Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Indefinite Spacetime: Part II

Ding Jia

Published Sep 10, 2018• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We adopt an operational mode of thinking to study spacetime fluctuations and their impacts on questions of quantum gravity. Particular emphasis is put on studying causal structure fluctuations. The study is guided by the principle of causal neutrality, which says that fundamental concepts and laws of physics should be stated without assuming a definite spacetime causal structure. Most traditional concepts and theories of physics violate this principle. A major theme of this thesis is to upgrade the traditional concepts and theories in accordance with the principle of causal neutrality. \n \nAmong other things, the thesis include works on the following. (1) An axiomatic derivation of the complex Hilbert space structure of quantum theory without assuming definite causal structure. (2) A so-called causally neutral quantum field theory (CNQFT) framework for algebraic quantum physics allowing indefinite causal structure. (3) A proposal that causal fluctuation regularizes quantum field ultraviolet divergences (UV) and that the UV regularizing correlation functions with causal fluctuations characterize the UV structure of physical states. (4) A study on quantitative measures of causality. (5) A so-called ``correlation networks'' framework to study quantum theory with indefinite causal structure, which generalizes previous frameworks. (6) New definitions of entanglement and entanglement measures that conform to the causal neutrality principle. (7) Ideas on finding a causally neutral analogue of Einstein's equation for quantum spacetime. (8) A simple theorem showing that the communication capacities of general correlations (with definite or indefinite causal structure) defined with respect to state transmission can be reduced to those of channels.

Related papers

Quantum theories from principles without assuming a definite causal structure

Ding Jia

There has been a body of work deriving the complex Hilbert-space structure of quantum theory from axioms/principles/postulates to deepen our understanding of quantum theory and to reveal ways to go beyond it to resolve foundational issues. Recent progress in incorporating indefinite causal structure into physical theories suggests that a more comprehensive understanding of both quantum theory and the theory beyond it accounts for indefinite causal structure. We formulate a framework of physical theories without assuming definite causal structure and identify postulates that single out the complex Hilbert-space structure. More than one complex Hilbert-space theory is compatible with the postulates, which leaves room for further search for the best among these theories.

arXiv:1808.00898•Physical Review A•Sep 19, 2018•9 citations

Formalism locality in quantum theory and quantum gravity

Lucién Hardy

We expect a theory of Quantum Gravity to be both probabilistic and have indefinite causal structure. Indefinite causal structure poses particular problems for theory formulation since many of the core ideas used in the usual approaches to theory construction depend on having definite causal structure. For example, the notion of a state across space evolving in time requires that we have some definite causal structure so we can define a state on a space-like hypersurface. We will see that many of these problems are mitigated if we are able to formulate the theory in a "formalism local" (or F-local) fashion. A formulation of a physical theory is said to be F-local if, in making predictions for any given arbitrary space-time region, we need only refer to mathematical objects pertaining to that region. This is a desirable property both on the grounds of efficiency and since, if we have indefinite causal structure, it is not clear how to select some other space-time region on which our calculations may depend. The usual ways of formulating physical theories (the time evolving state picture, the histories approach, and the local equations approach) are not F-local. We set up a framework for probabilistic theories with indefinite causal structure. This, the causaloid framework, is F-local. We describe how Quantum Theory can be formulated in the causaloid framework (in an F-local fashion). This provides yet another formulation of Quantum Theory. This formulation, however, may be particularly relevant to the problem of finding a theory of Quantum Gravity.

arXiv:0804.0054•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 10, 2010•17 citations

Generalizing entanglement

Ding Jia

The expected indefinite causal structure in quantum gravity poses a challenge to the notion of entanglement: If two parties are in an indefinite causal relation of being causally connected and not, can they still be entangled? If so, how does one measure the amount of entanglement? We propose to generalize the notions of entanglement and entanglement measure to address these questions. Importantly, the generalization opens the path to study quantum entanglement of states, channels, networks, and processes with definite or indefinite causal structure in a unified fashion, e.g., we show that the entanglement distillation capacity of a state, the quantum communication capacity of a channel, and the entanglement generation capacity of a network or a process are different manifestations of one and the same entanglement measure.

arXiv:1707.07340•Physical Review A•Dec 28, 2017•5 citations

Reduction of correlations by quantum indefinite causal structure

Ding Jia

We show that quantum indefinite causal structure generically reduce two-party correlations. For significant indefiniteness in the causal structure captured by some general conditions, the correlation is shown to be reduced down to zero. The result offers an operational model-independent ultraviolet regularization mechanism. It may be applied to various approaches of quantum gravity that allow quantum indefinite spacetime causal structure.

