Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Today

Questionable Questions in Analysis and Synthesis

Joe Lacetera

Published Sep 1, 2004• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Frank Wilczek says that the question of precisely when a radioactive nucleus will decay has been “rendered questionable by quantum mechanics.” Apparently, most physicists take that for granted. However, using quantum mechanics as the reason we physicists can’t solve complex subatomic problems is simply too convenient. We can just as easily think of classical, deterministic problems that exhibit the same statistical characteristics as subatomic problems do. As an example, I offer a gedanken experiment: the radioactive wiffle ball.Take a baseball-sized wiffle ball, place a BB inside, and shake it vigorously. After a time, the excited wiffle ball will emit a BB and thus become stable. Repeat the experiment thousands of times, and you will observe that radioactive wiffle balls have a half-life. Should an outside observer assume that the internal processes of the wiffle ball are random? No, what we have is a deterministic problem with an infinite number of initial conditions. The behavior is describable only statistically, but is not due to random processes. Statistical behavior at any level is not proof of randomness in the physical world.© 2004 American Institute of Physics.

DOI
10.1063/1.4796675

Related papers

A Hypothesis on State-Dependent Nuclear Decay Rates and Emergent Randomness

Moritz Kopp

This project presents a conceptual and mathematical hypothesis concerning the apparent randomness of radioactive decay. While current nuclear physics models describe decay as a fundamentally stochastic and random process with a constant decay rate, this work explores the possibility that the randomness may come from rapidly fluctuating internal nuclear states that are not directly obsercable by measurement. The central idea is that the effective decay constant measured experimentally represents a time-averaged quantity over a distribution of internal configurations, associated with slightly different decay probabilities. In this framework, radioactive decay remains statistically exponential at observable timescales, while allowing for hidden internal dynamics consistent with established quantum mechanical principles. My work does not claim experimental verification. Instead, it aims to outline a phenomenological structure compatible with known decay laws and to identify conditions under which small, systematic deviations might arise under perturbations.

•Mar 5, 2026•0 citations

A thinking on Quantum Physics and common sense

Carlo Artemi

The author attempts to answer the questions there are in the title of this paper. These questions are questions that scientists and philosophers have been asking themselves for many decades since Quantum Mechanics was formulated to explain the phenomena of the atomic and subatomic world. First of all a short but complete historical review of the transition between Classical Mechanics and Quantum Mechanics there is. It is preceded by some of the methodological premises that fit a certain vision of science. Then the author examines the issues and debates that have occurred on aspects of quantum mechanics such as realism, non-locality and probabilism (in contrast to determinism of Classic Mechanics). In doing this author llustrates the foundations of the various interpretations of quantum mechanics which, in an attempt to resolve these problems, have been given. The absurdities, and conflicts with the common sense, of quantum mechanics are shown to be largely apparent. In doing this, we examine the analogies of classical physics, as well as those of everyday life. Recent experimental results are taken into consideration. It is concluded that Quantum Mechanics presents elements of rupture more with Classical Physics than with the everyday experience.

Advanced Research Journal•Feb 22, 2025•0 citations

Personal Conclusions

Jonathan Allday

Most physicists use quantum mechanics every day in their working lives without needing to worry about the fundamental problem of its interpretation. Being sensible people with very little time to follow up all the ideas and data in their own specialties and not having to worry about this fundamental problem. Significantly, complex numbers must be used for amplitudes. In no other physical theory is this a necessity, rather than a calculational convenience. Instead of being a reason to doubt that complex-valued wave functions are representational of some aspect of the world. Classical physics is structured in a very deterministic way. Given a sufficiently detailed knowledge of the positions, momenta, and forces for every particle in the universe, classical physics.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

