Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Superconductivity of an Ideal Charged Boson System

T.D. Lee

Published Oct 25, 1991• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Recently Friedberg, Lee and Ren have pointed out that at low density the ideal charged boson system turns out not to be a superconductor, but becomes a type II superconductor at high density. This conclusion differs from the well-known Schafroth solution of superconductivity at any density for the same problem. Schafroth's analysis is found to contain a mistake due to the neglect of the electrostatic exchange energy E ex . Based on the Schafroth solution, E ex is shown to be +∞ in the normal phase, but 0 in the condensed phase (at T = 0). Of course, the correct solution has to give a finite E ex . This research was supported in part by the U.S. Department of Energy. SCHAFROTH'S SOLUTION Schafroth's superconductivity solution of an ideal charged boson system published 35 years ago has always been considered to be the definitive work, comparable in depth to the analysis made by Landau on the diamagnetism of an ideal charged fermion system. However, recently it was found that the Schafroth solution contains a serious mistake due to the neglect of the electrostatic exchange energy E ex . It turns out that based on the Schafroth solution, E ex is +∞ in the normal phase, but 0 in the condensed phase (at T = 0). Of course, the correct solution has to give a finite E ex . For ideal charged particles, bosons or fermions, there is only the electromagnetic interaction.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511563980.012

Related papers

Superconductivity of a Charged Ideal Bose Gas

M. R. Schafroth

It is shown that an ideal gas of charged bosons exhibits the essential equilibrium features of a superconductor. The onset of Bose-Einstein condensation marks the transition temperature ${T}_{c}$. Below ${T}_{c}$ a Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect is exhibited which is described in a very good approximation by London's equation.The singular nature of the condensed ideal Bose gas exhibits itself in a space dependence of the London constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, determined by the boundary conditions on the wave function. It is shown that the electrostatic repulsion between the bosons compensates this effect and leads to a spatially constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, independently of the boundary conditions.The critical field ${H}_{c}(T)$ is determined and found to be related to the penetration depth $d(T)$ by ${H}_{c}=\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}c}{2e{d}^{2}}$ ($e$ being the boson charge).The $B(H)$ law is different from the one usually assumed for actual superconductors. Corresponding changes occur in the thermodynamical relation.A comparison with superconducting metals is made. The main conclusion is that if superconductivity in metals is due to the concurrence of bosons, then the number of these bosons must be strongly temperaturedependent below ${T}_{c}$.

Physical Review•Oct 15, 1955•360 citations

BCS Theory of Superconductivity

A. S. Alexandrov, Nevill Mott

The crucial demonstration that superfluidity was linked to Bose particles and Bose-Einstein condensation came after the discovery of He3 in 1949, which failed to show the characteristic A transition within a reasonable wide temperature interval around the critical temperature for the onset of superfluidity in He4. The idea of the bosonization of electrons due to their pairing, introduced by Ogg (1946) became very attractive as an explanation for superconductivity after Schafroth (1955) showed that a gas of charged bosons with charge 2e would indeed show a Meissner effect, which is one of the most crucial features of superconductors (see Chapter 1). However this phenomenological Bose-gas picture was condemned and later on practically forgotten because it was unable to account quantitatively for the critical parameters of the classical (low-temperature) superconductors. Using for Tc the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature Eq.(l.S) one obtains the utterly meaningless result Tc = lOOOO.R&s; with the atomic density of electron pairs ~ 1022cm~3 and with the effective mass m** = 2me. The failure of the Schafroth picture stems from a very large size £ of pairs in classical superconductors, which can be estimated from the uncertainty principle: The uncertainty of the momentum 8p is estimated from the uncertainty of the kinetic energy 8E ~ vpSp, which should be of the order of Tc, the only characteristic energy of the superconducting state. Therefore and turns out to be more than one micron for simple metals with Tc ~ IK and the Fermi velocity VF — I0scm/s. That means that pairs in classical superconductors overlap strongly and the Shafroth model of real space pairs is wrong. The finally successful theory for classical superconductors was formulated by Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (1957). In this chapter we present the main points of the BCS theory, using the Bogoliubov transformation (1947,1958) for the weak-coupling regime and the Green&s;s function technique for the intermediate coupling in Chapter 3. More details will be found in the excellent books by Schrieffer(1965), De Gennes (1989) and Abrikosov, Gor&s;kov and Dzyaloshinskii (1963).

