Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Communication: Adiabatic quantum trajectory capture for cold and ultra-cold chemical reactions

Yohann Scribano, Gérard Parlant, Bill Poirier

Published Jul 13, 2018• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Langevin capture model is often used to describe barrierless reactive collisions. At very low temperatures, quantum effects may alter this simple capture image and dramatically affect the reaction probability. In this paper, we use the trajectory-ensemble reformulation of quantum mechanics, as recently proposed by one of the authors (Poirier) to compute adiabatic-channel capture probabilities and cross-sections for the highly exothermic reaction Li + CaH(v = 0, j = 0) → LiH + Ca, at low and ultra-low temperatures. Each captured quantum trajectory takes full account of tunneling and quantum reflection along the radial collision coordinate. Our approach is found to be very fast and accurate, down to extremely low temperatures. Moreover, it provides an intuitive and practical procedure for determining the capture distance (i.e., where the capture probability is evaluated), which would otherwise be arbitrary.

DOI
10.1063/1.5041091

Related papers

Adiabatic quantum trajectory capture method for cold and ultra-cold chemical reactions

Yohann Scribano, Gérard Parlant, Bill Poirier

While direct reactions with activation barriers are now routinely calculated, reactions going through a longlivedintermediate complex are much more difficult to study[1, 2]. Complex-forming reactions are often barrierlessand are thus relevant to the field of cold and utra-cold chemistry [2]. With decreasing temperature, wave effectsbecome increasingly important and may dominate the collisional behavior at ultralow temperatures. Capture theories(close-coupling expansion with boundary conditions applied in the reactant channel) are often used to studycomplex-forming reactions [3, 4].The Langevin capture model is often used to describe barrierless reactive collisions. At very low temperature,quantum effects may alter this simple capture image and dramatically affect the reaction probability. In this talk,we use the trajectory-ensemble reformulation of quantum mechanics without wavefunctions recently proposed byPoirier and coworkers[5, 6] to compute adiabatic-channel capture probabilities and cross-sections for the reactionLi + CaH(v = 0; j = 0)!LiH + Ca at low and ultra-low temperatures. The captured quantum trajectory takes fullaccount of tunneling and quantum reflection along the radial collision coordinate. Our approach turns out to bevery fast and accurate, down to extremely low temperatures.

•Jun 12, 2018•0 citations

Adiabatic channel capture theory applied to cold atom–molecule reactions: Li + CaH $\to $ LiH + Ca at 1K

Timur V. Tscherbul, Alexei A. Buchachenko

We use quantum and classical adiabatic capture theories to study the chemical reaction Li + CaH LiH + Ca. Using a recently developed ab initio potential energy surface, which provides an accurate representation of long-range interactions in the entrance reaction channel, we calculate the adiabatic channel potentials by diagonalizing the Li-CaH Hamiltonian as a function of the atom-molecule separation. The resulting adiabatic channel potentials are used to calculate both the classical and quantum capture probabilities as a function of collision energy, as well as the temperature dependencies of the partial and total reaction rates. The calculated reaction rate agrees well with the measured value at 1 K (V Singh et al 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 108 203201), suggesting that the title reaction proceeds without an activation barrier. The calculated classical adiabatic capture rate agrees well with the quantum result in the multiple-partial-wave regime of relevance to the experiment. Significant differences are found only in the ultracold limit ( mK), demonstrating that adiabatic capture theories can predict the reaction rates with nearly quantitative accuracy in the multiple-partial-wave regime.

arXiv:1412.4575•New Journal of Physics•Mar 20, 2015•17 citations

Quantum reactive scattering calculations for the cold and ultracold Li + LiNa → Li2 + Na reaction

Brian K. Kendrick

A first-principles based quantum dynamics study of the Li + LiNa(v = 0, j = 0) → Li2(v′, j′) + Na reaction is reported for collision energies spanning the ultracold (1 nK) to cold (1 K) regimes. A full-dimensional ab initio potential energy surface for the ground electronic state of Li2Na is utilized that includes an accurate treatment of the long-range interactions. The Li + LiNa reaction is barrierless and exoergic and exhibits a deep attractive potential well that supports complex formation. Thus, significant reactivity occurs even for collision temperatures approaching absolute zero. The reactive scattering calculations are based on a numerically exact time-independent quantum dynamics methodology in hyperspherical coordinates. Total and rotationally resolved rate coefficients are reported at 56 collision energies and include all contributing partial waves. Several shape resonances are observed in many of the rotationally resolved rate coefficients and a small resonance feature is also reported in the total rate coefficient near 50 mK. Of particular interest, the angular distributions or differential cross sections are reported as a function of both the collision energy and scattering angle. Unique quantum fingerprints (bumps, channels, and ripples) are observed in the angular distributions for each product rotational state due to quantum interference and shape resonance contributions. The Li + LiNa reaction is under active experimental investigation so that these intriguing features could be verified experimentally when sufficient product state resolution becomes feasible for collision energies below 1 K.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 22, 2021•16 citations

