The common random string model permits the construction of cryptographic protocols that are provably impossible to realize in the standard model. In this model, a trusted party generates a random string and gives it to all parties in the protocol. However, the introduction of such a third party should set alarm bells going off: Who is this trusted party? Why should we trust that the string is random? Even if the string is uniformly random, how do we know it does not leak private information to the trusted party? The very point of doing cryptography in the first place is to prevent us from trusting the wrong people with our secrets. In this paper, we propose the more realistic multi-string model. Instead of having one trusted authority, we have several authorities that generate random strings. We do not trust any single authority, we only assume a majority of them generate the random string honestly. We demonstrate the use of this model for two fundamental cryptographic taks. We define non-interactive zero-knowledge in the multi-string model and construct NIZK proofs in the multi-string model. We also consider multi-party computation and show that any functionality can be securely realized in the multi-string model.
The common random string model permits the construction of cryptographic protocols that are provably impossible to realize in the standard model. In this model, a trusted party generates a random string and gives it to all parties in the protocol. However, the introduction of such a third party should set alarm bells going off: Who is this trusted party? Why should we trust that the string is random? Even if the string is uniformly random, how do we know it does not leak private information to the trusted party? The very point of doing cryptography in the first place is to prevent us from trusting the wrong people with our secrets. In this paper, we propose the more realistic multi-string model. Instead of having one trusted authority, we have several authorities that generate random strings. We do not trust any single authority, we only assume a majority of them generate the random string honestly. We demonstrate the use of this model for two fundamental cryptographic taks. We define non-interactive zero-knowledge in the multi-string model and construct NIZK proofs in the multi-string model. We also consider multi-party computation and show that any functionality can be securely realized in the multi-string model.
We present the first constant-round non-malleable commitment scheme and the first constant-round non-malleable zero-knowledge argument system, as defined by Dolev, Dwork and Naor (1991). Previous constructions either used a non-constant number of rounds, or were only secure under stronger setup assumptions. An example of such an assumption is the shared random string model where we assume all parties have access to a reference string that was chosen uniformly at random by a trusted dealer. We obtain these results by defining an adequate notion of non-malleable coin-tossing, and presenting a constant-round protocol that satisfies it. This protocol allows us to transform protocols that are non-malleable in (a modified notion of) the shared random string model into protocols that are non-malleable in the plain model (without any trusted dealer or setup assumptions). Observing that known constructions of a non-interactive non-malleable zero-knowledge argument systems in the shared random string model (De Santis et. al., 2001) are in fact non-malleable in the modified model, and combining them with our coin-tossing protocol we obtain the results mentioned above. The techniques we use are different from those used in previous constructions of non-malleable protocols. In particular our protocol uses diagonalization and a non-black-box proof of security (in a sense similar to Barak's zero-knowledge argument (2001)).
The question of how to construct optimally efficient secure protocols is a central question in cryptography and in the computer security world at large. We focus in this work on several facets of this question, with a particular view towards the role of randomness in secure computation.
The use of random inputs is ubiquitous in cryptographic primitives. However, the ability to consistently draw from large random sources may be a barrier in practice. We examine the existence of optimally strong pseudorandom sources with particularly efficient implementations; namely, we construct exponentially hard pseudorandom generators that can be computed by circuits that have size linear in the generator output.
Conversely, we also examine efficient protocols that rely only minimally on their random inputs. In the resettable security model, parties may be forced to use the same random input across polynomially many interactions with other parties. We examine this security model in the case of zero knowledge proofs, which are a primitive frequently required in secure computation protocols when one party must prove that they have executed the protocol correctly to another party without revealing secret inputs and compromising security.
Finally, we examine the secure and efficient implementation of a specific functionality, including its various required cryptographic primitives (such as zero knowledge arguments of knowledge). In particular, we construct a protocol that securely realizes pattern matching, including single character wildcards and substring matching.
