Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Globecom Workshops (GC Wkshps)

Reciprocity for Physical Layer Security with Wireless FDD and in Wireline Communications

Werner Henkel, Oana Graur, Nazia Islam, Uwe Pagel, Navdeep Manak, Onur Can

Published Dec 1, 2018• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The reciprocity of the channel transfer functions between legitimate users changing randomly delivers the common randomness used in physical-layer key generation. Time-Division Duplexing (TDD) provides this symmetry of the bidirectional channel measurements, despite of uncorrelated noise on both sides and possible hardware imperfections. We now show that also Frequency-Division Duplexing (FDD) yields a usable symmetry as far as the direction of arrival is concerned. Even in wireline communications, be it over power lines or twisted pairs, transfer and far-end crosstalk functions provide useful symmetries, where especially key generation for power line communication may become important for IoT applications.

DOI
10.1109/glocomw.2018.8644261

Related papers

Common Randomness for Physical-Layer Key Generation in Power-Line Transmission

Werner Henkel, Abderraheem M. Turjman, Hayoung Kim +1 more

Physical layer key generation is based on reciprocal channels providing common randomness, which was so far known from TDD wireless channels. This paper opens the door to wireline physical-layer security, especially focusing on power-line connections. Additionally to the known reciprocity, we now also provide randomization by terminating idle branching connections (e.g., empty sockets) with random (reactive) loads. Alternatively, unused pairs at the power-line modem's end may be terminated by random (reactive) loads. Simulation and measurement results are shown. We also indicate, how the actual key generation can be realized by quantizing a frequency range and using the position of notches of the transfer function or of transmission coefficients selecting a quantization interval and with it a binary label as a key segment. Key reconciliation can simply be realized by a publicly announced shift of the quantization grid. Applications are seen for in-home and industrial devices required to exchange data over the power-line network securely.

International Conference on Communications•Jun 1, 2020•16 citations

A Simple Physical-Layer Key Generation for Frequency-Division Duplexing (FDD)

Werner Henkel, Maria Namachanja

Common randomness of channels offers the possibility to create cryptographic keys without the need for a key exchange procedure. Channel reciprocity for TDD (time-division duplexing) systems has been used for this purpose many times. FDD (frequency-division duplexing) systems, however, were long considered to not provide any usable symmetry. However, since the scattering transmission parameters S12and S21would ideally be the same due to reciprocity, when using neighboring frequency ranges for both directions, they would just follow a continuous curve when putting them next to each other. To not rely on absolute phase, we use phase differences between antennas and apply a polynomial curve fitting, thereafter, quantize the midpoint between the two frequency ranges with the two measurement directions. This is shown to work even with some spacing between the two bands. For key reconciliation, we force the measurement point from one direction to be in the midpoint of the quantization interval by a grid shift (or likewise measurement data shift). Since the histogram over the quantization intervals does not follow a uniform distribution, some source coding / hashing will be necessary. The key disagreement rate toward an eavesdropper was found to be close to 0.5. Additionally, when using an antenna array, a random permutation of antenna measurements can even further improve the protection against eavesdropping.

International Conference on Signal Processing and Communication Systems•Dec 13, 2021•8 citations

Exploiting FDD Channel Reciprocity for Physical Layer Secret Key Generation in IoT Networks

Ehsan Olyaei Torshizi, Werner Henkel

The utilization of physical layer Secret Key Generation (SKG) is increasingly prevalent in securing wireless communication within Internet of Things systems, particularly in Narrow-band IoT. While most key-generation schemes are tailored for Time Division Duplex (TDD) systems, generating secret keys in Frequency Division Duplex (FDD) systems presents challenges due to the distinct frequency bands for uplink and downlink. In response to this, we propose an efficient FDD-based key generation technique that capitalizes on the reciprocity of scattering matrix parametersS12andS21within the same frequency range. Specifically, we harness the capabilities of MUSIC algorithm during the direction of arrival estimation phase. Numerical results demonstrate promising outcomes in addressing key challenges, including randomness, and Key Disagreement Ratio (KDR).

