Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Reports

Hamilton Equations, Commutator, and Energy Conservation

Weng Cho Chew, Aiyin Y. Liu, C. Salazar-Lazaro, Dong-Yeop Na, Wei E. I. Sha

Published Dec 9, 2019• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We show that the classical Hamilton equations of motion can be derived from the energy conservation condition. A similar argument is shown to carry to the quantum formulation of Hamiltonian dynamics. Hence, showing a striking similarity between the quantum formulation and the classical formulation. Furthermore, it is shown that the fundamental commutator can be derived from the Heisenberg equations of motion and the quantum Hamilton equations of motion. Also, that the Heisenberg equations of motion can be derived from the Schrödinger equation for the quantum state, which is the fundamental postulate. These results are shown to have important bearing for deriving the quantum Maxwell’s equations.

DOI
10.3390/quantum1020027

Related papers

Quantum deformations of the Heisenberg equations of motion

Alan Chodos, Daniel G. Caldi

The authors consider various formulations of what may be called q-quantum mechanics. One involves replacing the commutator that appears in the Heisenberg equations of motion by the 'quommutator': (A,B) q =qAB-(1/q)BA. They formally integrate the equations of motion, study some simple examples and discuss various apparent difficulties such as lack of conservation of energy, lack of unitarity and the unboundedness of the norm. They also consider another formulation in which the quantum bracket of the time derivative of an operator is used instead of just the time derivative, but the commutator is unchanged, in the Heisenberg equations of motion. This nonlinear treatment while preserving conservation of energy, has its own set of difficulties due to the nonlinearities. They also suggest that the quantum parameter may function as a kind of regulator for the time evolution of the system.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 7, 1991•10 citations

Proposal for the Quantum Mechanical Orbit Equation

Yoshio Nishiyama

The orbit equation for the motion of a quantum in a potential is proposed by defining uniquely the quantum mechanical momentum from the Schrodinger wave equation of a one-particle system and using the Hamilton-Jacobi formalism. On this occasion it is necessary to introduce a new dynamical postulate, “initial condition”, which is independent of the quantization condition as well as of the Schrodinger wave equation. The momentum is determined in such a way that it is approximately equal to the corresponding classical mechanical momentum in the classical region of validity of the coordinates. The momentum in the non-classical region is in general very small in comparison with that in the classical region. The quantum-mechanical motion well corresponds to the classical motion. If a system is macroscopic, the motion of the particle is described by Newtonian mechanics and the quantization condition is of no validity. The “quantization of magnetic flux” derives from the quantization condition. It is closely related to the energy level structure of the atomic system. The above argument is applied to the scalar electromagnetic and sound wave equations to give the dynamical motion of a photon and a phonon without recourse to the so-called second quantization method.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 1965•0 citations

Unifying Quantum and Classical Dynamics

Abdul Rahaman Shaikh, Tabish Qureshi

Classical and quantum physics represent two distinct theories; however, quantum physics is regarded as the more fundamental of the two. It is posited that classical mechanics should arise from quantum mechanics under certain limiting conditions. Nevertheless, this remains a challenging objective. In this work, we explore the potential for unifying the dynamics of classical and quantum physics. This discussion does not suggest that classical behavior emerges from quantum mechanics; rather, it demonstrates the exact equivalence between the dynamics of quantum observables and their classical counterparts. It is shown that the Heisenberg equations of motion can be cast in a form that is structurally equivalent to Newton's equations of motion, with $\hbar$ dropping out from the equations. In a generalized analysis, the Heisenberg equations are cast in a form that is identical to the classical Hamilton's equations of motion. This implies that both quantum and classical dynamics are governed by the same form of equations, with the Heisenberg operators substituting the classical observables.

quant-pharXiv:2601.10423•Jan 16, 2026•1 citation

Fourier Transform, Dirac Commutator, Energy Conservation, and Correspondence Principle for Electrical Engineers

