Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mass Without Mass

Jean Louis Van Belle

Published Aug 1, 2019• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This paper revisits the oscillator model of an electron, applying Wheeler’s ‘mass without mass’ concept to the Zitterbewegung model of an electron. We then use this model to derive the electron properties (spin, magnetic moment, energy, etcetera). We also use this model to calculate the Zitterbewegung force and the implied energy densities inside of the electron. Finally, we offer some reflections on how this simple but complete ‘mass without mass’ model may provide a basis for a more complete realist interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Related papers

A Classical Quantum Theory of Light

Jean Louis Van Belle

The Zitterbewegung model of an electron offers a classical interpretation for interference and diffraction of electrons. The idea is very intuitive because it incorporates John Wheeler’s idea of mass without mass: we have an indivisible naked charge that has no properties but its charge and its size (the classical electron radius) and it is easy to understand that the electromagnetic oscillation that keeps this tiny circular current going – like a perpetual current ring in some superconducting material – cannot be separated from it. In contrast, we keep wondering: what keeps a photon together? Hence, the real challenge for any realist interpretation of quantum mechanics is to explain the quantization of light: what are these photons? In this paper, we offer a classical quantum theory for light. The intuition behind the model is the same as the one we developed for an electron: we think of the photon as a harmonic electromagnetic oscillator, and its elementary cycle determines its properties, including spin and its size (the effective area of interference).

•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

In Search of Schroedinger's Electron and Einstein's Atom Too !

Jean Louis Van Belle

This article explores a possible physical interpretation of the wavefunction. It zooms in on the physical model it implies for an electron in free space (further building on Schroedinger's ideas in regard to the apparent Zitterbewegung of an electron), but then also discusses the wavefunction for particles (including non-charged particles) in general. While it basically concludes that the mainstream interpretation of quantum physics (the Copenhagen interpretation) is and remains the most parsimonious explanation, it also argues that one or two extra assumptions – the wavefunction as a two-dimensional self-sustaining electromagnetic or gravitational oscillation in space – would make more frivolous explanations (many worlds, pilot wave, etcetera) redundant.

•Sep 1, 2018•0 citations

Philosophy and Physics

Jean Louis Van Belle

This paper offers a philosophical-epistemological basis for the realist interpretation of quantum mechanics on the basis of the Zitterbewegung model of an electron. It does so by a detailed analysis of the logic and assumptions underpinning the mainstream (Copenhagen) interpretation of quantum mechanics. For ease of reference, we use the logic and analytical pieces which Richard Feynman developed for his Lectures on quantum mechanics for sophomore students.

•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Zitterbewegung and the internal geometry of the electron

A. O. Barut, Anthony J. Bracken

Schr\"odinger's work on the Zitterbewegung of the free electron is reexamined. His proposed "microscopic momentum" vector for the Zitterbewegung is rejected in favor of a "relative momentum" vector, with the value $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{P}}=mc\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ in the rest frame of the center of mass. His oscillatory "microscopic coordinate" vector is retained. In the rest frame, it takes the form $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{Q}}=\ensuremath{-}i(\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{2mc})\ensuremath{\beta}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, and the Zitterbewegung is described in this frame in terms of $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{P}}$, $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{Q}}$, and the Hamiltonian $m{c}^{2}\ensuremath{\beta}$, as a finite three-dimensional harmonic oscillator with a compact phase space. The Lie algebra generated by $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{Q}}$ and $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{P}}$ is that of SO(5), and in particular $[{Q}_{i},{P}_{j}]=\ensuremath{-}i\ensuremath{\hbar}{\ensuremath{\delta}}_{\mathrm{ij}}\ensuremath{\beta}$. It is argued that the simplest possible finite, three-dimensional, isotropic, quantum-mechanical system requires such an SO(5) structure, incorporates a fundamental length, and has harmonic-oscillator dynamics. Dirac's equation is derived as the wave equation appropriate to the description of such a finite quantum system in an arbitrary moving frame of reference, using a dynamical group SO(3,2) which can be extended to SO(4,2). Spin appears here as the orbital angular momentum associated with the internal system, and rest-mass energy appears as the internal energy in the rest frame. Possible generalizations of these ideas are indicated, in particular those involving higher-dimensional representations of SO(5).

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 1981•290 citations

Nonrelativistic Dynamics of the Point with Internal Degrees of Freedom and Spinning Electron

А. Н. Тараканов

Nonrelativistic formalism is developed, which allows describing systems with internal degrees of freedom in the scalar potential field U, which is a function both on relative coordinates and time, and on relative speed and accelerations. The equation for energy, which is an integral of motion when U satisfies to certain differential condition, is derived for the general case. For a free mass point all solutions of the equations of motion in the center-of-inertia reference frame, moving with constant velocity, are obtained. As a result, the center of mass follows along a complicated trajectory round a direction of motion of the center of inertia. This motion can be interpreted as Zitterbewegung. It is shown that equation of moments is a consequence of the equation of motion. The general equation of motion for a spin which can be interpreted from positions of a classical mechanics is written down. Application of the obtained results to the electron leads to new conception of electrical charge, sign of which corresponds to a sign of spin polarization.

