Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science

Classical Lower Bounds from Quantum Upper Bounds

Shalev Ben-David, Adam Bouland, Ankit Garg, Robin Kothari

Published Oct 1, 2018• 17 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We prove lower bounds on complexity measures, such as the approximate degree of a Boolean function and the approximate rank of a Boolean matrix, using quantum arguments. We prove these lower bounds using a quantum query algorithm for the combinatorial group testing problem. We show that for any function f, the approximate degree of computing the OR of n copies of f is Omega(sqrt n) times the approximate degree of f, which is optimal. No such general result was known prior to our work, and even the lower bound for the OR of ANDs function was only resolved in 2013. We then prove an analogous result in communication complexity, showing that the logarithm of the approximate rank (or more precisely, the approximate gamma-2 norm) of F: X x Y to 0,1 grows by a factor of Omega (sqrtn) when we take the OR of n copies of F, which is also essentially optimal. As a corollary, we give a new proof of Razborov's celebrated Omega(sqrtn) lower bound on the quantum communication complexity of the disjointness problem. Finally, we generalize both these results from composition with the OR function to composition with arbitrary symmetric functions, yielding nearly optimal lower bounds in this setting as well.

DOI
10.1109/focs.2018.00040

Related papers

Classical lower bounds from quantum upper bounds

Shalev Ben-David, Adam Bouland, Ankit Garg +1 more

We prove lower bounds on complexity measures, such as the approximate degree of a Boolean function and the approximate rank of a Boolean matrix, using quantum arguments. We prove these lower bounds using a quantum query algorithm for the combinatorial group testing problem. We show that for any function f, the approximate degree of computing the OR of n copies of f is Omega(sqrt{n}) times the approximate degree of f, which is optimal. No such general result was known prior to our work, and even the lower bound for the OR of ANDs function was only resolved in 2013. We then prove an analogous result in communication complexity, showing that the logarithm of the approximate rank (or more precisely, the approximate gamma_2 norm) of F: X x Y -> {0,1} grows by a factor of Omega~(sqrt{n}) when we take the OR of n copies of F, which is also essentially optimal. As a corollary, we give a new proof of Razborov's celebrated Omega(sqrt{n}) lower bound on the quantum communication complexity of the disjointness problem. Finally, we generalize both these results from composition with the OR function to composition with arbitrary symmetric functions, yielding nearly optimal lower bounds in this setting as well.

arXiv:1807.06256•Jul 17, 2018•2 citations

Separating Quantum Communication and Approximate Rank

Anurag Anshu, Shalev Ben-David, Ankit Garg +3 more

One of the best lower bound methods for the quantum communication complexity of a function H (with or without shared entanglement) is the logarithm of the approximate rank of the communication matrix of H. This measure is essentially equivalent to the approximate gamma-2 norm and generalized discrepancy, and subsumes several other lower bounds. All known lower bounds on quantum communication complexity in the general unbounded-round model can be shown via the logarithm of approximate rank, and it was an open problem to give any separation at all between quantum communication complexity and the logarithm of the approximate rank. In this work we provide the first such separation: We exhibit a total function H with quantum communication complexity almost quadratically larger than the logarithm of its approximate rank. We construct H using the communication lookup function framework of Anshu et al. (FOCS 2016) based on the cheat sheet framework of Aaronson et al. (STOC 2016). From a starting function F, this framework defines a new function H=F_G. Our main technical result is a lower bound on the quantum communication complexity of F_G in terms of the discrepancy of F, which we do via quantum information theoretic arguments. We show the upper bound on the approximate rank of F_G by relating it to the Boolean circuit size of the starting function F.

arXiv:1611.05754•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Nov 17, 2016•7 citations

