Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Weak measurements for quantum characterization and control

Jonathan A. Gross

Published Jan 1, 2018• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This dissertation concerns itself with the virtues and vices of weak measurements. Weak measurements are all around us, but this does not mean that one should manufacture weakness on all occasions. We critically evaluate two proposals that claim weak measurements provide a novel means of performing quantum state tomography, allegedly increasing tomographic efficacy and yielding foundational insights into the nature of quantum mechanics. We find weak measurements are not an essential ingredient for most of their advertised features. In contrast to this negative finding, we highlight an optimal tomographic scheme for which weak continuous measurements are the best known implementation, taking the opportunity to present this result in the language of quantum noise. Weak measurements are also used to describe continuous measurements and the associated unconditional and conditional master equations. Though this description has been presented before, we provide a new perspective by using tools and terminology from the discipline of quantum information and quantum computing. We do so by showing how the continuous-time evolution of these master equations arises from discretizing in time the interaction between a system and a probe field and by formulating quantum-circuit diagrams for the discretized evolution. We then reformulate this interaction by replacing the probe field with a bath of qubits, one for each discretized time segment, reproducing all of the standard quantum-optical master equations. This provides an economical formulation of the white-noise theory of continuous measurements, highlighting its fundamental underlying assumptions and limitations. White-noise theory is incapable of describing photon-counting measurements in the presence of thermal and squeezed noise. We accommodate such scenarios by considering an environment that includes traveling wave packets that are squeezed, deriving a hierarchy of equations similar to those used to describe traveling wave packets with fixed photon number. Squeezing introduces qualitatively different effects, however, complicating numerical solution of these hierarchies. We provide preliminary numerical analysis of the formalism and showcase its utility by calculating the resonance fluorescence of a two-level atom in squeezed vacuum with squeezing bandwidth narrower than the atomic linewidth, a regime previous techniques cannot explore.

Related papers

Qubit models of weak continuous measurements: markovian conditional and open-system dynamics

Jonathan A. Gross, Carlton M. Caves, Gerard J Milburn +1 more

Abstract In this paper we approach the theory of continuous measurements and the associated unconditional and conditional (stochastic) master equations from the perspective of quantum information and quantum computing. We do so by showing how the continuous-time evolution of these master equations arises from discretizing in time the interaction between a system and a probe field and by formulating quantum-circuit diagrams for the discretized evolution. We then reformulate this interaction by replacing the probe field with a bath of qubits, one for each discretized time segment, reproducing all of the standard quantum-optical master equations. This provides an economical formulation of the theory, highlighting its fundamental underlying assumptions.

arXiv:1710.09523•Quantum Science and Technology•Dec 22, 2017•110 citations

Novelty, efficacy, and significance of weak measurements for quantum tomography

Jonathan A. Gross, Ninnat Dangniam, Christopher Ferrie +1 more

The use of weak measurements for performing quantum tomography is enjoying increased attention due to several recent proposals. The claimed merits of using weak measurements in this context are varied, but are generally represented by novelty, increased efficacy, and foundational significance. We critically evaluate two proposals that make such claims and find that weak measurements are not an essential ingredient for most of their claimed features.

arXiv:1506.08892•Physical Review A•Dec 30, 2015•29 citations

Concepts and applications of quantum measurement

George C. Knee

In this thesis I discuss the nature of ‘measurement’ in quantum theory. ‘Measurement’ is associated with several different processes: the gradual imprinting of information about one system onto another, which is well understood; the collapse of the wavefunction, which is ill-defined and troublesome; and finally, the means by which inferences about unknown experimental parameters are made. I present a theoretical extension to an experimental proposal from Leggett and Garg, who suggested that the quantum-or-classical reality of a macroscopic system may be probed with successive measurements arrayed in time. The extension allows for a finite level of imperfection in the protocol, and makes use of Leggett’s ‘null result’ measurement scheme. I present the results of an experiment conducted in Oxford that, up to certain loopholes, defies a non-quantum interpretation of the dynamics of phosphorous nuclei embedded in silicon. I also present the theory of statistical parameter estimation, and discover that a recent trend to employ time symmetric ‘postselected’ measurements offers no true advantage over standard methods. The technique, known as weak-value amplification, combines a weak transfer of quantum information from system to meter with conditional data rejection, to surprising effect. The Fisher information is a powerful tool for evaluating the performance of any parameter estimation model, and it reveals the technique to be worse than ordinary, preselected only measurements. That this is true despite the presence of noise (including magnetic field fluctuations causing deco- herence, poor resolution detection, and random displacements), casts serious doubt on the utility of the method.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Continuous observation of quantum dynamics

