Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

The wow and the woo

Philip Moriarty

Published Jun 1, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

To say that I eagerly anticipated the arrival of my review copy of Jean Bricmont’s latest book, Quantum Sense and Nonsense , would be an understatement approaching “we physicists have maybe got one or two loose ends to tie up when it comes to interpreting quantum mechanics” proportions.
DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/31/6/33

Related papers

Out of My Mind: A Cosmic Flow

Jeremy Bernstein

Not long ago I was invited to dinner to meet a young artist who, I was told, had recently developed a strong interest in physics, especially in the physics of elementary particles my own field of research. Ever eager to bridge the yawning crevasse that, it appears, separates the two cultures coupled with the prospect of an excellent meal I accepted at once. Upon my arrival, it turned out that the young man in question was accompanied by an attractive girlfriend and that she too had a burgeoning interest in the physics of elementary particles. This intriguing concidence, it developed, did not have its origin in any of the more recent discoveries in our discipline, but rather in a book they had read that, according to them, demonstrated that elementary particle physics provided a scientific basis for many of the revelations of Eastern mysticism. Could I, they wondered, enlighten them further on this remarkable development? Their faces, however, fell to half-mast when I confessed that (a) I had never heard of the source of their inspirationone Fritjof Capra and that (b) I had not read his chef d'oeuvre, The Tao of Physics, which, they assured me, was the book in which this reconciliation was detailed. They were further discomfited when I remarked that for the sake of Eastern mystic philosophy I hoped it wasn't true. In fact, I added, if I were a Tibetan monk or the swami in an ashram in New Delhi and if Fritjof Capra or anyone else came to my door clutching the latest copy of the Physical Review

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Interpreting the Quantum World

Asher Peres

This is an "Essay-Review" of a book with the same title, by Jeffrey Bub (Cambridge University Press, 1997).

arXiv:quant-ph/9711003•Nov 5, 1997•4 citations

What is ‘real’: A brief comparison

Karl David Stephan

Steven French’s review of Bernard d’Espagnat’s 500-page tome On Physics and Philosophy (Physics Today, Physics Today 0031-9228 60 6 2007 66 https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2754610. June 2007, page 66 ) got my attention, with its repeated discussion of something d’Espagnat calls “the Real.” I must confess I have not seen d’Espagnat’s book, but the more I read about this Real in French’s review, the more I thought I’d heard of it somewhere before. In the true scientific spirit of bringing to the attention of a researcher the results of prior research bearing on his work, I have interspersed citations from the Summa Theologica by Thomas Aquinas (1225–74) between passages from French’s review of d’Espagnat’s book.French states that the Real “nevertheless exerts an influence on the phenomena.”Aquinas wrote, “As there can be nothing which is not created by God, so there can be nothing which is not subject to His government” (part 1, question 103, article 5).French writes, “The grand laws of physics are ‘highly distorted reflections … of the great structures of “the Real”’ (page 455)…. The Real, although impossible to conceive, is nonseparable; from it, both consciousness and empirical reality ‘co-emerge.’”Aquinas wrote, “From the knowledge of sensible things the whole power of God cannot be known; nor therefore can His essence be seen. But because they are His effects and depend on their cause, we can be led from them so far as to know of God whether He exists, and to know of Him what must necessarily belong to Him, as the first cause of all things, exceeding all things caused by Him” (part 1, question 12, article 12).Aquinas maintained that there cannot ultimately be any disagreement between faith and reason because both come from an infinitely faithful and infinitely reasonable God. It is amusing that an apparently secular philosopher such as d’Espagnat, writing for a modern audience of physicists and philosophers and basing his thought on the latest results of quantum mechanics, has nevertheless arrived at conclusions in harmony with the greatest philosopher of the Middle Ages.© 2008 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2008•0 citations