Analysis and Synthesis IV: Limits and Supplements

Frank A. Wilczek

The earlier columns in this series recounted extraordinary triumphs of physicists using analysis and synthesis or, alternatively, (the dreaded epithet) reductionism to account for the behavior of matter and the structure of the universe as a whole. But I left off by admitting that we scored a bull’s-eye only by painting the target around our shot. There’s quite a lot that physicists might once have hoped to derive or explain based on fundamental principles, for which that hope now seems dubious or forlorn. In this column I explore some sources of these limitations and the role different sorts of explanations might play in filling the voids.Selection by energy Section:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energy <<Stability: Answer or ques...From questionable questio...… To answerable answersCITING ARTICLESOne important limitation, which we started to explore last time (Physics Today, Physics Today 0031-9228 56 10 2003 10 https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1628983. October 2003, page 10 ), concerned the lack of a principle that could lead to a unique choice among different seemingly possible solutions of the fundamental equations and could select out the universe we actually observe.To get oriented, it’s very instructive to consider the corresponding problem for atoms and matter. Like the classical equations governing planetary systems, the equations of quantum mechanics for electrons in a complex atom allow all kinds of solutions. In fact, the quantum equations allow even more freedom of choice in the initial conditions than the classical equations do. The wavefunctions for N particles live in a much larger space than the particles do: They inhabit a full-bodied 3N-dimensional configuration space, as opposed to 2N copies of three-dimensional space. (For example, the quantum description of the state of two particles requires a wavefunction ψ(x 1, x 2) that depends on six variables, whereas the classical description requires 12 numbers, namely their positions and velocities.)Yet the atoms we observe are always described by the same solutions—otherwise we wouldn’t be able to do stellar spectroscopy, or even chemistry. Why? A proper answer involves combining insights from quantum field theory, mathematics, and a smidgen of cosmology. Quantum field theory tells us that electrons—unlike planets—are all rigorously the same. Then the mathematics of the Schrödinger equation, or its refinements, tells us that the low-energy spectrum is discrete, which is to say that if our atom has only a small amount of energy, then only a few solutions are available for its wavefunction. But because energy is conserved, this explanation begs another question: What made the energy small in the first place? Well, the atoms we study are not closed systems; they can emit and absorb radiation. So the question becomes: Why do they emit more often than they absorb, and thereby settle down into a low-energy state? That’s where cosmology comes in. The expanding universe is quite an effective heat sink. In excited atoms, energy radiated as photons eventually leaks into the vast interstellar spaces and redshifts away. By way of contrast, a planetary system has no comparably efficient way to lose energy—gravitational radiation is ridiculously feeble—and it can’t relax.So one selection principle that applies to many important cases is to choose solutions with low energy. In the same spirit, when the residual energy can’t be neglected, one should choose thermal equilibrium solutions. This is appropriate for systems and degrees of freedom that have relaxed, but is not appropriate in general.Stability: Answer or question?Section:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energyStability: Answer or ques... <<From questionable questio...… To answerable answersCITING ARTICLESThe selection procedure that dominates the literature of high-energy physics and string theory is energy based, along the lines we just discussed for atoms. It is traditional to identify the lowest-energy solution with the physical vacuum, and to model the content of the world using low-energy excitations above that state. For the solution to count as successful, the excitations should include at least the particles of the standard model. One can’t seriously quarrel with this selection procedure as a practical necessary criterion. The universe does appear to be a low-energy excitation around a stable state. But why? For atoms, selection of low-energy solutions was justified by their tendency to dissipate energy into radiation that ultimately finds its way into interstellar space and does not return. That mechanism can’t work for the universe as a whole, of course, but a different form of dissipation comes into play, depending on a different aspect of cosmology. The universe has been expanding for a long time—a very long time, many orders of magnitude longer than the natural time scales associated with elementary interactions.For present purposes, the mismatch of time scales has two profound consequences. First, as the universe expands, the matter in it cools. We can think of the cooling as a sort of radiation leak into the future. In any case, it takes the universe toward a local minimum of the energy. Second, the mismatch gives many sorts of instabilities time to play out. (Not all, however. Instabilities involving quantum tunneling can have absurdly long time scales, and as a logical possibility they might figure in our future.) Altogether, then, the vastness of cosmological time serves to justify focus on low-energy excitations around stable “vacuum” configurations that are at least local minima of the energy density.This answer to the question of why the universe can be described as a low-energy excitation, though, frames a new question: What sets the cosmic time scale to be so different from the scale of fundamental interactions? And that question is a thinly veiled form of the question, Why is the cosmological term so small?, for which we have no good answer! In that same dark neck of the woods lurks the specter of the observed dark energy, which might well expose the provisional nature of our selection criteria. Indeed, a leading hypothesis for this energy, known under the rubric of “quintessence,” is that it reflects a difference between empty space as it actually exists and the ideal stable vacuum.In string theory, as currently understood, the selection problem poses severe foundational challenges, because in