Hideo Mabuchi

NOTE: Text or symbols not renderable in plain ASCII are indicated by [...]. Abstract is included in .pdf document. Previous work in cavity quantum electrodynamics has focused principally on achieving the condition of strong coupling, such that the single-photon Rabi frequency for one atom in a cavity dominates the rates associated with all forms of dissipation and dephasing. Although strong coupling was convincingly demonstrated in these experiments, the use of thermal atomic beams as a source of atoms invariably limited the intracavity dwell time of any given atom to values marginally longer than the system's characteristic dynamical timescales. Accordingly, the observation of single-atom effects in these experiments required integration over the transits of many successive atoms through the optical resonator. In such ensemble-averaged experiments, the quantitative effects of dissipation and measurement could always be understood from the perspective of Master Equation formalisms. By contrast, our most recent work has incorporated laser cooling techniques to accomplish a thousand-fold increase in the dwell time of individual atoms while maintaining conditions of strong coupling. With this extreme separation of timescales, the effects of individual atoms on the cavity transmission can clearly be resolved. Moreover, detailed information on each individual atom's spatial trajectory through the cavity can be inferred from the time-varying amplitude and phase of the transmitted light. Understanding the exact nature of such correlations in real laboratory measurements requires not only a careful characterization of excess technical noise, but also an in-depth study of how (and when) aspects of continuous quantum measurement theory should properly be applied. This thesis primarily contains a detailed description of an experiment in which we used broadband heterodyne spectroscopy to record the complete time-evolution of interaction energy between one atom and a high-finesse optical cavity, during individual scattering events of [...] duration. With a characteristic interaction energy scale [...], we achieve a shot-noise limited measurement sensitivity [...] over a bandwidth that covers the dominant rates of variation in [...]. I also include two brief studies in quantum measurement theory, which highlight the significance of the experimental work for continuing research on conditional quantum dynamics. The first investigates quantum limits to broadband measurement of position and force, and the second proposes a novel trajectory-based approach to quantum system identification.

•Mar 17, 2006•1 citation

Experimental Feedback Control of Quantum Systems Using Weak Measurements

Geoff Gillett, R. B. Dalton, B. P. Lanyon +7 more

A goal of the emerging field of quantum control is to develop methods for quantum technologies to function robustly in the presence of noise. Central issues are the fundamental limitations on the available information about quantum systems and the disturbance they suffer in the process of measurement. In the context of a simple quantum control scenario-the stabilization of nonorthogonal states of a qubit against dephasing-we experimentally explore the use of weak measurements in feedback control. We find that, despite the intrinsic difficultly of implementing them, weak measurements allow us to control the qubit better in practice than is even theoretically possible without them. Our work shows that these more general quantum measurements can play an important role for feedback control of quantum systems.

arXiv:0911.3698•Physical Review Letters•Feb 26, 2010•154 citations

Stochastic approach to evolution of a quantum system interacting with environment in squeezed number state

Anita Magdalena Dąbrowska, Marcin Marciniak

Abstract We determine filtering and master equations for a quantum system interacting with wave packet of light in a continuous-mode squeezed number state. We formulate the problem of conditional evolution of a quantum system making use of model of repeated interactions and measurements. In this approach, the quantum system undergoes a sequence of interactions with an environment defined by a chain of harmonic oscillators. We assume that the environment is prepared in an entangled state being a discrete analogue of a continuous-mode squeezed number state. We present a derivation of a discrete stochastic dynamics that depends on the results of measurement performed on the field after its interaction with the system. In this paper, we consider a photon counting measurement scheme. By taking a continuous time limit, we finally obtain differential stochastic equations for the system. Analytical formulae for quantum trajectories and exclusive probability densities that allow to fully characterize the statistics of photons in the output field are given.