IEEE Communications Letters•Apr 12, 2024•23 citations

Circular Shifting-Based Secure Key Generation for FDD Wireless Systems

Mehmet Ali Aygül, Ebubekir Memişoğlu, Hakan Ali Çırpan +1 more

Wireless channel-based secret key generation (SKG) exploits channel reciprocity in time division duplexing (TDD) systems for symmetric key extraction. In frequency division duplexing (FDD), the lack of reciprocity requires multiple exchanges, exposing channel information to eavesdroppers. To mitigate this, we propose a circular shifting-based physical-layer method for FDD-SKG, where pilot sequences are circularly shifted and transmitted. This adds randomness, improves security, and remains lightweight. In addition, the letter presents a unified theoretical analysis of wireless channel-based SKG performance in both TDD and FDD systems, deriving key mismatch probability and key generation rate. Simulation results validate the proposed method’s security, confirm key randomness through the National Institute of Standards and Technology Statistical Test Suite, and validate the theoretical analyses.

IEEE Wireless Communications Letters•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

CSI-Driven Physical Layer Secret Key Generation for FDD Systems

Ehsan Olyaei Torshizi, Anas Alashqar, Werner Henkel

Physical Layer Secret Key Generation (PLSKG), which utilizes wireless channel reciprocity, is increasingly adopted to secure wireless communications. In Time Division Duplexing (TDD) systems, the inherent channel reciprocity facilitates the generation of cryptographic keys without requiring a key exchange process. Conversely, Frequency Division Duplexing (FDD) systems present greater challenges for key generation due to the use of distinct frequency bands for uplink and downlink, resulting in differing frequency responses. In this paper, we address this challenge by modeling the channel along with connecting cables as a two-port network and utilizing the reciprocity principles applicable to such networks within the same frequency range. For key generation, we construct the channel profile for each FDD band by utilizing the amplitude of the bidirectional scattering parameters S12and S21in two closely spaced FDD bands, thereby ensuring the required reciprocity in FDD systems. To assess the practicality of the proposed scheme, we analyze its performance across various indoor scenarios and compare it with other key generation schemes using multiple performance indicators. The comparative results confirm the feasibility and effectiveness of our scheme in terms of randomness and key disagreement ratio.

IEEE International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications (PIMRC)•Sep 1, 2025•0 citations

A Simulation and Experimental Study of Channel Reciprocity in TDD and FDD Wiretap Channels

Li Yao, Linning Peng, Guyue Li +2 more

In recent years, secret key generation based on physical layer security has gradually attracted high attentions. The wireless channel reciprocity and eavesdropping attack are critical problems in secret key generation studies. In this paper, we carry out a simulation and experimental study of channel reciprocity in terms of measuring channel state information (CSI) in both time division duplexing (TDD) and frequency division duplexing (FDD) modes. In simulation study, a close eavesdropping wiretap channel model is introduced to evaluate the security of the CSI by using Pearson correlation coefficient. In experimental study, an indoor wireless CSI measurement system is built with N210 and X310 universal software radio peripheral (USRP) platforms. In TDD mode, theoretical analysis and most of experimental results show that the closer eavesdropping distance, the higher CSI correlation coefficient between eavesdropping channel and legitimate channel. However, in actual environment, when eavesdropping distance is too close (less than 1/4 wavelength), this CSI correlation seriously dropped. In FDD mode, both theoretical analysis and experimental results show that the wireless channel still owns some reciprocity. When frequency interval increases, the FDD channel reciprocity in actual environment is better than that in theoretical analysis.

