Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Question order experimental constraints on quantum-like models of judgement

Patrick Cassam‐Chenaï

Published Mar 29, 2016• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In this paper, we extend the critical approach of Boyer-Kassem et al. (Boyer-Kassem, Thomas, Duchêne , Sbastien, Guerci Eric (2016), " Testing quantum-like models of judgment for question order effect " , Mathematical Social Sciences 80: 33-46.) to degenerate quantum models.

Related papers

Testing Quantum-like Models of Judgment for Question Order Effects

Thomas Boyer‐Kassem, Sébastien Duchêne, Éric Guerci

Lately, so-called 'quantum models' based on parts of the mathematics of quantum mechanics, have been developed in decision theory and cognitive sciences to account for seemingly irrational or paradoxical human judgments. In this paper, we limit ourselves to such quantum-like models that address order effects. It has been argued that such models are able to account for existing and new empirical data, and meet some a priori predictions. From the quantum law of reciprocity, we derive new empirical predictions that we call the Grand Reciprocity equations, that must be satisfied by quantum-like models on the condition that they are non-degenerate. We show that existing non-degenerate quantum-like models for order effects fail this test on several existing data sets. We take it to suggest that degenerate quantum-like models should be the focus of forthcoming research in the area.

•Jan 1, 2015•10 citations

A Brief Comment on Some Recent Evaluations by Basieva and Khrennikov, Wang et al., Boyer-Kassem et al., on Order Effects in Quantum Cognition

Elio Conte

A brief comment is introduced about some recent elaborations of some authors relating the question of the order effects in experiments on quantum cognition.

NeuroQuantology•May 29, 2015•4 citations

Testing quantum-like models of judgment for question order effect

Thomas Boyer‐Kassem, Sébastien Duchêne, Éric Guerci

arXiv:1501.04901•Mathematical Social Sciences•Feb 13, 2016•31 citations

Are Quantum Models for Order Effects Quantum?

Catarina Moreira, Andreas Wichert

arXiv:1706.05080•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•May 24, 2017•7 citations

A Quantum Question Order Model Supported by Empirical Tests of anA Prioriand Precise Prediction

Zheng Wang, Jerome R. Busemeyer

Question order effects are commonly observed in self-report measures of judgment and attitude. This article develops a quantum question order model (the QQ model) to account for four types of question order effects observed in literature. First, the postulates of the QQ model are presented. Second, an a priori, parameter-free, and precise prediction, called the QQ equality, is derived from these mathematical principles, and six empirical data sets are used to test the prediction. Third, a new index is derived from the model to measure similarity between questions. Fourth, we show that in contrast to the QQ model, Bayesian and Markov models do not generally satisfy the QQ equality and thus cannot account for the reported empirical data that support this equality. Finally, we describe the conditions under which order effects are predicted to occur, and we review a broader range of findings that are encompassed by these very same quantum principles. We conclude that quantum probability theory, initially invented to explain order effects on measurements in physics, appears to be a powerful natural explanation for order effects of self-report measures in social and behavioral sciences, too.

Topics in Cognitive Science•Sep 11, 2013•235 citations

New Empirical Tests of a Quantum Model for Question Order Effects

Zheng Wang, Tyler Solloway, Jerome R. Busemeyer

Recent findings show that human inferences and decisions interfere in ways analogous to incompatible quantum observables, and conceptual judgments are inseparable in ways similar to entangled quantum states.This discovery has led a group of physicists and psychologists to form a new field called "quantum cognition," which uses mathematical principles of quantum theory to explain human cognitive behavior.The power of this new theoretical approach is illustrated here by testing an a priori and precise prediction derived from quantum theory regarding question order effects commonly observed in survey research.The test of quantum theory was statistically satisfied across a set of 26 national surveys on presidential job approval and country satisfaction in past 10 years.These results suggest that quantum theory, initially invented to explain order effects on measurements in physics, provides a powerful prediction for measurement order effects in social and behavioral sciences too.

Cognitive Science•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation
Lately, so-called 'quantum models' based on parts of the mathematics of quantum mechanics, have been developed in decision theory and cognitive sciences to account for seemingly irrational or paradoxical human judgments. In this paper, we limit ourselves to such quantum-like models that address order effects. It has been argued that such models are able to account for existing and new empirical data, and meet some a priori predictions. From the quantum law of reciprocity, we derive new empirical predictions that we call the Grand Reciprocity equations, that must be satisfied by quantum-like models on the condition that they are non-degenerate. We show that existing non-degenerate quantum-like models for order effects fail this test on several existing data sets. We take it to suggest that degenerate quantum-like models should be the focus of forthcoming research in the area.
Question order effects are commonly observed in self-report measures of judgment and attitude. This article develops a quantum question order model (the QQ model) to account for four types of question order effects observed in literature. First, the postulates of the QQ model are presented. Second, an a priori, parameter-free, and precise prediction, called the QQ equality, is derived from these mathematical principles, and six empirical data sets are used to test the prediction. Third, a new index is derived from the model to measure similarity between questions. Fourth, we show that in contrast to the QQ model, Bayesian and Markov models do not generally satisfy the QQ equality and thus cannot account for the reported empirical data that support this equality. Finally, we describe the conditions under which order effects are predicted to occur, and we review a broader range of findings that are encompassed by these very same quantum principles. We conclude that quantum probability theory, initially invented to explain order effects on measurements in physics, appears to be a powerful natural explanation for order effects of self-report measures in social and behavioral sciences, too.
Recent findings show that human inferences and decisions interfere in ways analogous to incompatible quantum observables, and conceptual judgments are inseparable in ways similar to entangled quantum states.This discovery has led a group of physicists and psychologists to form a new field called "quantum cognition," which uses mathematical principles of quantum theory to explain human cognitive behavior.The power of this new theoretical approach is illustrated here by testing an a priori and precise prediction derived from quantum theory regarding question order effects commonly observed in survey research.The test of quantum theory was statistically satisfied across a set of 26 national surveys on presidential job approval and country satisfaction in past 10 years.These results suggest that quantum theory, initially invented to explain order effects on measurements in physics, provides a powerful prediction for measurement order effects in social and behavioral sciences too.