Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics of Atomic Nuclei

Projection Evolution of Quantum States—the Delayed Choice Puzzle

Marek Góźdź, ANDRZEJ GÓŹDŹ, Alexander A. Gusev, Sergue Il'ich Vinitsky

Published Nov 1, 2018• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We discuss the problem of the time variable in the nearly standard formulation of the quantum mechanics. In order to be able to describe the outcome of some of the experiments, we have used a novel formulation of the time evolution of quantum states called the projection evolution. As an example a delayed-choice experiment is described. We show that this description recreates the experimental results without relaying on the spatial parts of the wave functions.

DOI
10.1134/s1063778818060157

Related papers

Projection evolution and delayed-choice experiments

ANDRZEJ GÓŹDŹ, K. Stefańska

A theoretical description of Wheeler's delayed-choice Gedankenexperiment is presented in the non-relativistic space-time in terms of quantum events. It turns out that the description, in which time is a dynamical variable, allows to explain the delayed-choice problem as a result of spread of quantum states in time.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2008•9 citations

Delayed Choice Phenomena in the Projection Evolution Model

Marek Góźdź, Andrzej Góźdź, Krzysztof Lider

In the Schrödinger evolution of a quantum state time enters as a real parameter representing the coordinate. In a more consistent approach time should be defined as a quantum observable, with the evolution taking place in a four-dimensional spacetime. This is possible in the projection evolution model in which the wave function is defined in both space and time. This allows to construct the time operator and discuss the temporal structure of quantum processes. In this paper we discuss a photon travelling through a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, focusing the description on the temporal profile of the wave function. We show that in this approach the delayed-choice experiments can be explained by the temporal overlap of the photon and the devices in the interferometer.

quant-pharXiv:2604.26716•Entropy•Apr 30, 2026•1 citation

Projection evolution of quantum states

ANDRZEJ GÓŹDŹ, Marek Góźdź, Aleksandra Pȩdrak

We discuss the problem of time in quantum mechanics. In the traditional formulation time enters the model as a parameter, not an observable, which follows from the famous Pauli theorem. It is now known, that Pauli's assumptions were too strong and that by removing some of them time can be represented as a quantum observable. In this case, instead of the unitary time evolution, other operators which map the space of initial states into the space of final states at each step of the evolution can be used. This allows to treat time as a quantum observable in a consistent way. We present the projection evolution model and show how the traditional Schroedinger evolution can be obtained from it. We propose the form of the time operator which satisfies the energy-time uncertainty relation. As an example, we discuss the temporal version of the double-slit experiment.

•Oct 24, 2019•2 citations

Delayed choice experiments, the arrow of time, and quantum measurement

Lawrence S. Schulman, Daniel P. Sheehan

By a radical modification of statistical mechanics the measurement process of quantum mechanics can be described in terms of pure, unitary time evolution, with no wave function collapse or many‐world ideas. The key notion is “special states,” rare microscopic states of a complex system. Recovering the standard probabilities requires of this theory the appearance of Cauchy‐distributed noise in some measurement processes. This article treats experimental situations where such noise might be detected and correlated with the need or absence of need for special states. Included in this possibility are “delayed choice” experiments, in which the correlation contravenes conventional ideas on causality. Background material on all topics is provided.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Causal Intuition and Delayed-Choice Experiments

Michael B. Heaney

The conventional explanation of delayed-choice experiments appears to violate our causal intuition at the quantum level. I reanalyze these experiments using time-reversed and time-symmetric formulations of quantum mechanics. The time-reversed formulation does not give the same experimental predictions. The time-symmetric formulation gives the same experimental predictions but actually violates our causal intuition at the quantum level. I explore the reasons why our causal intuition may be wrong at the quantum level, suggest how conventional causation might be recovered in the classical limit, propose a quantum analog to the classical block universe viewpoint, and speculate on implications of the time-symmetric formulation for cosmological boundary conditions.

