This chapter addresses the fundamental role of order parameters and symmetry breaking in characterizing phases and understanding phase transitions and argues that the origin of non-analyticity is in fact the thermodynamic limit. It explores the Landau definition that a transition is first order if the order parameter is discontinuous at the transition point and second order if it is continuous. The chapter presents a general theory which in leading approximation embodies the physics of the Landau function of the order parameter. The mean field theory may be applied quite generally to any system for which the local order parameter has been identified. Once the order parameter for Bose condensation is recognized, the order parameter for superconducting or superfluid transitions follow naturally. For superconducting metals, pairs of electrons at the Fermi surface form bound states which behave effectively as Bosons and thus undergo Bose condensation.
This chapter addresses the fundamental role of order parameters and symmetry breaking in characterizing phases and understanding phase transitions and argues that the origin of non-analyticity is in fact the thermodynamic limit. It explores the Landau definition that a transition is first order if the order parameter is discontinuous at the transition point and second order if it is continuous. The chapter presents a general theory which in leading approximation embodies the physics of the Landau function of the order parameter. The mean field theory may be applied quite generally to any system for which the local order parameter has been identified. Once the order parameter for Bose condensation is recognized, the order parameter for superconducting or superfluid transitions follow naturally. For superconducting metals, pairs of electrons at the Fermi surface form bound states which behave effectively as Bosons and thus undergo Bose condensation.
While analyzing second order thermodynamical phase transitions, Lev Landau (the famous Russian physicist) introduced a very vital concept, the concept of an "order parameter". This not only amalgamated the previous fragmentary theoretical understanding of phase transitions (an arsenal of mean-field theories) but also it put forward the important theory of "spontaneous symmetry breaking". Today, order parameter concept is a paradigm both in condensed matter physics and in high energy physics, and Landau theory is a pinnacle of all mean-field theories. Mean field theories are good qualitative descriptors of the phase transition behavior. But all mean-field theories (including Landau's theory) fail at the critical point (the problem of large correlation length). The problems with large correlation length in quantum many-body systems are the hardest problems known in theoretical physics (both in condensed matter and in particle physics). It was Ken Wilson's physical insights and his powerful mathematical skills that opened a way to the solution of such hard problems. This manuscript is a perspective on these issues. Starting with simple examples of phase transitions (like ice/water; diamond/graphite etc.) we address the following important questions: Why does non-analyticity (sharp phase transitions) arise when thermodynamical functions (i.e., free energies etc) are good analytic functions? How does Landau's program unify all the previous mean-field theories? Why do all the mean-field theories fail near the critical point? How does Wilson's program go beyond all the mean-field theories? What is the origin emergence and universality?
Abstract We have seen in the previous chapters that the concept of the macroscopic wave functionΨ(r), is central to understanding atomic Bose–Einstein condensates (BEC), superfluid He, and even superconductivity within the Ginzburg–Landau (GL) theory. But the connection between these ideas is not at all clear, since the atom condensates and He are bosonic systems, while super-conductivity is associated with the conduction electrons in metals which are fermions. The physical meaning of the GL order parameter was not explained until after 1957 when Bardeen Cooper and Schrieffer (BCS) published the first truly microscopic theory of superconductivity. Soon afterward the connection was finally established by Gor’ kov. He was able to show that, at least in the range of temperatures near Tc, the GL theory can indeed be derived from the BCS theory. Furthermore this provides a physical interpretation of the nature of the order parameter. Essentially it is describing a macroscopic wave function, or condensate, of Cooper pairs.
In this chapter we begin, in Section 9.1, by discussing in detail one of the most striking consequences of quantum statistics, the condensation of a noninteracting Bose gas. We next turn our attention (Section 9.2) to an interacting Bose system and to the phenomenon of superfluidity. Our treatment of this subject is limited mainly to low-temperature properties and is primarily qualitative. The first part of Section 9.3 is devoted to the Bardeen, Cooper, Schrieffer [24] (BCS) theory of superconductivity, in which fermion pairs undergo a transition that is similar to Bose condensation . We also consider the macroscopic theory of superconductivity due to Ginzburg and Landau. This approach is also applicable to the theory of superfluidity and briefly discussed in that context. We encountered the Landau–Ginzburg formalism previously in Sections 3.10 and 4.4. In the present context we use it to describe some of the important physical properties of superconductors and to indicate why the mean field approach of the BCS theory works so effectively . A useful general reference for much of the material of this chapter is Part 2 of the book by Landau and Lifshitz [141].