Quantum Sense and Nonsense

Jean Bricmont

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2017•19 citations

Common Sense and a “Wigner-Dirac” Approach to Quantum Mechanics

Peter Forrest

The Monist•Jan 1, 1997•2 citations

Interpretations of quantum mechanics

Robert B. Griffiths

Jean Bricmont’s review of Travis Norsen’s Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: An Exploration of the Physical Meaning of Quantum Theory (Physics Today, April 2018, page 58) stresses the virtues of Louis de Broglie and David Bohm’s pilot-wave interpretation of quantum mechanics, also referred to as Bohmian mechanics (BM), but the review omits mention of some of that interpretation’s rather serious defects. As Bricmont notes, in BM the standard Schrödinger wavefunction ψ(r, t) for a particle is augmented with a classical trajectory r(t) that is interpreted as the actual precise physical position of the particle as a function of time. Sometimes that Bohmian trajectory can provide a helpful intuitive picture, but in other cases it is quite misleading.John Bell presented an example of how Bohmian trajectories can mislead: a modified double-slit experiment with a lens placed right after each slit so that the emerging beams cross on their way to two distant detectors located beyond the crossing point.11. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press (1987). The beam from the lower slit arrives at the upper detector, and that from the upper slit at the lower detector. If a particle arrives at the upper detector, which slit did it pass through?Bell claims that the naive answer—that the particle came from the lower slit, based on the intuition that particles move in straight lines in a vacuum—is wrong. He notes that a Bohmian particle cannot cross the symmetry plane separating the upper slit and detector from their lower counterparts, and thus a particle arriving at the upper detector actually came from the upper slit: first it moved downward, but when it arrived in the region where the beams cross, it “bounced” back upward toward the upper detector.Years ago I published an analysis that contradicted Bell and showed that the answer he regarded as naive—the particle passes through the crossing region without bouncing—was perfectly good quantum mechanics.22. R. B. Griffiths, Phys. Lett. A 261, 227 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9601(99)00542-3 I am still waiting for someone in the Bohmian community to publish a reply.Norsen is troubled because the nonlocal, often superluminal influences needed to make sense of BM are hard to reconcile with special relativity. Indeed, the widely accepted no-signaling principle of quantum mechanics asserts that those influences cannot transmit information, so a direct experimental detection of them is out of reach. Defenders of BM say they know that nonlocal influences exist because quantum mechanics violates Bell’s inequalities. But as I and others have pointed out, the hidden variables used in derivations of Bell inequalities are fundamentally classical,33. See R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5 in contrast to the representation of quantum properties by Hilbert subspaces, as introduced by John von Neumann.44. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, R. T. Beyer, trans., Princeton U. Press (1955), chap. 3.5. Projectors on those subspaces do not generally commute, which clearly distinguishes quantum physics from classical. Thus that feature, rather than a failure of locality, is why Bell’s inequalities do not agree with quantum theory and experiment.The BM particle trajectories are instances of classical hidden variables, so the nonlocality of the pilot-wave interpretation of quantum mechanics is not surprising. Indeed, when proper account is taken of noncommutativity, one can show that quantum theory satisfies a principle of locality that Albert Einstein might well have agreed with: Objective properties of an isolated individual system do not change when something is done to another, noninteracting system.33. See R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5 Thus a consistent Hilbert-space formulation of quantum theory without hidden variables removes any worry about a conflict with special relativity.Although Bohmian mechanics was worthy of consideration and has been useful in the development of quantum foundations, ignoring more recent developments is not the way to honor the memory of one of the great physicists of the last century. I hope that a second edition of Norsen’s well-written book will take account of more recent work.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press (1987). Google Scholar2. R. B. Griffiths, Phys. Lett. A 261, 227 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9601(99)00542-3, Google ScholarCrossref3. See R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5, Google ScholarCrossref4. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, R. T. Beyer, trans., Princeton U. Press (1955), chap. 3.5. Google Scholar© 2019 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Oct 1, 2019•5 citations
Not long ago I was invited to dinner to meet a young artist who, I was told, had recently developed a strong interest in physics, especially in the physics of elementary particles my own field of research. Ever eager to bridge the yawning crevasse that, it appears, separates the two cultures coupled with the prospect of an excellent meal I accepted at once. Upon my arrival, it turned out that the young man in question was accompanied by an attractive girlfriend and that she too had a burgeoning interest in the physics of elementary particles. This intriguing concidence, it developed, did not have its origin in any of the more recent discoveries in our discipline, but rather in a book they had read that, according to them, demonstrated that elementary particle physics provided a scientific basis for many of the revelations of Eastern mysticism. Could I, they wondered, enlighten them further on this remarkable development? Their faces, however, fell to half-mast when I confessed that (a) I had never heard of the source of their inspirationone Fritjof Capra and that (b) I had not read his chef d'oeuvre, The Tao of Physics, which, they assured me, was the book in which this reconciliation was detailed. They were further discomfited when I remarked that for the sake of Eastern mystic philosophy I hoped it wasn't true. In fact, I added, if I were a Tibetan monk or the swami in an ashram in New Delhi and if Fritjof Capra or anyone else came to my door clutching the latest copy of the Physical Review