Approximation norms and duality for communication complexity lower bounds

Troy Lee, Adi Shraibman

Abstract: We will discuss a general norm based framework for showing lower bounds on communication complexity. An advantage of this approach is that one can use duality theory to obtain a lower bound quantity phrased as a maximization problem, which can be more convenient to work with in showing lower bounds. We discuss two applications of this approach. 1. The approximation rank of a matrix A is the minimum rank of a matrix close to A in ell_infty norm. The logarithm of approximation rank lower bounds quantum communication complexity and is one of the most powerful techniques available, albeit difficult to compute in practice. We show that an approximation norm known as gamma_2 is polynomially related to approximation rank. This results in a polynomial time algorithm to approximate approximation rank, and also shows that the logarithm of approximation rank lower bounds quantum communication complexity even with entanglement which was previously not known. 2. By means of an approximation norm which lower bounds multiparty number-on-the-forehead complexity, we show non-trivial lower bounds on the complexity of the disjointness function for up to c log log n players, c <1.

Dagstuhl Seminar Proceedings•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

The pattern matrix method for lower bounds on quantum communication

Alexander A. Sherstov

In a breakthrough result, Razborov (2003) gave optimal lower bounds on the communication complexity of every function f of the form f(x,y)=D(|x AND y|) for some D:{0,1,...,n}->{0,1}, in the bounded-error quantum model with and without prior entanglement. This was proved by the multidimensional discrepancy method. We give an entirely different proof of Razborov's result, using the original, one-dimensional discrepancy method. This refutes the commonly held intuition (Razborov 2003) that the original discrepancy method fails for functions such as DISJOINTNESS. More importantly, our communication lower bounds hold for a much broader class of functions for which no methods were available. Namely, fix an arbitrary function f:{0,1}n/4->{0,1} and let A be the Boolean matrix whose columns are each an application of f to some subset of the variables x1,x2,...,xn. We prove that the communication complexity of A in the bounded-error quantum model with and without prior entanglement is Omega(d), where d is the approximate degree of f. From this result, Razborov's lower bounds follow easily. Our result also establishes a large new class of total Boolean functions whose quantum communication complexity (regardless of prior entanglement) is at best polynomially smaller than their classical complexity. Our proof method is a novel combination of two ingredients. The first is a certain equivalence of approximation and orthogonality in Euclidean n-space, which follows by linear-programming duality. The second is a new construction of suitably structured matrices with low spectral norm, the pattern matrices, which we realize using matrix analysis and the Fourier transform over (Z2)n. The method of this paper has recently inspired important progress in multiparty communication complexity.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•May 17, 2008•77 citations

Approximate Degree in Classical and Quantum Computing

Mark Bun, Justin Thaler

The ability (or inability) to represent or approximate Boolean functions by polynomials is a central concept in complexity theory, underlying interactive and probabilistically checkable proof systems, circuit lower bounds, quantum complexity theory, and more. In this book, the authors survey what is known about a particularly natural notion of approximation by polynomials, capturing pointwise approximation over This book covers recent progress on proving approximate degree lower and upper bounds and describes some applications of the new bounds to oracle separations, quantum query and communication complexity, and circuit complexity. The authors explain how several of these advances have been unlocked by a particularly simple and elegant technique, called dual block composition, for constructing solutions to this dual linear program. They also provide concise coverage of even more recent lower bound techniques based on a new complexity measure called spectral sensitivity. Finally, they show how explicit constructions of approximating polynomials have been inspired by quantum query algorithms. This book provides a comprehensive review of the foundational and recent developments of an important topic in both classical and quantum computing. The reader has a considerable body of knowledge condensed in an accessible form to quickly understand the principles and further their own research.

