Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Solvay Conference on Physics

DIRECT DETECTION OF QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT

Paweł Horodecki, ARTUR K. EKERT, CAROLINA MOURA ALVES, Daniel K. L. Oi, L. C. Kwek, Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Michał Horodecki

Published Aug 1, 2003• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum entanglement, after playing a significant role in the development of the foundations of quantum mechanics, has been recently rediscovered as a new physical resource with potential commercial applications such as, for example, quantum cryptography, better frequency standards or quantum-enhanced positioning and clock synchronization. On the mathematical side the studies of entanglement have revealed very interesting connections with the theory of positive maps. The capacity to generate entangled states is one of the basic requirements for building quantum computers. Hence, efficient experimental methods for detection, verification and estimation of quantum entanglement are of great practical importance. Here, we propose an experimentally viable, \\emph{direct} detection of quantum entanglement which is efficient and does not require any \\emph{a priori} knowledge about the quantum state. In a particular case of two entangled qubits it provides an estimation of the amount of entanglement. We view this method as a new form of quantum computation, namely, as a decision problem with quantum data structure.

DOI
10.1142/9789812704634_0043

Related papers

Method for Direct Detection of Quantum Entanglement

Paweł Horodecki, ARTUR K. EKERT

Basing on positive maps separability criterion we propose the experimentally viable, direct detection of quantum entanglement. It is efficient and does not require any a priori knowledge about the state. For two qubits it provides a sharp (i.e., "if and only if") separability test and estimation of amount of entanglement. We view this method as a new form of quantum computation, namely, as a decision problem with quantum data structure.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111064•Physical Review Letters•Aug 30, 2002•280 citations

HOW TO DETECT ENTANGLEMENT IN QUANTUM SYSTEMS

Miłosz R. Michalski

The present paper is a brief, elementary introduction to the theory of entangled states in quantum systems, based on the lecture given by the author at the Suwa Satellite Conference of QBIC09, held at Tokyo University of Science in Suwa, March 6–8, 2009. We focus here on the mathematical problem of entanglement detection. The duality between positive maps and entanglement witnesses is emphasized. One particular class of experimentally relevant entanglement witnesses and the method of their construction is further discussed in another paper appearing in this volume. 1 An interested reader may find much more information about recent developments in the entanglement theory and applications in a review paper [2].

Quantum Bio-Informatics•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Theory on detection of multipartite entanglement

宏二 長田

Since the 1980s, there has been a physical problem relating to the detection of multipartite entangled states that helps us to investigate fundamental point of view on interpretations of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, information theories based on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics, for example, quantum cryptography and quantum computation, have been investigated by researchers whose number has been increasing day by day in the world. This field became to be called quantum information theories. A practical experimental realization of quantum information processing needs that we detect experimentally multipartite entangled states. The number of researchers for multipartite entangled states is increasing rapidly. Especially, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states are useful for quantum information processing information processing using quantum mechanics, which improves the conventional information processing ability which had been based on classical theories. However, practical experimental realization of the theories and controlling quantum states have inevitable difficulties due to the interaction with environments. The requirement in maintaining multipartite entangled states in relation to the time that takes to make a practical experiment is also a problem. Many experimentalists are tackling this problem, and recently, several groups have reported that multipartite entangled states have been physically detected in their laboratories. The main difficulty is how to judge whether or not the observed quantum state is indeed a multipartite entangled state. For this purpose, it is necessary to construct theoretical models to analyze such experimental data. In this thesis, we apply a mathematical structure as to density operators described in a high-dimensional Hilbert space, and we employ mathematical theories to prove if the corresponding density operator represents a multipartite entangled state or not. The main aim for constructing such models is to analyze the raw experimental data. Moreover, this model helps experimentalists in the sense that it allows them to see how to confirm that observed states are indeed the desired state. With mathematical theories developed before this thesis, only limited applications for this purpose were allowed. Some theories cover two-dimensional Hilbert space only. It has not been even discussed how to analyze the fidelity to GHZ states of the observed state. This has led to some doubt of that experimental data might not always confirm three-partite entangled states. However, by using the method of this thesis, statistical check based on such experimental data of the existence of three particle-entangled states is possible under appropriate assumptions. This example symbolizes that our analytical knowledge has improved very much in the last few years. This thesis gives us an advanced mathematical model for analyzing experimental data.