The Landau theory of phase and phase transition, which describes the state of matter by the spontaneous symmetry breaking, and the Fermi liquid theory of interacting Fermi systems are the two corner stones of contemporary condensed matter physics. They act as our starting points to understand the structure, excitations and phase transitions of any condensed matter system. According to such a Landau paradigm, an interacting Fermi system will behave just as non-interacting Fermi gas system at sufficient low energy, if the interaction is not strong enough to induce a symmetry breaking phase transition in the system. In such a case, the perturbation expansion in the interaction strength is assumed to converge and the low energy excitation can be connected to that of a Fermi gas system adiabatically. In strongly correlated electron systems, such as the high temperature superconductors and quantum antiferromagnets, a pertubative picture on the interaction effect usually fails. The correlation effect between the electrons can induce new forms of order that are beyond the Landau symmetry breaking paradigm. Non-Fermi liquid behavior can emerge in the fully symmetric correlated phases. The Mott insulating phase and the quantum spin liquid phase are the most prominent example of such exotic state of matter. After about three decades of intensive studies, people find that the quantum non-locality effect is at the heart of such new forms of order. The quantum non-locality effect manifests itself in the emergence of gauge degree of freedom in the low energy physics of such strongly correlated system. Such emergent gauge filed is not only important for the characterization and classification of the ground state structure, but is also directly responsible for the non-Fermi liquid behavior of the system. The Landau paradigm should be extended to accommodate such new forms of order and the related new form of excitations and new universal class of phase transitions. Such an extension will elevate our understanding of the structure of matter to the level of quantum wave function. Unlike the conventional symmetry breaking order, which is characterized by the correlation functions between local physical observables, the new form of orders, which are commonly called quantum order (with the topological order as one of its typical example), can be better characterized by the entanglement property in the quantum wave function. From a mathematical point of view, the new form of order is closely related to the projective representation theory of the symmetry group, while the conventional symmetry breaking order is well described by the linear representation theory of the symmetry group.
This and the four next chapters are devoted to the study of several aspects of the theory of phase transition. This has been for more than one century, and still remains, a subject of intense experimental and theoretical activity, with important breakthroughs having impacts on different fields in physics but also on other disciplines such as mathematics, economics, sociology, biology In the first section of this chapter, the transition between the ferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases of the Ising system will be studied in the framework of a mean field approximation. The problem will first be addressed by means of the intuitive Weiss molecular field approximation ( Section 9.1.2 ) and then by means of the more detailed Bragg-Williams approximation ( Section 9.1.3 ) which will serve as a base to develop, in Section 9.2 , a general theory of continuous phase transitions: the Landau mean field theory for which the concept of order parameter will first be introduced. Other types of phase transitions will then be studied using the mean field approximation. Phase transitions in liquid crystals will be studied in Section 9.3 . These are systems with a tensor order parameter which exhibit a rich phenomenology. Finally, in Section 9.4 , a transition of a fairly more elaborate nature than a simple first or second order phase transition will be discussed.
The Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson (LGW) paradigm is the backbone of the modern understanding of critical phenoma. It rests on the assumption that a continuous phase transition can be described solely in terms of a fluctuating order parameter. In this sandwich thesis, we analyze several quantum phase transitions in two-dimensional systems where this basic assumption is violated. Our analysis is structured in three parts: In the first part, two ordering transitions in metals are studied, where the presence of gapless fermionic modes invalidates the pure order parameter description. Instead, we apply a renormalization group approach which retains both fermionic and bosonic (order paramater) degrees of freedom, using the deviation from an upper critical dimension of d = 5/2 as a control parameter. We first apply this technique to describe the quantum phase transition between a normal metal and an inhomogeneous (FFLO) superconductor. Our analysis rigorously confirms the mean field expectation that this transition is continuous, and shows that interesting non-Fermi liquid physics can arise at the critical point, manifesting itself in unusual scaling of various observables. The second case study is the onset of incommensurate 2kF charge density wave order. While non-Fermi liquid features are less pronounced at this transition, we find a strong dynamical nesting of the Fermi surface, which stabilizes the density wave formation and results in a continuous transition, opposed to early theoretical claims. In the second part, we present a novel case study of “deconfined criticality” for a quantum magnet: Here, symmetries are broken on both sides of the phase transition, which would be first order within a conventional two-order-parameter LGW description. By contrast, the scenario of deconfined criticality predicts a continuous transition, driven by condensation of topological defects which carry quantum numbers of the opposite phase. Its paradigmatic application is the transition from a SU (2)-Neél state to a valence-bond solid (a singlet covering configuration that breaks spatial symmetries) on the square lattice. Here, we propose a novel extension and study a SU (3) antiferromagnet on a triangular lattice, which supports a transition between a magnetic, three-sublattice color-ordered phase and a trimerized SU (3) singlet phase. We provide a critical theory in terms of fractional bosonic degrees of freedom (and with a topological defect interpretation), and study its fixed point properties with functional renormalization group. This yields a critical fixed point in a suitable large-N -limit, implying a continuous transition in accordance with the deconfined criticality framework. In the third and final part, we study the “polaron”-problem of a single impurity coupled to a majority Fermi sea, which is particularly interesting when formation of a bound state (“molecule”) between impurity and majority is allowed for. Starting from the exactly solvable limit of infinite impurity mass, we present a controlled computation of impurity spectra (both single- and two-particle) for heavy impurities based on Feynman diagram techniques, with an eye for experiments on doped semiconductors and ultracold gases. Furthermore, we discuss various aspects of the “molecule-to-polaron” transition that occurs in these systems, which also defies a simple LGW description in the single-impurity limit.