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 24, 1994•0 citations

Universal behavior of the condensation energy of Superconducting BCS Bose gases

Juan José Valencia Acevedo, M. Atala, Patricia Salas Casales +1 more

Using the Boson-Fermion formalism of superconductivity we calculate the condensation energy for several superconductors ranging from conventional to unconventional, or high temperature superconductors. It is calculated as the difference between the Helmholtz free energies of the superconducting and the normal state, which is a gas of N attractive electron gas, while the superconducting state is formed by the condensed Cooper pairs taken as composite bosons, coming from a fraction of the electrons inside the Debye shell, plus those electrons inside and outside the Debye shell that are unable to pair. After giving the analytic expressions for the internal energy U and the entropy S we obtain the Helmholtz free energy F = U -TS for both the superconducting and the normal states as functions of temperature. In the search for universalities, we calculate the ratio of the condensation energy at T=0 to the Sommerfeld constant (the normal state electronic specific heat over the temperature when T it's almost zero) using two different methods: the Boson-Fermion formalism developed here, as well as an analytical expression deduced from a combination of the BCS and Ginzburg-Landau theories. We find for the Boson-Fermion formalism $E_{cond}/γ_0= 0.252\,T_{c}^{1.997}$, which is the same behavior described by the experimental fit of Kim et al $E_{cond}/γ_0= 0.2\,T_{c}^{2.06}$ and by the one recently reported by Tallon et al for overdoped cuprate superconductors; while for the Ginzburg-Landau-BCS we get the expression $E_{cond}/γ_0= 0.236\,T_{c}^{2}$, also in very good agreement with the partifirst method.

arXiv:2606.25316•Jun 24, 2026•0 citations

Superfluidity and Superconductivity

To a large extent, superfluidity in boson and fermion systems can be understood on a common basis. In the first part of this chapter, we study these quantum phenomena from general principles with no reference to microscopic theories. Starting from the very definition of superfluidity — the existence of persistent (dissipationless) macroscopic currents — we show that superfluids are characterized by current–current correlations of infinite range. This property implies the Meissner effect in charged superconductors (Sec. 3.4.5). We then introduce the concepts of off-diagonal long-range order and spontaneous U(1) symmetry breaking. The latter enables us to introduce a low-energy effective action for the phase of the superfluid order parameter, from which we can deduce the characteristic equations of a superfluid. The coupling to the electromagnetic field in (charged) superconductors is easily incorporated into this phenomenological approach and leads to the Anderson–Higgs mechanism. In the second part of the chapter, we study microscopic theories of superfluidity and superconductivity: the Gross–Pitaevskii approach and the Bogoliubov theory for boson systems and, for superconductors, the Bardeen–Cooper–Shrieffer (BCS) theory, with particular emphasis on collective modes in both neutral and charged systems. The last section is devoted to the BCS–BEC crossover in fermion superfluids. Unless otherwise specified, we consider only three-dimensional systems.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Aug 1, 2023•44 citations

Charged Bose gas

A charged Coulomb Bose-gas (CBG) is a fundamental reference system in many-particle physics with a superfluid phase transition. It has been studied by several authors and recently became of particular interest motivated by the bipolaron theory of high temperature superconductivity. As we have discussed in Chapter 6 the long-wave excitations of the bipolaronic liquid are those of charged bosons with the Coulomb repulsion between them. Schafroth (1955) demonstrated that an ideal gas of charged bosons exhibits the Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect (expulsion of a magnetic field) below the ideal Bose-gas condensation temperature. Later on the one-particle excitation spectrum at T = 0 was calculated by Foldy (1961), who worked at zero temperature using the Bogoliubov (1947) approach. The Bogoliubov method leads to the result that the ground state of the system has a negative correlation energy, whose magnitude increases with the density of bosons. Perhaps more interesting is the fact that the elementary excitations of the system have, for small momenta, energies characteristic of plasma oscillations which pass over smoothly for large momenta to the energies characteristic of single particle excitations. Further investigations have been carried out at or near T c , the transition temperature for the gas. These works has been concerned with the critical exponents (Bishop (1974)) and the change in the transition temperature from that of the ideal gas (Bishop (1974), Fetter (1971)). The RPA dielectric response function and screening in CBG have been studied in the high-density limit (Hore and Frankel (1975, 1976), including a low-dimensional (2 D ) CBG (Hines and Frankel (1979), Gold (1991)). In this Chapter we verify superfluid properties of charged bosons with the Bogoliubov-de Genes type equations derived for CBG by Alexandrov and Beere (1995) and discuss superconducting as well as normal state CBG kinetics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

A New Method in the Theory of Superconductivity

N. N. Bogoljubov, V. V. Tolmachov, D. V. Širkov

Abstract The method of canonical transformations proposed by one of the authors ten years ago in connection with a microscopic theory of superfluidity for Bose systems, is generalized here to Fermi systems, and forms the basis of a method for investigating the problem of superconductivity. Starting from Fröhlich's Hamiltonian, the energy of the superconducting ground state and the one‐Fermion and collective excitations corresponding to this state are obtained. It turns out that the final formulae for the ground state and one‐Fermion excitations recently obtained by Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer are correct in the first approximation. The physical picture appears to be closer to the one proposed by Schafroth, Butler and Blatt. The effect on superconductivity of the Coulomb interaction between the electrons is analyzed in detail. A criterion for the superfluidity of a Fermi system with a four‐line vertex Hamiltonian is established.

