Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Interference in Time: A Comment

Lawrence Paul Horwitz

Published Jul 5, 2005• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

I comment on the interpretation of a recent experiment showing quantum interference in time. It is pointed out that the standard nonrelativistic quantum theory, used by the authors in their analysis, cannot account for the results found, and therefore that this experiment has fundamental importance beyond the technical advances it represents. The recent experiment of Lindner, et al 1, clearly shows the effect of interference in time for a particle wave function. The results are discussed in that paper in terms of a very precise solution of the time-dependent nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation. In this Comment, I wish to point out that the nonrelativistic Schrödinger theory cannot predict interference phenomena in time, and therefore the very striking results of this beautiful experiment have a fundamental importance which goes beyond the technical advances which it represents. It is well known, in fact, that the nonrelativistic quantum theory cannot predict interference in time. For example, Ludwig 2 has pointed out that the time variable cannot be a quantum observable, a prerequisite for the development of interference phenomena, since

Related papers

Interference in time

ANDRZEJ GÓŹDŹ, M. DȨBICKI, K. Stefańska

A series of experiments has shown the possibility of existence of interference in time, a phenomenon similar to interference in space. A possible description of this phenomenon based on the hypothesis of the quantum projection evolution is presented.

Physics of Atomic Nuclei•May 1, 2008•6 citations

Diffraction in Time

M. Moshińsky

In a previous note a dynamical description of resonance scattering was given, and transient terms appeared in the wave function describing the process. To understand the physical significance of these terms, the transient effects that appear when a shutter is opened are discussed in this paper. For a nonrelativistic beam of particles, the transient current has a close mathematical resemblance with the intensity of light in the Fresnel diffraction by a straight edge. This is the reason for calling the transient phenomena by the name of diffraction in time.The shutter problem is discussed for particles whose wave functions satisfy the Schr\"odinger equation, the ordinary wave equation, and the Klein-Gordon equation. Only for the Schr\"odinger time-dependent equation do the transient wave functions resemble the solutions that appear in Sommerfeld's theory of diffraction. The connection of transient phenomena with the time-energy uncertainty relation, and the interpretation of the transient current in a scattering process, are briefly discussed. The relativistic wave functions for the shutter problem may play an important role in the dynamical description of a relativistic scattering process.

Physical Review•Nov 1, 1952•314 citations

Schroedinger equation and classical physics

M. V. Lokajíček

Any time-dependent solution of Schrödinger equation may be always correlated to a solution of Hamilton equations or to a statistical combination of their solutions; only the set of corresponding solutions is somewhat smaller (due to existence of quantization). There is not any reason to the physical interpretation according to Copenhagen alternative as Bell's inequalities are valid in the classical physics only (and not in any alternative based on Schrödinger equation). The advantage of Schrödinger equation consists then in that it enables to represent directly the time evolution of a statistical distribution of classical initial states (which is usual in collision experiments). The Schrödinger equation (without assumptions added by Bohr) may then represent the common physical theory for microscopic as well as macroscopic physical systems. However, together with the last possibility the solutions of Schrödinger equation may be helpful also in analyzing the influence of other statistically distributed properties (e.g., spin orientations or space structures) of individual matter objects forming a corresponding physical system, which goes in principle beyond the classical physics. In any case, the contemporary quantum theory represents the phenomenological approximative description of some matter characteristics only, without providing any insight into quantum mechanism emergence. In such a case it is necessary to take into account more detailed properties at least of some involved objects.

arXiv:1205.6720•May 30, 2012•2 citations

On Time in Quantum Physics

Jeremy Butterfield

First, I briefly review the different conceptions of time held by three rival interpretations of quantum theory: the collapse of the wave-packet, the pilot-wave interpretation, and the Everett interpretation (Section 2). Then I turn to a much less controversial task: to expound the recent understanding of the time-energy uncertainty principle, and indeed of uncertainty principles in general, that has been established by such authors as Busch, Hilgevoord and Uffink. Although this may at first seem a narrow topic, I point out connections to other conceptual topics about time in quantum theory: for example, the question under what circumstances there is a time operator (Section 4.3).