•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

Designing quantum information processing via structural physical approximation

Joonwoo Bae

In quantum information processing it may be possible to have efficient computation and secure communication beyond the limitations of classical systems. In a fundamental point of view, however, evolution of quantum systems by the laws of quantum mechanics is more restrictive than classical systems, identified to a specific form of dynamics, that is, unitary transformations and, consequently, positive and completely positive maps to subsystems. This also characterizes classes of disallowed transformations on quantum systems, among which positive but not completely maps are of particular interest as they characterize entangled states, a general resource in quantum information processing. Structural physical approximation offers a systematic way of approximating those non-physical maps, positive but not completely positive maps, with quantum channels. Since it has been proposed as a method of detecting entangled states, it has stimulated fundamental problems on classifications of positive maps and the structure of Hermitian operators and quantum states, as well as on quantum measurement such as quantum design in quantum information theory. It has developed efficient and feasible methods of directly detecting entangled states in practice, for which proof-of-principle experimental demonstrations have also been performed with photonic qubit states. Here, we present a comprehensive review on quantum information processing with structural physical approximations and the related progress. The review mainly focuses on properties of structural physical approximations and their applications toward practical information applications.

arXiv:1707.02583•Reports on Progress in Physics•Jul 4, 2017•23 citations

Witness expansion: A unified framework for analytical and measurable mixed-state resource detection

Yifan Tang, Chengkai Zhu, Yuzhen Zhang +6 more

Quantum information science aims to harness different kinds of quantum resources to accomplish specific information-processing tasks. These resources also play an increasingly important role in addressing fundamental questions concerning quantum phases and dynamics. Therefore, developing powerful and practical methods for identifying and detecting quantum resources is of great significance, with applications ranging from benchmarking quantum devices to understanding the fundamental structure of quantum theory. In this work, we propose witness expansion, a unified framework for constructing nonlinear criteria for detecting quantum resources that are associated with a well-defined group of free unitaries. These criteria apply to both pure and mixed quantum states and are based on polynomial functions of the target state, which can be estimated experimentally using multiple copies of the state and evaluated analytically in certain physical models. We show how several well-known resource-detection quantities naturally emerge from our framework, including the $l_2$ norm of coherence, partial-transpose moments for entanglement, stabilizer entropy for nonstabilizerness (quantum magic), and fermionic antiflatness for fermionic non-Gaussianity. Beyond recovering these existing structures, our framework also yields new criteria for detecting qubit and qudit magic states, substantially enhancing witness-based detection capabilities. In addition, it gives, to the best of our knowledge, the first analytical criterion for detecting mixed-state fermionic non-Gaussianity with respect to the convex hull of pure fermionic Gaussian states that remains nontrivial for arbitrary numbers of qubits, demonstrating the broad applicability and conceptual unifying power of the framework.

quant-pharXiv:2606.27105•Jun 26, 2026•8 citations

Efficient Device-Independent Entanglement Detection for Multipartite Systems

F. Baccari, Daniel Cavalcanti, P. Wittek +1 more

Quantum entanglement lies at the heart of proposals for encoding and manipulating information in a quantum computer, but detecting its presence in large ensembles of particles remains challenging. A new technique for entanglement detection promises to be both computationally and experimentally efficient in systems involving tens of particles.