arXiv:2303.12162•Quantum Information Processing•Oct 19, 2023•1 citation
This dissertation concerns itself with the virtues and vices of weak measurements. Weak measurements are all around us, but this does not mean that one should manufacture weakness on all occasions. We critically evaluate two proposals that claim weak measurements provide a novel means of performing quantum state tomography, allegedly increasing tomographic efficacy and yielding foundational insights into the nature of quantum mechanics. We find weak measurements are not an essential ingredient for most of their advertised features. In contrast to this negative finding, we highlight an optimal tomographic scheme for which weak continuous measurements are the best known implementation, taking the opportunity to present this result in the language of quantum noise. Weak measurements are also used to describe continuous measurements and the associated unconditional and conditional master equations. Though this description has been presented before, we provide a new perspective by using tools and terminology from the discipline of quantum information and quantum computing. We do so by showing how the continuous-time evolution of these master equations arises from discretizing in time the interaction between a system and a probe field and by formulating quantum-circuit diagrams for the discretized evolution. We then reformulate this interaction by replacing the probe field with a bath of qubits, one for each discretized time segment, reproducing all of the standard quantum-optical master equations. This provides an economical formulation of the white-noise theory of continuous measurements, highlighting its fundamental underlying assumptions and limitations. White-noise theory is incapable of describing photon-counting measurements in the presence of thermal and squeezed noise. We accommodate such scenarios by considering an environment that includes traveling wave packets that are squeezed, deriving a hierarchy of equations similar to those used to describe traveling wave packets with fixed photon number. Squeezing introduces qualitatively different effects, however, complicating numerical solution of these hierarchies. We provide preliminary numerical analysis of the formalism and showcase its utility by calculating the resonance fluorescence of a two-level atom in squeezed vacuum with squeezing bandwidth narrower than the atomic linewidth, a regime previous techniques cannot explore.
Abstract In this paper we approach the theory of continuous measurements and the associated unconditional and conditional (stochastic) master equations from the perspective of quantum information and quantum computing. We do so by showing how the continuous-time evolution of these master equations arises from discretizing in time the interaction between a system and a probe field and by formulating quantum-circuit diagrams for the discretized evolution. We then reformulate this interaction by replacing the probe field with a bath of qubits, one for each discretized time segment, reproducing all of the standard quantum-optical master equations. This provides an economical formulation of the theory, highlighting its fundamental underlying assumptions.
In this thesis I discuss the nature of ‘measurement’ in quantum theory. ‘Measurement’ is associated with several different processes: the gradual imprinting of information about one system onto another, which is well understood; the collapse of the wavefunction, which is ill-defined and troublesome; and finally, the means by which inferences about unknown experimental parameters are made. I present a theoretical extension to an experimental proposal from Leggett and Garg, who suggested that the quantum-or-classical reality of a macroscopic system may be probed with successive measurements arrayed in time. The extension allows for a finite level of imperfection in the protocol, and makes use of Leggett’s ‘null result’ measurement scheme. I present the results of an experiment conducted in Oxford that, up to certain loopholes, defies a non-quantum interpretation of the dynamics of phosphorous nuclei embedded in silicon. I also present the theory of statistical parameter estimation, and discover that a recent trend to employ time symmetric ‘postselected’ measurements offers no true advantage over standard methods. The technique, known as weak-value amplification, combines a weak transfer of quantum information from system to meter with conditional data rejection, to surprising effect. The Fisher information is a powerful tool for evaluating the performance of any parameter estimation model, and it reveals the technique to be worse than ordinary, preselected only measurements. That this is true despite the presence of noise (including magnetic field fluctuations causing deco- herence, poor resolution detection, and random displacements), casts serious doubt on the utility of the method.
NOTE: Text or symbols not renderable in plain ASCII are indicated by [...]. Abstract is included in .pdf document. Previous work in cavity quantum electrodynamics has focused principally on achieving the condition of strong coupling, such that the single-photon Rabi frequency for one atom in a cavity dominates the rates associated with all forms of dissipation and dephasing. Although strong coupling was convincingly demonstrated in these experiments, the use of thermal atomic beams as a source of atoms invariably limited the intracavity dwell time of any given atom to values marginally longer than the system's characteristic dynamical timescales. Accordingly, the observation of single-atom effects in these experiments required integration over the transits of many successive atoms through the optical resonator. In such ensemble-averaged experiments, the quantitative effects of dissipation and measurement could always be understood from the perspective of Master Equation formalisms. By contrast, our most recent work has incorporated laser cooling techniques to accomplish a thousand-fold increase in the dwell time of individual atoms while maintaining conditions of strong coupling. With this extreme separation of timescales, the effects of individual atoms on the cavity transmission can clearly be resolved. Moreover, detailed information on each individual atom's spatial trajectory through the cavity can be inferred from the time-varying amplitude and phase of the transmitted light. Understanding the exact nature of such correlations in real laboratory measurements requires not only a careful characterization of excess technical noise, but also an in-depth study of how (and when) aspects of continuous quantum measurement theory should properly be applied. This thesis primarily contains a detailed description of an experiment in which we used broadband heterodyne spectroscopy to record the complete time-evolution of interaction energy between one atom and a high-finesse optical cavity, during individual scattering events of [...] duration. With a characteristic interaction energy scale [...], we achieve a shot-noise limited measurement sensitivity [...] over a bandwidth that covers the dominant rates of variation in [...]. I also include two brief studies in quantum measurement theory, which highlight the significance of the experimental work for continuing research on conditional quantum dynamics. The first investigates quantum limits to broadband measurement of position and force, and the second proposes a novel trajectory-based approach to quantum system identification.
A goal of the emerging field of quantum control is to develop methods for quantum technologies to function robustly in the presence of noise. Central issues are the fundamental limitations on the available information about quantum systems and the disturbance they suffer in the process of measurement. In the context of a simple quantum control scenario-the stabilization of nonorthogonal states of a qubit against dephasing-we experimentally explore the use of weak measurements in feedback control. We find that, despite the intrinsic difficultly of implementing them, weak measurements allow us to control the qubit better in practice than is even theoretically possible without them. Our work shows that these more general quantum measurements can play an important role for feedback control of quantum systems.
Abstract We determine filtering and master equations for a quantum system interacting with wave packet of light in a continuous-mode squeezed number state. We formulate the problem of conditional evolution of a quantum system making use of model of repeated interactions and measurements. In this approach, the quantum system undergoes a sequence of interactions with an environment defined by a chain of harmonic oscillators. We assume that the environment is prepared in an entangled state being a discrete analogue of a continuous-mode squeezed number state. We present a derivation of a discrete stochastic dynamics that depends on the results of measurement performed on the field after its interaction with the system. In this paper, we consider a photon counting measurement scheme. By taking a continuous time limit, we finally obtain differential stochastic equations for the system. Analytical formulae for quantum trajectories and exclusive probability densities that allow to fully characterize the statistics of photons in the output field are given.