string theory the criterion of stability is by no means sufficient to select a unique solution. Many stable solutions apparently exist, including flat 10-dimensional spacetime, anti-deSitter space that supports a huge negative cosmological term, and tens of thousands of other possibilities the vast majority of which bear no resemblance whatsoever to the world as we know it. The pragmatic response, which dominates the literature, has been to add phenomenological inputs (effective spacetime dimension, gauge group, number of families, and so on) to the selection criteria. One can then try to derive relations among the remaining parameters. Success along those lines could be very significant, reassuring us that the theory was on the right track. So far, that hasn’t happened. But even if it did, it would hardly fulfill the promise of a final analysis of nature.So, how does the solution that actually describes the world get selected out? It remains a deep question.From questionable questions …Section:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energyStability: Answer or ques...From questionable questio... <<… To answerable answersCITING ARTICLESThe analysis and synthesis program, in the course of its pursuit, exposed other limitations. Consider these three questions, whose elucidations were once considered major goals for science: •Why is the Solar System as it is?•When will a given radioactive nucleus decay?•What will the weather be in Boston a year from today? They are questions that suffered an unusual fate: instead of being answered, they were discredited. In each case, the scientific community at first believed that unique, clear-cut answers would be possible. And in each case, it was a major advance, with wide implications, to discover that there are good fundamental reasons why a clean answer is not possible.I discussed the solar-system question in my October column, with reference to Johannes Kepler’s struggles. That question is questionable because it suffers from a problem I call projection. If there were only one solar system, or if all such systems were the same, tracing that system’s properties to a unique cause would be important. Those might have once seemed reasonable hypotheses, but now we see that they are illegitimate projections that ascribe universal significance to what is actually a very limited slice of the world. There are serious premonitions that we physicists might need to relearn this lesson on a cosmic scale. Popular speculations that we live in a “multiverse” or inhabit “braneworlds” involve the idea that the world is extremely inhomogeneous on large scales—that the values of fundamental parameters, the structure of the standard model, or even the effective dimensionality of spacetime varies from place to place. If so, attempts to predict such things from fundamentals are as misguided as Kepler’s polyhedra. The second question, of course, was rendered questionable by quantum mechanics. The precise time that any particular radioactive nucleus will decay is postulated to be inherently random—a postulate that has acquired, by now, tremendous empirical support. Erwin Schrödinger, with his macroscopic cat, thought he was reducing quantum mechanics to absurdity. But the emerging standard account traces the origin of structure in the universe back to quantum fluctuations in an inflaton field! If that account holds up, it will mean that attempting to predict the specific pattern of structures we observe from fundamentals is as misguided as trying to predict when a nucleus will decay or a Schrödinger cat expire.The third question was rendered questionable by the discovery of chaos: the phenomenon that the solution of perfectly deterministic, innocuous-seeming equations can have solutions whose long-term behavior depends extremely sensitively on exquisite details of the initial conditions. Chaos raises another barrier that can separate ideal analysis from successful synthesis.… To answerable answersSection:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energyStability: Answer or ques...From questionable questio...… To answerable answers <<CITING ARTICLESIt is possible, I suppose, that the apparent limitations will prove illusory and that, in the end, the vision of a unique, deterministic Universe fully accessible to rational analysis, championed by Baruch Spinoza and Albert Einstein, will be restored. But to me it seems wise to accept what appears to be overwhelming evidence that projection, quantum uncertainty, and chaos are inherent in the nature of things, and to build on those insights. With acceptance, new constructive principles appear, supplementing pure logical deduction from finegrained analysis as irreducible explanations of observed phenomena.By accepting the occurrence of projection, we license anthropic explanations. How do we understand why Earth is at the distance it is from the Sun, or why our sun is the kind of star it is? Surely important insights into these questions follow from our existence as intelligent observers. Some day, we may be able to check such arguments by testing their predictions for exobiology.By accepting quantum uncertainty, we license, well … quantum mechanics. Specifically, in the spirit of this column, we can test the hypothesized quantum origin of primordial fluctuations by checking whether those fluctuations satisfy statistical criteria for true randomness. By accepting the implications of chaos, broadly defined, we license evolutionary explanations. Outstanding examples include an explanation of why the Moon always faces us due to the long-term action of tidal friction, and of the structure of gaps in the asteroid belt due to resonance with planetary periods. Also from considerations internal to the program of analysis and synthesis, we motivate the search for emergent properties of complex systems that Philip Anderson has advocated under the rubric “More is different.” For these emergent properties can form the elements of robust descriptions—they transcend the otherwise incapacitating sensitivity to initial conditions.In constructing explanations based on anthropics, randomness, and dynamical evolution, we must use intermediate models incorporating many things that can’t be calculated. Such necessary concessions to reality compromise the formal purity of the ideal of understanding the world by analysis and synthesis, but in compensation, they allow its spirit much wider scope.JUSTIN A. KNIGHTPPT|High resolution© 2004 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jan 1, 2004•1 citation

