Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics

A. Driessen

Published Jan 1, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The four antinomies of Zeno of Elea, especially Achilles and the tortoise continue to be provoking issues which are even now not always satisfactory solved. Aristotle himself used this antinomy to develop his understanding of movement: it is a fluent continuum that has to be treated as a whole. The parts, if any, are only potentially present in the whole. And that is exactly what quantum mechanics is claiming: movement is quantized in contrast to classical mechanics. The objective of this study is to show the merits of the Aristotelian approach. It is a good candidate for serving as the philosophical background for understanding fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics. Especially mentioned are the influence of the final state in quantum mechanics that in philosophy could be correlated with the final cause. Like in the work of Aristotle also in this study examples from science are presented to illustrate the philosophical approach. But, in contrast to ancient Greek, the examples now relate to issues which are only fully accessible to the scientifically trained reader. As the main conclusion the dialogue between scientists and philosophers is strongly recommended which will result in progress in both disciplines.

DOI
10.13140/rg.2.2.24028.03205

Related papers

Aristotle and the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics

A. Driessen

The four antinomies of Zeno of Elea continue to be provoking issues that remain relevant for the foundation of science. Aristotle used this antinomy to arrive at a deeper understanding of movement: it is a fluent continuum that he considers to be a whole. The parts, if any, are only potentially present. Similarly, quantum mechanics states that movement is quantized; things move or change in nonreducible steps, the so-called quanta. This view is in contrast to classical mechanics, where infinitesimally small steps are permitted. The objective of the present study is to show the merits of the Aristotelian approach. Examples from modern science serve to illustrate the philosophical statements.

Acta Philosophica: rivista internazionale di filosofia•Jul 3, 2019•4 citations

Zeno's Paradoxes in the Mechanical World View

Shiro Ishikawa

There is a very reason to consider that to solve Zeno's paradoxes is to propose the theory of mechanical world view. We believe that this is not only our opinion but also most philosophers' opinion. Recently, in order to justify Heisenberg`s uncertainty principle (cf. Rep. Math. Phys Vol. 29, No. 3, 1991) more firmly. we proposed the linguistic interpretation of quantum mechanics (called quantum and classical measurement theory), which was characterized as the metaphysical and linguistic turn of the Copenhagen interpretation. This turn from physics to language does not only extend quantum mechanicsto classical systems but also yield the (quantum and classical) mechanical world view (and therefore, establish the method of science). If it be so, we may assert that Zeno's paradoxes (Flying Arrow Paradox, Achilles and the tortoise, etc.) were already solved in measurement theory. The purpose of this paper is to examine this assertion.

arXiv:1205.1290•May 7, 2012•4 citations

Quantum Mechanics as the Offspring of Classical Thought: A Philosophical Analysis of Continuity and Rupture

Christopher Alexander Udofia

The study of the motion of bodies is referred to as mechanics. The study of the motion of subatomic particles is involved in the field of quantum mechanics. The argument that quantum mechanics is the offspring of earlier mechanics continues to be supported by this body of study. To maintain this perspective, the work traces the origins of the study of mechanics back to Aristotle. This research was subsequently rethought and given a new orientation in modern Newtonian mechanics. It is demonstrated in this work, via the use of the philosophical mechanism of analysis, that the disintegration of these two mechanics resulted in the development of quantum mechanics. The study makes the key observation that, when Quantum mechanics is compared with the two earlier types of mechanics, the concepts of objectivity, causality, determinism, and certainty characteristic of the earlier types are rendered obsolete within the framework of Quantum physics. The discussion concludes with the thesis that, given the current state of scientific research, which enables the unification of all domains of knowledge, the combination of metaphysics and science in the pursuit of greater human understanding ought to create a new dimension of knowledge acquisition.

FMDB Transactions on Sustainable Humanities and Society•Sep 9, 2025•0 citations

Solving Zeno's aporias based on a dialectical approach and the latest discoveries in physics: ontological consequences

Виталий Валерьевич Коромыслов

This study analyzes the aporias of Zeno of Elea: "Achilles", "Arrow" and "Dichotomy" in order to propose approaches to their resolution in accordance with the latest results of scientific research in the field of natural science. In this case, the dialectical method is used. The relevance of the problems posed by Zeno related to the nature of space, time and motion is shown. The results of this study made it possible to formulate in some cases their final resolution, and in others, formulate hypotheses that require confirmation through the further development of quantum physics. In the case of the Achilles aporia, the solution is based on understanding the closest possible bodies not as strictly isolated from each other, but as exchanging matter and energy, for example, in heat exchange processes or in the photoelectric effect. Thus, the contact of the catching object with the pursued is not reducible to a certain moment, but consists in a gradual process of increasing the intensity of interaction between them. In the case of Zeno's "Arrow" and "Dichotomy" aporias, the complexity of the problems raised and the hypothetical nature of many theoretical constructs related to them, as well as the presence of various interpretations of quantum mechanics, do not allow us to formulate definitive solutions that could claim universal acceptance. However, a solution is proposed based on the interpretation of Heisenberg-Fock quantum mechanics in the philosophical interpretation of A. Yu. Sevalnikov, which describes the mechanism of transition from the indefinite state of subatomic reality to an ordered picture of movement at the macro level through the process of decoherence, due to the property of photons, which has received the name of "quantum time reversal".

