Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Griot Revista de Filosofia

Teoria quântica, física nuclear e filosofia grega: ensaio sobre os físicos filósofos do século XX

Vinícius Carvalho da Silva

Published Jun 18, 2017• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

At the beginning of the twentieth century it would be unthinkable, among european scientists, to separate natural science and philosophy. Physicists-philosophers were scientists such as Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, Schrödinger, among others, who refounded physics by laying the foundations of quantum mechanics and special and general relativity. In this paper we briefly review how some of these thinkers have looked at the issues of the value of science, the relationship between science and philosophy, and the importance of Greek philosophy to nuclear physics and quantum theory.

DOI
10.31977/grirfi.v15i1.741

Related papers

Quantum Foundations and the Building Blocks of Matter

To trace the evolution of the universe, it is necessary to understand at least the basic ideas behind quantum physics. Science up until the beginning of the 20 th century could be traced back to its ancient Greek origins beginning perhaps in the sixth century B.C. Its evolution became what is known as the classical view of the world and in particular of physics. The beginning of the 20 th century brought with it two great revolutions in physics both due to Albert Einstein. The first was special relativity to be followed later by general relativity or the theory of gravity; the second was quantum mechanics initiated by Einstein’s discovery of the photoelectric effect, which showed that the energy of the electrons emitted by some materials when light is shown on them depends on the frequency of light not on its intensity. The attempt to reconcile quantum mechanics with concepts brought over from classical mechanics has led to an enormous literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics and much confusion especially among non-physicists and students of physics. Part of this is due to the historical approach to teaching the subject coupled with the understandable struggle to carry over the basic concepts of particle and wave from classical physics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 12, 2018•0 citations

Polémica de un nuevo paradigma: Einstein frente a Bohr y Born

Frank Daboín, Braulio Briceño, Iris Materán +3 more

Resumen El presente ensayo tiene como propósito rememorar la fascinante historia de la física moderna, junto a la ineludible filosofía de sus actores: Planck, Einstein, De Broglie, Schrödinger, Heisenberg, Bohr y Born. Una disertación llena de polémicas, paradigmas y grandes transformaciones emergidas a finales del siglo XIX e inicios del XX. En este contexto, el nuevo paradigma converge en un debate físico-filosófico centrado en la interpretación de la Física Cuántica, liderada por Einstein y Bohr en el seno de los Congresos Solvay y extendiéndose fuera de los mismos, en el que unos defienden el determinismo como teoría física afianzada en la realidad misma de sus entes, frente a la visión en que es preciso renunciar al determinismo y a la pretensión de un realismo objetivista. Controversy of a new paradigm: from einstein bohr y born Abstract This essay aims to relive the fascinating story of modern physics, with the inevitable philosophy of its actors: Planck, Einstein, de Broglie, Schrödinger, Heisenberg, Bohr and Born. A dissertation full of controversies, paradigms and large transformations emerged in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. In this context, the new paradigm converge on a physical and philosophical debate focused on the interpretation of quantum theory, Einstein and Bohr led within the Solvay Conferences and extending outside thereof, in which some defend determinism as physical theory entrenched in the reality of its authorities, against the view that determinism is necessary to waive the claim and an objectivist realism.

•Sep 23, 2014•0 citations

Philosophy of Physics

Anouk Barberousse

Philosophical reflections on physics and its theories have been shaping the agenda of general philosophy of science, including issues such as the nature of scientific theories, the meaning of scientific terms, and scientific modeling. But physics is also well worth being considered a special science of its own, whose methods and tools raised specific questions for philosophers of science: this is the approach followed in this chapter, which has as its main thread the role of mathematics in physical theories. It tackles classical issues concerning measurement and determinism and long-standing controversies in the philosophy of statistical mechanics (how may the reversible laws of mechanics account for the irreversible principles of thermodynamics?) and in the philosophy of quantum physics (does quantum mechanics provide us a with a complete description of quantum phenomena?). It also addresses emerging issues in the field, such as computer simulations and their role between theory and observation.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 19, 2018•4 citations

Werner Heisenberg e a Interpretação de Copenhague: a filosofia platônica e a consolidação da teoria quântica

Anderson Cleiton Fernandes Leite, Samuel J. Simon

Este artigo discute o uso que Werner Heisenberg faz da filosofia grega clássica no âmbito dos debates acerca da teoria quântica realizados na primeira metade do século xx. Para esse autor, a ciência foi determinada pelo influxo de duas correntes de pensamento que surgiram na Grécia antiga: o materialismo e o idealismo. A partir de tal clivagem, Heisenberg fundamenta sua crítica aos opositores da Interpretação de Copenhague, além de justificar filosoficamente suas próprias teses sobre a mecânica quântica. Apesar de suas concepções filosóficas não serem passíveis de uma sistematização completa, a relação que Heisenberg estabeleceu entre a filosofia grega e os problemas da teoria dos quanta acabou por resultar em uma interpretação da realidade física na qual é predominante um platonismo e um incipiente estruturalismo matemático.

