Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Physics

Axioms for the Boltzmann Distribution

Adam M. Brandenburger, Kai Steverson

Published May 1, 2019• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A fundamental postulate of statistical mechanics is that all microstates in an isolated system are equally probable. This postulate, which goes back to Boltzmann, has often been criticized for not having a clear physical foundation. In this note, we provide a derivation of the canonical (Boltzmann) distribution that avoids this postulate. In its place, we impose two axioms with physical interpretations. The first axiom (thermal equilibrium) ensures that, as our system of interest comes into contact with different heat baths, the ranking of states of the system by probability is unchanged. Physically, this axiom is a statement that in thermal equilibrium, population inversions do not arise. The second axiom (energy exchange) requires that, for any heat bath and any probability distribution on states, there is a universe consisting of a system and heat bath that can achieve this distribution. Physically, this axiom is a statement that energy flows between system and heat bath are unrestricted. We show that our two axioms identify the Boltzmann distribution.

DOI
10.1007/s10701-019-00257-z

Related papers

A REMARK ON BOLTZMANN H THEOREM

CHANG TSUNG-SDEI, 中国科学院数学研究所,北京师范大学物理系

It is pointed out that the quantum-mechanical Boltzmann H theorem in the restricted sense (i.e. with explicit consideration of the statistics of the particles constituting the system and their interactions) does not lead directly to the distribution laws for the particles among their various states as is commonly believed, but to the equality of the probability for all states belonging to the system as a whole if the system is isolated, (or to the Boltzmann factor for the probabilities of states belonging to a system at constant temperature), in agreement with the result of the generalized quantum-mechanical H theorem as given by Pauli. The distribution laws for the particles among their various states may of course be deduced from the latter.In the course of proof, we have also introduced the following minor improvements:(i) To avoid conservation of energy in microscopic processes which lead to changes in the states of the particles and thus to equilibrium, we let our system be in interaction with a heat reservoir, so that energy may be supplied by or given to it. This is tauto-mount to changing the study of the entropy for an isolated system to that of the free energy for a system at constant temperature.(ii) Interaction energies between the particles which affect the total energy of the system and thus the distribution laws for the particles among their various states are included.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 1954•2 citations

From Quantum Dynamics to the Canonical Distribution: General Picture and a Rigorous Example

Hal Tasaki

Derivation of the canonical (or Boltzmann) distribution based only on quantum dynamics is discussed. Consider a closed system which consists of a mutually interacting subsystem and a heat bath, and assume that the whole system is initially in a pure state (which can be far from equilibrium) with small energy fluctuation. Under the ``hypothesis of equal weights for eigenstates,'' we derive the canonical distribution in the sense that, at sufficiently large and typical time, the (instantaneous) quantum mechanical expectation value of an arbitrary operator of the subsystem is almost equal to the desired canonical expectation value. We present a class of examples in which the above derivation can be rigorously established without any unproven hypotheses.

arXiv:cond-mat/9707253•Physical Review Letters•Feb 16, 1998•426 citations

Analysis of Absolute Temperature and Thermal Equilibrium: From Classical Axioms to Quantum and Statistical Frontiers

Raja Ram M

A system, or a set of systems, is said to be in thermal equilibrium when no net flow of heat energy occurs between its constituent parts when they are connected by a path permeable to heat (a diathermal wall).1 This condition is the endpoint of a spontaneous process: if two bodies at different temperatures are brought into thermal contact, energy will flow from the higher-temperature object to the lower-temperature object until this flow ceases and the equilibrium state is achieved.3 Within a single system, thermal equilibrium is characterized by a temperature that is both spatially uniform (the same at all points) and temporally constant (unchanging over time).4 This uniformity of macroscopic properties—such as temperature and pressure—is what defines the state of the system.1 It is important to distinguish this from the broader state of thermodynamic equilibrium. Thermal equilibrium (uniform temperature) is a necessary component, but full thermodynamic equilibrium also requires mechanical equilibrium (uniform pressure) and diffusive equilibrium (uniform chemical potential).6 Systems can achieve thermal equilibrium without achieving full thermodynamic equilibrium.6 The Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics: The "Discovery" of Temperature The concept of temperature, while intuitive, requires a formal physical principle to exist as a measurable, fundamental property. This principle is the Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics. Although it was formulated and named after the First and Second Laws, its foundational role was recognized as a logical prerequisite for the entire structure of thermodynamics.8 The law states: If system A is in thermal equilibrium with system C, and system B is in thermal equilibrium with system C, then systems A and B are in thermal equilibrium with each other.1 In this construction, system C plays the role of a thermometer.13 The profound implication of this law is mathematical: it establishes thermal equilibrium as a transitive relation 9, or more formally, an equivalence relation.14 In mathematics, any equivalence relation partitioning a set of objects implies the existence of a common, scalar property shared by all members of a given equivalence class. The Zeroth Law thus proves the existence of a scalar function of state—a property we call temperature—that is common to all systems in mutual thermal equilibrium.9 The law is, therefore, the fundamental basis for defining temperature and building consistent, reproducible temperature scales.1 This axiomatic foundation also provides the logical origin for one of temperature's most critical characteristics: it is an intensive property. An intensive property is one that does not depend on the size or amount of the system.15 If a large system 'A' is in internal thermal equilibrium 6, any two parts of it, subsystems 'A1' and 'A2', must also be in thermal equilibrium with each other. By the Zeroth Law, a thermometer 'C' that is in thermal equilibrium with the whole system 'A' must also be in thermal equilibrium with 'A1' and 'A2' individually.13 The thermometer, therefore, gives the same reading for all three. This demonstrates that the temperature of a system in thermal equilibrium is the same as the temperature of any part of it.16

