The conclusion of the Planck radiation law is proposed, which does not require the involvement of non-thermodynamic considerations. The conclusion is based on the concept of the wave nature of the radiation process and the existence of harmonics in oscillators. It is shown that the true radiation quantum is a wave that is discrete both in time and in space, and the Planck constant plays the role of the proportionality coefficient between the fluxes of radiant energy and traveling waves. The de Broglie relation is obtained as a consequence of the identity of the oscillation frequency of the oscillators to the flow of emitted waves. The proposed approach removes a number of contradictions of quantum theory with classical physics.
The conclusion of the Planck radiation law is proposed, which does not require the involvement of non-thermodynamic considerations. The conclusion is based on the concept of the wave nature of the radiation process and the existence of harmonics in oscillators. It is shown that the true radiation quantum is a wave that is discrete both in time and in space, and the Planck constant plays the role of the proportionality coefficient between the fluxes of radiant energy and traveling waves. The de Broglie relation is obtained as a consequence of the identity of the oscillation frequency of the oscillators to the flow of emitted waves. The proposed approach removes a number of contradictions of quantum theory with classical physics.
The idea about a quantum nature of Planck's blackbody radiation law is deeply rooted in minds of most physicists. Einstein's work, in which the coefficients of spontaneous and induced emission were introduced, has always been regarded as a proof that quantum energy discreteness of an atom plays a crucial role in the derivation of this law. In our paper we avoid this standpoint. It may be shown that the de Broglie wave assigned to every material particle is a result of interaction of the particle with zero-point vibrations of electromagnetic ground field. The energetic spectrum of a harmonic oscillator is obtained from this fact within classical physics which coincides with the quantum result. Thus, it is explained here how the energy discreteness came into existence in stochastic electrodynamics (SED) --- the classical electrodynamics with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation. Next we reconsider the Einstein work from the viewpoint of SED and derive the Planck formula.
In Chapter 1, we discussed about the black-body radiation where in we learnt regarding Wien's law, Rayleigh−Jeans law and Planck's radiation law. Planck's quantum hypothesis or Planck's radiation equation is general by which Wien's Law and Rayleigh−Jeans radiation law can be arrived at. Actually, Wien's law and Rayleigh−Jeans law are special cases of Planck's radiation law. We also studied the photoelectric effect, Compton effect and atomic spectra in the first chapter. The photoelectric effect and Compton effect are vividly indicative of the corpuscular (particle) nature of visible light; X-radiation, interference and diffraction phenomena are evidence of its wave nature. Therefore, it can be concluded that the motion of photons clearly obeys special laws in which corpuscular and wave characteristics are combined. In the same chapter, we dealt with the atomic spectrum of hydrogen. Analysis of hydrogen atom spectrum should convince us that light is emitted or absorbed in energy quanta, i.e., in particles, which we know as photons. It does not mean that we must revive the old controversy of the corpuscular versus the undulatory theories of light. On the contrary, we know now that both theories are part of a more general theory. In some instances one theory applies and in others we must invoke the alternative. Einstein explained the photoelectric effect by Planck's quantum theory and he also handled the specific heat of solids considering the said theory. In the present chapter, we shall focus on wave−particle duality and Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and their verification by experiments. Dual nature of electron/de Broglie wave Keeping in view that light has dual nature, in 1924 de Broglie suggested that a small particle like electron would also behave both as a particle and as a wave. This is called the dual nature electron or matter wave or de Broglie wave. We know that the energy of a photon can be written in terms of Planck's quantum theory, i.e., E = hʋ But according to Einstein theory of relativity energy can be expressed as E = mcs 2 where, m = mass of electron; c = velocity of light; h = Planck's constant; ʋ = frequency of radiation.
Energy is proportional to frequency. With this single, austere relation Max Planck introduced the quantum of action and opened the door to a new physics. The constant of proportionality, h, is now known as Planck’s constant; the equation E = hv asserts that electromagnetic energy can be absorbed or emitted only in discrete packets whose size is fixed by the frequency of the radiation. First proposed in December 1900 as a formal device to save the theory of black-body radiation, the relation became the foundation of quantum theory. Few equations of comparable brevity have so thoroughly overturned the classical picture of nature.