Christopher Jayun Ryu, Erhan Kudeki, Dong-Yeop Na +2 more

The canonical commutation relation is a fundamental postulate of the quantum theory regarding the operators needed in quantum description of physical observables. It is shown that the Fourier transform is derivable from this seemingly simple postulate along with the basic properties of the position and momentum operators. Further discussions on the canonical commutation relation reveal its connection to a more fundamental notion that energy must be conserved. This discussion also unveils the mathematical homomorphism between the classical and quantum theories for systems represented by sum separable Hamiltonians. Another link between the classical and quantum theories is established by the correspondence principle which states that the classical theory emerges from quantum theory in the limit of vanishingly small Planck constant. Finally, the quantum Maxwell’s equations, which have been derived in our previous works, are presented and briefly discussed, and the 3-D mode transform is derived that can be interpreted as a generalization of the Fourier transform. We present both the details and meanings of the 3-D mode transform which will serve as a foundation for a full 3-D quantum finite-difference time-domain method.

IEEE journal on multiscale and multiphysics computational techniques•Jan 1, 2022•3 citations

Derivation of the Schrödinger equation from the Hamilton–Jacobi equation in Feynman's path integral formulation of quantum mechanics

J.H. Field

It is shown how the time-dependent Schrödinger equation may be simply derived from the dynamical postulate of Feynman's path integral formulation of quantum mechanics and the Hamilton–Jacobi equation of classical mechanics. Schrödinger's own published derivations of quantum wave equations, the first of which was also based on the Hamilton–Jacobi equation, are also reviewed. The derivation of the time-dependent equation is based on an a priori assumption equivalent to Feynman's dynamical postulate. de Broglie's concepts of ‘matter waves’ and their phase and group velocities are also critically discussed.

arXiv:1204.0653•European Journal of Physics•Nov 17, 2010•35 citations

Framework for generalized Hamiltonian systems through reasonable postulates

Libo Jiang, Daniel R. Terno, Oscar Dahlsten

Hamiltonian mechanics describes the evolution of a system through its Hamiltonian. The Hamiltonian typically also represents the energy observable, a Noether-conserved quantity associated with the time invariance of the law of evolution. In both quantum and classical mechanics, Hamiltonian mechanics demands a precise relationship between time evolution and observable energy, albeit using slightly different terminology. We distill basic conditions satisfied in both quantum and classical mechanics, including canonical coordinate symmetries and inner product invariance. We express these conditions in the framework of generalized probabilistic theories, which includes generalizing the definition of energy eigenstates in terms of time-invariant properties of the Hamiltonian system. By postulating these conditions to hold, we derive a unified Hamiltonian system model. This unified framework describes quantum and classical mechanics in a consistent language, facilitating their comparison. We moreover discuss alternative theories: an equation of motion given by a mixture of commutation relations, an information-restricted version of quantum theory, and Spekken's toy theory. The findings give a deeper understanding of the Hamiltonian in quantum and classical theories and point to several potential research topics.