•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Approximate Degree Lower Bounds for Oracle Identification Problems

Mark Bun, Nadiia Voronova

The approximate degree of a Boolean function is the minimum degree of real polynomial that approximates it pointwise. For any Boolean function, its approximate degree serves as a lower bound on its quantum query complexity, and generically lifts to a quantum communication lower bound for a related function. We introduce a framework for proving approximate degree lower bounds for certain oracle identification problems, where the goal is to recover a hidden binary string $x \in \{0, 1\}^n$ given possibly non-standard oracle access to it. Our lower bounds apply to decision versions of these problems, where the goal is to compute the parity of $x$. We apply our framework to the ordered search and hidden string problems, proving nearly tight approximate degree lower bounds of $Ω(n/\log^2 n)$ for each. These lower bounds generalize to the weakly unbounded error setting, giving a new quantum query lower bound for the hidden string problem in this regime. Our lower bounds are driven by randomized communication upper bounds for the greater-than and equality functions.

arXiv:2303.03921•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2023•3 citations
We prove lower bounds on complexity measures, such as the approximate degree of a Boolean function and the approximate rank of a Boolean matrix, using quantum arguments. We prove these lower bounds using a quantum query algorithm for the combinatorial group testing problem. We show that for any function f, the approximate degree of computing the OR of n copies of f is Omega(sqrt n) times the approximate degree of f, which is optimal. No such general result was known prior to our work, and even the lower bound for the OR of ANDs function was only resolved in 2013. We then prove an analogous result in communication complexity, showing that the logarithm of the approximate rank (or more precisely, the approximate gamma-2 norm) of F: X x Y to 0,1 grows by a factor of Omega (sqrtn) when we take the OR of n copies of F, which is also essentially optimal. As a corollary, we give a new proof of Razborov's celebrated Omega(sqrtn) lower bound on the quantum communication complexity of the disjointness problem. Finally, we generalize both these results from composition with the OR function to composition with arbitrary symmetric functions, yielding nearly optimal lower bounds in this setting as well.
We prove lower bounds on complexity measures, such as the approximate degree of a Boolean function and the approximate rank of a Boolean matrix, using quantum arguments. We prove these lower bounds using a quantum query algorithm for the combinatorial group testing problem. We show that for any function f, the approximate degree of computing the OR of n copies of f is Omega(sqrt{n}) times the approximate degree of f, which is optimal. No such general result was known prior to our work, and even the lower bound for the OR of ANDs function was only resolved in 2013. We then prove an analogous result in communication complexity, showing that the logarithm of the approximate rank (or more precisely, the approximate gamma_2 norm) of F: X x Y -> {0,1} grows by a factor of Omega~(sqrt{n}) when we take the OR of n copies of F, which is also essentially optimal. As a corollary, we give a new proof of Razborov's celebrated Omega(sqrt{n}) lower bound on the quantum communication complexity of the disjointness problem. Finally, we generalize both these results from composition with the OR function to composition with arbitrary symmetric functions, yielding nearly optimal lower bounds in this setting as well.
One of the best lower bound methods for the quantum communication complexity of a function H (with or without shared entanglement) is the logarithm of the approximate rank of the communication matrix of H. This measure is essentially equivalent to the approximate gamma-2 norm and generalized discrepancy, and subsumes several other lower bounds. All known lower bounds on quantum communication complexity in the general unbounded-round model can be shown via the logarithm of approximate rank, and it was an open problem to give any separation at all between quantum communication complexity and the logarithm of the approximate rank. In this work we provide the first such separation: We exhibit a total function H with quantum communication complexity almost quadratically larger than the logarithm of its approximate rank. We construct H using the communication lookup function framework of Anshu et al. (FOCS 2016) based on the cheat sheet framework of Aaronson et al. (STOC 2016). From a starting function F, this framework defines a new function H=F_G. Our main technical result is a lower bound on the quantum communication complexity of F_G in terms of the discrepancy of F, which we do via quantum information theoretic arguments. We show the upper bound on the approximate rank of F_G by relating it to the Boolean circuit size of the starting function F.