We show how to securely realize any multi-party functionality in a way that preserves security under an a-priori bounded number of concurrent executions, regardless of the number of corrupted parties. Previous protocols for the above task either rely on set-up assumptions such as a Common Reference String, or require an honest majority. Our constructions are in the plain model and rely on standard intractability assumptions (enhanced trapdoor permutations and collision resistant hash functions). Even though our main focus is on feasibility of concurrent multi-party computation we actually obtain a protocol using only a constant number of communication rounds. As a consequence our protocol yields the first construction of constant-round phstand-alone secure multi-party computation with a dishonest majority, proven secure under standard (polynomial-time) hardness assumptions; previous solutions to this task either require logarithmic round-complexity, or subexponential hardness assumptions. The core of our protocol is a novel construction of (concurrently) simulation-sound zero-knowledge protocols, which might be of independent interest. Finally, we extend the framework constructed to give a protocol for secure multi-party (and thus two-party) computation for any number of corrupted parties, which remains secure even when arbitrary subsets of parties concurrently execute the protocol, possibly with interchangeable roles. As far as we know, for the case of two-party or multi-party protocols with a dishonest majority, this is the first positive result for any non-trivial functionality which achieves this property in the plain model.
Abstract It is well known that several cryptographic primitives cannot be achieved without a common reference string (CRS). Those include, for instance, non-interactive zero-knowledge for NP, or maliciously secure computation in fewer than four rounds. The security of those primitives heavily relies on the assumption that the trusted authority, who generates the CRS, does not misuse the randomness used in the CRS generation. However, we argue that there is no such thing as an unconditionally trusted authority and every authority must be held accountable for any trust to be well-founded. Indeed, a malicious authority can, for instance, recover private inputs of honest parties given transcripts of the protocols executed with respect to the CRS it has generated. While eliminating trust in the trusted authority may not be entirely feasible, can we at least move towards achieving some notion of accountability? We propose a new notion in which, if the CRS authority releases the private inputs of protocol executions to others, we can then provide a publicly-verifiable proof that certifies that the authority misbehaved. We study the feasibility of this notion in the context of non-interactive zero knowledge and two-round secure two-party computation.
Abstract. Universally composable (UC) multi-party computation has been studied in two settings. When a majority of parties are honest, UC multi-party computation is possible without any assumptions. Without a majority of honest parties, UC multi-party computation is impossible in the plain model, but feasibility results have been obtained in various augmented models. The most popular such model posits a common reference string (CRS) available to parties executing the protocol. In either of the above settings, some assumption regarding the protocol execution is made: i.e., that many parties are honest in the first case, or that a legitimately-chosen string is available in the second. If this assumption is incorrect then all security is lost. A natural question is whether it is possible to design protocols secure if either one of these assumptions holds, i.e., a protocol which is secure if either at most s players are dishonest or if up to t> s players are dishonest but the CRS is chosen in the prescribed manner. We show that such protocols exist if and only if s + t < n. 1
Abstract. The recently proposed universally composable (UC) security framework, for analyzing security of cryptographic protocols, provides very strong security guarantees. In particular, a protocol proven secure in this framework is guaranteed to maintain its security even when deployed in arbitrary multi-party, multi-protocol, multi-execution environments. Protocols for securely carrying out essentially any cryptographic task in a universally composable way exist, both in the case of an honest majority (in the plain model, i.e., without set-up assumptions) and in the case of no honest majority (in the common reference string model). However, in the plain model, little was known for the case of no honest majority and, in particular, for the important special case of two-party protocols. We study the feasibility of universally composable two-party function evaluation in the plain model. Our results show that very few functions can be computed in this model so as to provide the UC security guarantees. Specifically, for the case of deterministic functions, we provide a full characterization of the functions computable in this model. (Essentially, these are the functions that depend on at most one of the parties’ inputs, and furthermore are “efficiently invertible ” in a sense defined within.) For the case of probabilistic functions, we show that the only functions computable in this model are those where one of the parties can essentially uniquely determine the joint output. 1