arXiv:1612.08551•Physical Review X•Jun 14, 2017•57 citations
Quantum entanglement, after playing a significant role in the development of the foundations of quantum mechanics, has been recently rediscovered as a new physical resource with potential commercial applications such as, for example, quantum cryptography, better frequency standards or quantum-enhanced positioning and clock synchronization. On the mathematical side the studies of entanglement have revealed very interesting connections with the theory of positive maps. The capacity to generate entangled states is one of the basic requirements for building quantum computers. Hence, efficient experimental methods for detection, verification and estimation of quantum entanglement are of great practical importance. Here, we propose an experimentally viable, \emph{direct} detection of quantum entanglement which is efficient and does not require any \emph{a priori} knowledge about the quantum state. In a particular case of two entangled qubits it provides an estimation of the amount of entanglement. We view this method as a new form of quantum computation, namely, as a decision problem with quantum data structure.
The present paper is a brief, elementary introduction to the theory of entangled states in quantum systems, based on the lecture given by the author at the Suwa Satellite Conference of QBIC09, held at Tokyo University of Science in Suwa, March 6–8, 2009. We focus here on the mathematical problem of entanglement detection. The duality between positive maps and entanglement witnesses is emphasized. One particular class of experimentally relevant entanglement witnesses and the method of their construction is further discussed in another paper appearing in this volume. 1 An interested reader may find much more information about recent developments in the entanglement theory and applications in a review paper [2].
Since the 1980s, there has been a physical problem relating to the detection of multipartite entangled states that helps us to investigate fundamental point of view on interpretations of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, information theories based on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics, for example, quantum cryptography and quantum computation, have been investigated by researchers whose number has been increasing day by day in the world. This field became to be called quantum information theories. A practical experimental realization of quantum information processing needs that we detect experimentally multipartite entangled states. The number of researchers for multipartite entangled states is increasing rapidly. Especially, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states are useful for quantum information processing information processing using quantum mechanics, which improves the conventional information processing ability which had been based on classical theories. However, practical experimental realization of the theories and controlling quantum states have inevitable difficulties due to the interaction with environments. The requirement in maintaining multipartite entangled states in relation to the time that takes to make a practical experiment is also a problem. Many experimentalists are tackling this problem, and recently, several groups have reported that multipartite entangled states have been physically detected in their laboratories. The main difficulty is how to judge whether or not the observed quantum state is indeed a multipartite entangled state. For this purpose, it is necessary to construct theoretical models to analyze such experimental data. In this thesis, we apply a mathematical structure as to density operators described in a high-dimensional Hilbert space, and we employ mathematical theories to prove if the corresponding density operator represents a multipartite entangled state or not. The main aim for constructing such models is to analyze the raw experimental data. Moreover, this model helps experimentalists in the sense that it allows them to see how to confirm that observed states are indeed the desired state. With mathematical theories developed before this thesis, only limited applications for this purpose were allowed. Some theories cover two-dimensional Hilbert space only. It has not been even discussed how to analyze the fidelity to GHZ states of the observed state. This has led to some doubt of that experimental data might not always confirm three-partite entangled states. However, by using the method of this thesis, statistical check based on such experimental data of the existence of three particle-entangled states is possible under appropriate assumptions. This example symbolizes that our analytical knowledge has improved very much in the last few years. This thesis gives us an advanced mathematical model for analyzing experimental data.
In quantum information processing it may be possible to have efficient computation and secure communication beyond the limitations of classical systems. In a fundamental point of view, however, evolution of quantum systems by the laws of quantum mechanics is more restrictive than classical systems, identified to a specific form of dynamics, that is, unitary transformations and, consequently, positive and completely positive maps to subsystems. This also characterizes classes of disallowed transformations on quantum systems, among which positive but not completely maps are of particular interest as they characterize entangled states, a general resource in quantum information processing. Structural physical approximation offers a systematic way of approximating those non-physical maps, positive but not completely positive maps, with quantum channels. Since it has been proposed as a method of detecting entangled states, it has stimulated fundamental problems on classifications of positive maps and the structure of Hermitian operators and quantum states, as well as on quantum measurement such as quantum design in quantum information theory. It has developed efficient and feasible methods of directly detecting entangled states in practice, for which proof-of-principle experimental demonstrations have also been performed with photonic qubit states. Here, we present a comprehensive review on quantum information processing with structural physical approximations and the related progress. The review mainly focuses on properties of structural physical approximations and their applications toward practical information applications.
Quantum information science aims to harness different kinds of quantum resources to accomplish specific information-processing tasks. These resources also play an increasingly important role in addressing fundamental questions concerning quantum phases and dynamics. Therefore, developing powerful and practical methods for identifying and detecting quantum resources is of great significance, with applications ranging from benchmarking quantum devices to understanding the fundamental structure of quantum theory. In this work, we propose witness expansion, a unified framework for constructing nonlinear criteria for detecting quantum resources that are associated with a well-defined group of free unitaries. These criteria apply to both pure and mixed quantum states and are based on polynomial functions of the target state, which can be estimated experimentally using multiple copies of the state and evaluated analytically in certain physical models. We show how several well-known resource-detection quantities naturally emerge from our framework, including the l2l_2l2​ norm of coherence, partial-transpose moments for entanglement, stabilizer entropy for nonstabilizerness (quantum magic), and fermionic antiflatness for fermionic non-Gaussianity. Beyond recovering these existing structures, our framework also yields new criteria for detecting qubit and qudit magic states, substantially enhancing witness-based detection capabilities. In addition, it gives, to the best of our knowledge, the first analytical criterion for detecting mixed-state fermionic non-Gaussianity with respect to the convex hull of pure fermionic Gaussian states that remains nontrivial for arbitrary numbers of qubits, demonstrating the broad applicability and conceptual unifying power of the framework.