Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bloomsbury Academic eBooks

Bohr and the Problem of the Quantum-to-Classical Transition

Maximillian Schlosshauer, Kristian Camilleri

Published Jan 1, 2017• 4 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.5040/9781350035140.ch-010

Related papers

The quantum-to-classical transition: Decoherence and beyond

Maximilian Andreas Schlosshauer-Selbach

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

The quantum-to-classical transition: Bohr's doctrine of classical concepts, emergent classicality, and decoherence

Maximilian Schlosshauer, Kristian Camilleri

It is now widely accepted that environmental entanglement and the resulting decoherence processes play a crucial role in the quantum-to-classical transition and the emergence of "classicality" from quantum mechanics. To this extent, decoherence is often understood as signifying a break with the Copenhagen interpretation, and in particular with Bohr's view of the indispensability of classical concepts. This paper analyzes the relationship between Bohr's understanding of the quantum-classical divide and his doctrine of classical concepts and the decoherence-based program of emergent classicality. By drawing on Howard's reconstruction of Bohr's doctrine of classical concepts, and by paying careful attention to a hitherto overlooked disagreement between Heisenberg and Bohr in the 1930s about the placement of the quantum-classical "cut," we show that Bohr's view of the quantum-classical divide can be physically justified by appealing to decoherence. We also discuss early anticipations of the role of the environment in the quantum-classical problem in Heisenberg's writings. Finally, we distinguish four different formulations of the doctrine of classical concepts in an effort to present a more nuanced assessment of the relationship between Bohr's views and decoherence that challenges oversimplified statements frequently found in the literature.

arXiv:0804.1609•Apr 10, 2008•39 citations

Bohr and the Development of Quantum Theory: A Brief Review

Makoto Katsumori

Boston studies in the philosophy of science•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

On Bohr’s Epistemological Contribution to the Quantum-Classical Cut Problems

Manuel Bächtold

Although microscopic systems are described by means of quantum mechanics, the outcomes obtained when performing measurements on such systems “appear” to us as being “classical” (Giulini et al. 2003). This situation is puzzling. How does the classical appearance of these measurement outcomes emerge (problem A)? And why, after all, couldn’t we describe these measurement outcomes by means of quantummechanics (problem B)? Problem A can be tackled within the domain of physics. As a matter of fact, it has been partly solved by means of decoherence theory (Zurek 1981, 1982, 1991; Blanchard et al. 2000; Joos et al. 2003). Problem B falls under the competency of epistemology, as it deals with the respective role of classical physics and quantum mechanics. Concerning this topic of the quantum- classical cut, the contribution of Bohr and especially his thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts have been very influential during the twentieth century. Many scholars in the past have examined Bohr’s writings concerning this thesis (Folse 1985; Honner 1987; Murdoch 1987; Faye 1991; Chevalley 1991; Scheibe 1993). Recently, this thesis has been discussed in relation to decoherence theory. More precisely, Camilleri and Schlosshauer (2015) asked if Bohr’s thesis is challenged by decoherence theory. Their inquiry leads them to conclude that this is not the case. In other words, Bohr’s viewis still defendable. This chapter aims at showing that Bohr’s view is not only defendable but can throw light on the problems associated with the quantum- classical cut. First, I will recall that Bohr’s way of dealing with this cut is not ontological but epistemological. I will then put forward four conceptual distinctions and argue that those are essential to understand and discuss Bohr’s thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts. Finally, on the basis of this clarification, the relation between Bohr’s thesis and decoherence theory will be discussed.

Bloomsbury Academic eBooks•Jan 1, 2017•4 citations

The Bohr-Maxwell Description of the Hydrogen L-to-K Transition

Daniel Scretching

This paper develops and verifies a physics-first description of the hydrogen-atom transition from the L shell (n = 2) to the K shell (n = 1) by combining the historical Bohr model of atomic structure with classical Maxwell electrodynamics. Beginning with the Coulomb force, centripetal dynamics, and Bohr’s angular-momentum quantization condition, the analysis derives the allowed orbital radii, electron velocities, angular momenta, kinetic energies, electrostatic potential energies, and total bound-state energies of the hydrogen atom. For the n = 2 → n = 1 transition, the calculated energy difference is approximately 10.2 eV, corresponding through the Planck–Einstein relation ΔE = hν to a frequency of approximately 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz and a wavelength near 121.6 nm, consistent with the hydrogen Lyman-α transition. The emitted radiation is then examined through Maxwell’s equations and the vacuum constitutive relations. The resulting electromagnetic-wave description yields the transverse electric and magnetic fields together with the associated electromagnetic energy density, Poynting energy flux, momentum density, radiation pressure, and Maxwell stress tensor. In this way, the atomic energy difference obtained from the Bohr model is connected quantitatively to the classical propagation properties of the outgoing electromagnetic radiation. The derivation is mathematically consistent as a historical Bohr–Maxwell reconstruction, but it does not constitute a closed dynamical theory of spontaneous emission. The essential bridge between discrete atomic energy levels and the continuous Maxwell field is supplied by the quantum frequency condition ΔE = hν. Neither classical Maxwell electrodynamics nor Newtonian orbital mechanics independently derives this relation, and classical Maxwell theory does not by itself quantize the emitted radiation energy into individual photons. A complete treatment of spontaneous emission, transition probabilities, radiative lifetimes, and photon-field quantization requires quantum mechanics and ultimately quantum electrodynamics. Accordingly, the framework is presented as a verified correspondence between established limiting descriptions rather than as a replacement for Schrödinger wave mechanics, Dirac theory, or quantum electrodynamics. By clearly separating the atomic bound-state calculation, the quantum energy-frequency bridge, and the classical electromagnetic propagation problem, the analysis provides a rigorous conceptual and mathematical foundation for subsequent Maxwell–Schrödinger, Dirac–Maxwell, quantum-electrodynamic, Maxwell–Scretching, and Scretching Quantum Chain formulations of hydrogenic radiative transitions.