arXiv:1409.6297•Entropy•Dec 26, 2020•3 citations

On Delay of the Delayed Choice Experiment

Jun Ying Sun, Yong-Nan Sun, Chuan‐Feng Li +1 more

Following a suggestion by Wheeler, several delayed choice experiments have been performed. However, in those experiments one fact has always been ignored: that due to the fact that the single photon is nonlocal in time, the outcome will change if one changes the time to switch the experimental configuration within the photon's wavepacket. This study obtains some insights into this aspect by proposing an experimental scheme based on the delayed choice experiment and giving some related analysis. The result shows a transitional behavior from a particle to a wave, leading to a conclusion that the measuring operator could be time dependent and be changed in a single measurement.

Chinese Physics Letters•Sep 1, 2015•3 citations
We discuss the problem of the time variable in the nearly standard formulation of the quantum mechanics. In order to be able to describe the outcome of some of the experiments, we have used a novel formulation of the time evolution of quantum states called the projection evolution. As an example a delayed-choice experiment is described. We show that this description recreates the experimental results without relaying on the spatial parts of the wave functions.
In the Schrödinger evolution of a quantum state time enters as a real parameter representing the coordinate. In a more consistent approach time should be defined as a quantum observable, with the evolution taking place in a four-dimensional spacetime. This is possible in the projection evolution model in which the wave function is defined in both space and time. This allows to construct the time operator and discuss the temporal structure of quantum processes. In this paper we discuss a photon travelling through a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, focusing the description on the temporal profile of the wave function. We show that in this approach the delayed-choice experiments can be explained by the temporal overlap of the photon and the devices in the interferometer.
We discuss the problem of time in quantum mechanics. In the traditional formulation time enters the model as a parameter, not an observable, which follows from the famous Pauli theorem. It is now known, that Pauli's assumptions were too strong and that by removing some of them time can be represented as a quantum observable. In this case, instead of the unitary time evolution, other operators which map the space of initial states into the space of final states at each step of the evolution can be used. This allows to treat time as a quantum observable in a consistent way. We present the projection evolution model and show how the traditional Schroedinger evolution can be obtained from it. We propose the form of the time operator which satisfies the energy-time uncertainty relation. As an example, we discuss the temporal version of the double-slit experiment.
By a radical modification of statistical mechanics the measurement process of quantum mechanics can be described in terms of pure, unitary time evolution, with no wave function collapse or many‐world ideas. The key notion is “special states,” rare microscopic states of a complex system. Recovering the standard probabilities requires of this theory the appearance of Cauchy‐distributed noise in some measurement processes. This article treats experimental situations where such noise might be detected and correlated with the need or absence of need for special states. Included in this possibility are “delayed choice” experiments, in which the correlation contravenes conventional ideas on causality. Background material on all topics is provided.
The conventional explanation of delayed-choice experiments appears to violate our causal intuition at the quantum level. I reanalyze these experiments using time-reversed and time-symmetric formulations of quantum mechanics. The time-reversed formulation does not give the same experimental predictions. The time-symmetric formulation gives the same experimental predictions but actually violates our causal intuition at the quantum level. I explore the reasons why our causal intuition may be wrong at the quantum level, suggest how conventional causation might be recovered in the classical limit, propose a quantum analog to the classical block universe viewpoint, and speculate on implications of the time-symmetric formulation for cosmological boundary conditions.
Following a suggestion by Wheeler, several delayed choice experiments have been performed. However, in those experiments one fact has always been ignored: that due to the fact that the single photon is nonlocal in time, the outcome will change if one changes the time to switch the experimental configuration within the photon's wavepacket. This study obtains some insights into this aspect by proposing an experimental scheme based on the delayed choice experiment and giving some related analysis. The result shows a transitional behavior from a particle to a wave, leading to a conclusion that the measuring operator could be time dependent and be changed in a single measurement.