Fortschritte der Physik•Jan 1, 1958•734 citations
Recently Friedberg, Lee and Ren have pointed out that at low density the ideal charged boson system turns out not to be a superconductor, but becomes a type II superconductor at high density. This conclusion differs from the well-known Schafroth solution of superconductivity at any density for the same problem. Schafroth's analysis is found to contain a mistake due to the neglect of the electrostatic exchange energy E ex . Based on the Schafroth solution, E ex is shown to be +∞ in the normal phase, but 0 in the condensed phase (at T = 0). Of course, the correct solution has to give a finite E ex . This research was supported in part by the U.S. Department of Energy. SCHAFROTH'S SOLUTION Schafroth's superconductivity solution of an ideal charged boson system published 35 years ago has always been considered to be the definitive work, comparable in depth to the analysis made by Landau on the diamagnetism of an ideal charged fermion system. However, recently it was found that the Schafroth solution contains a serious mistake due to the neglect of the electrostatic exchange energy E ex . It turns out that based on the Schafroth solution, E ex is +∞ in the normal phase, but 0 in the condensed phase (at T = 0). Of course, the correct solution has to give a finite E ex . For ideal charged particles, bosons or fermions, there is only the electromagnetic interaction.
It is shown that an ideal gas of charged bosons exhibits the essential equilibrium features of a superconductor. The onset of Bose-Einstein condensation marks the transition temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. Below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ a Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect is exhibited which is described in a very good approximation by London's equation.The singular nature of the condensed ideal Bose gas exhibits itself in a space dependence of the London constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, determined by the boundary conditions on the wave function. It is shown that the electrostatic repulsion between the bosons compensates this effect and leads to a spatially constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, independently of the boundary conditions.The critical field Hc(T){H}_{c}(T)Hc​(T) is determined and found to be related to the penetration depth d(T)d(T)d(T) by ${H}_{c}=\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}c}{2e{d}^{2}}$ (eee being the boson charge).The B(H)B(H)B(H) law is different from the one usually assumed for actual superconductors. Corresponding changes occur in the thermodynamical relation.A comparison with superconducting metals is made. The main conclusion is that if superconductivity in metals is due to the concurrence of bosons, then the number of these bosons must be strongly temperaturedependent below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​.
The crucial demonstration that superfluidity was linked to Bose particles and Bose-Einstein condensation came after the discovery of He3 in 1949, which failed to show the characteristic A transition within a reasonable wide temperature interval around the critical temperature for the onset of superfluidity in He4. The idea of the bosonization of electrons due to their pairing, introduced by Ogg (1946) became very attractive as an explanation for superconductivity after Schafroth (1955) showed that a gas of charged bosons with charge 2e would indeed show a Meissner effect, which is one of the most crucial features of superconductors (see Chapter 1). However this phenomenological Bose-gas picture was condemned and later on practically forgotten because it was unable to account quantitatively for the critical parameters of the classical (low-temperature) superconductors. Using for Tc the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature Eq.(l.S) one obtains the utterly meaningless result Tc = lOOOO.R&s; with the atomic density of electron pairs ~ 1022cm~3 and with the effective mass m** = 2me. The failure of the Schafroth picture stems from a very large size £ of pairs in classical superconductors, which can be estimated from the uncertainty principle: The uncertainty of the momentum 8p is estimated from the uncertainty of the kinetic energy 8E ~ vpSp, which should be of the order of Tc, the only characteristic energy of the superconducting state. Therefore and turns out to be more than one micron for simple metals with Tc ~ IK and the Fermi velocity VF — I0scm/s. That means that pairs in classical superconductors overlap strongly and the Shafroth model of real space pairs is wrong. The finally successful theory for classical superconductors was formulated by Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (1957). In this chapter we present the main points of the BCS theory, using the Bogoliubov transformation (1947,1958) for the weak-coupling regime and the Green&s;s function technique for the intermediate coupling in Chapter 3. More details will be found in the excellent books by Schrieffer(1965), De Gennes (1989) and Abrikosov, Gor&s;kov and Dzyaloshinskii (1963).