Scientiae Studia•Jun 1, 2010•3 citations

GREEK PHILOSOPHY FOR QUANTUM PHYSICS. THE RETURN TO THE GREEKS IN THE WORKS OF HEISENBERG, PAULI AND SCHRÖDINGER

Raimundo Fernández Mouján

Werner Heisenberg, Erwin Schr�odinger and Wolfgang Pauli exhibited in their works a strong and insistent interest in Greek philosophy. And this interest --they claimed-- was not at all separated from their investigations into the new quantum theory. Heisenberg directly a�rmed that "one could hardly make progress in modern atomic physics without a knowledge of Greek natural philosophy". What does this claim mean? Why do these central �gures in the development of quantum mechanics saw the Greeks as their main inspiring source? Why do they took them as a model for contemporary science, even over their modern predecessors of Enlightenment? This work attempts to answer these questions focusing on three main reasons: the revision of atomism, the recasting of the meaning of "understanding" in physics, and the critique of separations in science.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 1, 2023•2 citations

La filosofia de la teoria quàntica

Vicent Picó

The philosophy of quantum theory Resumen: La teoria quàntica representa una de les fites més importants de la història de la ciència del segle XX, tant pel que fa a les seues implicacions teòriques i tecnològiques com pel que fa als problemes conceptuals que planteja la seua interpretació. Aquest article constitueix una revisió de les propostes interpretatives del formalisme quàntic d’ençà que la teoria es va axiomatitzar a les acaballes de la dècada dels anys 20 del segle passat. Aquestes propostes incideixen en problemes filosòfics com la no-localitat, l’indeterminisme, la probabilitat o el realisme científic, per a cadascun dels quals s’ofereix una resposta temptativa a partir de la interpretació del formalisme corresponent. Abstract: Quantum theory represents one of the most important milestones in the history of science in the 20th century, both in terms of its theoretical and technological implications and in terms of the conceptual problems posed by its interpretation. This article constitutes a review of the interpretive proposals of the quantum formalism since the theory was axiomatized at the end of the decade of the 20s of the last century. These proposals rise philosophical problems such as non-locality, indeterminism, probability or scientific realism, for each of which a tentative answer is offered based on the interpretation of the corresponding formalism. Palabras clave: Teoria quàntica, problema de la mesura, variables ocultes, molts mons, col.lapse objectiu. Keywords: Quantum theory, measurement problem, hidden variables, many worlds, objective collapse.