IEEE International Conference on Communication Technology (ICCT)•Oct 1, 2019•4 citations
The reciprocity of the channel transfer functions between legitimate users changing randomly delivers the common randomness used in physical-layer key generation. Time-Division Duplexing (TDD) provides this symmetry of the bidirectional channel measurements, despite of uncorrelated noise on both sides and possible hardware imperfections. We now show that also Frequency-Division Duplexing (FDD) yields a usable symmetry as far as the direction of arrival is concerned. Even in wireline communications, be it over power lines or twisted pairs, transfer and far-end crosstalk functions provide useful symmetries, where especially key generation for power line communication may become important for IoT applications.
Physical layer key generation is based on reciprocal channels providing common randomness, which was so far known from TDD wireless channels. This paper opens the door to wireline physical-layer security, especially focusing on power-line connections. Additionally to the known reciprocity, we now also provide randomization by terminating idle branching connections (e.g., empty sockets) with random (reactive) loads. Alternatively, unused pairs at the power-line modem's end may be terminated by random (reactive) loads. Simulation and measurement results are shown. We also indicate, how the actual key generation can be realized by quantizing a frequency range and using the position of notches of the transfer function or of transmission coefficients selecting a quantization interval and with it a binary label as a key segment. Key reconciliation can simply be realized by a publicly announced shift of the quantization grid. Applications are seen for in-home and industrial devices required to exchange data over the power-line network securely.
Common randomness of channels offers the possibility to create cryptographic keys without the need for a key exchange procedure. Channel reciprocity for TDD (time-division duplexing) systems has been used for this purpose many times. FDD (frequency-division duplexing) systems, however, were long considered to not provide any usable symmetry. However, since the scattering transmission parameters S12and S21would ideally be the same due to reciprocity, when using neighboring frequency ranges for both directions, they would just follow a continuous curve when putting them next to each other. To not rely on absolute phase, we use phase differences between antennas and apply a polynomial curve fitting, thereafter, quantize the midpoint between the two frequency ranges with the two measurement directions. This is shown to work even with some spacing between the two bands. For key reconciliation, we force the measurement point from one direction to be in the midpoint of the quantization interval by a grid shift (or likewise measurement data shift). Since the histogram over the quantization intervals does not follow a uniform distribution, some source coding / hashing will be necessary. The key disagreement rate toward an eavesdropper was found to be close to 0.5. Additionally, when using an antenna array, a random permutation of antenna measurements can even further improve the protection against eavesdropping.
The utilization of physical layer Secret Key Generation (SKG) is increasingly prevalent in securing wireless communication within Internet of Things systems, particularly in Narrow-band IoT. While most key-generation schemes are tailored for Time Division Duplex (TDD) systems, generating secret keys in Frequency Division Duplex (FDD) systems presents challenges due to the distinct frequency bands for uplink and downlink. In response to this, we propose an efficient FDD-based key generation technique that capitalizes on the reciprocity of scattering matrix parametersS12andS21within the same frequency range. Specifically, we harness the capabilities of MUSIC algorithm during the direction of arrival estimation phase. Numerical results demonstrate promising outcomes in addressing key challenges, including randomness, and Key Disagreement Ratio (KDR).
Wireless channel-based secret key generation (SKG) exploits channel reciprocity in time division duplexing (TDD) systems for symmetric key extraction. In frequency division duplexing (FDD), the lack of reciprocity requires multiple exchanges, exposing channel information to eavesdroppers. To mitigate this, we propose a circular shifting-based physical-layer method for FDD-SKG, where pilot sequences are circularly shifted and transmitted. This adds randomness, improves security, and remains lightweight. In addition, the letter presents a unified theoretical analysis of wireless channel-based SKG performance in both TDD and FDD systems, deriving key mismatch probability and key generation rate. Simulation results validate the proposed method’s security, confirm key randomness through the National Institute of Standards and Technology Statistical Test Suite, and validate the theoretical analyses.
Physical Layer Secret Key Generation (PLSKG), which utilizes wireless channel reciprocity, is increasingly adopted to secure wireless communications. In Time Division Duplexing (TDD) systems, the inherent channel reciprocity facilitates the generation of cryptographic keys without requiring a key exchange process. Conversely, Frequency Division Duplexing (FDD) systems present greater challenges for key generation due to the use of distinct frequency bands for uplink and downlink, resulting in differing frequency responses. In this paper, we address this challenge by modeling the channel along with connecting cables as a two-port network and utilizing the reciprocity principles applicable to such networks within the same frequency range. For key generation, we construct the channel profile for each FDD band by utilizing the amplitude of the bidirectional scattering parameters S12and S21in two closely spaced FDD bands, thereby ensuring the required reciprocity in FDD systems. To assess the practicality of the proposed scheme, we analyze its performance across various indoor scenarios and compare it with other key generation schemes using multiple performance indicators. The comparative results confirm the feasibility and effectiveness of our scheme in terms of randomness and key disagreement ratio.
In recent years, secret key generation based on physical layer security has gradually attracted high attentions. The wireless channel reciprocity and eavesdropping attack are critical problems in secret key generation studies. In this paper, we carry out a simulation and experimental study of channel reciprocity in terms of measuring channel state information (CSI) in both time division duplexing (TDD) and frequency division duplexing (FDD) modes. In simulation study, a close eavesdropping wiretap channel model is introduced to evaluate the security of the CSI by using Pearson correlation coefficient. In experimental study, an indoor wireless CSI measurement system is built with N210 and X310 universal software radio peripheral (USRP) platforms. In TDD mode, theoretical analysis and most of experimental results show that the closer eavesdropping distance, the higher CSI correlation coefficient between eavesdropping channel and legitimate channel. However, in actual environment, when eavesdropping distance is too close (less than 1/4 wavelength), this CSI correlation seriously dropped. In FDD mode, both theoretical analysis and experimental results show that the wireless channel still owns some reciprocity. When frequency interval increases, the FDD channel reciprocity in actual environment is better than that in theoretical analysis.