Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Competing orders II: A spin on the dimer model

Leon Balents, Lorenz Bartosch, A. A. Burkov, Subir Sachdev A, K. Sengupta

Published Sep 20, 2004• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We study the phases of doped spin S=1/2 quantum antiferromagnets on the square lattice, as they evolve from paramagnetic Mott insulators with valence bond solid (VBS) order at zero doping, to superconductors at moderate doping. The interplay between density wave/VBS order and superconductivity is efficiently described by the quantum dimer model, which acts as an effective theory for the total spin S=0 sector. We extend the dimer model to include fermionic S=1/2 excitations, and show that its mean-field, static gauge field saddle points have projective symmetries (PSGs) similar to those of `slave' particle U(1) and SU(2) gauge theories. We account for the non-perturbative effects of gauge fluctuations by a duality mapping of the S=0 dimer model. The dual theory of vortices has a PSG identical to that found in a previous paper (L. Balents et al., cond-mat/0408329) by a duality analysis of bosons on the square lattice. The previous theory therefore also describes fluctuations across superconducting, supersolid and Mott insulating phases of the present electronic model. Finally, with the aim of describing neutron scattering experiments, we present a phenomenological model for collective S=1 excitations and their coupling to superflow and density wave fluctuations.

Related papers

Putting competing orders in their place near the Mott transition. II. The doped quantum dimer model

Leon Balents, Lorenz Bartosch, A. A. Burkov +2 more

We study the phases of doped spin $S=1∕2$ quantum antiferromagnets on the square lattice as they evolve from paramagnetic Mott insulators with valence bond solid (VBS) order at doping $\ensuremath{\delta}=0$ to superconductors at moderate $\ensuremath{\delta}$. The interplay between density-wave and VBS order and superconductivity is efficiently described by the quantum dimer model, which acts as an effective theory for the total spin $S=0$ sector. We extend the dimer model to include fermionic $S=1∕2$ excitations and show that its mean-field, static gauge-field saddle points have projective symmetries (PSG's) similar to those of ``slave''-particle U(1) and SU(2) gauge theories. We account for the nonperturbative effects of gauge fluctuations by a duality mapping of the $S=0$ dimer model. The dual theory of vortices has a PSG identical to that found in a previous paper [L. Balents et al., preceding paper, Phys. Rev. B 71, 144508 (2005)] by a duality analysis of bosons on the square lattice. The previous theory therefore also describes fluctuations across superconducting, supersolid, and Mott insulating phases of the present electronic model. Finally, with the aim of describing neutron scattering experiments, we present a phenomenological model for collective $S=1$ excitations and their coupling to superflow and density-wave fluctuations.

arXiv:cond-mat/0409470•Physical Review B•Apr 19, 2005•49 citations

Fermionic Spinon Theory of Square Lattice Spin Liquids near the Néel State

Alex Thomson, Subir Sachdev A

Quantum fluctuations of the Néel state of the square lattice antiferromagnet are usually described by a CP 1 theory of bosonic spinons coupled to a U(1) gauge field, and with a global SU(2) spin rotation symmetry.Such a theory also has a confining phase with valence bond solid (VBS) order, and upon including spin-singlet charge-2 Higgs fields, deconfined phases with Z 2 topological order possibly intertwined with discrete broken global symmetries.We present dual theories of the same phases starting from a mean-field theory of fermionic spinons moving in π flux in each square lattice plaquette.Fluctuations about this π-flux state are described by (2 þ 1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD 3 ) with a SU(2) gauge group and N f ¼ 2 flavors of massless Dirac fermions.It has recently been argued by Wang et al. [Deconfined Quantum Critical Points: Symmetries and Dualities, Phys. Rev. X 7, 031051 (2017).]that this QCD 3 theory describes the Néel-VBS quantum phase transition.We introduce adjoint Higgs fields in QCD 3 and obtain fermionic dual descriptions of the phases with Z 2 topological order obtained earlier using the bosonic CP 1 theory.We also present a fermionic spinon derivation of the monopole Berry phases in the U(1) gauge theory of the VBS state.The global phase diagram of these phases contains multicritical points, and our results imply new boson-fermion dualities between critical gauge theories of these points.