arXiv:1806.02331•Jun 6, 2018•4 citations

Indefinite order in the interface of quantum mechanics and gravity

Bruna Sahdo

Researchers have long been aiming to understand how the characteristics of Quantum Theory and General Relativity combine to account for regimes in their interface. One reason why this is a hard task is how differently the theories approach time and causality. For instance, causal structure in relativity is determined by the distribution of mass in spacetime while, in the quantum formalism, it is supposed to be fixed and given in advance. In this master's thesis, we discuss the notion of indefinite order, which first appears in an abstract generalization of Quantum Theory [...] where the demand for global causal structure is removed, in principle allowing cases for which the order of operations in protocols is not necessarily well defined. One epitomical example of indefinite order is the quantum switch process, which realizes a quantum superposition of orders of two operations on a target system. The quantum switch probabilities have been reproduced in experimental optical setups that are fully described in principle by quantum mechanics. Since these experiments are compatible with spacetime causal structure, this generated uncertainty about the conclusions that can be drawn from obtaining these results depending on the context. Here, we return to the initial motivations and also present how scenarios involving gravity in low energies could lead to indefinite order. This includes the formulation of a quantum switch in a quantum gravity scenario and of a quantum switch in a classical Schwarzschild metric. The switch then provides a common ground to discuss different kinds of setups. The latter proposal of a quantum switch in a classical metric is an original work that, aside from being an example of indefinite order, proposes the realization of the protocol in Earth's gravity as a test of quantum mechanics on curved spacetimes, a regime which has not yet been explored experimentally.

arXiv:2310.02290•Oct 3, 2023•2 citations

Quantum correlations with no causal order

Ognyan Oreshkov, Fabio Costa, Časlav Brukner

The idea that events obey a definite causal order is deeply rooted in our understanding of the world and at the basis of the very notion of time. But where does causal order come from, and is it a necessary property of nature? Here, we address these questions from the standpoint of quantum mechanics in a new framework for multipartite correlations that does not assume a pre-defined global causal structure but only the validity of quantum mechanics locally. All known situations that respect causal order, including space-like and time-like separated experiments, are captured by this framework in a unified way. Surprisingly, we find correlations that cannot be understood in terms of definite causal order. These correlations violate a 'causal inequality' that is satisfied by all space-like and time-like correlations. We further show that in a classical limit causal order always arises, which suggests that space-time may emerge from a more fundamental structure in a quantum-to-classical transition. Causal order is a concept that is engrained in the standard understanding of time, both in classical and quantum mechanics. Oreshkovet al.generalize the standard formalism of quantum theory to a framework with no pre-existing causal order, and find a new class of correlations that have no analogue in the classical world.