Ion-neutral chemistry at ultralow energies: Dynamics of reactive collisions between laser-cooled Ca^+ ions and Rb atoms in an ion-atom hybrid trap

Felix H. J. Hall, Pascal Eberle, Gregor Hegi +4 more

Cold chemical reactions between laser-cooled Ca^+ ions and Rb atoms were studied in an ion-atom hybrid trap. Reaction rate constants were determined in the range of collision energies /k_B = 20 mK-20 K. The lowest energies were achieved in experiments using single localized Ca^+ ions. Product branching ratios were studied using resonant-excitation mass spectrometry. The dynamics of the reactive processes in this system (non-radiative and radiative charge transfer as well as radiative association leading to the formation of CaRb^+ molecular ions) have been analyzed using high-level quantum-chemical calculations of the potential energy curves of CaRb^+ and quantum-scattering calculations for the radiative channels. For the present low-energy scattering experiments, it is shown that the energy dependence of the reaction rate constants is governed by long-range interactions in line with the classical Langevin model, but their magnitude is determined by short-range non-adiabatic and radiative couplings which only weakly depend on the asymptotic energy. The quantum character of the collisions is predicted to manifest itself in the occurrence of narrow shape resonances at well-defined collision energies. The present results highlight both universal and system-specific phenomena in cold ion-neutral reactive collisions.

•Feb 19, 2013•0 citations

Observation of quantum capture in an ion-molecule reaction

Katharina Höveler, Johannes Deiglmayr, Josef A. Agner +3 more

Vogt and Wannier [Phys. Rev. 95, 1190 (1954)] predicted that the capture rate of a polarizable neutral atom or molecule by an ion should increase by a factor of 2 compared to the classical Langevin rate as the collision energy approaches zero. This prediction has not been verified experimentally. The ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}^{+}$ $+$ ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}$ reaction is ideally suited to observe this effect because the small reduced mass makes quantum effects related to $s$-wave scattering observable at higher collision energies than in other systems. Moreover, the reaction rate for this barrierless, strongly exothermic reaction follows the classical Langevin capture model down to cold-collision conditions (about ${k}_{\mathrm{B}}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}1$ K) and is not affected by short-range interactions. Below this temperature, a strong enhancement of the reaction rate resulting from charge--quadrupole interaction between ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}^{+}$ and ground-state ortho ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}$ ($J=1$) was observed. Here we present an experimental study of the reaction of ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}^{+}$ and para ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}$ ($J=0$), which has no dipole and no quadrupole moments, at collision energies below ${k}_{\mathrm{B}}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}1$ K. We observe an enhancement at the lowest collision energies which is attributed to the quantum enhancement predicted by Vogt and Wannier. Measurements of the reaction of ${\mathrm{HD}}^{+}$ with HD support this conclusion.

arXiv:2211.06290•Physical Review A•Nov 14, 2022•6 citations

Cold ion-neutral reactions

Felix H. J. Hall

Cold ion-neutral reactive processes were studied in an hybrid trap down to average collision energies <E_coll>/k_B > 20 mK. The atomic ion-neutral systems Ca^+ + Rb and Ba^+ + Rb were studied, and the results interpreted with high-level quantum chemical and quantum scattering calculations. Three reactive processes were found to be in competition, namely non-radiative charge transfer induced by non-adiabatic couplings between potential energy surfaces, radiative charge transfer, and radiative association of molecular ions, which were observed using mass spectrometry. The role of light in these processes was investigated. Enhancement of reaction rate constants from electronically excited entrance channels was observed and rationalised using computed potential energy curves. The collision-energy dependence of the reaction rate constants was investigated, and was found to be in line with predictions of both classical and quantum models uncovering general effects in cold ion-neutral systems. Cold reactions in the molecular ion-neutral system N_2^+ + Rb were also investigated with average collision energies two orders of magnitude lower than previously realised. The reaction rate constant in this system was found to depend strongly on the Rb ^2P_3/2 population, with the rate constant from the corresponding excited entrance channel being significantly faster than the collision rate predicted by Langevin theory. A classical capture model was developed taking into account the charge permanent-quadrupole intermolecular force and was found to reproduce the observed rate. The implied near unit reaction probability was rationalised by a near electronic resonance of entrance and product channels. A detailed description of the implementation of the ion-neutral hybrid trap is given. A thorough comparison of the results from state-of-the-art experiments and theory reveals general features of light assisted cold ion-neutral reactions. \n