It is in accordance with such experiments as single photon self-interference that a photon, conveying one radiation energy quantum " h × frequency", is spatially extensive and stretches an electromagnetic wave train. A wave train, hence an energy quantum, can only be emitted (or absorbed) by its source (or absorber) gradually. In both two processes the wave and "particle" attributes of the radiation field are simultaneously prominent, where an overall satisfactory theory has been lacking; for the latter process no known theoretical description currently exists. This paper presents a first principles treatment, in a unified framework of the classical and quantum mechanics, of the latter process, the emission (similarly absorption) of a single radiation quantum based on the dynamics of the radiation-emitting source, a charged oscillator, which is itself extensive across the potential well in which it oscillates. During the emission of one single radiation quantum, the extensive charged oscillator undergoes a continuous radiation damping and is non-stationary. This process is in this work treated using a quasi stationary approach, whereby the classical equation of motion, which directly facilitates the correspondence principle for a particle oscillator, and the quantum wave equation are established for each sufficiently brief time interval. As an inevitable consequence of the division of the total time for emitting one single quantum, a fractional Planck constant h is introduced. The solutions to the two simultaneous equations yield for the charged oscillator a continuously exponentially decaying Hamiltonian that is at the same time quantised with respect to the fractional- h at any instant of time; and the radiation wave field emitted over time stretches a wave train of finite length. The total system of the source and radiation field maintains at any time (integer n times) one whole energy quantum, ( n × ) h × frequency, in complete accordance with the standard notion of quantum mechanics and experiment.
The discovery of the Planck relation is generally regarded as the starting point of quantum physics. Planck’s constant h is now regarded as one of the most important universal constants. The physical nature of h , however, has not been well understood. It was originally suggested as a fitting constant to explain the black-body radiation. Although Planck had proposed a theoretical justification of h , he was never satisfied with that. To solve this outstanding problem, we use the Maxwell theory to directly calculate the energy and momentum of a radiation wave packet. We find that the energy of the wave packet is indeed proportional to its oscillation frequency. This allows us to derive the value of Planck’s constant. Furthermore, we show that the emission and transmission of a photon follows the all-or-none principle. The “strength” of the wave packet can be characterized by ζ , which represents the integrated strength of the vector potential along a transverse axis. We reason that ζ should have a fixed cut-off value for all photons. Our results suggest that a wave packet can behave like a particle. This offers a simple explanation to the recent satellite observations that the cosmic microwave background follows closely the black-body radiation as predicted by Planck’s law.
This chapter deals with the important experimental studies on black-body radiation, Wein’s law, Rayleigh–Jeans law, Planck’s distribution law, etc. The black-body radiation studies reveal that the maximum wavelength of radiation 1 is inversely proportional to temperature T . The expression for Wein’s law has been deduced on the basis of thermodynamic considerations. The law gives a clue to understand that it holds true only at low temperatures and short wavelengths. The Rayleigh–Jeans law is based on the general theorem of elasticity and is in excellent quantitative agreement with experimental observations for large wavelengths and high temperatures, leading to ultraviolet ‘catastrophe’. Actually, Max Planck enunciated the correct form of the temperature–radiation law based on some assumptions and finally proposed Planck’s quantum theory. This chapter also explains the photoelectric effect and important conclusions drawn on the basis of experimental facts. Einstein applied the quantum theory to explain the photoelectric effect and to define threshold frequency. On the basis of plot of frequency of radiation versus voltage applied, a linear graph was obtained, which enabled finding the value of Planck’s constant h. The Compton effect has also been written in a lucid manner involving the mathematical formulation from which the Compton shift can easily be obtained. This chapter also details the atomic hydrogen spectrum including Bohr’s model of an atom, energy of electron revolving around the nucleus, radius of an orbit and expression for velocity of electron. It also mentions the drawbacks of Bohr’s theory. References, problems, and questions on this concept are provided at the end of the chapter.