•Jan 1, 2012•4 citations

The Anomalous Magnetic Moment: Classical Calculations

Jean Louis Van Belle

Critics of the Zitterbewegung model often ask what predictions come out of the model. The answer to this question is quite simple: in order to gain credibility, the model would need to explain the anomalous magnetic moment as measured in experiments. If it can do this, then it should probably be recognized as a valid and alternative interpretation of quantum mechanics. This paper explores the geometry of the model in very much depth and, as such, lays the foundations for such explanation.

•Jun 1, 2019•1 citation
This paper revisits the oscillator model of an electron, applying Wheeler’s ‘mass without mass’ concept to the Zitterbewegung model of an electron. We then use this model to derive the electron properties (spin, magnetic moment, energy, etcetera). We also use this model to calculate the Zitterbewegung force and the implied energy densities inside of the electron. Finally, we offer some reflections on how this simple but complete ‘mass without mass’ model may provide a basis for a more complete realist interpretation of quantum mechanics.
The Zitterbewegung model of an electron offers a classical interpretation for interference and diffraction of electrons. The idea is very intuitive because it incorporates John Wheeler’s idea of mass without mass: we have an indivisible naked charge that has no properties but its charge and its size (the classical electron radius) and it is easy to understand that the electromagnetic oscillation that keeps this tiny circular current going – like a perpetual current ring in some superconducting material – cannot be separated from it. In contrast, we keep wondering: what keeps a photon together? Hence, the real challenge for any realist interpretation of quantum mechanics is to explain the quantization of light: what are these photons? In this paper, we offer a classical quantum theory for light. The intuition behind the model is the same as the one we developed for an electron: we think of the photon as a harmonic electromagnetic oscillator, and its elementary cycle determines its properties, including spin and its size (the effective area of interference).
This article explores a possible physical interpretation of the wavefunction. It zooms in on the physical model it implies for an electron in free space (further building on Schroedinger's ideas in regard to the apparent Zitterbewegung of an electron), but then also discusses the wavefunction for particles (including non-charged particles) in general. While it basically concludes that the mainstream interpretation of quantum physics (the Copenhagen interpretation) is and remains the most parsimonious explanation, it also argues that one or two extra assumptions – the wavefunction as a two-dimensional self-sustaining electromagnetic or gravitational oscillation in space – would make more frivolous explanations (many worlds, pilot wave, etcetera) redundant.
Schr\"odinger's work on the Zitterbewegung of the free electron is reexamined. His proposed "microscopic momentum" vector for the Zitterbewegung is rejected in favor of a "relative momentum" vector, with the value $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{P}}=mc\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ in the rest frame of the center of mass. His oscillatory "microscopic coordinate" vector is retained. In the rest frame, it takes the form $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{Q}}=\ensuremath{-}i(\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{2mc})\ensuremath{\beta}\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$, and the Zitterbewegung is described in this frame in terms of $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{P}}$, $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{Q}}$, and the Hamiltonian $m{c}^{2}\ensuremath{\beta}$, as a finite three-dimensional harmonic oscillator with a compact phase space. The Lie algebra generated by $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{Q}}$ and $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{P}}$ is that of SO(5), and in particular $[{Q}_{i},{P}_{j}]=\ensuremath{-}i\ensuremath{\hbar}{\ensuremath{\delta}}_{\mathrm{ij}}\ensuremath{\beta}$. It is argued that the simplest possible finite, three-dimensional, isotropic, quantum-mechanical system requires such an SO(5) structure, incorporates a fundamental length, and has harmonic-oscillator dynamics. Dirac's equation is derived as the wave equation appropriate to the description of such a finite quantum system in an arbitrary moving frame of reference, using a dynamical group SO(3,2) which can be extended to SO(4,2). Spin appears here as the orbital angular momentum associated with the internal system, and rest-mass energy appears as the internal energy in the rest frame. Possible generalizations of these ideas are indicated, in particular those involving higher-dimensional representations of SO(5).
Nonrelativistic formalism is developed, which allows describing systems with internal degrees of freedom in the scalar potential field U, which is a function both on relative coordinates and time, and on relative speed and accelerations. The equation for energy, which is an integral of motion when U satisfies to certain differential condition, is derived for the general case. For a free mass point all solutions of the equations of motion in the center-of-inertia reference frame, moving with constant velocity, are obtained. As a result, the center of mass follows along a complicated trajectory round a direction of motion of the center of inertia. This motion can be interpreted as Zitterbewegung. It is shown that equation of moments is a consequence of the equation of motion. The general equation of motion for a spin which can be interpreted from positions of a classical mechanics is written down. Application of the obtained results to the electron leads to new conception of electrical charge, sign of which corresponds to a sign of spin polarization.