Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

BENTHAM SCIENCE PUBLISHERS eBooks

Newton-Eulerian Axiomatic: The Notion of State

P. Enders

Published Feb 12, 2019• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter deals with the all-important notion of state as it is central to all parts of physics. For this book, most important are, on the one hand, the notions of state by Newton and Euler – on the other hand, the notion of state by Lagrange and Laplace used nowadays. Surprisingly enough, Newton and Euler’s notions of state are closer to quantum mechanics than the nowadays’ one. Newton’s axiomatic contains solely the conservation of states (1st and 3rd axioms) and the change of states (2nd axiom). In contrast, the equation of motion is not part of the axiomatic. Euler’s axiomatic contains solely the conservation of states. The change of state (and subsequently the equation of motion) is to be examined according to the problem under consideration. In contrast to Newton’s axiomatic and correcting Bohr’s corresponding claim, Euler’s principles of state change for classical bodies are formulated such, that they can be translated even to quantum-mechanical motion. Their power is also demonstrated through an alternative derivation of Hamilton’s equation of motion.

DOI
10.2174/9781681084497119010004

Related papers

Conservation and Change of Stationary States

Peter Enders

The time-independent Schrödinger equation represents a stationary-state equation. The stationary wave functions obtained so far are time independent. Their time-dependence is obtained by means of rather general arguments. Then, stationarystate functions are found. The next step in Newton’s and Euler’s representations of classical mechanics is (to derive) the equation of change of stationary-states. Here, Euler’s principles of stationary-state change are generalized to quantum-mechanical systems. This enables us to derive the quantum-mechanical equation of change of stationary-states. The time-independent Schrödinger equation, i.e, the equation of motion will follow in the next chapter.

BENTHAM SCIENCE PUBLISHERS eBooks•Feb 12, 2019•0 citations

Classical Mechanics and Quantum Mechanics: An Historic-Axiomatic Approach

P. Enders

This unique textbook presents a novel, axiomatic pedagogical path from classical to quantum physics. Readers are introduced to the description of classical mechanics, which rests on Euler's and Helmholtz's rather than Newton's or Hamilton's representations. Special attention is given to the common attributes rather than to the differences between classical and quantum mechanics. Readers will also learn about Schrödinger's forgotten demands on quantization, his equation, Einstein's idea of 'quantization as selection problem'. The Schrödinger equation is derived without any assumptions about the nature of quantum systems, such as interference and superposition, or the existence of a quantum of action, h. The use of the classical expressions for the potential and kinetic energies within quantum physics is justified. Key features:Presents extensive reference to original texts. Includes many details that do not enter contemporary representations of classical mechanics, although these details are essential for understanding quantum physics.Contains a simple level of mathematics which is seldom higher than that of the common (Riemannian) integral. Brings information about important scientistsCarefully introduces basic equations, notations and quantities in simple steps This book addresses the needs of physics students, teachers and historians with its simple easy to understand presentation and comprehensive approach to both classical and quantum mechanics.

BENTHAM SCIENCE PUBLISHERS eBooks•Feb 12, 2019•0 citations

Description of a Physical System

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

The measure of greatness in a scientific idea is the extent to which it stimulates thought and opens up new lines of research. —P. A. M. Dirac From our day-to-day experience, we develop our notion of reality. However, our perception of physical properties, such as position and momentum, needs refinement to describe natural phenomena correctly. In this chapter we introduce fundamental principles of the quantum theory that does so with enduring cogency. The laws of nature that govern the functioning of the physical universe cannot be accounted for using classical physics of Newton, Lagrange, and Hamilton. Foundational principles and mathematical structure of quantum theory are introduced in this chapter. 1.1 Quantum versus Classical Physics Theories In classical physics, the mechanical state of a system is represented by a point in the position– velocity phase space, or equivalently in the position–momentum phase space. The entire theoretical formalism of Newtonian–Lagrangian–Hamiltonian mechanics is based on this Galilean conjecture. The classical hypothesis seems appropriate in a large number of physical situations that concern our day-to-day experiences. With this ansatz, the temporal evolution of a system is described by the trajectory of the point in the phase space. The trajectory is obtained from the equation of motion that governs the time dependence of position and velocity, represented respectively by q and (or alternatively the time dependence of position and momentum, represented respectively by q and p ). The alternative equations of motion – Newton’s, Lagrange’s, and Hamilton's – are equivalent. Their applicability must be reconciled with the upper limit on accuracy with which conjugate physical properties of an object, viz. position and momentum , are simultaneously measured. There is, however, an inverse relation between the accuracy of simultaneous measurement of these two properties. The more accurately you measure either, the less accurately can you measure the other. The act of measuring either of the conjugate properties requires an observation. Observations resulting in accurate measurements of conjugate variables are, however, not compatible with each other. Heisenberg's principle of uncertainty is the quantitative expression of this law of nature. It is expressed as a rigorous mathematical inequality that is neatly written in a compact form. Nonetheless, we refrain from advancing its mathematical expression too soon. It has no classical analogue. It cannot be written in any terms of what we are familiar with from classical mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•1 citation

