained, uses no complex notation, and is fully compatible with established quantum theory. It includes a testable experimental signature and connects to quantum tomography, interferometry, and foundational questions about the role of complex numbers in physics. This work is conceptually related to recent discussions on the necessity of complex numbers in quantum theory (Renou et al. 2021; Chen et al. 2022; Weilenmann et al. 2025), but takes a different approach by giving an explicitly real two-component interpretation of the imaginary part.”
Abstract This chapter explains why complex numbers are important for more general quantum mechanical situations. The complex exponential function, aka Euler’s formula, plays a critical role in expressing phase differences between components of a quantum state vector. These phase differences affect the outcome of quantum operations. The Bloch sphere and Bloch vector provide a visual representation of these more complex quantum states with the real and imaginary parts on different axes. The complex exponential is important in the quantum Fourier transform, which is then used to prove an important result for finding the repetition period in the Shor algorithm.
Mathematically, the imaginary unit 𝑖 has long been regarded as an algebraic generator extending the real numbers to the complex field. Yet a century after the birth of quantum mechanics (1925–2025), the answer to its oldest question is now clear: quantum mechanics is not merely a mathematical structure—it is a physical reality, and all quantities appearing in its non-commutative relations are physical. Therefore, 𝑖 is not a mere algebraic extension but the universal operator demanded by the geometric completeness of non-commutative reality between position and momentum. The imaginary unit is a physical reality. The canonical relation [𝑥, 𝑝] = 𝑖ℏ is not merely algebraic—it is a geometric law, showing that the complex structure of quantum mechanics arises inevitably from physical reality itself. It stands without contradiction, without complexity. This is nature. In the (𝑥, 𝑝) plane, 𝑖 represents a 90° rotation and ℏ quantizes the curvature of that rotation. Complex numbers thus arise as the natural geometric language of non-commutative physics, providing a geometric resolution to the century-old question of physical completeness first raised by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935).
In 1927, Nobel prize winning physicist, E. Schrodinger, in correspondence with Ehrenfest, wrote the following about the new theory: “What is unpleasant here, and indeed directly to be objected to, is the use of complex numbers. Psi is surely fundamentally a real function.” This seemingly simple issue remains unexplained almost ninety years later. In this dissertation I elucidate the physical and theoretical origins of the complex requirement. I identify a freedom/constraint situation encountered by vectors when, employed in accordance with adopted quantum representational methodology, and representing angular momentum states in particular. Complex vectors, quite simply, provide more available adjustable variables than do real vectors. The additional variables relax the constraint situation allowing the theory’s representational program to carry through. This complex number issue, which lies at the deepest foundations of the theory, has implications for important issues located higher in the theory. For example, any unification of the classical and quantum accounts of the settled order of nature, will rest squarely on our ability to account for the introduction of the imaginary unit.
Introduction to the Maths and Physics of Quantum Mechanics details the mathematics and physics that are needed to learn the principles of quantum mechanics. It provides an accessible treatment of how to use quantum mechanics and why it is so successful in explaining natural phenomena. This book clarifies various aspects of quantum physics such as ‘why quantum mechanics equations contain “I”, the imaginary number?’, ‘Is it possible to make a transition from classical mechanics to quantum physics without using postulates?’ and ‘What is the origin of the uncertainty principle?’. A significant proportion of discussion is dedicated to the issue of why the wave function must be complex to properly describe our “real” world. The book also addresses the different formulations of quantum mechanics. A relatively simple introductory treatment is given for the “standard” Heisenberg matrix formulation and Schrodinger wave-function formulation and Feynman path integrals and second quantization are then discussed. This book will appeal to first- and second-year university students in physics, mathematics, engineering and other sciences studying quantum mechanics who will find material and clarifications not easily found in other textbooks. It will also appeal to self-taught readers with a genuine interest in modern physics who are willing to examine the mathematics and physics in a simple but rigorous way. Key Features: Written in an engaging and approachable manner, with fully explained mathematics and physics concepts Suitable as a companion to all introductory quantum mechanics textbooks Accessible to a general audience
In this paper, some of Schrödinger's initial struggles with the complex nature of his wave function are outlined. It is shown that he first attached physical meaning only to its real component and even tried to avoid the explicit appearance of the imaginary unit i in his fundamental (time-dependent) equation. This attitude is quite understandable, since he was committed to the classical framework of wave theory, not only ontologically, but also formally. Around one year after the publication of his famous papers on wave mechanics, Schrödinger seems to have accepted that the wave function must be complex and that the physical interpretation is to be related to its absolute square. This is justified by him both due to equivalence considerations with matrix mechanics and in analogy with Maxwell's equations. It is argued that an awareness of the struggles Schrödinger went through to accept a complex wave function can be a relief to students who themselves wonder why ψ needs to be complex when they encounter the topic for the first time.