Quantum Randomness and Underdetermination

Jeffrey Alan Barrett, Simon M. Huttegger

We consider the nature of quantum randomness and how one might have empirical evidence for it. We will see why, depending on one’s computational resources, it may be impossible to determine whether a particular notion of randomness properly characterizes one’s empirical data. Indeed, we will see why even an ideal observer under ideal epistemic conditions may never have any empirical evidence whatsoever for believing that the results of one’s quantum-mechanical experiments are randomly determined. This illustrates a radical sort of empirical underdetermination faced by fundamentally stochastic theories like quantum mechanics.

Philosophy of Science•Feb 20, 2020•23 citations

JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER

Freeman J. Dyson

9 JULY 1911 * 13 APRIL 2008JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER (1911-2008) was a great physicist and also a great teacher. He famously said, We all know that the real reason universities have students is in order to educate the professors. During his tenure (1938-76) in the Princeton University physics department, he broke all the records by supervising forty-six graduate students and forty-six undergraduate seniors. Besides that, he supervised several more at the University of North Carolina (1935-38) and the University of Texas (1976-86). He was a central figure in the international community of physicists for seventy years. He was a fiercely patriotic American who took pride in his contributions to nuclear weaponry, and he was a warm personal friend of physicists all over the world.Complementarity is the philosophical principle that Niels Bohr invented to make sense of quantum mechanics. Complementarity says that nature is too rich to be described by a single picture. To describe a quantum process, we need two complementary pictures that cannot be seen simultaneously. classic example of complementarity is the behavior of light, which can be seen in one experiment as a wave and in another experiment as a collection of particles. wave and the particles cannot be seen together in one experiment, but they are both essential for defining the nature of light. Complementarity is firmly established by a wealth of experiments in the domain of atomic physics. But Bohr extended complementarity to a wider domain where its validity is still controversial. He wrote of complementarity between molecular and organic descriptions in biology, between practical usage and strict definition in linguistics, between justice and mercy in ethics, and between quantum and classical physics in descriptions of the world at large.Complementarity played two separate roles in Wheeler's life. In his technical activity as a theoretical physicist, complementarity was a working tool on which he could rely to get the right answers to practical questions. In his broader activities as a philosophical thinker, complementarity enabled him to combine opposites, to be a conservative revolutionary, a prosaic poet, a calculating dreamer. Wheeler's technical mastery of physics is best seen in the classic paper of Bohr and Wheeler, The Mechanism of Nuclear Fission (1939), published on the day when Hitler's armies marched into Poland and World War II began. Bohr and Wheeler wrote the paper in Princeton, where Bohr was visiting in the spring of 1939, a few months after the discovery of fission. paper is a masterpiece of clear thinking and lucid writing. It reveals, at the center of the mystery of fission, a tiny world where everything can be calculated and everything understood. tiny world is a nucleus of uranium 236, formed when a neutron is freshly captured by a nucleus of uranium 235.The uranium 236 nucleus sits precisely on the border between classical and quantum physics. Seen from the classical point of view, it is a liquid drop composed of a positively charged fluid. electrostatic force that is trying to split it apart is balanced by the nuclear surface tension that is holding it together. energy supplied by the captured neutron causes the drop to oscillate in various normal modes that can be calculated classically. Seen from the quantum point of view, the nucleus is a superposition of a variety of quantum states leading to different final outcomes. final outcome may be a uranium 235 nucleus with a re-emitted neutron, or a uranium 236 nucleus with an emitted gamma-ray, or a pair of fission-fragment nuclei with one or more free neutrons. Bohr and Wheeler calculate the cross-section for fission of uranium 235 by a slow neutron and get the right answer within a factor of two. Their calculation is a marvelous demonstration of the power of classical mechanics and quantum mechanics working together. By studying this process in detail, they show how the complementary views provided by classical and quantum pictures are both essential to the understanding of nature. …