Research Result Social Studies and Humanities•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations

History of Western Philosophy and Quantum Language (Including Quantum Mechanics, Statistics, Fuzzy Logic, etc.)

Shiro Ishikawa

Although there are many different types of philosophy, many philosophers agree that the mainstream of Western philosophy (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, Kant, Wittgenstein) developed toward the perfection of Socrates’ absolutism. But can the absolutism maintain its central position after analytic philosophy? There are pessimistic views on this problem, such as that of R. Rorty, the standard-bearer of neo-pragmatism. Recently, I proposed quantum language (which is including quantum mechanics, statistics, fuzzy sets, etc.). I think that that this theory is not only one of the most fundamental scientific theories, but also the scientific final destination of Western philosophy. If so, Socrates’ dream has come true. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the above and to inform readers that quantum language has the power to create a paradigm shift from the classical mechanical world view to the quantum mechanical worldview.

Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics•Jan 1, 2024•2 citations

From Classical Neurobiological Conception to Quantum One. Critical Revision

Probably no theory in the history of science has produced such a profound cultural and scientific revolution as is determined by quantum mechanics. Founded around 1920 by illustrious physicists, all Nobel Prize winners, it has completely subverted the conception of matter and the universe. The theory that all matter is made up of atoms has already been formulated by Greek philosophers, starting with Democritus. Quantum mechanics provided a description based on a new conception of the elementary structure of atoms, and formulated the fundamental laws to which atoms obey. Quantum theory has obtained the unanimous and shared consent of the scientific world, although some aspects have not been definitively confirmed. Strengthened by the universal acceptance of his theories, quantum mechanics claims its intellectual primacy over all the other sciences, and the scientific world seems to grant it, so much so as to archive all the knowledge and achievements gathered in its thousand-year history. From the epistemological point of view all established theories are worthy of consideration and must be shared and accepted until proven groundless. Dating, quantum mechanics still enjoys the consent of many scientists, but this does not mean that it can claim to be the repository of all truth, based on an unacceptable and anti-scientific syllogism for which: A) all organic and inorganic matter is formed by atoms and molecules; B) quantum mechanics has founded theories and formulas to which atoms and molecules obey; C) accordingly quantum mechanics can control all universal matter. But the presumption of its predominance goes further than willing to dominate living matter. In this article we are going to examine with a sharp criticism, the aberrant and anti-scientific claim of this discipline to dominate not only science but also universal matter. We propose a more moderate and considered vision of the observable natural phenomena and consider them events in continuous evolution, and to adapt our hypotheses and theories with an equal evolutionary approach.

