Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology

OBSERVATION OF HANBURY BROWN-TWISS CORRELATIONS FOR FREE ELECTRONS

Harald Kiesel, FRANZ HASSELBACH

Published Oct 1, 2002• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The astronomers Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) were the first to observe in 1956 that the fluctuations in the counting rate of photons originating from uncorrelated point sources become, within the coherently illuminated area, slightly enhanced compared to a random sequence of classical particles 1,2,3 . This at a first glance mysterious formation of correlations in the process of propagation turns out to be a consequence of quantum interference between two indistinguishable photons and Bose-Einstein statistics 4 . The latter requires that the composite wave function is a symmetrized superposition of the two possible paths. For fermions, by virtue of the Pauli principle, no two particles are allowed to be in the same state. The corresponding antisymmetrized two particle wave function excludes overlapping wave trains, i.e., simultaneous arrivals of two fermions at contiguous, coherently illuminated detectors are forbidden. These anticorrelations have been observed for the first time for a beam of free electrons in spite of the low mean number (degeneracy) of ~10 -4 electrons per cell in phase space. With respect to the low degeneracy, our experiment is the fermionic twin of HBT's experiment with photons.

DOI
10.1142/9789812776716_0054

Related papers

Hanbury Brown–Twiss Effect with Wave Packets

Tabish Qureshi, Ushba Rizwan

The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) effect, at the quantum level, is essentially an interference of one particle with another, as opposed to interference of a particle with itself. Conventional treatments of identical particles encounter difficulties while dealing with entanglement. A recently introduced label-free approach to indistinguishable particles is described, and is used to analyze the HBT effect. Quantum wave-packets have been used to provide a better understanding of the quantum interpretation of the HBT effect. The effect is demonstrated for two independent particles governed by Bose–Einstein or Fermi–Dirac statistics. The HBT effect is also analyzed for pairs of entangled particles. Surprisingly, entanglement has almost no effect on the interference seen in the HBT effect. In the light of the results, an old quantum optics experiment is reanalyzed, and it is argued that the interference seen in that experiment is not a consequence of non-local correlations between the photons, as is commonly believed. Quanta 2017; 6: 61–69.

arXiv:1509.02221•Quanta•Nov 29, 2017•8 citations

The colored Hanbury Brown–Twiss effect

B. Silva, Carlos Sánchez Muñoz, D. Ballarini +8 more

The Hanbury Brown-Twiss effect is one of the celebrated phenomenologies of modern physics that accommodates equally well classical (interferences of waves) and quantum (correlations between indistinguishable particles) interpretations. The effect was discovered in the late thirties with a basic observation of Hanbury Brown that radio-pulses from two distinct antennas generate signals on the oscilloscope that wiggle similarly to the naked eye. When Hanbury Brown and his mathematician colleague Twiss took the obvious step to propose bringing the effect in the optical range, they met with considerable opposition as single-photon interferences were deemed impossible. The Hanbury Brown-Twiss effect is nowadays universally accepted and, being so fundamental, embodies many subtleties of our understanding of the wave/particle dual nature of light. Thanks to a novel experimental technique, we report here a generalized version of the Hanbury Brown-Twiss effect to include the frequency of the detected light, or, from the particle point of view, the energy of the detected photons. Our source of light is a polariton condensate, that allows high-resolution filtering of a spectrally broad source with a high degree of coherence. In addition to the known tendencies of indistinguishable photons to arrive together on the detector, we find that photons of different colors present the opposite characteristic of avoiding each others. We postulate that fermions can be similarly brought to exhibit positive (boson-like) correlations by frequency filtering.

arXiv:1406.0964•Scientific Reports•Dec 6, 2016•57 citations

Fermions go it alone

Thierry Martin

In quantum mechanics it is possible to pack an arbitrary number of bosons into the same quantum state. The maximum occupancy for fermions, however is one. Back in 1956 two British scientists, Hanbury Brown and Twiss, conducted a classic experiment that showed that photons, a type of boson, have a tendency to bunch into clusters. Their experiment comprised two light sources and two detectors set up to measure the light that was transmitted and reflected by a beam splitter at the centre of the experimental configuration (see figure a). The bunching was observed by measuring the intensity correlation between the two coherent beams of light as a function of time. Hanbury Brown and Twiss measured the likelihood of observing a fluctuation in one detector at a particular time when a signal was detected at an earlier time in the other detector. The positive correlation they found was consistent with the bunching property of bosons.