Quaderns de Filosofia•Nov 29, 2022•0 citations
At the beginning of the twentieth century it would be unthinkable, among european scientists, to separate natural science and philosophy. Physicists-philosophers were scientists such as Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg, Schrödinger, among others, who refounded physics by laying the foundations of quantum mechanics and special and general relativity. In this paper we briefly review how some of these thinkers have looked at the issues of the value of science, the relationship between science and philosophy, and the importance of Greek philosophy to nuclear physics and quantum theory.
To trace the evolution of the universe, it is necessary to understand at least the basic ideas behind quantum physics. Science up until the beginning of the 20 th century could be traced back to its ancient Greek origins beginning perhaps in the sixth century B.C. Its evolution became what is known as the classical view of the world and in particular of physics. The beginning of the 20 th century brought with it two great revolutions in physics both due to Albert Einstein. The first was special relativity to be followed later by general relativity or the theory of gravity; the second was quantum mechanics initiated by Einstein’s discovery of the photoelectric effect, which showed that the energy of the electrons emitted by some materials when light is shown on them depends on the frequency of light not on its intensity. The attempt to reconcile quantum mechanics with concepts brought over from classical mechanics has led to an enormous literature on the foundations of quantum mechanics and much confusion especially among non-physicists and students of physics. Part of this is due to the historical approach to teaching the subject coupled with the understandable struggle to carry over the basic concepts of particle and wave from classical physics.
Resumen El presente ensayo tiene como propósito rememorar la fascinante historia de la física moderna, junto a la ineludible filosofía de sus actores: Planck, Einstein, De Broglie, Schrödinger, Heisenberg, Bohr y Born. Una disertación llena de polémicas, paradigmas y grandes transformaciones emergidas a finales del siglo XIX e inicios del XX. En este contexto, el nuevo paradigma converge en un debate físico-filosófico centrado en la interpretación de la Física Cuántica, liderada por Einstein y Bohr en el seno de los Congresos Solvay y extendiéndose fuera de los mismos, en el que unos defienden el determinismo como teoría física afianzada en la realidad misma de sus entes, frente a la visión en que es preciso renunciar al determinismo y a la pretensión de un realismo objetivista. Controversy of a new paradigm: from einstein bohr y born Abstract This essay aims to relive the fascinating story of modern physics, with the inevitable philosophy of its actors: Planck, Einstein, de Broglie, Schrödinger, Heisenberg, Bohr and Born. A dissertation full of controversies, paradigms and large transformations emerged in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. In this context, the new paradigm converge on a physical and philosophical debate focused on the interpretation of quantum theory, Einstein and Bohr led within the Solvay Conferences and extending outside thereof, in which some defend determinism as physical theory entrenched in the reality of its authorities, against the view that determinism is necessary to waive the claim and an objectivist realism.
Philosophical reflections on physics and its theories have been shaping the agenda of general philosophy of science, including issues such as the nature of scientific theories, the meaning of scientific terms, and scientific modeling. But physics is also well worth being considered a special science of its own, whose methods and tools raised specific questions for philosophers of science: this is the approach followed in this chapter, which has as its main thread the role of mathematics in physical theories. It tackles classical issues concerning measurement and determinism and long-standing controversies in the philosophy of statistical mechanics (how may the reversible laws of mechanics account for the irreversible principles of thermodynamics?) and in the philosophy of quantum physics (does quantum mechanics provide us a with a complete description of quantum phenomena?). It also addresses emerging issues in the field, such as computer simulations and their role between theory and observation.
Este artigo discute o uso que Werner Heisenberg faz da filosofia grega clássica no âmbito dos debates acerca da teoria quântica realizados na primeira metade do século xx. Para esse autor, a ciência foi determinada pelo influxo de duas correntes de pensamento que surgiram na Grécia antiga: o materialismo e o idealismo. A partir de tal clivagem, Heisenberg fundamenta sua crítica aos opositores da Interpretação de Copenhague, além de justificar filosoficamente suas próprias teses sobre a mecânica quântica. Apesar de suas concepções filosóficas não serem passíveis de uma sistematização completa, a relação que Heisenberg estabeleceu entre a filosofia grega e os problemas da teoria dos quanta acabou por resultar em uma interpretação da realidade física na qual é predominante um platonismo e um incipiente estruturalismo matemático.
Werner Heisenberg, Erwin Schr�odinger and Wolfgang Pauli exhibited in their works a strong and insistent interest in Greek philosophy. And this interest --they claimed-- was not at all separated from their investigations into the new quantum theory. Heisenberg directly a�rmed that "one could hardly make progress in modern atomic physics without a knowledge of Greek natural philosophy". What does this claim mean? Why do these central �gures in the development of quantum mechanics saw the Greeks as their main inspiring source? Why do they took them as a model for contemporary science, even over their modern predecessors of Enlightenment? This work attempts to answer these questions focusing on three main reasons: the revision of atomism, the recasting of the meaning of "understanding" in physics, and the critique of separations in science.
The philosophy of quantum theory Resumen: La teoria quàntica representa una de les fites més importants de la història de la ciència del segle XX, tant pel que fa a les seues implicacions teòriques i tecnològiques com pel que fa als problemes conceptuals que planteja la seua interpretació. Aquest article constitueix una revisió de les propostes interpretatives del formalisme quàntic d’ençà que la teoria es va axiomatitzar a les acaballes de la dècada dels anys 20 del segle passat. Aquestes propostes incideixen en problemes filosòfics com la no-localitat, l’indeterminisme, la probabilitat o el realisme científic, per a cadascun dels quals s’ofereix una resposta temptativa a partir de la interpretació del formalisme corresponent. Abstract: Quantum theory represents one of the most important milestones in the history of science in the 20th century, both in terms of its theoretical and technological implications and in terms of the conceptual problems posed by its interpretation. This article constitutes a review of the interpretive proposals of the quantum formalism since the theory was axiomatized at the end of the decade of the 20s of the last century. These proposals rise philosophical problems such as non-locality, indeterminism, probability or scientific realism, for each of which a tentative answer is offered based on the interpretation of the corresponding formalism. Palabras clave: Teoria quàntica, problema de la mesura, variables ocultes, molts mons, col.lapse objectiu. Keywords: Quantum theory, measurement problem, hidden variables, many worlds, objective collapse.