Fields and Equations of Classical Mechanics for Quantum Mechanics

James P. Finley

A generalized Euler equation of fluid dynamics is derived for describing many-body states of quantum mechanics. The Eulerian Eq. can be viewed as representing the interaction of two substates, where each substate has its own velocity and pressure fields. These field quantities are given by maps of the wavefunction. For one-body systems, the Eulerian Eq. can model either a fluid or particle description of quantum states. The generalized Euler Eq. is shown to be the gradient of an equation representing the total-energy of the two substates, having two energy fields. This total-energy Eq. is a generalization of the Bernoulli Eq. of fluid dynamics. The total-energy Eq., along with a continuity-equation, is equivalent to the time-dependent Schroedinger Eq. An equation is also derived that is equivalent to the main equation of Bohmian mechanics with additional identifications: The quantum potential of Bohmian mechanics is given as a sum of a kinetic energy and pressure fields. Also, the time derivative of the wavefunction phase is replaced by an energy field. In the formalism, field quantities are identified from their placement in equations of classical mechanics and separately, by definitions that involve the wavefunction and operators of quantum mechanics. This approach yields, unintended, and unknown energy and pressure fields. These fields, however, are shown to satisfy a continuity Eq., an equation that is equivalent to the other equation of Bohmian mechanics. It is also demonstrated that energy conservation holds for both of these energy fields, if the wavefunction is a linear-combination of eigenvectors, where the eigenvectors can be nondegenerate. A detailed investigation is given on the possible behavior, or source, of an electron that has one of the velocity fields. Alternate formulae for this velocity fields are also considered.

arXiv:2207.04349•Jul 9, 2022•2 citations

A formulation of quantum fluid mechanics and trajectories

James P. Finley

Abstract A formalism of classical mechanics is given for time-dependent many-body states of quantum mechanics, describing both fluid flow and point mass trajectories. The familiar equations of energy, motion, and those of Lagrangian mechanics are obtained. An energy and continuity equation is demonstrated to be equivalent to the real and imaginary parts of the time dependent Schrödinger equation, respectively, where the Schrödinger equation is in density matrix form. For certain stationary states, using Lagrangian mechanics and a Hamiltonian function for quantum mechanics, equations for point-mass trajectories are obtained. For 1-body states and fluid flows, the energy equation and equations of motion are the Bernoulli and Euler equations of fluid mechanics, respectively. Generalizations of the energy and Euler equations are derived to obtain equations that are in the same form as they are in classical mechanics. The fluid flow type is compressible, inviscid, irrotational, with the nonclassical element of local variable mass. Over all space mass is conserved. The variable mass is a necessary condition for the fluid flow to agree with the zero orbital angular momentum for s states of hydrogen. Cross flows are examined, where velocity directions are changed without changing the kinetic energy. For one-electron atoms, the velocity modification gives closed orbits for trajectories, and mass conservation, vortexes, and density stratification for fluid flows. For many body states, under certain conditions, and by hypotheses, Euler equations of orbital-flows are obtained. One-body Schrödinger equations that are a generalization of the Hartree–Fock equations are also obtained. These equations contain a quantum Coulomb’s law, involving the 2-body pair function of reduced density matrix theory that replace the charge densities.

