Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics

Experimental Test of Bell’s Inequality for Temporal Orders

Giulia Rubino, Lee A. Rozema, Francesco Massa, Mateus Araújo, Magdalena Zych, Časlav Brukner, Philip John Walther

Published Jan 1, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Bell’s inequality has been violated using different physical systems, but never for the temporal order between events. Here we present such a Bell inequality and experimentally violate it by entangling the temporal order between events.
DOI
10.1364/cleo_qels.2018.fth4g.1

Related papers

Experimental Violation of Bell's Inequality for Temporal Orders

Lee A. Rozema, Giulia Rubino, Francesco Massa +4 more

Entanglement is a prediction of quantum mechanics that suggests that our physical laws cannot be described by a local causal model. This has led to much debate, including Einstein's famous suggestion that quantum mechanics is an incomplete theory, and we may one day discover a deeper theory that can be described by a locally causal model. However, loophole free violations of Bell inequalities demonstrate that this is not the case. Bell's theorem is independent of quantum mechanics, and it shows that any theory attempting to supplant quantum mechanics must be somehow nonlocal. Since then, there have been many experimental violations of Bell inequalities using different physical systems, culminating in three loophole-free experiments [1-3].

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Experimental entanglement of temporal order

Giulia Rubino, Lee A. Rozema, Francesco Massa +4 more

The study of causal relations has recently been applied to the quantum realm, leading to the discovery that not all physical processes have a definite causal structure. While indefinite causal processes have previously been experimentally shown, these proofs relied on the quantum description of the experiments. Yet, the same experimental data could also be compatible with definite causal structures within different descriptions. Here, we present the first demonstration of indefinite temporal order outside of quantum formalism. We show that our experimental outcomes are incompatible with a class of generalised probabilistic theories satisfying the assumptions of locality and definite temporal order. To this end, we derive physical constraints (in the form of a Bell-like inequality) on experimental outcomes within such a class of theories. We then experimentally invalidate these theories by violating the inequality using entangled temporal order. This provides experimental evidence that there exist correlations in nature which are incompatible with the assumptions of locality and definite temporal order.

arXiv:1712.06884•Quantum•Jan 11, 2022•76 citations

Proposed test for temporal Bell inequalities

Juan Pablo Paz, Günter Mahler A

Temporal Bell inequalities can be violated for sequences of events (histories) for which probabilities satisfying consistent sum rules cannot be defined. We discuss possible experiments in which such violations, never observed so far, may indeed be seen. The basic scheme, which uses three optically driven and mutually interacting two-level systems, could be implemented in a variety of nanostructures. It could even be mapped onto the dynamics of a single electron four-level system thus allowing for a realization in atomic physics.

Physical Review Letters•Nov 15, 1993•69 citations

A note on the violation of Bell's inequality

Thomas Schürmann

With Bell's inequalities one has a formal expression to show how essentially all local theories of natural phenomena that are formulated within the framework of realism may be tested using a simple experimental arrangement. For the case of entangled pairs of spin-1/2 particles we propose an alternative measurement setup which is consistent to the necessary assumptions corresponding to the derivation of the Bell inequalities. We find that the Bell inequalities are never violated with respect to our suggested measurement process.

arXiv:1703.10030•Mar 17, 2017•1 citation

Experimental Entanglement of Temporal Orders

Giulia Rubino, Lee A. Rozema, Francesco Massa +4 more

Various physical systems have been entangled, never the temporal order between events. Here we do just that, and then use the entanglement to create and characterize a process with genuinely indefinite temporal order.

Quantum Information and Measurement (QIM)•Jan 1, 2019•29 citations

Experimentation with Bell’s Inequality

Hong Joo Ryoo

Recently, an experiment was done in the realm of Quantum Information that won the recent 2022 Nobel prize in Physics. This experiment breaks Bell's inequality, supporting quantum theory over hidden variable theory—the research done is considered one of the pioneering experiments for quantum information science. This research paper documented the theory of the experiment done and experimentally tested for the violation of Bell's inequality, using materials similar to the experiments from the past, in an attempt to provide more support for quantum information. Through repetition of the experiment, it was simple to brainstorm more potential experimentation and design that will further develop entanglement. The mathematical formulation and terms are the same as defined in past works in detail in order to keep notation and inequalities constant throughout the analysis. Using the data points and error propagation, I have shown that Bell's inequality is violated to a great extent. This paper finally addresses potential experimentation regarding quantum entanglement and its applications to quantum sensors and computing technology.

AIAA Regional Student Conferences•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations
Entanglement is a prediction of quantum mechanics that suggests that our physical laws cannot be described by a local causal model. This has led to much debate, including Einstein's famous suggestion that quantum mechanics is an incomplete theory, and we may one day discover a deeper theory that can be described by a locally causal model. However, loophole free violations of Bell inequalities demonstrate that this is not the case. Bell's theorem is independent of quantum mechanics, and it shows that any theory attempting to supplant quantum mechanics must be somehow nonlocal. Since then, there have been many experimental violations of Bell inequalities using different physical systems, culminating in three loophole-free experiments [1-3].
The study of causal relations has recently been applied to the quantum realm, leading to the discovery that not all physical processes have a definite causal structure. While indefinite causal processes have previously been experimentally shown, these proofs relied on the quantum description of the experiments. Yet, the same experimental data could also be compatible with definite causal structures within different descriptions. Here, we present the first demonstration of indefinite temporal order outside of quantum formalism. We show that our experimental outcomes are incompatible with a class of generalised probabilistic theories satisfying the assumptions of locality and definite temporal order. To this end, we derive physical constraints (in the form of a Bell-like inequality) on experimental outcomes within such a class of theories. We then experimentally invalidate these theories by violating the inequality using entangled temporal order. This provides experimental evidence that there exist correlations in nature which are incompatible with the assumptions of locality and definite temporal order.
Temporal Bell inequalities can be violated for sequences of events (histories) for which probabilities satisfying consistent sum rules cannot be defined. We discuss possible experiments in which such violations, never observed so far, may indeed be seen. The basic scheme, which uses three optically driven and mutually interacting two-level systems, could be implemented in a variety of nanostructures. It could even be mapped onto the dynamics of a single electron four-level system thus allowing for a realization in atomic physics.
With Bell's inequalities one has a formal expression to show how essentially all local theories of natural phenomena that are formulated within the framework of realism may be tested using a simple experimental arrangement. For the case of entangled pairs of spin-1/2 particles we propose an alternative measurement setup which is consistent to the necessary assumptions corresponding to the derivation of the Bell inequalities. We find that the Bell inequalities are never violated with respect to our suggested measurement process.
Recently, an experiment was done in the realm of Quantum Information that won the recent 2022 Nobel prize in Physics. This experiment breaks Bell's inequality, supporting quantum theory over hidden variable theory—the research done is considered one of the pioneering experiments for quantum information science. This research paper documented the theory of the experiment done and experimentally tested for the violation of Bell's inequality, using materials similar to the experiments from the past, in an attempt to provide more support for quantum information. Through repetition of the experiment, it was simple to brainstorm more potential experimentation and design that will further develop entanglement. The mathematical formulation and terms are the same as defined in past works in detail in order to keep notation and inequalities constant throughout the analysis. Using the data points and error propagation, I have shown that Bell's inequality is violated to a great extent. This paper finally addresses potential experimentation regarding quantum entanglement and its applications to quantum sensors and computing technology.