Steven French’s review of Bernard d’Espagnat’s 500-page tome On Physics and Philosophy (Physics Today, Physics Today 0031-9228 60 6 2007 66 https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2754610. June 2007, page 66 ) got my attention, with its repeated discussion of something d’Espagnat calls “the Real.” I must confess I have not seen d’Espagnat’s book, but the more I read about this Real in French’s review, the more I thought I’d heard of it somewhere before. In the true scientific spirit of bringing to the attention of a researcher the results of prior research bearing on his work, I have interspersed citations from the Summa Theologica by Thomas Aquinas (1225–74) between passages from French’s review of d’Espagnat’s book.French states that the Real “nevertheless exerts an influence on the phenomena.”Aquinas wrote, “As there can be nothing which is not created by God, so there can be nothing which is not subject to His government” (part 1, question 103, article 5).French writes, “The grand laws of physics are ‘highly distorted reflections … of the great structures of “the Real”’ (page 455)…. The Real, although impossible to conceive, is nonseparable; from it, both consciousness and empirical reality ‘co-emerge.’”Aquinas wrote, “From the knowledge of sensible things the whole power of God cannot be known; nor therefore can His essence be seen. But because they are His effects and depend on their cause, we can be led from them so far as to know of God whether He exists, and to know of Him what must necessarily belong to Him, as the first cause of all things, exceeding all things caused by Him” (part 1, question 12, article 12).Aquinas maintained that there cannot ultimately be any disagreement between faith and reason because both come from an infinitely faithful and infinitely reasonable God. It is amusing that an apparently secular philosopher such as d’Espagnat, writing for a modern audience of physicists and philosophers and basing his thought on the latest results of quantum mechanics, has nevertheless arrived at conclusions in harmony with the greatest philosopher of the Middle Ages.© 2008 American Institute of Physics.
Jean Bricmont’s review of Travis Norsen’s Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: An Exploration of the Physical Meaning of Quantum Theory (Physics Today, April 2018, page 58) stresses the virtues of Louis de Broglie and David Bohm’s pilot-wave interpretation of quantum mechanics, also referred to as Bohmian mechanics (BM), but the review omits mention of some of that interpretation’s rather serious defects. As Bricmont notes, in BM the standard Schrödinger wavefunction ψ(r, t) for a particle is augmented with a classical trajectory r(t) that is interpreted as the actual precise physical position of the particle as a function of time. Sometimes that Bohmian trajectory can provide a helpful intuitive picture, but in other cases it is quite misleading.John Bell presented an example of how Bohmian trajectories can mislead: a modified double-slit experiment with a lens placed right after each slit so that the emerging beams cross on their way to two distant detectors located beyond the crossing point.11. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press (1987). The beam from the lower slit arrives at the upper detector, and that from the upper slit at the lower detector. If a particle arrives at the upper detector, which slit did it pass through?Bell claims that the naive answer—that the particle came from the lower slit, based on the intuition that particles move in straight lines in a vacuum—is wrong. He notes that a Bohmian particle cannot cross the symmetry plane separating the upper slit and detector from their lower counterparts, and thus a particle arriving at the upper detector actually came from the upper slit: first it moved downward, but when it arrived in the region where the beams cross, it “bounced” back upward toward the upper detector.Years ago I published an analysis that contradicted Bell and showed that the answer he regarded as naive—the particle passes through the crossing region without bouncing—was perfectly good quantum mechanics.22. R. B. Griffiths, Phys. Lett. A 261, 227 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9601(99)00542-3 I am still waiting for someone in the Bohmian community to publish a reply.Norsen is troubled because the nonlocal, often superluminal influences needed to make sense of BM are hard to reconcile with special relativity. Indeed, the widely accepted no-signaling principle of quantum mechanics asserts that those influences cannot transmit information, so a direct experimental detection of them is out of reach. Defenders of BM say they know that nonlocal influences exist because quantum mechanics violates Bell’s inequalities. But as I and others have pointed out, the hidden variables used in derivations of Bell inequalities are fundamentally classical,33. See R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5 in contrast to the representation of quantum properties by Hilbert subspaces, as introduced by John von Neumann.44. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, R. T. Beyer, trans., Princeton U. Press (1955), chap. 3.5. Projectors on those subspaces do not generally commute, which clearly distinguishes quantum physics from classical. Thus that feature, rather than a failure of locality, is why Bell’s inequalities do not agree with quantum theory and experiment.The BM particle trajectories are instances of classical hidden variables, so the nonlocality of the pilot-wave interpretation of quantum mechanics is not surprising. Indeed, when proper account is taken of noncommutativity, one can show that quantum theory satisfies a principle of locality that Albert Einstein might well have agreed with: Objective properties of an isolated individual system do not change when something is done to another, noninteracting system.33. See R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5 Thus a consistent Hilbert-space formulation of quantum theory without hidden variables removes any worry about a conflict with special relativity.Although Bohmian mechanics was worthy of consideration and has been useful in the development of quantum foundations, ignoring more recent developments is not the way to honor the memory of one of the great physicists of the last century. I hope that a second edition of Norsen’s well-written book will take account of more recent work.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. J. S. Bell, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy, Cambridge U. Press (1987). Google Scholar2. R. B. Griffiths, Phys. Lett. A 261, 227 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9601(99)00542-3, Google ScholarCrossref3. See R. B. Griffiths, Found. Phys. 41, 705 (2011), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-010-9512-5, Google ScholarCrossref4. J. von Neumann, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, R. T. Beyer, trans., Princeton U. Press (1955), chap. 3.5. Google Scholar© 2019 American Institute of Physics.