arXiv:2405.01486•Physica Scripta•Jul 17, 2024•0 citations

From classical mechanics to quantum mechanics

Gennaro Auletta, Mauro Fortunato, Giorgio Parisi A

In this chapter we shall first summarize some conceptual and formal features of classical mechanics (Sec. 1.1). Modern physics started with the works of Galileo Galilei and Isaac Newton from which classical mechanics, one of the most beautiful and solid intellectual buildings of the human history, came out. The architecture of classical mechanics was developed between the end of the eighteenth century and the second half of the nineteenth century, and its present form is largely due to Lagrange, Jacobi, and Hamilton. As we shall see in this chapter, classical mechanics is built upon the requirement of determinism, a rather complex assumption which is far from being obvious. In Sec. 1.2 we shall present the two main conceptual features of quantum mechanics on the basis of an ideal interferometry experiment: the superposition principle and the principle of complementarity. In Sec. 1.3 a first formal treatment of quantum-mechanical states is developed: quantum states are represented by vectors in a space that turns out to be a Hilbert space. In Sec. 1.4 the significance of probability for quantum mechanics is explained briefly: we will show that probability is not just an ingredient of quantum mechanics, but is rather an intrinsic feature of the theory. Furthermore, we shall see that quantum probability is not ruled by Kolmogorov axioms of classical probability. Finally, we discuss the main evidences which have historically revealed the necessity of a departure from classical mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 16, 2009•30 citations
This chapter deals with the all-important notion of state as it is central to all parts of physics. For this book, most important are, on the one hand, the notions of state by Newton and Euler – on the other hand, the notion of state by Lagrange and Laplace used nowadays. Surprisingly enough, Newton and Euler’s notions of state are closer to quantum mechanics than the nowadays’ one. Newton’s axiomatic contains solely the conservation of states (1st and 3rd axioms) and the change of states (2nd axiom). In contrast, the equation of motion is not part of the axiomatic. Euler’s axiomatic contains solely the conservation of states. The change of state (and subsequently the equation of motion) is to be examined according to the problem under consideration. In contrast to Newton’s axiomatic and correcting Bohr’s corresponding claim, Euler’s principles of state change for classical bodies are formulated such, that they can be translated even to quantum-mechanical motion. Their power is also demonstrated through an alternative derivation of Hamilton’s equation of motion.
The time-independent Schrödinger equation represents a stationary-state equation. The stationary wave functions obtained so far are time independent. Their time-dependence is obtained by means of rather general arguments. Then, stationarystate functions are found. The next step in Newton’s and Euler’s representations of classical mechanics is (to derive) the equation of change of stationary-states. Here, Euler’s principles of stationary-state change are generalized to quantum-mechanical systems. This enables us to derive the quantum-mechanical equation of change of stationary-states. The time-independent Schrödinger equation, i.e, the equation of motion will follow in the next chapter.
This unique textbook presents a novel, axiomatic pedagogical path from classical to quantum physics. Readers are introduced to the description of classical mechanics, which rests on Euler's and Helmholtz's rather than Newton's or Hamilton's representations. Special attention is given to the common attributes rather than to the differences between classical and quantum mechanics. Readers will also learn about Schrödinger's forgotten demands on quantization, his equation, Einstein's idea of 'quantization as selection problem'. The Schrödinger equation is derived without any assumptions about the nature of quantum systems, such as interference and superposition, or the existence of a quantum of action, h. The use of the classical expressions for the potential and kinetic energies within quantum physics is justified. Key features:Presents extensive reference to original texts. Includes many details that do not enter contemporary representations of classical mechanics, although these details are essential for understanding quantum physics.Contains a simple level of mathematics which is seldom higher than that of the common (Riemannian) integral. Brings information about important scientistsCarefully introduces basic equations, notations and quantities in simple steps This book addresses the needs of physics students, teachers and historians with its simple easy to understand presentation and comprehensive approach to both classical and quantum mechanics.
The measure of greatness in a scientific idea is the extent to which it stimulates thought and opens up new lines of research. —P. A. M. Dirac From our day-to-day experience, we develop our notion of reality. However, our perception of physical properties, such as position and momentum, needs refinement to describe natural phenomena correctly. In this chapter we introduce fundamental principles of the quantum theory that does so with enduring cogency. The laws of nature that govern the functioning of the physical universe cannot be accounted for using classical physics of Newton, Lagrange, and Hamilton. Foundational principles and mathematical structure of quantum theory are introduced in this chapter. 