arXiv:1406.4745•Wiley eBooks•Jan 29, 2013•31 citations

Comment on “Solution of the Schrödinger equation for the time-dependent linear potential”

Jarosław H. Bauer

It is shown that the wave function recently found by Guedes [Phys. Rev. A 63, 034102 (2001)] is a special case of the well-known Volkov solution to the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation describing a nonrelativistic charged particle moving in an electromagnetic field.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 2002•34 citations

Time in Quantum Theory

H. D. Zeh

The concept of time as used in various applications and interpretations of quantum theory is briefly reviewed.

arXiv:0705.4638•May 31, 2007•3 citations
I comment on the interpretation of a recent experiment showing quantum interference in time. It is pointed out that the standard nonrelativistic quantum theory, used by the authors in their analysis, cannot account for the results found, and therefore that this experiment has fundamental importance beyond the technical advances it represents. The recent experiment of Lindner, et al 1, clearly shows the effect of interference in time for a particle wave function. The results are discussed in that paper in terms of a very precise solution of the time-dependent nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation. In this Comment, I wish to point out that the nonrelativistic Schrödinger theory cannot predict interference phenomena in time, and therefore the very striking results of this beautiful experiment have a fundamental importance which goes beyond the technical advances which it represents. It is well known, in fact, that the nonrelativistic quantum theory cannot predict interference in time. For example, Ludwig 2 has pointed out that the time variable cannot be a quantum observable, a prerequisite for the development of interference phenomena, since
In a previous note a dynamical description of resonance scattering was given, and transient terms appeared in the wave function describing the process. To understand the physical significance of these terms, the transient effects that appear when a shutter is opened are discussed in this paper. For a nonrelativistic beam of particles, the transient current has a close mathematical resemblance with the intensity of light in the Fresnel diffraction by a straight edge. This is the reason for calling the transient phenomena by the name of diffraction in time.The shutter problem is discussed for particles whose wave functions satisfy the Schr\"odinger equation, the ordinary wave equation, and the Klein-Gordon equation. Only for the Schr\"odinger time-dependent equation do the transient wave functions resemble the solutions that appear in Sommerfeld's theory of diffraction. The connection of transient phenomena with the time-energy uncertainty relation, and the interpretation of the transient current in a scattering process, are briefly discussed. The relativistic wave functions for the shutter problem may play an important role in the dynamical description of a relativistic scattering process.
Any time-dependent solution of Schrödinger equation may be always correlated to a solution of Hamilton equations or to a statistical combination of their solutions; only the set of corresponding solutions is somewhat smaller (due to existence of quantization). There is not any reason to the physical interpretation according to Copenhagen alternative as Bell's inequalities are valid in the classical physics only (and not in any alternative based on Schrödinger equation). The advantage of Schrödinger equation consists then in that it enables to represent directly the time evolution of a statistical distribution of classical initial states (which is usual in collision experiments). The Schrödinger equation (without assumptions added by Bohr) may then represent the common physical theory for microscopic as well as macroscopic physical systems. However, together with the last possibility the solutions of Schrödinger equation may be helpful also in analyzing the influence of other statistically distributed properties (e.g., spin orientations or space structures) of individual matter objects forming a corresponding physical system, which goes in principle beyond the classical physics. In any case, the contemporary quantum theory represents the phenomenological approximative description of some matter characteristics only, without providing any insight into quantum mechanism emergence. In such a case it is necessary to take into account more detailed properties at least of some involved objects.
First, I briefly review the different conceptions of time held by three rival interpretations of quantum theory: the collapse of the wave-packet, the pilot-wave interpretation, and the Everett interpretation (Section 2). Then I turn to a much less controversial task: to expound the recent understanding of the time-energy uncertainty principle, and indeed of uncertainty principles in general, that has been established by such authors as Busch, Hilgevoord and Uffink. Although this may at first seem a narrow topic, I point out connections to other conceptual topics about time in quantum theory: for example, the question under what circumstances there is a time operator (Section 4.3).