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

The Critical Analysis of the Foundations of Statistical Physics. 1. Boltzmann Distribution

Temur Z. Kalanov

Abstract. Modern analysis of the Boltzmann distribution on the basis of probability theory and of Gibbs quantum canonical distribution is proposed. It is shown that the Boltzmann distribution function is neither a reliable result of probability theory nor a consequence of Gibbs quantum canonical distribution. Conclusion is that the Boltzmann distribution function has no statistical and physical meaning, and the concept “Boltzmann distribution” should be abolished.

•Jun 1, 2017•0 citations

Quantum Wave Probability Derive Thermodynamic Distribution

li xiao lin

Using the concept of quantum wave probability, combined with the identity principle, we can derive the Boltzmann distribution, Fermi distribution, and Bose distribution. Different distributions correspond to different conditions. The Boltzmann condition corresponds to the Boltzmann distribution. The Fermi condition corresponds to the Fermi distribution. The Bose condition corresponds to the Bose distribution. This demonstrates that the foundation of these three statistical distributions is quantum wave probability, all originating from quantum mechanics. The Boltzmann distribution is also an independent quantum distribution and is not simply a sparse limit of the Fermi or Bose distributions. The essence of the Boltzmann distribution is a uniform distribution. The Fermi and Bose distributions are deviations from the uniform distribution. Boltzmann entropy based on the quantum wave probability can resolve the Gibbs paradox. Using this new approach, we can also derive the results of eigenstate thermalization. The equilibrium state is the state in which all eigenstates have the same temperatures. We need to rethink the fundamentals of statistical mechanics.

•Jan 20, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Wave Probability Derive Thermodynamic Distribution

Xiaolin Li

Using the concept of quantum wave probability, combined with the identity principle, we can derive the Boltzmann distribution, Fermi distribution, and Bose distribution. Different distributions correspond to different conditions. The Boltzmann condition corresponds to the Boltzmann distribution. The Fermi condition corresponds to the Fermi distribution. The Bose condition corresponds to the Bose distribution. This demonstrates that the foundation of these three statistical distributions is quantum wave probability, all originating from quantum mechanics. The Boltzmann distribution is also an independent quantum distribution and is not simply a sparse limit of the Fermi or Bose distributions. The essence of the Boltzmann distribution is a uniform distribution. The Fermi and Bose distributions are deviations from the uniform distribution. Boltzmann entropy based on the quantum wave probability can resolve the Gibbs paradox. Using this new approach, we can also derive the results of eigenstate thermalization. The equilibrium state is the state in which all eigenstates have the same temperature. We need to rethink the fundamentals of statistical mechanics.