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 2015•0 citations
Frank Wilczek says that the question of precisely when a radioactive nucleus will decay has been “rendered questionable by quantum mechanics.” Apparently, most physicists take that for granted. However, using quantum mechanics as the reason we physicists can’t solve complex subatomic problems is simply too convenient. We can just as easily think of classical, deterministic problems that exhibit the same statistical characteristics as subatomic problems do. As an example, I offer a gedanken experiment: the radioactive wiffle ball.Take a baseball-sized wiffle ball, place a BB inside, and shake it vigorously. After a time, the excited wiffle ball will emit a BB and thus become stable. Repeat the experiment thousands of times, and you will observe that radioactive wiffle balls have a half-life. Should an outside observer assume that the internal processes of the wiffle ball are random? No, what we have is a deterministic problem with an infinite number of initial conditions. The behavior is describable only statistically, but is not due to random processes. Statistical behavior at any level is not proof of randomness in the physical world.© 2004 American Institute of Physics.
This project presents a conceptual and mathematical hypothesis concerning the apparent randomness of radioactive decay. While current nuclear physics models describe decay as a fundamentally stochastic and random process with a constant decay rate, this work explores the possibility that the randomness may come from rapidly fluctuating internal nuclear states that are not directly obsercable by measurement. The central idea is that the effective decay constant measured experimentally represents a time-averaged quantity over a distribution of internal configurations, associated with slightly different decay probabilities. In this framework, radioactive decay remains statistically exponential at observable timescales, while allowing for hidden internal dynamics consistent with established quantum mechanical principles. My work does not claim experimental verification. Instead, it aims to outline a phenomenological structure compatible with known decay laws and to identify conditions under which small, systematic deviations might arise under perturbations.
The author attempts to answer the questions there are in the title of this paper. These questions are questions that scientists and philosophers have been asking themselves for many decades since Quantum Mechanics was formulated to explain the phenomena of the atomic and subatomic world. First of all a short but complete historical review of the transition between Classical Mechanics and Quantum Mechanics there is. It is preceded by some of the methodological premises that fit a certain vision of science. Then the author examines the issues and debates that have occurred on aspects of quantum mechanics such as realism, non-locality and probabilism (in contrast to determinism of Classic Mechanics). In doing this author llustrates the foundations of the various interpretations of quantum mechanics which, in an attempt to resolve these problems, have been given. The absurdities, and conflicts with the common sense, of quantum mechanics are shown to be largely apparent. In doing this, we examine the analogies of classical physics, as well as those of everyday life. Recent experimental results are taken into consideration. It is concluded that Quantum Mechanics presents elements of rupture more with Classical Physics than with the everyday experience.
Most physicists use quantum mechanics every day in their working lives without needing to worry about the fundamental problem of its interpretation. Being sensible people with very little time to follow up all the ideas and data in their own specialties and not having to worry about this fundamental problem. Significantly, complex numbers must be used for amplitudes. In no other physical theory is this a necessity, rather than a calculational convenience. Instead of being a reason to doubt that complex-valued wave functions are representational of some aspect of the world. Classical physics is structured in a very deterministic way. Given a sufficiently detailed knowledge of the positions, momenta, and forces for every particle in the universe, classical physics.
The earlier columns in this series recounted extraordinary triumphs of physicists using analysis and synthesis or, alternatively, (the dreaded epithet) reductionism to account for the behavior of matter and the structure of the universe as a whole. But I left off by admitting that we scored a bull’s-eye only by painting the target around our shot. There’s quite a lot that physicists might once have hoped to derive or explain based on fundamental principles, for which that hope now seems dubious or forlorn. In this column I explore some sources of these limitations and the role different sorts of explanations might play in filling the voids.Selection by energy Section:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energy <<Stability: Answer or ques...From questionable questio...