arXiv:1105.4464•Nature Communications•Oct 1, 2012•787 citations
We adopt an operational mode of thinking to study spacetime fluctuations and their impacts on questions of quantum gravity. Particular emphasis is put on studying causal structure fluctuations. The study is guided by the principle of causal neutrality, which says that fundamental concepts and laws of physics should be stated without assuming a definite spacetime causal structure. Most traditional concepts and theories of physics violate this principle. A major theme of this thesis is to upgrade the traditional concepts and theories in accordance with the principle of causal neutrality. \n \nAmong other things, the thesis include works on the following. (1) An axiomatic derivation of the complex Hilbert space structure of quantum theory without assuming definite causal structure. (2) A so-called causally neutral quantum field theory (CNQFT) framework for algebraic quantum physics allowing indefinite causal structure. (3) A proposal that causal fluctuation regularizes quantum field ultraviolet divergences (UV) and that the UV regularizing correlation functions with causal fluctuations characterize the UV structure of physical states. (4) A study on quantitative measures of causality. (5) A so-called ``correlation networks'' framework to study quantum theory with indefinite causal structure, which generalizes previous frameworks. (6) New definitions of entanglement and entanglement measures that conform to the causal neutrality principle. (7) Ideas on finding a causally neutral analogue of Einstein's equation for quantum spacetime. (8) A simple theorem showing that the communication capacities of general correlations (with definite or indefinite causal structure) defined with respect to state transmission can be reduced to those of channels.
There has been a body of work deriving the complex Hilbert-space structure of quantum theory from axioms/principles/postulates to deepen our understanding of quantum theory and to reveal ways to go beyond it to resolve foundational issues. Recent progress in incorporating indefinite causal structure into physical theories suggests that a more comprehensive understanding of both quantum theory and the theory beyond it accounts for indefinite causal structure. We formulate a framework of physical theories without assuming definite causal structure and identify postulates that single out the complex Hilbert-space structure. More than one complex Hilbert-space theory is compatible with the postulates, which leaves room for further search for the best among these theories.
We expect a theory of Quantum Gravity to be both probabilistic and have indefinite causal structure. Indefinite causal structure poses particular problems for theory formulation since many of the core ideas used in the usual approaches to theory construction depend on having definite causal structure. For example, the notion of a state across space evolving in time requires that we have some definite causal structure so we can define a state on a space-like hypersurface. We will see that many of these problems are mitigated if we are able to formulate the theory in a "formalism local" (or F-local) fashion. A formulation of a physical theory is said to be F-local if, in making predictions for any given arbitrary space-time region, we need only refer to mathematical objects pertaining to that region. This is a desirable property both on the grounds of efficiency and since, if we have indefinite causal structure, it is not clear how to select some other space-time region on which our calculations may depend. The usual ways of formulating physical theories (the time evolving state picture, the histories approach, and the local equations approach) are not F-local. We set up a framework for probabilistic theories with indefinite causal structure. This, the causaloid framework, is F-local. We describe how Quantum Theory can be formulated in the causaloid framework (in an F-local fashion). This provides yet another formulation of Quantum Theory. This formulation, however, may be particularly relevant to the problem of finding a theory of Quantum Gravity.
The expected indefinite causal structure in quantum gravity poses a challenge to the notion of entanglement: If two parties are in an indefinite causal relation of being causally connected and not, can they still be entangled? If so, how does one measure the amount of entanglement? We propose to generalize the notions of entanglement and entanglement measure to address these questions. Importantly, the generalization opens the path to study quantum entanglement of states, channels, networks, and processes with definite or indefinite causal structure in a unified fashion, e.g., we show that the entanglement distillation capacity of a state, the quantum communication capacity of a channel, and the entanglement generation capacity of a network or a process are different manifestations of one and the same entanglement measure.
Researchers have long been aiming to understand how the characteristics of Quantum Theory and General Relativity combine to account for regimes in their interface. One reason why this is a hard task is how differently the theories approach time and causality. For instance, causal structure in relativity is determined by the distribution of mass in spacetime while, in the quantum formalism, it is supposed to be fixed and given in advance. In this master's thesis, we discuss the notion of indefinite order, which first appears in an abstract generalization of Quantum Theory [...] where the demand for global causal structure is removed, in principle allowing cases for which the order of operations in protocols is not necessarily well defined. One epitomical example of indefinite order is the quantum switch process, which realizes a quantum superposition of orders of two operations on a target system. The quantum switch probabilities have been reproduced in experimental optical setups that are fully described in principle by quantum mechanics. Since these experiments are compatible with spacetime causal structure, this generated uncertainty about the conclusions that can be drawn from obtaining these results depending on the context. Here, we return to the initial motivations and also present how scenarios involving gravity in low energies could lead to indefinite order. This includes the formulation of a quantum switch in a quantum gravity scenario and of a quantum switch in a classical Schwarzschild metric. The switch then provides a common ground to discuss different kinds of setups. The latter proposal of a quantum switch in a classical metric is an original work that, aside from being an example of indefinite order, proposes the realization of the protocol in Earth's gravity as a test of quantum mechanics on curved spacetimes, a regime which has not yet been explored experimentally.
The idea that events obey a definite causal order is deeply rooted in our understanding of the world and at the basis of the very notion of time. But where does causal order come from, and is it a necessary property of nature? Here, we address these questions from the standpoint of quantum mechanics in a new framework for multipartite correlations that does not assume a pre-defined global causal structure but only the validity of quantum mechanics locally. All known situations that respect causal order, including space-like and time-like separated experiments, are captured by this framework in a unified way. Surprisingly, we find correlations that cannot be understood in terms of definite causal order. These correlations violate a 'causal inequality' that is satisfied by all space-like and time-like correlations. We further show that in a classical limit causal order always arises, which suggests that space-time may emerge from a more fundamental structure in a quantum-to-classical transition. Causal order is a concept that is engrained in the standard understanding of time, both in classical and quantum mechanics. Oreshkovet al.generalize the standard formalism of quantum theory to a framework with no pre-existing causal order, and find a new class of correlations that have no analogue in the classical world.