Abstract: We will discuss a general norm based framework for showing lower bounds on communication complexity. An advantage of this approach is that one can use duality theory to obtain a lower bound quantity phrased as a maximization problem, which can be more convenient to work with in showing lower bounds. We discuss two applications of this approach. 1. The approximation rank of a matrix A is the minimum rank of a matrix close to A in ell_infty norm. The logarithm of approximation rank lower bounds quantum communication complexity and is one of the most powerful techniques available, albeit difficult to compute in practice. We show that an approximation norm known as gamma_2 is polynomially related to approximation rank. This results in a polynomial time algorithm to approximate approximation rank, and also shows that the logarithm of approximation rank lower bounds quantum communication complexity even with entanglement which was previously not known. 2. By means of an approximation norm which lower bounds multiparty number-on-the-forehead complexity, we show non-trivial lower bounds on the complexity of the disjointness function for up to c log log n players, c <1.
In a breakthrough result, Razborov (2003) gave optimal lower bounds on the communication complexity of every function f of the form f(x,y)=D(|x AND y|) for some D:{0,1,...,n}->{0,1}, in the bounded-error quantum model with and without prior entanglement. This was proved by the multidimensional discrepancy method. We give an entirely different proof of Razborov's result, using the original, one-dimensional discrepancy method. This refutes the commonly held intuition (Razborov 2003) that the original discrepancy method fails for functions such as DISJOINTNESS. More importantly, our communication lower bounds hold for a much broader class of functions for which no methods were available. Namely, fix an arbitrary function f:{0,1}n/4->{0,1} and let A be the Boolean matrix whose columns are each an application of f to some subset of the variables x1,x2,...,xn. We prove that the communication complexity of A in the bounded-error quantum model with and without prior entanglement is Omega(d), where d is the approximate degree of f. From this result, Razborov's lower bounds follow easily. Our result also establishes a large new class of total Boolean functions whose quantum communication complexity (regardless of prior entanglement) is at best polynomially smaller than their classical complexity. Our proof method is a novel combination of two ingredients. The first is a certain equivalence of approximation and orthogonality in Euclidean n-space, which follows by linear-programming duality. The second is a new construction of suitably structured matrices with low spectral norm, the pattern matrices, which we realize using matrix analysis and the Fourier transform over (Z2)n. The method of this paper has recently inspired important progress in multiparty communication complexity.
The ability (or inability) to represent or approximate Boolean functions by polynomials is a central concept in complexity theory, underlying interactive and probabilistically checkable proof systems, circuit lower bounds, quantum complexity theory, and more. In this book, the authors survey what is known about a particularly natural notion of approximation by polynomials, capturing pointwise approximation over This book covers recent progress on proving approximate degree lower and upper bounds and describes some applications of the new bounds to oracle separations, quantum query and communication complexity, and circuit complexity. The authors explain how several of these advances have been unlocked by a particularly simple and elegant technique, called dual block composition, for constructing solutions to this dual linear program. They also provide concise coverage of even more recent lower bound techniques based on a new complexity measure called spectral sensitivity. Finally, they show how explicit constructions of approximating polynomials have been inspired by quantum query algorithms. This book provides a comprehensive review of the foundational and recent developments of an important topic in both classical and quantum computing. The reader has a considerable body of knowledge condensed in an accessible form to quickly understand the principles and further their own research.
The approximate degree of a Boolean function is the minimum degree of real polynomial that approximates it pointwise. For any Boolean function, its approximate degree serves as a lower bound on its quantum query complexity, and generically lifts to a quantum communication lower bound for a related function. We introduce a framework for proving approximate degree lower bounds for certain oracle identification problems, where the goal is to recover a hidden binary string x∈{0,1}nx \in \{0, 1\}^nx∈{0,1}n given possibly non-standard oracle access to it. Our lower bounds apply to decision versions of these problems, where the goal is to compute the parity of xxx. We apply our framework to the ordered search and hidden string problems, proving nearly tight approximate degree lower bounds of Ω(n/log⁡2n)Ω(n/\log^2 n)Ω(n/log2n) for each. These lower bounds generalize to the weakly unbounded error setting, giving a new quantum query lower bound for the hidden string problem in this regime. Our lower bounds are driven by randomized communication upper bounds for the greater-than and equality functions.