The unexpected plays an important but little-understood role in physics. We are working to understand how the unexpected functions in theory and in experiment. This work leads to novel theoretical and instrumental structures of “two-clock physics”, with implications for the scientific method. The path to these structures that express the unexpected draws on three roots: 1. Physicists write strings of symbols. Quantum theory implies that physicists act as agents who make guesses, expressed as strings of symbols, in the face of unpredictability far more drastic than quantum uncertainty. Assimilating unpredictability as pervasive in theory and experiment opens new avenues to investigation. 2. No two clocks tick alike. We formulate a concept network of transmission of symbols among agents, without assuming any spacetime or any global time variable, but requiring that agents adjust local clock rates. This structure offers alternatives to time and distance adapted to a variety of cases and is an important element of what we call two-clock physics. 3. Sometimes a flipped coin lands on edge. Agents must rely on guesses to steer clock rates to achieve a logical synchronization that avoids confusion of one symbol with another.
The unexpected plays an important but little-understood role in physics. We are working to understand how the unexpected functions in theory and in experiment. This work leads to novel theoretical and instrumental structures of “two-clock physics”, with implications for the scientific method. The path to these structures that express the unexpected draws on three roots: 1. Physicists write strings of symbols. Quantum theory implies that physicists act as agents who make guesses, expressed as strings of symbols, in the face of unpredictability far more drastic than quantum uncertainty. Assimilating unpredictability as pervasive in theory and experiment opens new avenues to investigation. 2. No two clocks tick alike. We formulate a concept network of transmission of symbols among agents, without assuming any spacetime or any global time variable, but requiring that agents adjust local clock rates. This structure offers alternatives to time and distance adapted to a variety of cases and is an important element of what we call two-clock physics. 3. Sometimes a flipped coin lands on edge. Agents must rely on guesses to steer clock rates to achieve a logical synchronization that avoids confusion of one symbol with another.
The basic equations of physics involve a time variable t and are invariant under the transformation t → −t. This invariance at first sight appears to impose time reversibility as a principle of physics, in conflict with thermodynamics. But equations written on the blackboard are not the whole story in physics. In prior work we sharpened a distinction obscured in today’s theoretical physics, the distinction between obtaining evidence from experiments on the laboratory bench and explaining that evidence in mathematical symbols on the blackboard. The sharp distinction rests on a proof within the mathematics of quantum theory that no amount of evidence, represented in quantum theory in terms of probabilities, can uniquely determine its explanation in terms of wave functions and linear operators. Building on the proof we show here a role in physics for unpredictable symbol-handling agents acting both at the blackboard and at the workbench, communicating back and forth by means of transmitted symbols. Because of their unpredictability, symbol-handling agents introduce a heretofore overlooked source of irreversibility into physics, even when the equations they write on the blackboard are invariant under t → −t. Widening the scope of descriptions admissible to physics to include the agents and the symbols that link theory to experiments opens up a new source of time-irreversibility in physics.
Preoccupied with measurement, physics has neglected the need, before anything can be measured, to recognize what it is that is to be measured. The recognition of symbols employs a known physical mechanism. The elemental mechanism-a damped inverted pendulum joined by a driven adjustable pendulum (in effect a clock)-both recognizes a binary distinction and records a single bit. Referred to by engineers as a "clocked flip-flop," this paired-pendulum mechanism pervades scientific investigation. It shapes evidence by imposing discrete phases of allowable leeway in clock readings; and it generates a mathematical form of evidence that neither assumes a geometry nor assumes quantum states, and so separates statements of evidence from further assumptions required to explain that evidence, whether the explanations are made in quantum terms or in terms of general relativity. Cleansed of unnecessary assumptions, these expressions of evidence form a platform on which to consider the working together of general relativity and quantum theory as explanatory language for evidence from clock networks, such as the Global Positioning System. Quantum theory puts Planck's constant into explanations of the required timing leeway, while explanations of leeway also draw on the theory of general relativity, prompting the question: does Planck's constant in the timing leeway put the long known tension between quantum theory and general relativity in a new light?