Physics World•Jul 1, 1999•0 citations

Interference between two independent electrons: observation of two-particle Aharonov-Bohm interference

Izhar Neder, Nissim Ofek, Yunchul Chung +3 more

Very much like the ubiquitous quantum interference of a single particle with itself, quantum interference of two independent, but indistinguishable, particles is also possible. This interference is a direct result of quantum exchange statistics, however, it is observed only in the joint probability to find the particles in two separated detectors. Here we report the first observation of such interference fringes between two independent and non-interacting electrons in an interferometer proposed by Yurke et al. and Samuelsson et al. Our experiment resembles the "Hanbury Brown and Twiss" (HBT) experiment, which was performed with classical waves. In the experiment, two independent and mutually incoherent electron beams were each partitioned into two trajectories. The combined four trajectories enclosed an Aharonov-Bohm (AB) flux (but not the two trajectories of a single electron). While individual currents were found to be independent of the AB flux, as expected, the cross-correlation between current fluctuations in two opposite points across the device exhibited strong AB oscillations. This is a direct signature of orbital entanglement between two electrons even though they never interact with each other.

arXiv:0705.0173•May 1, 2007•5 citations

Generalized Hanbury Brown–Twiss interferometer

Yiqi Song, Meixue Chen, Yuhan Ma +7 more

The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) interferometer, which is used to measure the correlation of two photons or two light beams, has played a crucial role in quantum optics and quantum information. We propose a generalized HBT interferometer, which is able to measure the correlation of photons or light beams up to eight in a single experimental run. With an improved time correlated single-photon counting (TCSPC) algorithm, two-, three-, and four-photon coincidence counts, and the degree of fifth-order coherence of pseudothermal light are measured with a data collection time of 60 s. The generalized HBT interferometer can be used to measure the correlation of two multi-photon detection events by simulating photon number resolving detectors with multiple single-photon detectors. The generalized HBT interferometer and improved TCSPC algorithm provide a versatile framework for studying multi-photon correlations and interference, which is helpful to understand the physics of multi-photon interference and may find applications in fluorescence lifetime imaging and other techniques using TCSPC.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Mar 3, 2026•0 citations

Quantum optics of particles: distinctive features of a Hanbury Brown-Twiss experiment with electrons