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations
The Langevin capture model is often used to describe barrierless reactive collisions. At very low temperatures, quantum effects may alter this simple capture image and dramatically affect the reaction probability. In this paper, we use the trajectory-ensemble reformulation of quantum mechanics, as recently proposed by one of the authors (Poirier) to compute adiabatic-channel capture probabilities and cross-sections for the highly exothermic reaction Li + CaH(v = 0, j = 0) → LiH + Ca, at low and ultra-low temperatures. Each captured quantum trajectory takes full account of tunneling and quantum reflection along the radial collision coordinate. Our approach is found to be very fast and accurate, down to extremely low temperatures. Moreover, it provides an intuitive and practical procedure for determining the capture distance (i.e., where the capture probability is evaluated), which would otherwise be arbitrary.
While direct reactions with activation barriers are now routinely calculated, reactions going through a longlivedintermediate complex are much more difficult to study[1, 2]. Complex-forming reactions are often barrierlessand are thus relevant to the field of cold and utra-cold chemistry [2]. With decreasing temperature, wave effectsbecome increasingly important and may dominate the collisional behavior at ultralow temperatures. Capture theories(close-coupling expansion with boundary conditions applied in the reactant channel) are often used to studycomplex-forming reactions [3, 4].The Langevin capture model is often used to describe barrierless reactive collisions. At very low temperature,quantum effects may alter this simple capture image and dramatically affect the reaction probability. In this talk,we use the trajectory-ensemble reformulation of quantum mechanics without wavefunctions recently proposed byPoirier and coworkers[5, 6] to compute adiabatic-channel capture probabilities and cross-sections for the reactionLi + CaH(v = 0; j = 0)!LiH + Ca at low and ultra-low temperatures. The captured quantum trajectory takes fullaccount of tunneling and quantum reflection along the radial collision coordinate. Our approach turns out to bevery fast and accurate, down to extremely low temperatures.
We use quantum and classical adiabatic capture theories to study the chemical reaction Li + CaH LiH + Ca. Using a recently developed ab initio potential energy surface, which provides an accurate representation of long-range interactions in the entrance reaction channel, we calculate the adiabatic channel potentials by diagonalizing the Li-CaH Hamiltonian as a function of the atom-molecule separation. The resulting adiabatic channel potentials are used to calculate both the classical and quantum capture probabilities as a function of collision energy, as well as the temperature dependencies of the partial and total reaction rates. The calculated reaction rate agrees well with the measured value at 1 K (V Singh et al 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 108 203201), suggesting that the title reaction proceeds without an activation barrier. The calculated classical adiabatic capture rate agrees well with the quantum result in the multiple-partial-wave regime of relevance to the experiment. Significant differences are found only in the ultracold limit ( mK), demonstrating that adiabatic capture theories can predict the reaction rates with nearly quantitative accuracy in the multiple-partial-wave regime.
A first-principles based quantum dynamics study of the Li + LiNa(v = 0, j = 0) → Li2(v′, j′) + Na reaction is reported for collision energies spanning the ultracold (1 nK) to cold (1 K) regimes. A full-dimensional ab initio potential energy surface for the ground electronic state of Li2Na is utilized that includes an accurate treatment of the long-range interactions. The Li + LiNa reaction is barrierless and exoergic and exhibits a deep attractive potential well that supports complex formation. Thus, significant reactivity occurs even for collision temperatures approaching absolute zero. The reactive scattering calculations are based on a numerically exact time-independent quantum dynamics methodology in hyperspherical coordinates. Total and rotationally resolved rate coefficients are reported at 56 collision energies and include all contributing partial waves. Several shape resonances are observed in many of the rotationally resolved rate coefficients and a small resonance feature is also reported in the total rate coefficient near 50 mK. Of particular interest, the angular distributions or differential cross sections are reported as a function of both the collision energy and scattering angle. Unique quantum fingerprints (bumps, channels, and ripples) are observed in the angular distributions for each product rotational state due to quantum interference and shape resonance contributions. The Li + LiNa reaction is under active experimental investigation so that these intriguing features could be verified experimentally when sufficient product state resolution becomes feasible for collision energies below 1 K.