… To answerable answersCITING ARTICLESOne important limitation, which we started to explore last time (Physics Today, Physics Today 0031-9228 56 10 2003 10 https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1628983. October 2003, page 10 ), concerned the lack of a principle that could lead to a unique choice among different seemingly possible solutions of the fundamental equations and could select out the universe we actually observe.To get oriented, it’s very instructive to consider the corresponding problem for atoms and matter. Like the classical equations governing planetary systems, the equations of quantum mechanics for electrons in a complex atom allow all kinds of solutions. In fact, the quantum equations allow even more freedom of choice in the initial conditions than the classical equations do. The wavefunctions for N particles live in a much larger space than the particles do: They inhabit a full-bodied 3N-dimensional configuration space, as opposed to 2N copies of three-dimensional space. (For example, the quantum description of the state of two particles requires a wavefunction ψ(x 1, x 2) that depends on six variables, whereas the classical description requires 12 numbers, namely their positions and velocities.)Yet the atoms we observe are always described by the same solutions—otherwise we wouldn’t be able to do stellar spectroscopy, or even chemistry. Why? A proper answer involves combining insights from quantum field theory, mathematics, and a smidgen of cosmology. Quantum field theory tells us that electrons—unlike planets—are all rigorously the same. Then the mathematics of the Schrödinger equation, or its refinements, tells us that the low-energy spectrum is discrete, which is to say that if our atom has only a small amount of energy, then only a few solutions are available for its wavefunction. But because energy is conserved, this explanation begs another question: What made the energy small in the first place? Well, the atoms we study are not closed systems; they can emit and absorb radiation. So the question becomes: Why do they emit more often than they absorb, and thereby settle down into a low-energy state? That’s where cosmology comes in. The expanding universe is quite an effective heat sink. In excited atoms, energy radiated as photons eventually leaks into the vast interstellar spaces and redshifts away. By way of contrast, a planetary system has no comparably efficient way to lose energy—gravitational radiation is ridiculously feeble—and it can’t relax.So one selection principle that applies to many important cases is to choose solutions with low energy. In the same spirit, when the residual energy can’t be neglected, one should choose thermal equilibrium solutions. This is appropriate for systems and degrees of freedom that have relaxed, but is not appropriate in general.Stability: Answer or question?Section:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energyStability: Answer or ques... <<From questionable questio...… To answerable answersCITING ARTICLESThe selection procedure that dominates the literature of high-energy physics and string theory is energy based, along the lines we just discussed for atoms. It is traditional to identify the lowest-energy solution with the physical vacuum, and to model the content of the world using low-energy excitations above that state. For the solution to count as successful, the excitations should include at least the particles of the standard model. One can’t seriously quarrel with this selection procedure as a practical necessary criterion. The universe does appear to be a low-energy excitation around a stable state. But why? For atoms, selection of low-energy solutions was justified by their tendency to dissipate energy into radiation that ultimately finds its way into interstellar space and does not return. That mechanism can’t work for the universe as a whole, of course, but a different form of dissipation comes into play, depending on a different aspect of cosmology. The universe has been expanding for a long time—a very long time, many orders of magnitude longer than the natural time scales associated with elementary interactions.For present purposes, the mismatch of time scales has two profound consequences. First, as the universe expands, the matter in it cools. We can think of the cooling as a sort of radiation leak into the future. In any case, it takes the universe toward a local minimum of the energy. Second, the mismatch gives many sorts of instabilities time to play out. (Not all, however. Instabilities involving quantum tunneling can have absurdly long time scales, and as a logical possibility they might figure in our future.) Altogether, then, the vastness of cosmological time serves to justify focus on low-energy excitations around stable “vacuum” configurations that are at least local minima of the energy density.This answer to the question of why the universe can be described as a low-energy excitation, though, frames a new question: What sets the cosmic time scale to be so different from the scale of fundamental interactions? And that question is a thinly veiled form of the question, Why is the cosmological term so small?, for which we have no good answer! In that same dark neck of the woods lurks the specter of the observed dark energy, which might well expose the provisional nature of our selection criteria. Indeed, a leading hypothesis for this energy, known under the rubric of “quintessence,” is that it reflects a difference between empty space as it actually exists and the ideal stable vacuum.In string theory, as currently understood, the selection problem poses severe foundational challenges, because in string theory the criterion of stability is by no means sufficient to select a unique solution. Many stable solutions apparently exist, including flat 10-dimensional spacetime, anti-deSitter