Mark P. Silverman

Interference experiments characterized by the degree of first-order coherence (Young’s fringes, Fresnel, and Fraunhofer diffraction, etc.) have been performed with massive particles, in particular electrons and neutrons, as well as with light. Optical intensity interference or correlation experiments characterized by the degree of second-order coherence have not yet been performed with particles. The theory for such experiments shows striking differences in the behavior of electrons compared with that of light deriving from the differences in quantum statistics and charge. Photons are neutral bosons. They can be prepared in states that exhibit bunching, no bunching, or antibunching; they are unaffected by the presence of electromagnetic potentials. Electrons are charged fermions. Theory indicates that they exhibit antibunching regardless of the coherence of the source, and that their degree of second-order coherence can be influenced by electromagnetic fields through which they do not pass. A remarkable example is the Hanbury Brown-Twiss experiment with electrons that have interacted locally with the vector potential of an inaccessible magnetic field. The electron intensity correlation at two detectors is shown to be sensitive to the confined magnetic flux; experimental conditions differ considerably from those of the well-known Aharonov-Bohm effect.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations
The astronomers Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) were the first to observe in 1956 that the fluctuations in the counting rate of photons originating from uncorrelated point sources become, within the coherently illuminated area, slightly enhanced compared to a random sequence of classical particles 1,2,3 . This at a first glance mysterious formation of correlations in the process of propagation turns out to be a consequence of quantum interference between two indistinguishable photons and Bose-Einstein statistics 4 . The latter requires that the composite wave function is a symmetrized superposition of the two possible paths. For fermions, by virtue of the Pauli principle, no two particles are allowed to be in the same state. The corresponding antisymmetrized two particle wave function excludes overlapping wave trains, i.e., simultaneous arrivals of two fermions at contiguous, coherently illuminated detectors are forbidden. These anticorrelations have been observed for the first time for a beam of free electrons in spite of the low mean number (degeneracy) of ~10 -4 electrons per cell in phase space. With respect to the low degeneracy, our experiment is the fermionic twin of HBT's experiment with photons.
The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) effect, at the quantum level, is essentially an interference of one particle with another, as opposed to interference of a particle with itself. Conventional treatments of identical particles encounter difficulties while dealing with entanglement. A recently introduced label-free approach to indistinguishable particles is described, and is used to analyze the HBT effect. Quantum wave-packets have been used to provide a better understanding of the quantum interpretation of the HBT effect. The effect is demonstrated for two independent particles governed by Bose–Einstein or Fermi–Dirac statistics. The HBT effect is also analyzed for pairs of entangled particles. Surprisingly, entanglement has almost no effect on the interference seen in the HBT effect. In the light of the results, an old quantum optics experiment is reanalyzed, and it is argued that the interference seen in that experiment is not a consequence of non-local correlations between the photons, as is commonly believed. Quanta 2017; 6: 61–69.
The Hanbury Brown-Twiss effect is one of the celebrated phenomenologies of modern physics that accommodates equally well classical (interferences of waves) and quantum (correlations between indistinguishable particles) interpretations. The effect was discovered in the late thirties with a basic observation of Hanbury Brown that radio-pulses from two distinct antennas generate signals on the oscilloscope that wiggle similarly to the naked eye. When Hanbury Brown and his mathematician colleague Twiss took the obvious step to propose bringing the effect in the optical range, they met with considerable opposition as single-photon interferences were deemed impossible. The Hanbury Brown-Twiss effect is nowadays universally accepted and, being so fundamental, embodies many subtleties of our understanding of the wave/particle dual nature of light. Thanks to a novel experimental technique, we report here a generalized version of the Hanbury Brown-Twiss effect to include the frequency of the detected light, or, from the particle point of view, the energy of the detected photons. Our source of light is a polariton condensate, that allows high-resolution filtering of a spectrally broad source with a high degree of coherence. In addition to the known tendencies of indistinguishable photons to arrive together on the detector, we find that photons of different colors present the opposite characteristic of avoiding each others. We postulate that fermions can be similarly brought to exhibit positive (boson-like) correlations by frequency filtering.
In quantum mechanics it is possible to pack an arbitrary number of bosons into the same quantum state. The maximum occupancy for fermions, however is one. Back in 1956 two British scientists, Hanbury Brown and Twiss, conducted a classic experiment that showed that photons, a type of boson, have a tendency to bunch into clusters. Their experiment comprised two light sources and two detectors set up to measure the light that was transmitted and reflected by a beam splitter at the centre of the experimental configuration (see figure a). The bunching was observed by measuring the intensity correlation between the two coherent beams of light as a function of time. Hanbury Brown and Twiss measured the likelihood of observing a fluctuation in one detector at a particular time when a signal was detected at an earlier time in the other detector. The positive correlation they found was consistent with the bunching property of bosons.
Very much like the ubiquitous quantum interference of a single particle with itself, quantum interference of two independent, but indistinguishable, particles is also possible. This interference is a direct result of quantum exchange statistics, however, it is observed only in the joint probability to find the particles in two separated detectors. Here we report the first observation of such interference fringes between two independent and non-interacting electrons in an interferometer proposed by Yurke et al. and Samuelsson et al. Our experiment resembles the "Hanbury Brown and Twiss" (HBT) experiment, which was performed with classical waves. In the experiment, two independent and mutually incoherent electron beams were each partitioned into two trajectories. The combined four trajectories enclosed an Aharonov-Bohm (AB) flux (but not the two trajectories of a single electron). While individual currents were found to be independent of the AB flux, as expected, the cross-correlation between current fluctuations in two opposite points across the device exhibited strong AB oscillations. This is a direct signature of orbital entanglement between two electrons even though they never interact with each other.
The Hanbury Brown–Twiss (HBT) interferometer, which is used to measure the correlation of two photons or two light beams, has played a crucial role in quantum optics and quantum information. We propose a generalized HBT interferometer, which is able to measure the correlation of photons or light beams up to eight in a single experimental run. With an improved time correlated single-photon counting (TCSPC) algorithm, two-, three-, and four-photon coincidence counts, and the degree of fifth-order coherence of pseudothermal light are measured with a data collection time of 60 s. The generalized HBT interferometer can be used to measure the correlation of two multi-photon detection events by simulating photon number resolving detectors with multiple single-photon detectors. The generalized HBT interferometer and improved TCSPC algorithm provide a versatile framework for studying multi-photon correlations and interference, which is helpful to understand the physics of multi-photon interference and may find applications in fluorescence lifetime imaging and other techniques using TCSPC.
Interference experiments characterized by the degree of first-order coherence (Young’s fringes, Fresnel, and Fraunhofer diffraction, etc.) have been performed with massive particles, in particular electrons and neutrons, as well as with light. Optical intensity interference or correlation experiments characterized by the degree of second-order coherence have not yet been performed with particles. The theory for such experiments shows striking differences in the behavior of electrons compared with that of light deriving from the differences in quantum statistics and charge. Photons are neutral bosons. They can be prepared in states that exhibit bunching, no bunching, or antibunching; they are unaffected by the presence of electromagnetic potentials. Electrons are charged fermions. Theory indicates that they exhibit antibunching regardless of the coherence of the source, and that their degree of second-order coherence can be influenced by electromagnetic fields through which they do not pass. A remarkable example is the Hanbury Brown-Twiss experiment with electrons that have interacted locally with the vector potential of an inaccessible magnetic field. The electron intensity correlation at two detectors is shown to be sensitive to the confined magnetic flux; experimental conditions differ considerably from those of the well-known Aharonov-Bohm effect.