•Jul 16, 2026•0 citations

A criticism of Bohr's quantum-mechanical concepts

V. Fock

Czechoslovak Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1955•1 citation
It is now widely accepted that environmental entanglement and the resulting decoherence processes play a crucial role in the quantum-to-classical transition and the emergence of "classicality" from quantum mechanics. To this extent, decoherence is often understood as signifying a break with the Copenhagen interpretation, and in particular with Bohr's view of the indispensability of classical concepts. This paper analyzes the relationship between Bohr's understanding of the quantum-classical divide and his doctrine of classical concepts and the decoherence-based program of emergent classicality. By drawing on Howard's reconstruction of Bohr's doctrine of classical concepts, and by paying careful attention to a hitherto overlooked disagreement between Heisenberg and Bohr in the 1930s about the placement of the quantum-classical "cut," we show that Bohr's view of the quantum-classical divide can be physically justified by appealing to decoherence. We also discuss early anticipations of the role of the environment in the quantum-classical problem in Heisenberg's writings. Finally, we distinguish four different formulations of the doctrine of classical concepts in an effort to present a more nuanced assessment of the relationship between Bohr's views and decoherence that challenges oversimplified statements frequently found in the literature.
Although microscopic systems are described by means of quantum mechanics, the outcomes obtained when performing measurements on such systems “appear” to us as being “classical” (Giulini et al. 2003). This situation is puzzling. How does the classical appearance of these measurement outcomes emerge (problem A)? And why, after all, couldn’t we describe these measurement outcomes by means of quantummechanics (problem B)? Problem A can be tackled within the domain of physics. As a matter of fact, it has been partly solved by means of decoherence theory (Zurek 1981, 1982, 1991; Blanchard et al. 2000; Joos et al. 2003). Problem B falls under the competency of epistemology, as it deals with the respective role of classical physics and quantum mechanics. Concerning this topic of the quantum- classical cut, the contribution of Bohr and especially his thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts have been very influential during the twentieth century. Many scholars in the past have examined Bohr’s writings concerning this thesis (Folse 1985; Honner 1987; Murdoch 1987; Faye 1991; Chevalley 1991; Scheibe 1993). Recently, this thesis has been discussed in relation to decoherence theory. More precisely, Camilleri and Schlosshauer (2015) asked if Bohr’s thesis is challenged by decoherence theory. Their inquiry leads them to conclude that this is not the case. In other words, Bohr’s viewis still defendable. This chapter aims at showing that Bohr’s view is not only defendable but can throw light on the problems associated with the quantum- classical cut. First, I will recall that Bohr’s way of dealing with this cut is not ontological but epistemological. I will then put forward four conceptual distinctions and argue that those are essential to understand and discuss Bohr’s thesis of the necessary use of classical concepts. Finally, on the basis of this clarification, the relation between Bohr’s thesis and decoherence theory will be discussed.
This paper develops and verifies a physics-first description of the hydrogen-atom transition from the L shell (n = 2) to the K shell (n = 1) by combining the historical Bohr model of atomic structure with classical Maxwell electrodynamics. Beginning with the Coulomb force, centripetal dynamics, and Bohr’s angular-momentum quantization condition, the analysis derives the allowed orbital radii, electron velocities, angular momenta, kinetic energies, electrostatic potential energies, and total bound-state energies of the hydrogen atom. For the n = 2 → n = 1 transition, the calculated energy difference is approximately 10.2 eV, corresponding through the Planck–Einstein relation ΔE = hν to a frequency of approximately 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz and a wavelength near 121.6 nm, consistent with the hydrogen Lyman-α transition. The emitted radiation is then examined through Maxwell’s equations and the vacuum constitutive relations. The resulting electromagnetic-wave description yields the transverse electric and magnetic fields together with the associated electromagnetic energy density, Poynting energy flux, momentum density, radiation pressure, and Maxwell stress tensor. In this way, the atomic energy difference obtained from the Bohr model is connected quantitatively to the classical propagation properties of the outgoing electromagnetic radiation. The derivation is mathematically consistent as a historical Bohr–Maxwell reconstruction, but it does not constitute a closed dynamical theory of spontaneous emission. The essential bridge between discrete atomic energy levels and the continuous Maxwell field is supplied by the quantum frequency condition ΔE = hν. Neither classical Maxwell electrodynamics nor Newtonian orbital mechanics independently derives this relation, and classical Maxwell theory does not by itself quantize the emitted radiation energy into individual photons. A complete treatment of spontaneous emission, transition probabilities, radiative lifetimes, and photon-field quantization requires quantum mechanics and ultimately quantum electrodynamics. Accordingly, the framework is presented as a verified correspondence between established limiting descriptions rather than as a replacement for Schrödinger wave mechanics, Dirac theory, or quantum electrodynamics. By clearly separating the atomic bound-state calculation, the quantum energy-frequency bridge, and the classical electromagnetic propagation problem, the analysis provides a rigorous conceptual and mathematical foundation for subsequent Maxwell–Schrödinger, Dirac–Maxwell, quantum-electrodynamic, Maxwell–Scretching, and Scretching Quantum Chain formulations of hydrogenic radiative transitions.