space that supports a huge negative cosmological term, and tens of thousands of other possibilities the vast majority of which bear no resemblance whatsoever to the world as we know it. The pragmatic response, which dominates the literature, has been to add phenomenological inputs (effective spacetime dimension, gauge group, number of families, and so on) to the selection criteria. One can then try to derive relations among the remaining parameters. Success along those lines could be very significant, reassuring us that the theory was on the right track. So far, that hasn’t happened. But even if it did, it would hardly fulfill the promise of a final analysis of nature.So, how does the solution that actually describes the world get selected out? It remains a deep question.From questionable questions …Section:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energyStability: Answer or ques...From questionable questio... <<… To answerable answersCITING ARTICLESThe analysis and synthesis program, in the course of its pursuit, exposed other limitations. Consider these three questions, whose elucidations were once considered major goals for science: •Why is the Solar System as it is?•When will a given radioactive nucleus decay?•What will the weather be in Boston a year from today? They are questions that suffered an unusual fate: instead of being answered, they were discredited. In each case, the scientific community at first believed that unique, clear-cut answers would be possible. And in each case, it was a major advance, with wide implications, to discover that there are good fundamental reasons why a clean answer is not possible.I discussed the solar-system question in my October column, with reference to Johannes Kepler’s struggles. That question is questionable because it suffers from a problem I call projection. If there were only one solar system, or if all such systems were the same, tracing that system’s properties to a unique cause would be important. Those might have once seemed reasonable hypotheses, but now we see that they are illegitimate projections that ascribe universal significance to what is actually a very limited slice of the world. There are serious premonitions that we physicists might need to relearn this lesson on a cosmic scale. Popular speculations that we live in a “multiverse” or inhabit “braneworlds” involve the idea that the world is extremely inhomogeneous on large scales—that the values of fundamental parameters, the structure of the standard model, or even the effective dimensionality of spacetime varies from place to place. If so, attempts to predict such things from fundamentals are as misguided as Kepler’s polyhedra. The second question, of course, was rendered questionable by quantum mechanics. The precise time that any particular radioactive nucleus will decay is postulated to be inherently random—a postulate that has acquired, by now, tremendous empirical support. Erwin Schrödinger, with his macroscopic cat, thought he was reducing quantum mechanics to absurdity. But the emerging standard account traces the origin of structure in the universe back to quantum fluctuations in an inflaton field! If that account holds up, it will mean that attempting to predict the specific pattern of structures we observe from fundamentals is as misguided as trying to predict when a nucleus will decay or a Schrödinger cat expire.The third question was rendered questionable by the discovery of chaos: the phenomenon that the solution of perfectly deterministic, innocuous-seeming equations can have solutions whose long-term behavior depends extremely sensitively on exquisite details of the initial conditions. Chaos raises another barrier that can separate ideal analysis from successful synthesis.… To answerable answersSection:ChooseTop of pageSelection by energyStability: Answer or ques...From questionable questio...… To answerable answers <<CITING ARTICLESIt is possible, I suppose, that the apparent limitations will prove illusory and that, in the end, the vision of a unique, deterministic Universe fully accessible to rational analysis, championed by Baruch Spinoza and Albert Einstein, will be restored. But to me it seems wise to accept what appears to be overwhelming evidence that projection, quantum uncertainty, and chaos are inherent in the nature of things, and to build on those insights. With acceptance, new constructive principles appear, supplementing pure logical deduction from finegrained analysis as irreducible explanations of observed phenomena.By accepting the occurrence of projection, we license anthropic explanations. How do we understand why Earth is at the distance it is from the Sun, or why our sun is the kind of star it is? Surely important insights into these questions follow from our existence as intelligent observers. Some day, we may be able to check such arguments by testing their predictions for exobiology.By accepting quantum uncertainty, we license, well … quantum mechanics. Specifically, in the spirit of this column, we can test the hypothesized quantum origin of primordial fluctuations by checking whether those fluctuations satisfy statistical criteria for true randomness. By accepting the implications of chaos, broadly defined, we license evolutionary explanations. Outstanding examples include an explanation of why the Moon always faces us due to the long-term action of tidal friction, and of the structure of gaps in the asteroid belt due to resonance with planetary periods. Also from considerations internal to the program of analysis and synthesis, we motivate the search for emergent properties of complex systems that Philip Anderson has advocated under the rubric “More is different.” For these emergent properties can form the elements of robust descriptions—they transcend the otherwise incapacitating sensitivity to initial conditions.In constructing explanations based on anthropics, randomness, and dynamical evolution, we must use intermediate models incorporating many things that can’t be calculated. Such necessary concessions to reality compromise the formal purity of the ideal of understanding the world by analysis and synthesis, but in compensation, they allow its spirit much wider scope.JUSTIN A. KNIGHTPPT|High resolution© 2004 American Institute of Physics.