arXiv:1708.04626•Physical Review X•Jan 24, 2018•36 citations

Robust d -Wave Superconductivity in the Square-Lattice t − J Model

Shou-Shu Gong, Wei Kang Zhu, D. N. Sheng

Unravelling competing orders emergent in doped Mott insulators and their interplay with unconventional superconductivity is one of the major challenges in condensed matter physics. To explore the possible superconducting state in a doped Mott insulator, we study the square-lattice t-J model with both the nearest-neighbor and next-nearest-neighbor electron hoppings and spin interactions. By using the state-of-the-art density matrix renormalization group calculation with imposing charge U(1) and spin SU(2) symmetries on the six-leg cylinders, we establish a quantum phase diagram including three phases: a stripe charge density wave phase, a superconducting phase without static charge order, and a superconducting phase coexistent with a weak charge stripe order. Crucially, we demonstrate that the superconducting phase has a power-law pairing correlation that decays much slower than the charge density and spin correlations, which is a quasi-1D descendant of the uniform d-wave superconductor in two dimensions. These findings reveal that enhanced charge and spin fluctuations with optimal doping is able to produce robust d-wave superconductivity in doped Mott insulators, providing a foundation for connecting theories of superconductivity to models of strongly correlated systems.

arXiv:2104.03758•Physical Review Letters•Aug 27, 2021•93 citations

Theory of Doped Mott insulators: Duality between Pairing and Magnetism

Qiang-Hua Wang

By bosonizing the electronic t-J model exactly on any two-dimensional (2D) lattices, and integrating out the gauge fluctuations combined to slave particles beyond mean fields, we obtain a theory in terms of physical Cooper pair and spin condensates. In the sense of mutual Berry phase they turn out to be dual to each other. The mutual duality is the missing key in the resonant-valance-bond idea [Science 235, 1196 (1987)]] to work as a paradigm of doped 2D Mott insulators. We argue that the essential aspects of high-T(c) phenomenology can be explained in the present framework.

arXiv:cond-mat/0306395•Physical Review Letters•Feb 4, 2004•15 citations

Confinement transition to density wave order in metallic doped spin liquids

Aavishkar A. Patel, Debanjan Chowdhury, Andrea Allais +1 more

Insulating quantum spin liquids can undergo a confinement transition to a valence bond solid via the condensation of topological excitations of the associated gauge theory. We extend the theory of such transitions to fractionalized Fermi liquids (FL*): These are metallic doped spin liquids in which the Fermi surfaces only have gauge neutral quasiparticles. Using insights from a duality transform on a doped quantum dimer model for the U(1)-FL* state, we show that projective symmetry group of the theory of the topological excitations remains unmodified, but the Fermi surfaces can lead to additional frustrating interactions. We propose a theory for the confinement transition of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$-FL* states via the condensation of visons. A variety of confining, incommensurate density wave states are possible, including some that are similar to the incommensurate $d$-form factor density wave order observed in several recent experiments on the cuprate superconductors.

arXiv:1602.05954•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 25, 2016•22 citations

Competing Orders in Strongly Correlated Systems

R. Ganesh

Systems with competing orders are of great interest in condensed matter physics. When\ntwo phases have comparable energies, novel interplay effects such can be induced by tuning an appropriate parameter. In this thesis, we study two problems of competing orders - (i) ultracold atom gases with competing superfluidity and Charge Density Wave(CDW) orders, and (ii) low dimensional antiferromagnets with Neel order competing against various disordered ground states. \n\nIn the first part of the thesis, we study the\n attractive Hubbard model which could soon be realized in ultracold atom experiments. Close to half-filling, the superfluid ground state competes with a low-lying CDW phase. We study the collective excitations of the superfluid using the Generalized Random Phase Approximation (GRPA) and strong-coupling spin wave analysis.\n The competing CDW phase manifests as a roton-like excitation. We characterize the collective mode spectrum, setting benchmarks for experiments.\n\nWe drive competition between orders by imposing superfluid flow. Superflow leads to various instabilities: in particular, we find a dynamical instability associated with CDW order. We also find a novel dynamical incommensurate instability analogous to exciton condensation in semiconductors.\n\nIn the second part, inspired by experiments on Bi3Mn4O12(NO3)(BMNO), we first study the interlayer dimer state in spin-S bilayer antiferromagnets. At a critical bilayer coupling strength, condensation of triplet excitations leads to Neel order. In describing this transition, bond operator mean field theory suffers from systematic deviations. We bridge these deviations by taking into account corrections arising from higher spin excitations. The interlayer dimer state shows a field induced Neel transition, as seen in BMNO. Our results are relevant to the quantitative modelling of spin-S dimerized systems. \n\nWe then study the J1−J2 model on the honeycomb lattice with frustrating next-nearest neighbour exchange.\n For J2>J1/6, quantum and thermal fluctuations lead to ‘lattice nematic’\nstates. For S=1/2, this lattice nematic takes the form of a valence bond solid.\n\nWith J2<J1 /6, quantum fluctuations melt Neel order so as to give rise to a field induced Neel transition. This scenario can explain the observed properties of BMNO.\n\nWe discuss implications for the honeycomb lattice Hubbard model.

