In this chapter, we examine a different case study, where the aim was to unify apparently unrelated domains, such as quantum states, probability assignments, and logical inference. This is John von Neumann’s development of an alternative framework to the Hilbert space formalism he pioneered: one articulated in terms of his theory of operators and what we now call von Neumann algebras. This allowed him to accommodate probabilities in the context of systems with infinite degrees of freedom. Here we find, in addition to ‘top-down’ moves from the mathematics to the physics, ‘bottom-up’ developments from empirical features, to a particular logic and thence to mathematical structures. Through a combination of such moves, crucially involving exploration of the structural relations that hold between the mathematical and the physical domains, von Neumann articulated the kind of unification across such domains that represents a further important aspect of the application of mathematics.
In this chapter, we examine a different case study, where the aim was to unify apparently unrelated domains, such as quantum states, probability assignments, and logical inference. This is John von Neumann’s development of an alternative framework to the Hilbert space formalism he pioneered: one articulated in terms of his theory of operators and what we now call von Neumann algebras. This allowed him to accommodate probabilities in the context of systems with infinite degrees of freedom. Here we find, in addition to ‘top-down’ moves from the mathematics to the physics, ‘bottom-up’ developments from empirical features, to a particular logic and thence to mathematical structures. Through a combination of such moves, crucially involving exploration of the structural relations that hold between the mathematical and the physical domains, von Neumann articulated the kind of unification across such domains that represents a further important aspect of the application of mathematics.
. We put forward a new take on the logic of quantum mechanics, following Schrödinger's point of view that it is composition which makes quantum theory what it is, rather than its particular propositional structure due to the existence of superpositions, as proposed by Birkhoff and von Neumann. This gives rise to an intrinsically quantitative kind of logic, which truly deserves the name ‘logic’ in that it also models meaning in natural language, the latter being the origin of logic, that it supports automation, the most prominent practical use of logic, and that it supports probabilistic inference. The physics and the logic of quantum-ish logic. In 1932 John von Neumann formalized Quantum Mechanics in his book “Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik”. This was effectively the official birth of the quantum mechanical formalism which until now, some 75 years later, has remained the same. Quantum theory underpins so many things in our daily lives including chemical industry, energy production and information technology, which arguably makes it the most technologically successful theory of physics ever. However, in 1935, merely three years after the birth of his brainchild, von Neumann wrote in a letter to American mathematician Garrett Birkhoff: “I would like to make a confession which may seem immoral: I do not believe absolutely in Hilbert space no more.” (sic)—for more details see [73]. Soon thereafter they published a paper entitled “The Logic of Quantum Mechanics” [13]. Their ‘quantum logic’ was cast in order-theoretic terms, very much in the spirit of the then reigning algebraic view of logic, with the distributive law being replaced with a weaker (ortho)modular law. This resulted in a research community of quantum logicians [68, 71, 47, 30]. However, despite von Neumann's reputation, and the large body of research that has been produced in the area, one does not find a trace of this activity neither in the mainstream physics, mathematics, nor logic literature. Hence, 75 years later one may want to conclude that this activity was a failure. What went wrong? The mathematics of it. Let us consider the raison d'être for the Hilbert space formalism.
In 1933, Kolmogorov synthesized the basic concepts of probability that were in general use at the time into concepts and deductions from a simple set of axioms that said probability was a σ-additive function from a boolean algebra of events into [0, 1]. In 1932, von Neumann realized that the use of probability in quantum mechanics required a different concept that he formulated as a σ-additive function from the closed subspaces of a Hilbert space onto [0,1]. In 1935, Birkhoff & von Neumann replaced Hilbert space with an algebraic generalization. Today, a slight modification of the Birkhoff-von Neumann generalization is called “quantum logic”. A central problem in the philosophy of probability is the justification of the definition of probability used in a given application. This is usually done by arguing for the rationality of that approach to the situation under consideration. A version of the Dutch book argument given by de Finetti in 1972 is often used to justify the Kolmogorov theory, especially in scientific applications. As von Neumann in 1955 noted, and his criticisms still hold, there is no acceptable foundation for quantum logic. While it is not argued here that a rational approach has been carried out for quantum physics, it is argued that (1) for many important situations found in behavioral science that quantum probability theory is a reasonable choice, and (2) that it has an arguably rational foundation to certain areas of behavioral science, for example, the behavioral paradigm of Between Subjects experiments.
Quantum mechanics and the theory of operator algebras have been intertwined since their origin.In the 1930s [20] von Neumann laid the foundations for the theory of (what are now known as) von Neumann algebras with the explicit goal of establishing Heisenberg's matrix mechanics on a rigorous footing (quoting from the preface, in the translation by Beyer: "The object of this book is to present the new quantum mechanics in a unified representation which, so far as it is possible and useful, is mathematically rigorous").Following the initial explorations of Murray and von Neumann, the new theory took on a life of its own, eventually leading to multiple applications unrelated to quantum mechanics, such as to free probability or noncommutative geometry.In his 1976 paper completing the classification of injective von Neumann algebras [6] Connes made a casual
This work introduces the Universal Principle of Algebraic Formalization (PUFA), formulated in an axiomatic–theorematic framework grounded in C*-algebra theory and operator algebras. The principle states that observable systems whose operations admit composition, involution, and completeness can be faithfully represented as subalgebras of operators on Hilbert spaces, allowing the emergence of dynamics, states, entropy, measurement, and composition from established mathematical results, including the Gelfand–Naimark–Segal construction, Tomita–Takesaki modular theory, Stinespring dilation, and the KMS equilibrium condition. The article proposes PUFA as a methodological protocol for formalization, enabling qualitative domains to be translated into algebraic structures with deductive consistency. The work explicitly distinguishes between rigorously demonstrated mathematical components, epistemological modeling hypotheses, and interpretative or ontological layers. Illustrative applications are developed across six domains—physics, political systems, the psyche, economics, music, and topological economics—aiming to demonstrate the structural generality of the framework while preserving the distinction between formal consistency and empirical validation. The PUFA framework is positioned at the intersection of functional analysis, mathematical physics, information theory, and systems theory, proposing a unified formal language for structural comparison across heterogeneous domains while maintaining explicit limits regarding empirical applicability and interpretation.
Abstract We have already mentioned that Schriöidinger’s formulation of quantum mechanics was slightly preceded by a totally different algebraic formulation proposed by Heisenberg. Although Schriöidinger’s methods were so much simpler that they were generally preferred, both approaches seemed to give the same answers, so it was natural to ask how they were related. This was particularly important because some features of quantum theory were easier to understand in Heisenberg’s formalism. In fact, as we have already noted, Schriöidinger was able to show that the two methods were essentially equivalent. Soon mathematicians like Hermann Weyland John von Neumann were able to find a general mathematical scheme that encompassed both approaches, and it is this that we shall now describe.
Philosophers concerned with making physical sense of the mathematical apparatus of quantum mechanics tend to distinguish between interpretations of the theory that aim to present a coherent picture of reality, and anti-realist (empiricist, operationalist, instrumentalist,…) interpretations, which content themselves with looking upon the theory’s formal apparatus as a tool for making predictions. It is rarely appreciated that these alternatives are not exclusive. There are other ways of presenting a coherent picture of reality than to invest with physical reality a calculational tool such as the wave function. In what follows we shall present a coherent picture of reality that explains why the formal apparatus of quantum mechanics is a probability calculus, and why the events to which it serves to assign probabilities are the possible outcomes of measurements.