arXiv:2403.00038•Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2024•6 citations
We show that the classical Hamilton equations of motion can be derived from the energy conservation condition. A similar argument is shown to carry to the quantum formulation of Hamiltonian dynamics. Hence, showing a striking similarity between the quantum formulation and the classical formulation. Furthermore, it is shown that the fundamental commutator can be derived from the Heisenberg equations of motion and the quantum Hamilton equations of motion. Also, that the Heisenberg equations of motion can be derived from the Schrödinger equation for the quantum state, which is the fundamental postulate. These results are shown to have important bearing for deriving the quantum Maxwell’s equations.
The authors consider various formulations of what may be called q-quantum mechanics. One involves replacing the commutator that appears in the Heisenberg equations of motion by the 'quommutator': (A,B) q =qAB-(1/q)BA. They formally integrate the equations of motion, study some simple examples and discuss various apparent difficulties such as lack of conservation of energy, lack of unitarity and the unboundedness of the norm. They also consider another formulation in which the quantum bracket of the time derivative of an operator is used instead of just the time derivative, but the commutator is unchanged, in the Heisenberg equations of motion. This nonlinear treatment while preserving conservation of energy, has its own set of difficulties due to the nonlinearities. They also suggest that the quantum parameter may function as a kind of regulator for the time evolution of the system.
The orbit equation for the motion of a quantum in a potential is proposed by defining uniquely the quantum mechanical momentum from the Schrodinger wave equation of a one-particle system and using the Hamilton-Jacobi formalism. On this occasion it is necessary to introduce a new dynamical postulate, “initial condition”, which is independent of the quantization condition as well as of the Schrodinger wave equation. The momentum is determined in such a way that it is approximately equal to the corresponding classical mechanical momentum in the classical region of validity of the coordinates. The momentum in the non-classical region is in general very small in comparison with that in the classical region. The quantum-mechanical motion well corresponds to the classical motion. If a system is macroscopic, the motion of the particle is described by Newtonian mechanics and the quantization condition is of no validity. The “quantization of magnetic flux” derives from the quantization condition. It is closely related to the energy level structure of the atomic system. The above argument is applied to the scalar electromagnetic and sound wave equations to give the dynamical motion of a photon and a phonon without recourse to the so-called second quantization method.
Classical and quantum physics represent two distinct theories; however, quantum physics is regarded as the more fundamental of the two. It is posited that classical mechanics should arise from quantum mechanics under certain limiting conditions. Nevertheless, this remains a challenging objective. In this work, we explore the potential for unifying the dynamics of classical and quantum physics. This discussion does not suggest that classical behavior emerges from quantum mechanics; rather, it demonstrates the exact equivalence between the dynamics of quantum observables and their classical counterparts. It is shown that the Heisenberg equations of motion can be cast in a form that is structurally equivalent to Newton's equations of motion, with ℏ\hbarℏ dropping out from the equations. In a generalized analysis, the Heisenberg equations are cast in a form that is identical to the classical Hamilton's equations of motion. This implies that both quantum and classical dynamics are governed by the same form of equations, with the Heisenberg operators substituting the classical observables.
The canonical commutation relation is a fundamental postulate of the quantum theory regarding the operators needed in quantum description of physical observables. It is shown that the Fourier transform is derivable from this seemingly simple postulate along with the basic properties of the position and momentum operators. Further discussions on the canonical commutation relation reveal its connection to a more fundamental notion that energy must be conserved. This discussion also unveils the mathematical homomorphism between the classical and quantum theories for systems represented by sum separable Hamiltonians. Another link between the classical and quantum theories is established by the correspondence principle which states that the classical theory emerges from quantum theory in the limit of vanishingly small Planck constant. Finally, the quantum Maxwell’s equations, which have been derived in our previous works, are presented and briefly discussed, and the 3-D mode transform is derived that can be interpreted as a generalization of the Fourier transform. We present both the details and meanings of the 3-D mode transform which will serve as a foundation for a full 3-D quantum finite-difference time-domain method.
It is shown how the time-dependent Schrödinger equation may be simply derived from the dynamical postulate of Feynman's path integral formulation of quantum mechanics and the Hamilton–Jacobi equation of classical mechanics. Schrödinger's own published derivations of quantum wave equations, the first of which was also based on the Hamilton–Jacobi equation, are also reviewed. The derivation of the time-dependent equation is based on an a priori assumption equivalent to Feynman's dynamical postulate. de Broglie's concepts of ‘matter waves’ and their phase and group velocities are also critically discussed.
Hamiltonian mechanics describes the evolution of a system through its Hamiltonian. The Hamiltonian typically also represents the energy observable, a Noether-conserved quantity associated with the time invariance of the law of evolution. In both quantum and classical mechanics, Hamiltonian mechanics demands a precise relationship between time evolution and observable energy, albeit using slightly different terminology. We distill basic conditions satisfied in both quantum and classical mechanics, including canonical coordinate symmetries and inner product invariance. We express these conditions in the framework of generalized probabilistic theories, which includes generalizing the definition of energy eigenstates in terms of time-invariant properties of the Hamiltonian system. By postulating these conditions to hold, we derive a unified Hamiltonian system model. This unified framework describes quantum and classical mechanics in a consistent language, facilitating their comparison. We moreover discuss alternative theories: an equation of motion given by a mixture of commutation relations, an information-restricted version of quantum theory, and Spekken's toy theory. The findings give a deeper understanding of the Hamiltonian in quantum and classical theories and point to several potential research topics.