•Aug 31, 2012•1 citation
We study the phases of doped spin S=1/2 quantum antiferromagnets on the square lattice, as they evolve from paramagnetic Mott insulators with valence bond solid (VBS) order at zero doping, to superconductors at moderate doping. The interplay between density wave/VBS order and superconductivity is efficiently described by the quantum dimer model, which acts as an effective theory for the total spin S=0 sector. We extend the dimer model to include fermionic S=1/2 excitations, and show that its mean-field, static gauge field saddle points have projective symmetries (PSGs) similar to those of `slave' particle U(1) and SU(2) gauge theories. We account for the non-perturbative effects of gauge fluctuations by a duality mapping of the S=0 dimer model. The dual theory of vortices has a PSG identical to that found in a previous paper (L. Balents et al., cond-mat/0408329) by a duality analysis of bosons on the square lattice. The previous theory therefore also describes fluctuations across superconducting, supersolid and Mott insulating phases of the present electronic model. Finally, with the aim of describing neutron scattering experiments, we present a phenomenological model for collective S=1 excitations and their coupling to superflow and density wave fluctuations.
We study the phases of doped spin S=1∕2S=1∕2S=1∕2 quantum antiferromagnets on the square lattice as they evolve from paramagnetic Mott insulators with valence bond solid (VBS) order at doping $\ensuremath{\delta}=0$ to superconductors at moderate $\ensuremath{\delta}$. The interplay between density-wave and VBS order and superconductivity is efficiently described by the quantum dimer model, which acts as an effective theory for the total spin S=0S=0S=0 sector. We extend the dimer model to include fermionic S=1∕2S=1∕2S=1∕2 excitations and show that its mean-field, static gauge-field saddle points have projective symmetries (PSG's) similar to those of ``slave''-particle U(1) and SU(2) gauge theories. We account for the nonperturbative effects of gauge fluctuations by a duality mapping of the S=0S=0S=0 dimer model. The dual theory of vortices has a PSG identical to that found in a previous paper [L. Balents et al., preceding paper, Phys. Rev. B 71, 144508 (2005)] by a duality analysis of bosons on the square lattice. The previous theory therefore also describes fluctuations across superconducting, supersolid, and Mott insulating phases of the present electronic model. Finally, with the aim of describing neutron scattering experiments, we present a phenomenological model for collective S=1S=1S=1 excitations and their coupling to superflow and density-wave fluctuations.
Quantum fluctuations of the Néel state of the square lattice antiferromagnet are usually described by a CP 1 theory of bosonic spinons coupled to a U(1) gauge field, and with a global SU(2) spin rotation symmetry.Such a theory also has a confining phase with valence bond solid (VBS) order, and upon including spin-singlet charge-2 Higgs fields, deconfined phases with Z 2 topological order possibly intertwined with discrete broken global symmetries.We present dual theories of the same phases starting from a mean-field theory of fermionic spinons moving in π flux in each square lattice plaquette.Fluctuations about this π-flux state are described by (2 þ 1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD 3 ) with a SU(2) gauge group and N f ¼ 2 flavors of massless Dirac fermions.It has recently been argued by Wang et al. [Deconfined Quantum Critical Points: Symmetries and Dualities, Phys. Rev. X 7, 031051 (2017).]that this QCD 3 theory describes the Néel-VBS quantum phase transition.We introduce adjoint Higgs fields in QCD 3 and obtain fermionic dual descriptions of the phases with Z 2 topological order obtained earlier using the bosonic CP 1 theory.We also present a fermionic spinon derivation of the monopole Berry phases in the U(1) gauge theory of the VBS state.The global phase diagram of these phases contains multicritical points, and our results imply new boson-fermion dualities between critical gauge theories of these points.
