Abstract Deffner and Lutz (2013 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 46 335302) extended the Margolus–Levitin bound to time-dependent closed system. We point out that thier analysis is incorrect. The Margolus–Levitin bound has not yet been established in time-dependent quantum systems, except for the adiabatic case.
The time–energy uncertainty relation in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics has been intensely debated with regard to its formal derivation, validity, and physical meaning. Here, we analyze two formal relations proposed by Mandelstam and Tamm and by Margolus and Levitin and evaluate their validity using a minimal quantum toy model composed of a single qubit inside an external magnetic field. We show that the ℓ1 norm of energy coherence C is invariant with respect to the unitary evolution of the quantum state. Thus, the ℓ1 norm of energy coherence C of an initial quantum state is useful for the classification of the ability of quantum observables to change in time or the ability of the quantum state to evolve into an orthogonal state. In the single-qubit toy model, for quantum states with the submaximal ℓ1 norm of energy coherence, C<1, the Mandelstam–Tamm and Margolus–Levitin relations generate instances of infinite “time uncertainty” that is devoid of physical meaning. Only for quantum states with the maximal ℓ1 norm of energy coherence, C=1, the Mandelstam–Tamm and Margolus–Levitin relations avoid infinite “time uncertainty”, but they both reduce to a strict equality that expresses the Einstein–Planck relation between energy and frequency. The presented results elucidate the fact that the time in the Schrödinger equation is a scalar variable that commutes with the quantum Hamiltonian and is not subject to statistical variance.
Quantum speed limits set the maximal pace of state evolution. Two well-known limits exist for a unitary time-independent Hamiltonian: the Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin bounds. The former restricts the rate according to the state energy uncertainty, while the latter depends on the mean energy relative to the ground state. Here we report on an additional bound that exists for states with a bounded energy spectrum. This bound is dual to the Margolus-Levitin one in the sense that it depends on the difference between the state's mean energy and the energy of the highest occupied eigenstate. Each of the three bounds can become the most restrictive one, depending on the spread and mean of the energy, forming three dynamical regimes which are accessible in a multilevel system. The new bound is relevant for quantum information applications, since in most of them, information is stored and manipulated in a Hilbert space with a bounded energy spectrum.
The Margolus-Levitin (ML) bound says that for any time-independent Hamiltonian, the time needed to evolve from one quantum state to another is at least $\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\alpha}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})/2\ensuremath{\langle}E\ensuremath{-}{E}_{0}\ensuremath{\rangle}$, where $\ensuremath{\langle}E\ensuremath{-}{E}_{0}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ is the expected energy of the system relative to the ground state of the Hamiltonian and $\ensuremath{\alpha}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ is a function of the fidelity $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ between the two states. For a long time, only an upper bound ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{>}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ and a lower bound ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{<}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ are known, although they agree up to at least seven significant figures. Recently, H\"ornedal and S\"onnerborn [arXiv:2301.10063] proved an analytical expression for $\ensuremath{\alpha}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$, a fully classified system whose evolution time saturates the ML bound, and gave this bound a symplectic-geometric interpretation. Here I solve the same problem through an elementary proof of the ML bound. By explicitly finding all the states that saturate the ML bound, I show that ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{>}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ is indeed equal to ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{<}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$. More importantly, I point out a numerical stability issue in computing ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{>}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ and report a simple way to evaluate it efficiently and accurately.