Journal of High Energy Physics Gravitation and Cosmology•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
A fundamental postulate of statistical mechanics is that all microstates in an isolated system are equally probable. This postulate, which goes back to Boltzmann, has often been criticized for not having a clear physical foundation. In this note, we provide a derivation of the canonical (Boltzmann) distribution that avoids this postulate. In its place, we impose two axioms with physical interpretations. The first axiom (thermal equilibrium) ensures that, as our system of interest comes into contact with different heat baths, the ranking of states of the system by probability is unchanged. Physically, this axiom is a statement that in thermal equilibrium, population inversions do not arise. The second axiom (energy exchange) requires that, for any heat bath and any probability distribution on states, there is a universe consisting of a system and heat bath that can achieve this distribution. Physically, this axiom is a statement that energy flows between system and heat bath are unrestricted. We show that our two axioms identify the Boltzmann distribution.
It is pointed out that the quantum-mechanical Boltzmann H theorem in the restricted sense (i.e. with explicit consideration of the statistics of the particles constituting the system and their interactions) does not lead directly to the distribution laws for the particles among their various states as is commonly believed, but to the equality of the probability for all states belonging to the system as a whole if the system is isolated, (or to the Boltzmann factor for the probabilities of states belonging to a system at constant temperature), in agreement with the result of the generalized quantum-mechanical H theorem as given by Pauli. The distribution laws for the particles among their various states may of course be deduced from the latter.In the course of proof, we have also introduced the following minor improvements:(i) To avoid conservation of energy in microscopic processes which lead to changes in the states of the particles and thus to equilibrium, we let our system be in interaction with a heat reservoir, so that energy may be supplied by or given to it. This is tauto-mount to changing the study of the entropy for an isolated system to that of the free energy for a system at constant temperature.(ii) Interaction energies between the particles which affect the total energy of the system and thus the distribution laws for the particles among their various states are included.
Derivation of the canonical (or Boltzmann) distribution based only on quantum dynamics is discussed. Consider a closed system which consists of a mutually interacting subsystem and a heat bath, and assume that the whole system is initially in a pure state (which can be far from equilibrium) with small energy fluctuation. Under the ``hypothesis of equal weights for eigenstates,'' we derive the canonical distribution in the sense that, at sufficiently large and typical time, the (instantaneous) quantum mechanical expectation value of an arbitrary operator of the subsystem is almost equal to the desired canonical expectation value. We present a class of examples in which the above derivation can be rigorously established without any unproven hypotheses.
A system, or a set of systems, is said to be in thermal equilibrium when no net flow of heat energy occurs between its constituent parts when they are connected by a path permeable to heat (a diathermal wall).1 This condition is the endpoint of a spontaneous process: if two bodies at different temperatures are brought into thermal contact, energy will flow from the higher-temperature object to the lower-temperature object until this flow ceases and the equilibrium state is achieved.3 Within a single system, thermal equilibrium is characterized by a temperature that is both spatially uniform (the same at all points) and temporally constant (unchanging over time).4 This uniformity of macroscopic properties—such as temperature and pressure—is what defines the state of the system.1 It is important to distinguish this from the broader state of thermodynamic equilibrium. Thermal equilibrium (uniform temperature) is a necessary component, but full thermodynamic equilibrium also requires mechanical equilibrium (uniform pressure) and diffusive equilibrium (uniform chemical potential).6 Systems can achieve thermal equilibrium without achieving full thermodynamic equilibrium.6 The Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics: The "Discovery" of Temperature The concept of temperature, while intuitive, requires a formal physical principle to exist as a measurable, fundamental property. This principle is the Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics. Although it was formulated and named after the First and Second Laws, its foundational role was recognized as a logical prerequisite for the entire structure of thermodynamics.8 The law states: If system A is in thermal equilibrium with system C, and system B is in thermal equilibrium with system C, then systems A and B are in thermal equilibrium with each other.1 In this construction, system C plays the role of a thermometer.13 The profound implication of this law is mathematical: it establishes thermal equilibrium as a transitive relation 9, or more formally, an equivalence relation.14 In mathematics, any equivalence relation partitioning a set of objects implies the existence of a common, scalar property shared by all members of a given equivalence class. The Zeroth Law thus proves the existence of a scalar function of state—a property we call temperature—that is common to all systems in mutual thermal equilibrium.9 The law is, therefore, the fundamental basis for defining temperature and building consistent, reproducible temperature scales.1 This axiomatic foundation also provides the logical origin for one of temperature's most critical characteristics: it is an intensive property. An intensive property is one that does not depend on the size or amount of the system.15 If a large system 'A' is in internal thermal equilibrium 6, any two parts of it, subsystems 'A1' and 'A2', must also be in thermal equilibrium with each other. By the Zeroth Law, a thermometer 'C' that is in thermal equilibrium with the whole system 'A' must also be in thermal equilibrium with 'A1' and 'A2' individually.13 The thermometer, therefore, gives the same reading for all three. This demonstrates that the temperature of a system in thermal equilibrium is the same as the temperature of any part of it.16
Using the concept of quantum wave probability, combined with the identity principle, we can derive the Boltzmann distribution, Fermi distribution, and Bose distribution. Different distributions correspond to different conditions. The Boltzmann condition corresponds to the Boltzmann distribution. The Fermi condition corresponds to the Fermi distribution. The Bose condition corresponds to the Bose distribution. This demonstrates that the foundation of these three statistical distributions is quantum wave probability, all originating from quantum mechanics. The Boltzmann distribution is also an independent quantum distribution and is not simply a sparse limit of the Fermi or Bose distributions. The essence of the Boltzmann distribution is a uniform distribution. The Fermi and Bose distributions are deviations from the uniform distribution. Boltzmann entropy based on the quantum wave probability can resolve the Gibbs paradox. Using this new approach, we can also derive the results of eigenstate thermalization. The equilibrium state is the state in which all eigenstates have the same temperatures. We need to rethink the fundamentals of statistical mechanics.
Using the concept of quantum wave probability, combined with the identity principle, we can derive the Boltzmann distribution, Fermi distribution, and Bose distribution. Different distributions correspond to different conditions. The Boltzmann condition corresponds to the Boltzmann distribution. The Fermi condition corresponds to the Fermi distribution. The Bose condition corresponds to the Bose distribution. This demonstrates that the foundation of these three statistical distributions is quantum wave probability, all originating from quantum mechanics. The Boltzmann distribution is also an independent quantum distribution and is not simply a sparse limit of the Fermi or Bose distributions. The essence of the Boltzmann distribution is a uniform distribution. The Fermi and Bose distributions are deviations from the uniform distribution. Boltzmann entropy based on the quantum wave probability can resolve the Gibbs paradox. Using this new approach, we can also derive the results of eigenstate thermalization. The equilibrium state is the state in which all eigenstates have the same temperature. We need to rethink the fundamentals of statistical mechanics.