Unravelling competing orders emergent in doped Mott insulators and their interplay with unconventional superconductivity is one of the major challenges in condensed matter physics. To explore the possible superconducting state in a doped Mott insulator, we study the square-lattice t-J model with both the nearest-neighbor and next-nearest-neighbor electron hoppings and spin interactions. By using the state-of-the-art density matrix renormalization group calculation with imposing charge U(1) and spin SU(2) symmetries on the six-leg cylinders, we establish a quantum phase diagram including three phases: a stripe charge density wave phase, a superconducting phase without static charge order, and a superconducting phase coexistent with a weak charge stripe order. Crucially, we demonstrate that the superconducting phase has a power-law pairing correlation that decays much slower than the charge density and spin correlations, which is a quasi-1D descendant of the uniform d-wave superconductor in two dimensions. These findings reveal that enhanced charge and spin fluctuations with optimal doping is able to produce robust d-wave superconductivity in doped Mott insulators, providing a foundation for connecting theories of superconductivity to models of strongly correlated systems.
By bosonizing the electronic t-J model exactly on any two-dimensional (2D) lattices, and integrating out the gauge fluctuations combined to slave particles beyond mean fields, we obtain a theory in terms of physical Cooper pair and spin condensates. In the sense of mutual Berry phase they turn out to be dual to each other. The mutual duality is the missing key in the resonant-valance-bond idea [Science 235, 1196 (1987)]] to work as a paradigm of doped 2D Mott insulators. We argue that the essential aspects of high-T(c) phenomenology can be explained in the present framework.
Insulating quantum spin liquids can undergo a confinement transition to a valence bond solid via the condensation of topological excitations of the associated gauge theory. We extend the theory of such transitions to fractionalized Fermi liquids (FL*): These are metallic doped spin liquids in which the Fermi surfaces only have gauge neutral quasiparticles. Using insights from a duality transform on a doped quantum dimer model for the U(1)-FL* state, we show that projective symmetry group of the theory of the topological excitations remains unmodified, but the Fermi surfaces can lead to additional frustrating interactions. We propose a theory for the confinement transition of Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​-FL* states via the condensation of visons. A variety of confining, incommensurate density wave states are possible, including some that are similar to the incommensurate ddd-form factor density wave order observed in several recent experiments on the cuprate superconductors.
Systems with competing orders are of great interest in condensed matter physics. When\ntwo phases have comparable energies, novel interplay effects such can be induced by tuning an appropriate parameter. In this thesis, we study two problems of competing orders - (i) ultracold atom gases with competing superfluidity and Charge Density Wave(CDW) orders, and (ii) low dimensional antiferromagnets with Neel order competing against various disordered ground states. \n\nIn the first part of the thesis, we study the\n attractive Hubbard model which could soon be realized in ultracold atom experiments. Close to half-filling, the superfluid ground state competes with a low-lying CDW phase. We study the collective excitations of the superfluid using the Generalized Random Phase Approximation (GRPA) and strong-coupling spin wave analysis.\n The competing CDW phase manifests as a roton-like excitation. We characterize the collective mode spectrum, setting benchmarks for experiments.\n\nWe drive competition between orders by imposing superfluid flow. Superflow leads to various instabilities: in particular, we find a dynamical instability associated with CDW order. We also find a novel dynamical incommensurate instability analogous to exciton condensation in semiconductors.\n\nIn the second part, inspired by experiments on Bi3Mn4O12(NO3)(BMNO), we first study the interlayer dimer state in spin-S bilayer antiferromagnets. At a critical bilayer coupling strength, condensation of triplet excitations leads to Neel order. In describing this transition, bond operator mean field theory suffers from systematic deviations. We bridge these deviations by taking into account corrections arising from higher spin excitations. The interlayer dimer state shows a field induced Neel transition, as seen in BMNO. Our results are relevant to the quantitative modelling of spin-S dimerized systems. \n\nWe then study the J1−J2 model on the honeycomb lattice with frustrating next-nearest neighbour exchange.\n For J2>J1/6, quantum and thermal fluctuations lead to ‘lattice nematic’\nstates. For S=1/2, this lattice nematic takes the form of a valence bond solid.\n\nWith J2<J1 /6, quantum fluctuations melt Neel order so as to give rise to a field induced Neel transition. This scenario can explain the observed properties of BMNO.\n\nWe discuss implications for the honeycomb lattice Hubbard model.