1.1 Quantum versus Classical Physics Theories In classical physics, the mechanical state of a system is represented by a point in the position– velocity phase space, or equivalently in the position–momentum phase space. The entire theoretical formalism of Newtonian–Lagrangian–Hamiltonian mechanics is based on this Galilean conjecture. The classical hypothesis seems appropriate in a large number of physical situations that concern our day-to-day experiences. With this ansatz, the temporal evolution of a system is described by the trajectory of the point in the phase space. The trajectory is obtained from the equation of motion that governs the time dependence of position and velocity, represented respectively by q and (or alternatively the time dependence of position and momentum, represented respectively by q and p ). The alternative equations of motion – Newton’s, Lagrange’s, and Hamilton's – are equivalent. Their applicability must be reconciled with the upper limit on accuracy with which conjugate physical properties of an object, viz. position and momentum , are simultaneously measured. There is, however, an inverse relation between the accuracy of simultaneous measurement of these two properties. The more accurately you measure either, the less accurately can you measure the other. The act of measuring either of the conjugate properties requires an observation. Observations resulting in accurate measurements of conjugate variables are, however, not compatible with each other. Heisenberg's principle of uncertainty is the quantitative expression of this law of nature. It is expressed as a rigorous mathematical inequality that is neatly written in a compact form. Nonetheless, we refrain from advancing its mathematical expression too soon. It has no classical analogue. It cannot be written in any terms of what we are familiar with from classical mechanics.
A generalized Euler equation of fluid dynamics is derived for describing many-body states of quantum mechanics. The Eulerian Eq. can be viewed as representing the interaction of two substates, where each substate has its own velocity and pressure fields. These field quantities are given by maps of the wavefunction. For one-body systems, the Eulerian Eq. can model either a fluid or particle description of quantum states. The generalized Euler Eq. is shown to be the gradient of an equation representing the total-energy of the two substates, having two energy fields. This total-energy Eq. is a generalization of the Bernoulli Eq. of fluid dynamics. The total-energy Eq., along with a continuity-equation, is equivalent to the time-dependent Schroedinger Eq. An equation is also derived that is equivalent to the main equation of Bohmian mechanics with additional identifications: The quantum potential of Bohmian mechanics is given as a sum of a kinetic energy and pressure fields. Also, the time derivative of the wavefunction phase is replaced by an energy field. In the formalism, field quantities are identified from their placement in equations of classical mechanics and separately, by definitions that involve the wavefunction and operators of quantum mechanics. This approach yields, unintended, and unknown energy and pressure fields. These fields, however, are shown to satisfy a continuity Eq., an equation that is equivalent to the other equation of Bohmian mechanics. It is also demonstrated that energy conservation holds for both of these energy fields, if the wavefunction is a linear-combination of eigenvectors, where the eigenvectors can be nondegenerate. A detailed investigation is given on the possible behavior, or source, of an electron that has one of the velocity fields. Alternate formulae for this velocity fields are also considered.
Abstract A formalism of classical mechanics is given for time-dependent many-body states of quantum mechanics, describing both fluid flow and point mass trajectories. The familiar equations of energy, motion, and those of Lagrangian mechanics are obtained. An energy and continuity equation is demonstrated to be equivalent to the real and imaginary parts of the time dependent Schrödinger equation, respectively, where the Schrödinger equation is in density matrix form. For certain stationary states, using Lagrangian mechanics and a Hamiltonian function for quantum mechanics, equations for point-mass trajectories are obtained. For 1-body states and fluid flows, the energy equation and equations of motion are the Bernoulli and Euler equations of fluid mechanics, respectively. Generalizations of the energy and Euler equations are derived to obtain equations that are in the same form as they are in classical mechanics. The fluid flow type is compressible, inviscid, irrotational, with the nonclassical element of local variable mass. Over all space mass is conserved. The variable mass is a necessary condition for the fluid flow to agree with the zero orbital angular momentum for s states of hydrogen. Cross flows are examined, where velocity directions are changed without changing the kinetic energy. For one-electron atoms, the velocity modification gives closed orbits for trajectories, and mass conservation, vortexes, and density stratification for fluid flows. For many body states, under certain conditions, and by hypotheses, Euler equations of orbital-flows are obtained. One-body Schrödinger equations that are a generalization of the Hartree–Fock equations are also obtained. These equations contain a quantum Coulomb’s law, involving the 2-body pair function of reduced density matrix theory that replace the charge densities.
In this chapter we shall first summarize some conceptual and formal features of classical mechanics (Sec. 1.1). Modern physics started with the works of Galileo Galilei and Isaac Newton from which classical mechanics, one of the most beautiful and solid intellectual buildings of the human history, came out. The architecture of classical mechanics was developed between the end of the eighteenth century and the second half of the nineteenth century, and its present form is largely due to Lagrange, Jacobi, and Hamilton. As we shall see in this chapter, classical mechanics is built upon the requirement of determinism, a rather complex assumption which is far from being obvious. In Sec. 1.2 we shall present the two main conceptual features of quantum mechanics on the basis of an ideal interferometry experiment: the superposition principle and the principle of complementarity. In Sec. 1.3 a first formal treatment of quantum-mechanical states is developed: quantum states are represented by vectors in a space that turns out to be a Hilbert space. In Sec. 1.4 the significance of probability for quantum mechanics is explained briefly: we will show that probability is not just an ingredient of quantum mechanics, but is rather an intrinsic feature of the theory. Furthermore, we shall see that quantum probability is not ruled by Kolmogorov axioms of classical probability. Finally, we discuss the main evidences which have historically revealed the necessity of a departure from classical mechanics.