Using the Boson-Fermion formalism of superconductivity we calculate the condensation energy for several superconductors ranging from conventional to unconventional, or high temperature superconductors. It is calculated as the difference between the Helmholtz free energies of the superconducting and the normal state, which is a gas of N attractive electron gas, while the superconducting state is formed by the condensed Cooper pairs taken as composite bosons, coming from a fraction of the electrons inside the Debye shell, plus those electrons inside and outside the Debye shell that are unable to pair. After giving the analytic expressions for the internal energy U and the entropy S we obtain the Helmholtz free energy F = U -TS for both the superconducting and the normal states as functions of temperature. In the search for universalities, we calculate the ratio of the condensation energy at T=0 to the Sommerfeld constant (the normal state electronic specific heat over the temperature when T it's almost zero) using two different methods: the Boson-Fermion formalism developed here, as well as an analytical expression deduced from a combination of the BCS and Ginzburg-Landau theories. We find for the Boson-Fermion formalism Econd/γ0=0.252 Tc1.997E_{cond}/γ_0= 0.252\,T_{c}^{1.997}Econd​/γ0​=0.252Tc1.997​, which is the same behavior described by the experimental fit of Kim et al Econd/γ0=0.2 Tc2.06E_{cond}/γ_0= 0.2\,T_{c}^{2.06}Econd​/γ0​=0.2Tc2.06​ and by the one recently reported by Tallon et al for overdoped cuprate superconductors; while for the Ginzburg-Landau-BCS we get the expression Econd/γ0=0.236 Tc2E_{cond}/γ_0= 0.236\,T_{c}^{2}Econd​/γ0​=0.236Tc2​, also in very good agreement with the partifirst method.
To a large extent, superfluidity in boson and fermion systems can be understood on a common basis. In the first part of this chapter, we study these quantum phenomena from general principles with no reference to microscopic theories. Starting from the very definition of superfluidity — the existence of persistent (dissipationless) macroscopic currents — we show that superfluids are characterized by current–current correlations of infinite range. This property implies the Meissner effect in charged superconductors (Sec. 3.4.5). We then introduce the concepts of off-diagonal long-range order and spontaneous U(1) symmetry breaking. The latter enables us to introduce a low-energy effective action for the phase of the superfluid order parameter, from which we can deduce the characteristic equations of a superfluid. The coupling to the electromagnetic field in (charged) superconductors is easily incorporated into this phenomenological approach and leads to the Anderson–Higgs mechanism. In the second part of the chapter, we study microscopic theories of superfluidity and superconductivity: the Gross–Pitaevskii approach and the Bogoliubov theory for boson systems and, for superconductors, the Bardeen–Cooper–Shrieffer (BCS) theory, with particular emphasis on collective modes in both neutral and charged systems. The last section is devoted to the BCS–BEC crossover in fermion superfluids. Unless otherwise specified, we consider only three-dimensional systems.
A charged Coulomb Bose-gas (CBG) is a fundamental reference system in many-particle physics with a superfluid phase transition. It has been studied by several authors and recently became of particular interest motivated by the bipolaron theory of high temperature superconductivity. As we have discussed in Chapter 6 the long-wave excitations of the bipolaronic liquid are those of charged bosons with the Coulomb repulsion between them. Schafroth (1955) demonstrated that an ideal gas of charged bosons exhibits the Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect (expulsion of a magnetic field) below the ideal Bose-gas condensation temperature. Later on the one-particle excitation spectrum at T = 0 was calculated by Foldy (1961), who worked at zero temperature using the Bogoliubov (1947) approach. The Bogoliubov method leads to the result that the ground state of the system has a negative correlation energy, whose magnitude increases with the density of bosons. Perhaps more interesting is the fact that the elementary excitations of the system have, for small momenta, energies characteristic of plasma oscillations which pass over smoothly for large momenta to the energies characteristic of single particle excitations. Further investigations have been carried out at or near T c , the transition temperature for the gas. These works has been concerned with the critical exponents (Bishop (1974)) and the change in the transition temperature from that of the ideal gas (Bishop (1974), Fetter (1971)). The RPA dielectric response function and screening in CBG have been studied in the high-density limit (Hore and Frankel (1975, 1976), including a low-dimensional (2 D ) CBG (Hines and Frankel (1979), Gold (1991)). In this Chapter we verify superfluid properties of charged bosons with the Bogoliubov-de Genes type equations derived for CBG by Alexandrov and Beere (1995) and discuss superconducting as well as normal state CBG kinetics.
Abstract The method of canonical transformations proposed by one of the authors ten years ago in connection with a microscopic theory of superfluidity for Bose systems, is generalized here to Fermi systems, and forms the basis of a method for investigating the problem of superconductivity. Starting from Fröhlich's Hamiltonian, the energy of the superconducting ground state and the one‐Fermion and collective excitations corresponding to this state are obtained. It turns out that the final formulae for the ground state and one‐Fermion excitations recently obtained by Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer are correct in the first approximation. The physical picture appears to be closer to the one proposed by Schafroth, Butler and Blatt. The effect on superconductivity of the Coulomb interaction between the electrons is analyzed in detail. A criterion for the superfluidity of a Fermi system with a four‐line vertex Hamiltonian is established.