Cold chemical reactions between laser-cooled Ca^+ ions and Rb atoms were studied in an ion-atom hybrid trap. Reaction rate constants were determined in the range of collision energies /k_B = 20 mK-20 K. The lowest energies were achieved in experiments using single localized Ca^+ ions. Product branching ratios were studied using resonant-excitation mass spectrometry. The dynamics of the reactive processes in this system (non-radiative and radiative charge transfer as well as radiative association leading to the formation of CaRb^+ molecular ions) have been analyzed using high-level quantum-chemical calculations of the potential energy curves of CaRb^+ and quantum-scattering calculations for the radiative channels. For the present low-energy scattering experiments, it is shown that the energy dependence of the reaction rate constants is governed by long-range interactions in line with the classical Langevin model, but their magnitude is determined by short-range non-adiabatic and radiative couplings which only weakly depend on the asymptotic energy. The quantum character of the collisions is predicted to manifest itself in the occurrence of narrow shape resonances at well-defined collision energies. The present results highlight both universal and system-specific phenomena in cold ion-neutral reactive collisions.
Vogt and Wannier [Phys. Rev. 95, 1190 (1954)] predicted that the capture rate of a polarizable neutral atom or molecule by an ion should increase by a factor of 2 compared to the classical Langevin rate as the collision energy approaches zero. This prediction has not been verified experimentally. The H2+{\mathrm{H}}_{2}^{+}H2+​ +++ H2{\mathrm{H}}_{2}H2​ reaction is ideally suited to observe this effect because the small reduced mass makes quantum effects related to sss-wave scattering observable at higher collision energies than in other systems. Moreover, the reaction rate for this barrierless, strongly exothermic reaction follows the classical Langevin capture model down to cold-collision conditions (about ${k}_{\mathrm{B}}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}1$ K) and is not affected by short-range interactions. Below this temperature, a strong enhancement of the reaction rate resulting from charge--quadrupole interaction between H2+{\mathrm{H}}_{2}^{+}H2+​ and ground-state ortho H2{\mathrm{H}}_{2}H2​ (J=1J=1J=1) was observed. Here we present an experimental study of the reaction of H2+{\mathrm{H}}_{2}^{+}H2+​ and para H2{\mathrm{H}}_{2}H2​ (J=0J=0J=0), which has no dipole and no quadrupole moments, at collision energies below ${k}_{\mathrm{B}}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}1$ K. We observe an enhancement at the lowest collision energies which is attributed to the quantum enhancement predicted by Vogt and Wannier. Measurements of the reaction of HD+{\mathrm{HD}}^{+}HD+ with HD support this conclusion.
Cold ion-neutral reactive processes were studied in an hybrid trap down to average collision energies <E_coll>/k_B > 20 mK. The atomic ion-neutral systems Ca^+ + Rb and Ba^+ + Rb were studied, and the results interpreted with high-level quantum chemical and quantum scattering calculations. Three reactive processes were found to be in competition, namely non-radiative charge transfer induced by non-adiabatic couplings between potential energy surfaces, radiative charge transfer, and radiative association of molecular ions, which were observed using mass spectrometry. The role of light in these processes was investigated. Enhancement of reaction rate constants from electronically excited entrance channels was observed and rationalised using computed potential energy curves. The collision-energy dependence of the reaction rate constants was investigated, and was found to be in line with predictions of both classical and quantum models uncovering general effects in cold ion-neutral systems. Cold reactions in the molecular ion-neutral system N_2^+ + Rb were also investigated with average collision energies two orders of magnitude lower than previously realised. The reaction rate constant in this system was found to depend strongly on the Rb ^2P_3/2 population, with the rate constant from the corresponding excited entrance channel being significantly faster than the collision rate predicted by Langevin theory. A classical capture model was developed taking into account the charge permanent-quadrupole intermolecular force and was found to reproduce the observed rate. The implied near unit reaction probability was rationalised by a near electronic resonance of entrance and product channels. A detailed description of the implementation of the ion-neutral hybrid trap is given. A thorough comparison of the results from state-of-the-art experiments and theory reveals general features of light assisted cold ion-neutral reactions. \n