Archives of Health Science•Dec 11, 2023•0 citations
The four antinomies of Zeno of Elea, especially Achilles and the tortoise continue to be provoking issues which are even now not always satisfactory solved. Aristotle himself used this antinomy to develop his understanding of movement: it is a fluent continuum that has to be treated as a whole. The parts, if any, are only potentially present in the whole. And that is exactly what quantum mechanics is claiming: movement is quantized in contrast to classical mechanics. The objective of this study is to show the merits of the Aristotelian approach. It is a good candidate for serving as the philosophical background for understanding fundamental aspects of quantum mechanics. Especially mentioned are the influence of the final state in quantum mechanics that in philosophy could be correlated with the final cause. Like in the work of Aristotle also in this study examples from science are presented to illustrate the philosophical approach. But, in contrast to ancient Greek, the examples now relate to issues which are only fully accessible to the scientifically trained reader. As the main conclusion the dialogue between scientists and philosophers is strongly recommended which will result in progress in both disciplines.
The four antinomies of Zeno of Elea continue to be provoking issues that remain relevant for the foundation of science. Aristotle used this antinomy to arrive at a deeper understanding of movement: it is a fluent continuum that he considers to be a whole. The parts, if any, are only potentially present. Similarly, quantum mechanics states that movement is quantized; things move or change in nonreducible steps, the so-called quanta. This view is in contrast to classical mechanics, where infinitesimally small steps are permitted. The objective of the present study is to show the merits of the Aristotelian approach. Examples from modern science serve to illustrate the philosophical statements.
There is a very reason to consider that to solve Zeno's paradoxes is to propose the theory of mechanical world view. We believe that this is not only our opinion but also most philosophers' opinion. Recently, in order to justify Heisenberg`s uncertainty principle (cf. Rep. Math. Phys Vol. 29, No. 3, 1991) more firmly. we proposed the linguistic interpretation of quantum mechanics (called quantum and classical measurement theory), which was characterized as the metaphysical and linguistic turn of the Copenhagen interpretation. This turn from physics to language does not only extend quantum mechanicsto classical systems but also yield the (quantum and classical) mechanical world view (and therefore, establish the method of science). If it be so, we may assert that Zeno's paradoxes (Flying Arrow Paradox, Achilles and the tortoise, etc.) were already solved in measurement theory. The purpose of this paper is to examine this assertion.
The study of the motion of bodies is referred to as mechanics. The study of the motion of subatomic particles is involved in the field of quantum mechanics. The argument that quantum mechanics is the offspring of earlier mechanics continues to be supported by this body of study. To maintain this perspective, the work traces the origins of the study of mechanics back to Aristotle. This research was subsequently rethought and given a new orientation in modern Newtonian mechanics. It is demonstrated in this work, via the use of the philosophical mechanism of analysis, that the disintegration of these two mechanics resulted in the development of quantum mechanics. The study makes the key observation that, when Quantum mechanics is compared with the two earlier types of mechanics, the concepts of objectivity, causality, determinism, and certainty characteristic of the earlier types are rendered obsolete within the framework of Quantum physics. The discussion concludes with the thesis that, given the current state of scientific research, which enables the unification of all domains of knowledge, the combination of metaphysics and science in the pursuit of greater human understanding ought to create a new dimension of knowledge acquisition.
This study analyzes the aporias of Zeno of Elea: "Achilles", "Arrow" and "Dichotomy" in order to propose approaches to their resolution in accordance with the latest results of scientific research in the field of natural science. In this case, the dialectical method is used. The relevance of the problems posed by Zeno related to the nature of space, time and motion is shown. The results of this study made it possible to formulate in some cases their final resolution, and in others, formulate hypotheses that require confirmation through the further development of quantum physics. In the case of the Achilles aporia, the solution is based on understanding the closest possible bodies not as strictly isolated from each other, but as exchanging matter and energy, for example, in heat exchange processes or in the photoelectric effect. Thus, the contact of the catching object with the pursued is not reducible to a certain moment, but consists in a gradual process of increasing the intensity of interaction between them. In the case of Zeno's "Arrow" and "Dichotomy" aporias, the complexity of the problems raised and the hypothetical nature of many theoretical constructs related to them, as well as the presence of various interpretations of quantum mechanics, do not allow us to formulate definitive solutions that could claim universal acceptance. However, a solution is proposed based on the interpretation of Heisenberg-Fock quantum mechanics in the philosophical interpretation of A. Yu. Sevalnikov, which describes the mechanism of transition from the indefinite state of subatomic reality to an ordered picture of movement at the macro level through the process of decoherence, due to the property of photons, which has received the name of "quantum time reversal".
Although there are many different types of philosophy, many philosophers agree that the mainstream of Western philosophy (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, Kant, Wittgenstein) developed toward the perfection of Socrates’ absolutism. But can the absolutism maintain its central position after analytic philosophy? There are pessimistic views on this problem, such as that of R. Rorty, the standard-bearer of neo-pragmatism. Recently, I proposed quantum language (which is including quantum mechanics, statistics, fuzzy sets, etc.). I think that that this theory is not only one of the most fundamental scientific theories, but also the scientific final destination of Western philosophy. If so, Socrates’ dream has come true. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the above and to inform readers that quantum language has the power to create a paradigm shift from the classical mechanical world view to the quantum mechanical worldview.
Probably no theory in the history of science has produced such a profound cultural and scientific revolution as is determined by quantum mechanics. Founded around 1920 by illustrious physicists, all Nobel Prize winners, it has completely subverted the conception of matter and the universe. The theory that all matter is made up of atoms has already been formulated by Greek philosophers, starting with Democritus. Quantum mechanics provided a description based on a new conception of the elementary structure of atoms, and formulated the fundamental laws to which atoms obey. Quantum theory has obtained the unanimous and shared consent of the scientific world, although some aspects have not been definitively confirmed. Strengthened by the universal acceptance of his theories, quantum mechanics claims its intellectual primacy over all the other sciences, and the scientific world seems to grant it, so much so as to archive all the knowledge and achievements gathered in its thousand-year history. From the epistemological point of view all established theories are worthy of consideration and must be shared and accepted until proven groundless. Dating, quantum mechanics still enjoys the consent of many scientists, but this does not mean that it can claim to be the repository of all truth, based on an unacceptable and anti-scientific syllogism for which: A) all organic and inorganic matter is formed by atoms and molecules; B) quantum mechanics has founded theories and formulas to which atoms and molecules obey; C) accordingly quantum mechanics can control all universal matter. But the presumption of its predominance goes further than willing to dominate living matter. In this article we are going to examine with a sharp criticism, the aberrant and anti-scientific claim of this discipline to dominate not only science but also universal matter. We propose a more moderate and considered vision of the observable natural phenomena and consider them events in continuous evolution, and to adapt our hypotheses and theories with an equal evolutionary approach.