In earlier papers we showed unpredictability beyond quantum uncertainty in atomic clocks, ensuing from a proven gap between given evidence and explanations of that evidence. Here we reconceive a clock, not as an isolated entity, but as enmeshed in a self-adjusting communications network adapted to one or another particular investigation, in contact with an unpredictable environment. From the practical uses of clocks, we abstract a clock enlivened with the computational capacity of a Turing machine, modified to transmit and to receive numerical communications. Such “live clocks” phase the steps of their computations to mesh with the arrival of transmitted numbers. We lift this phasing, known in digital communications, to a principle of logical synchronization, distinct from the synchronization defined by Einstein in special relativity. Logical synchronization elevates digital communication to a topic in physics, including applications to biology. One explores how feedback loops in clocking affect numerical signaling among entities functioning in the face of unpredictable influences, making the influences themselves into subjects of investigation. The formulation of communications networks in terms of live clocks extends information theory by expressing the need to actively maintain communications channels, and potentially, to create or drop them. We show how networks of live clocks are presupposed by the concept of coordinates in a spacetime. A network serves as an organizing principle, even when the concept of the rigid body that anchors a special-relativistic coordinate system is inapplicable, as is the case, for example, in a generic curved spacetime.
This paper contributes to a burgeoning area of investigation, the ambiguity inherent in mathematics and the implications for physics of this ambiguity. To display the mathematical form of equations of quantum theory used to describe experiments, we make explicit the knobs by which the devices of an experiment are arranged and adjusted. A quantum description comes in two parts: (1) a statement of results of an experiment, expressed by probabilities of detections as functions of knob settings, and (2) an explanation of how we think these results come about, expressed by linear operators, also as functions of knob settings. Because quantum mechanics separates the two parts of any description, it is known that between the statements of results and the explanations lurks a logical gap: given any statement of results one has a choice of explanations. Here we work out some consequences of this openness to choice. We show how quantum theory as mathematical language in which to describe experiments necessarily involves multiple descriptions: multiple explanations of a given result, as well as multiple statements of results and multiple arrangement of knobs. Appreciating these multiplicities resolves what otherwise is a confusion in the concept of invariance. Implications of multiplicity of description for the security of quantum key distribution are noted.
The concept of entanglement is at the heart of quantum physics.It plays a central role in all quantum phenomena involving composite systems.Interestingly, there is an intriguing idea that has attracted considerable attention recently, according to which quantum entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very emergence of time and dynamical evolution.Within this point of view, sometimes referred to as the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, the Universe is regarded as consisting of a clock and a system (or "rest of the Universe") that are jointly in a stationary quantum state, and time evolution arises as an emergent phenomenon rooted at the entanglement between the clock and the system.Here we provide a pedagogical and self-contained exposition, at the upper undergraduate level, of the role of entanglement in this timeless evolution approach to quantum mechanics.In particular, we give a detailed explanation of how the entanglement between the clock and the system is directly and quantitatively related to the average distinguishability between the states of the system at different times.
Relativity and quantum mechanics each contain a quantity that no experiment can fix: the simultaneity of distant events and the phase of a quantum state. They are usually discussed in separate literatures. We revisit them together, starting from a structural fact: in a stationary frame a resynchronization of clocks, t → t + f(x), acts on a state of energy ω as the local phase exp(iωf), with the same structure as an electromagnetic gauge transformation, energy playing the role of charge. For a charged clock the two freedoms combine into a single connection. We then follow two routes. Keeping time as an external coordinate, we ask how the convention is distributed: in rotating interferometers with electrostatic potentials varying along the paths, only the total holonomy and the Sagnac delay are invariant, and the attribution of the phase to the rotation or to the field is conventional. Treating time as a relation between quantum systems, in the Page–Wootters framework, we ask why distant simultaneity is conventional: the relative reading of two clocks is observable only under a joint constraint, i.e. after an exchange of energy. The two routes converge on a single statement: between separated systems, only what is closed is physical, either geometrically, by a loop, or dynamically, by an exchange; offsets and splittings that refer to open separations are conventional. No new prediction is claimed; all statements are checked against the standard field equations.