We consider the nature of quantum randomness and how one might have empirical evidence for it. We will see why, depending on one’s computational resources, it may be impossible to determine whether a particular notion of randomness properly characterizes one’s empirical data. Indeed, we will see why even an ideal observer under ideal epistemic conditions may never have any empirical evidence whatsoever for believing that the results of one’s quantum-mechanical experiments are randomly determined. This illustrates a radical sort of empirical underdetermination faced by fundamentally stochastic theories like quantum mechanics.
9 JULY 1911 * 13 APRIL 2008JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER (1911-2008) was a great physicist and also a great teacher. He famously said, We all know that the real reason universities have students is in order to educate the professors. During his tenure (1938-76) in the Princeton University physics department, he broke all the records by supervising forty-six graduate students and forty-six undergraduate seniors. Besides that, he supervised several more at the University of North Carolina (1935-38) and the University of Texas (1976-86). He was a central figure in the international community of physicists for seventy years. He was a fiercely patriotic American who took pride in his contributions to nuclear weaponry, and he was a warm personal friend of physicists all over the world.Complementarity is the philosophical principle that Niels Bohr invented to make sense of quantum mechanics. Complementarity says that nature is too rich to be described by a single picture. To describe a quantum process, we need two complementary pictures that cannot be seen simultaneously. classic example of complementarity is the behavior of light, which can be seen in one experiment as a wave and in another experiment as a collection of particles. wave and the particles cannot be seen together in one experiment, but they are both essential for defining the nature of light. Complementarity is firmly established by a wealth of experiments in the domain of atomic physics. But Bohr extended complementarity to a wider domain where its validity is still controversial. He wrote of complementarity between molecular and organic descriptions in biology, between practical usage and strict definition in linguistics, between justice and mercy in ethics, and between quantum and classical physics in descriptions of the world at large.Complementarity played two separate roles in Wheeler's life. In his technical activity as a theoretical physicist, complementarity was a working tool on which he could rely to get the right answers to practical questions. In his broader activities as a philosophical thinker, complementarity enabled him to combine opposites, to be a conservative revolutionary, a prosaic poet, a calculating dreamer. Wheeler's technical mastery of physics is best seen in the classic paper of Bohr and Wheeler, The Mechanism of Nuclear Fission (1939), published on the day when Hitler's armies marched into Poland and World War II began. Bohr and Wheeler wrote the paper in Princeton, where Bohr was visiting in the spring of 1939, a few months after the discovery of fission. paper is a masterpiece of clear thinking and lucid writing. It reveals, at the center of the mystery of fission, a tiny world where everything can be calculated and everything understood. tiny world is a nucleus of uranium 236, formed when a neutron is freshly captured by a nucleus of uranium 235.The uranium 236 nucleus sits precisely on the border between classical and quantum physics. Seen from the classical point of view, it is a liquid drop composed of a positively charged fluid. electrostatic force that is trying to split it apart is balanced by the nuclear surface tension that is holding it together. energy supplied by the captured neutron causes the drop to oscillate in various normal modes that can be calculated classically. Seen from the quantum point of view, the nucleus is a superposition of a variety of quantum states leading to different final outcomes. final outcome may be a uranium 235 nucleus with a re-emitted neutron, or a uranium 236 nucleus with an emitted gamma-ray, or a pair of fission-fragment nuclei with one or more free neutrons. Bohr and Wheeler calculate the cross-section for fission of uranium 235 by a slow neutron and get the right answer within a factor of two. Their calculation is a marvelous demonstration of the power of classical mechanics and quantum mechanics working together. By studying this process in detail, they show how the complementary views provided by classical and quantum pictures are both essential to the understanding of nature. …